I saw a theory about Lindir being Noldorin and I think that could track honestly.
Family hated and or killed at a young age (we don’t know his parentage)? Had to survive on his own, maybe taking care of siblings (common fan theories)? Soft boi who wants to be a minstrel and has to worry about being found out? Highly anxious could be hyper vigilance. Ends up in Elrond’s home? The elf famous for making a haven and being fostered by Maedhros and Maglor?
Hell ya I support this theory
11 notes
·
View notes
Concept: there is a massive linguistic debate among the Noldor on whether to use past tense or present tense when referring to dead elves, since they're dead but are presumably in the Halls and may one day return. (The Vanyar and the Amanyar Teleri (Falmari) don't care but mostly use present tense. All the Moriquendi use past tense.) The Noldor used to use present tense, but then Miriel..well, she's not coming back, is she?
So they start using past tense for Miriel, and then for all the dead. Predictably, Feanor explodes, and the issue becomes very controversial, very political, and another wedge between Feanor and Fingolfin.
(Fast-forward: by lake Mithrim after Maedhros is captured, the sons of Feanor have a few screaming matches whenever one of them slips and refers to Finwe, Feanor, Amrod (if burnt version), or Maedhros in the past tense.)
After the Noldor settle in Beleriand, the ever-loyal sons of Feanor continue to use the present tense, but death and Doom weight heavily on the Noldor, and the addition of the Sindar population (who habitually use past tense) and the transfer to Sindarin as the main language push some Feanorians to use past tense. The linguistic distinction becomes a less explosive issue and less of a way to declare your loyalties.
After the Dagor Bragollach, the scales tilt more in the past tense's favor. After the Nirnaeth Arnoediad, everyone, including the sons of Feanor, use the past tense, and the despair is such that no one notices the change.
565 notes
·
View notes
A few thoughts on Galadriel's Valor, Story, and "Girl-boss" energy
I've seen many things written about the "girl-bossification" of Galadriel, as though she 1. did not need anything extra given to her character, 2. she was diplomatically power hungry rather than vengeful, and 3. she was already Married and had her daughter by the time this show was taking place.
I'm not attempting to defend any creative choices or say why the show is "right" to portray them as they have, but I do think some things could be discussed with a bit more context and I do love some lore-diving and graceful discussions, so here goes.
To the first part (1.), she is recorded as not only engaging in the first kinslaying (she fought AGAINST Feanor, protecting the Teleri, but almost certainly killed other elves and elves aren't known for their weakness), but Tolkien himself said she was a "great warrior" in her youth. In the same vein, canonically she did initially go to Middle-earth to rule, but that is not clearly stated to be false here, merely that she is currently fueled by anger, pride, and vengeance, and rejecting the Valar's pardon which is canon for the most part (pg. 242 Unfinished Tales). Again, not defending, but I do think that this fits into established context as well as the next two points.
2. We're not given a clear reason as to why she, specifically, comes to Middle-earth in the show. There is a general reason why the elves go, yet not her. But I also realize that such logic goes both ways and I also understand that adapted stories are told by admissions AND omissions. However,
3. We know soooo little as to the intentions of the story yet. There's so much left to see, but the one thing I do think is the most important to bring up is the fact that this "character reversal" has been done before, by Peter Jackson and the character of Aragorn.
Aragorn in the books not only knows he's the king, but is downright giddy and excited to get going, reforging Narsil into Anduril before they even leave Rivendell. The rest of the trilogy is him slowly spreading his influence and making his grand "Return" Yet, in the movies it's the exact opposite. Movie Aragorn is not just reluctant, but almost hostile to the mere idea of reclaiming his throne, and slowly throughout the series he is pushed towards that reclamation of power.
In the RoP, we see Alatáriel/Artanis (Galadriel) as the daughter of a great Noldorin lord, single and alone in a quest for vengeance. Yet, we know she will become the most influential Elf in all of Middle-earth. The reason she doesn't fit that bill yet is because THAT is the story that I think they are telling. Literally the first episode is setting up the journey towards finally letting go of the sword, claiming the influential (but non-martial) power of her birthright and marrying (quite scandalously, I might add) a sindar elf that will unite the Noldorin and Sindarin Elves into a United people.
I think the story we are going to see is Alatáriel, the sword-wielding daughter of Arafinwë, become the Galadriel, Queen of the Elves of Middle-earth.
(*POSSIBLE SPOILERS FOR SHOW-ONLY WATCHERS*)
After all, when Sauron/Annatar does return and sway the Elven people, there are only two elves that find him untrustworthy and reject him (Galadriel and Elrond).... and the fact that no one listens to her has always been questionable and unexplained in the cannon narrative. If the most powerful and influential leader alive said someone seems sketchy and shouldn't be trusted, it doesn't make sense that you'd ignore those warnings off-hand, especially if she was regarded as one of the wisest elves alive.
But if it's a blood thirsty, vengeful war-leader who has spurned the commands of her king who is saying that this beautiful and gracious elf who has been kind and generous and infinitely helpful to all of her people is actually evil incarnate, perhaps she would not be given much credence and would instead be ignored. It might actually HELP explain a few things lol.
(*POSSIBLE SPOILERS CONCLUDED*)
In the end, we will simply have to wait and see. But I think she's (Morfydd Clark) bringing something to Galadriel we have never seen but always known about, and that's a personal history. Just like Aragorn, I'd bet my last penny that we will see the Galadriel we all know and love, but that's the journey she is on. And I am so excited to see it happen!
But perhaps I'm like Elrond and harbour naive hope for the future, only time (or perhaps a certain Elf's magical mirror) will tell.
In any case, I wish you all well!
Na lû e-govaded 'wîn, mellon nin!
~ Ramoth13
225 notes
·
View notes
"𝒀𝒐𝒖 𝒂𝒓𝒆 𝒕𝒉𝒆 𝒃𝒓𝒊𝒈𝒉𝒕𝒆𝒔𝒕 𝒔𝒕𝒂𝒓. 𝑴𝒚 𝑷𝒓𝒊𝒏𝒄𝒆"
_________
My headcanon based on a scene from the Book of Lost Tales. In the book there's a part where Eärendil "wept bitterly" and said that he cared no more to see Gondolin's streets after he was informed of Ecthelion's death. And the fact that Eärendil declared something so strong like that at a very young age, at that time makes me believe that Ecthelion must have been very special to him. And of course our Eärendil was, is and always will be 𝒕𝒉𝒆 𝒃𝒓𝒊𝒈𝒉𝒕𝒆𝒔𝒕 𝒍𝒊𝒈𝒉𝒕. Even when all other lights go out.
_____________________________________________________________
It's just me trying something simple during stressful time and I was stunned by the result. Maybe I will do this style again once in a while cause it really makes me feel calm and relax than I thought. Anyway pls don’t mind me mumbling nonsense just skip the caption. Hope u guys enjoy it ~
Thank you as always <3
******
See my other Silmarillion artwork HERE
https://www.deviantart.com/kaianguyen/gallery/73232246/silmarillion
https://twitter.com/sakurainguyen
https://www.instagram.com/kaia_art96/
Do not repost my art without permission.
146 notes
·
View notes
Does Imladris have anything like Croquet and if so, is Figwit any good at it?
I don't know jack shit about croquet, so I had to look things up. TLDR; I think it'd be delightful if they do.
I don't have thoughts on who started croquet in Arda, but this made me think about the Noldor and polo. I can't decide if it's funnier if the Noldor
saw croquet and went "This is lovely. 10/10. You know what would make it even better? More or less the same thing but on horseback" then invent polo.
already invented polo. Similar to how it developed in real life, it evolved out of a cavalry training game. When they come across croquet, they're like, "Oh yes! Love that. We have a similar game that also involves mallets and a ball."
Either way, the propieters of croquet watch a game of polo and are like "Dear gods. This is not similar to croquet. But we're glad you like it. ...We'll be sure to try out polo if we ever feel like playing a spectacularly dangerous version of team croquet."
Figwit specific thoughts under cut:
Figwit is decent at croquet when he's actually focused on playing, but he's usually distracted by conversation. If it's individual play, he doesn't care much about winning. The mistake he makes the most is getting the ball through a hoop but forgetting to line the shot up so that his ball is anywhere tactically useful afterward. He does much better at team croquet if his partner cares about winning.
Figwit is actually consistently decent at polo because it's fast-paced. He struggles with a lot of day-to-day, low stakes interactions but toss him in a high adrenaline / high stakes situation, and he's all right. The teams aspect of it also works better for him because the roles are more specialized. He's usually Position 4, which is the defensive position that protects the goal.
6 notes
·
View notes
Tenho dificuldade para achar uma foto ou ilustração para inspirar a aparência de Anoriel, principalmente por causa da heterocromia dela, mas postarei algumas inspirações ao longo dessa jornada, o resto é com a imaginação de vocês :)
Essa é uma delas, não sei quem é o artista ou se foi IA, mas eu amei ela.
7 notes
·
View notes