Diagnosing fictional characters is quite the challenge, but in working with kids who love anime, it can be par for the course and can open discussion about their own challenges. So, where to start with Kakashi:
*Note - kudos to Masashi Kishimoto, mangaka (manga creator) of Naruto. It looks like he did research and really did a pretty accurate representation of mental illness in his works and was respectful and humanizing in depiction.
*TW:suicidal ideation, panic attacks
Okay, as evidenced in several episodes, one would quite obviously conclude Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, PTSD. So, let's start with the elephant in the room that stares us in the face the whole series:
Criteria:
Exposure to trauma (death, injury, violence), learning about someone close experiencing trauma, and/or repeated exposure.
The wonderful skykashi has a beautifully written post delineating Kakashi's traumatic past. It's a must-read for those who want to know more about why Kakashi is the way he is.
2. At least one of these: intrusive thoughts, nightmares, flashbacks, emotional distress, physical reaction to triggers
3. Avoidance of triggers (people, places, or things that remind you of the event).
Okay, he did the opposite of avoiding. Instead of avoiding, he would spend literally HOURS at his friends' graves daily. However, this goes with the next criterion of self-blame, as yes, he would visit their graves and memorials daily, but would disparage himself every. single. day. For HOURS. Talk about how much of an "idiot" he was and become "stuck."
4. Negative cognitive or mood changes: not remembering what happened, negative beliefs about self, self-blame, negative emotional state (fear, shame, guilt), loss of interest in things that used to bring joy, detachment, inability to experience happiness or love
Even as an adult, in his late 20s/early 30s, he was still triggered/activated at times - unprocessed trauma does not go away, but can be treated and coping skills can help.
5. Altered reactions: irritability and anger, recklessness, hypervigilance (always on the lookout), easy to startle, can't concentrate, can't sleep
Hypervigilance. Context: Might Guy (friend in green suit) wanted to surprise Kakashi and hug him from behind. Kakashi tried to kill him, but then realized it was a friend, not foe.
In Anbu, he was known as "Cold-blooded Kakashi" due to his recklessness and general apathy. His friends sought to have him removed due to what they perceived as his being reckless and wanting to die.
6. Symptoms must last at least one month post exposure to traumatic event
So, when all is said and done, Kakashi would be deemed "clinically significant in meeting the criteria for a PTSD diagnosis"
Other diagnoses?
This is where it gets tricky.
Was Kakashi depressed?
Let's look at what depression is:
At least five: Depressed mood for at least two weeks, loss of interests in things once enjoyed, weight loss/gain, physical slow down, fatigue, feeling worthless, diminished concentration, thoughts of death/suicidal ideation.
Wait, but didn't he have a depressed mood for at least 2 weeks, didn't he lose interest in hanging with his friends? Didn't he feel worthless? Didn't he want to die? That's 4, right?
So, believe it or not, he was not clinically depressed. Doesn't meet the criteria. So what about those 4 symptoms? Look above. See symptoms 3, 4, and 5 of PTSD - Avoidance, change in mood, altered reactions? Ding, ding, ding.
This! This is why it's important to be your own advocate. If someone like Kakashi were to go to therapy, and did he ever need it, it would be so easy to be (mis)diagnosed with depression. However, once the trauma is brought into the forefront, the treatment and approach differs. So, in other words, SPEAK UP! Your therapist needs to know these things, so they can help you.
Anxiety?
Yes, Kakashi was notorious for had panic attacks at the worst moments, but c'mon. They're not predictable. So, did he have anxiety? Panic disorder? Were they panic attacks or anxiety attacks?
Being that they weren't 100% random and typically occurred in context, e.g., following the killing of a friend, thinking best friend had sacrificed himself, finding out dead friend is alive... his were in all likelihood PTSD/trauma-induced panic attacks, as panic attacks related to triggers are not uncommon with PTSD - unresolved trauma rears it's head again! See? Self-advocate!!
So, all that to say, and I know this is a hot take, but the "only," and I use the word "only" very lightly here as I would never downplay mental illness, diagnosis Kakashi Hatake would actually have is (untreated) PTSD and it wreaked havoc on his life. Someone needed therapy!
Next I'll do Naruto, since it's his show. But if there are any characters in any universe that you would like "analyzed," feel free to ask. In doing this, I've found that some people do find it makes their favorite characters more relatable and helps them feel they're not alone.
*Anyway, as usual, this post is for entertainment-educational purposes only. Please do not use this for mental health information. If you need mental health assistance, please speak to a local(!) qualified mental health professional. If you feel suicidal or need immediate help, please, in the US, call 988.
18 notes
·
View notes
NEW CHAPTER ALERT!~
This is a VERY hard one, so PLEASE mind the warnings and do not read if you can be triggered by it. You have a summary at the end notes, so you really don’t need to suffer just to know what happened.
If you need it, you have hot-lines to help with self-harm and suicide attempts. If you're not ready to confront the situation with other people, you can read about ways to help yourself (or others) here: https://www.autolesion.com/
It is an spanish webpage, but you can translate it, and I PROMISE there are really useful advices in here, some of which I have used myself, as well as described in this story. In case you have problem to find something, the most useful part is by clicking: Te Ayudamos -- Guía de Autolesión, there you can find a list of pages in case you need help, or you know someone that may need it.
I promise you the next chapter is way more happy and full of fluff. And the one I’m currently writing you cannot imagine (I’m basically vomiting rainbows with it(?)
I hope you enjoy the reading, and let me know what you think about it!
8 notes
·
View notes