Aziraphale and the Gray Area: Why is he like that though
Good omens season 2 spoilers ahead
One of the things religious trauma gave me is a strong sense of right vs. wrong. The idea that there is always a right way to do things or a right course of action, and to not do things that way is simply wrong. This is more than just feeling afraid of being punished for doing the wrong thing; it feels like part of my identity. I think of myself as a good person, so I want to do good things and I want to do the right thing. If I choose to do the wrong thing, I lose myself and I lose what I value in myself. Sometimes it’s a good thing to feel like this, it’s what led me away from a religion that preached hate. Sometimes it’s not such a good thing, because I can hurt people by trying to do the right thing, or by trying to put my personal sense of morals onto other peoples’ situations. I have been picking through my beliefs for over a decade trying to confront and dismantle the harmful ones. It’s a painful process and it takes a long, long time.
How much longer must it take for a literal angel, a servant of God? We have the pleasure of seeing this process in Aziraphale through the ages, and it’s a lot slower than fans want it to be. I think people see Aziraphale in his moments in the gray area - lying, disobeying orders, being a bastard, enjoying human food, and loving and trusting a demon - and they think that he must be just fine with being in the middle: mostly right, a bit wrong, very human. But that characterization oversimplifies and misses Aziraphale’s true nature.
The sense of justice and good vs. evil is central to who Aziraphale is. He is not just another angel following commands; he is doing what he truly thinks is right no matter what the consequences may be. He ends up being quite a bit more good and loving than any of the other angels we meet, because he isn’t okay with doing what he knows is wrong. He knows it innately, but also he knows it because of what he was taught. When you’re taught that hate and violence and greed is wrong, but then you see hate and violence and greed being perpetuated by your teachers, you start to wonder where that dividing line really is.
That’s where the gray area comes in. When Aziraphale gives away his sword, he’s aware it’s not technically the right thing to do, but decides it is the actual right thing to do to protect Eve and Adam and their child. Same as when he lies to the angels about Job’s children, only this time instead of fudging the truth and avoiding the confrontation, he has to make a direct choice to do something that is technically wrong - lying - in order to avoid doing something he really, really knows is Wrong - murder. In this case, he’s not okay with lying despite it being wrong, he’s okay with lying because it is the right thing to do. It still causes a large amount of internal conflict when he thinks he will be sent to Hell for disobeying, but that fear of punishment didn’t stop him from doing what he thought was good.
For Aziraphale, the gray area is not about being a little bit evil, it’s about fudging the Rules and disobeying authority in order to remain completely good. Since Crowley is in the gray area with him, surely Crowley must be in the same boat of wanting to do the Right thing. Throughout thousands of years of history Aziraphale never stops arguing the side of Good, trying to convince Crowley to do the right thing. Sometimes he finds that Crowley was actually right all along, and then Aziraphale can feel safe to align himself with whatever the demon is doing. Sometimes Aziraphale even tries to convince Heaven to do the right thing with him. During Armageddon, Aziraphale avoids telling Crowley the truth because he thinks it would be better to get Heaven to stop doing the wrong thing. And he’s right, a lot of problems would be solved and life would be easier if Heaven would listen to Aziraphale and stop inflicting their harmful views on the world.
It would be nice if Aziraphale would realize, at the end of the first season, that Heaven is not interested in being good or even being right; they just want to win. Aziraphale is too naive and pure to believe that of Heaven. After everything, he still wants to be an angel, and he still wants to be part of a Heaven that is doing good. What he did at the end of season 2 is not at all out of character for him. It makes perfect sense that he would want to take the opportunity to change Heaven for the better. Anyone can see what a delightful place it would be with Aziraphale making the decisions. Angels could drink hot chocolate and stack books in their offices or pop down to Earth to go to the theater. Humans could live without worrying about Armageddon or the Great Plan or having their lives destroyed over a bet. And demons (or at least one specific one) who were good and loving could be forgiven and become angels again so they don’t have to be forced to carry out evil acts and always be looking over their shoulders.
Aziraphale didn’t do what he did because he doesn’t accept or love who Crowley is. He just genuinely believes that Crowley is still an angel deep down and that Heaven is where he belongs, where he could be the most happy. A better Heaven, where Crowley could create stars to last millions of years and put anything he wanted in the suggestion box. Aziraphale wanted to create a life for them to be together without any more worry of secret meetings, gray areas, and war. When Crowley rejected that life, it broke Aziraphale’s view of Crowley and his goodness. As ridiculous as it sounds, Aziraphale never expected that Crowley wouldn’t jump at the chance to be an angel with him again, and now his perception of their relationship is shaken.
Ultimately, Aziraphale can’t be so selfish as to choose to run away with the being he loves, when he knows he can do so much more good if he returns to Heaven. And so in trying to do the right thing for everyone, Aziraphale does the wrong thing for Crowley and himself. This is what is so hard about Aziraphale’s gray area; it cuts both ways. He has so much learning and unpacking to do, and I’m afraid he’s going to find that he will have much less power to change Heaven than he thought. All we can do is beg for a third season and then Wait and See.
401 notes
·
View notes
OK, but can I talk about how Good Omens 2 took the quote/verse “It is easier for a camel to enter the eye of a needle that is for the rich to enter the kingdom of God” and just DESTROYED it?
Like that healed SO MUCH of my religious trauma
(Spoilers bellow)
The story of the resurrectionists where they’re digging up the bodies, and how her being poor made her do these terrible things… Aziraphale thought it was a good thing being poor, but here she was at the bottom doing “evil”. And then she lost the one thing she was living for, her friend, and so she needed money in order to enter the kingdom of heaven because the heaven she made with her friend was destroyed.
And then there’s the story of Job. He, for no reason, had everything taken away from him. And it almost destroyed his wife’s faith, and it almost destroyed him, and they were about to be really mad about not having their original children. They probably would’ve gone against heaven, but love is their heaven and love is where their family is so in the end they were happy.
And then with ineffable bureaucracy. They had the taste of the most powerful positions in all of heaven, Earth, and Hell. And they gave that up because their love was more than a heaven (or hell) to them. It’s because they tasted power that they realized it was meaningless compared to love.
And it’s only because of “evil” that any of them survived this long, they all broke and bent the rules (or had them broke/bent for them) because they realized that bending/breaking the rules was actually the least harmful outcome. And the most Heavenly (at least to them. And that’s all that matters.)
And when good tries to do good and evil tries to do evil, they both fail. As seen with Armageddon.  As seen with the story of Job (how heaven almost let them kill). As seen with the naazi zombies.
Emotion and love wins in the end, for both season 1 and 2.
78 notes
·
View notes
False God
-
If I burn down the chapel,
Where will they worship you?
Will the bricks fall with elegance,
Or crash to the ground with rage?
To think of the promises that left your lips
To capture me,
Lock me within the attic,
Strip me of the light and laughter
That drew you to me-
Will you fall with honor?
With respect for what you say we've built?
The manipulation replacing oxygen
In my bloodstream-
The sweet moments,
I can count on one hand,
Look me in my eyes-
The eyes you fought to smother,
The fire you said you love but kept
Hidden away, in the dark-
Will you fall with some fucking dignity?
Or was that a lie too?
x
15 notes
·
View notes