Between the Lines- Ep. 5
Warnings- PG-13 due to Swearing and Explicit Language, Mature Themes, possible Violent References
Index
Ep. 4
I knew for sure that I’d cracked once the angry hecklers started rolling in and I just felt a sense of amusement. At this point, I wished that the case was as simple to solve as “the creepy strangers did it”. Maybe then I’d get my own life back.
Fuck, I should have just let her win the vote. If they really wanted me to go, why should I fight it? She wasn’t my friend, it really wasn’t my problem. I should just send her what I had and tell her to have fun. She could deal with her sister’s secret sins and I’ll go back to watching cat videos in all of my abundant spare time.
Frankly, Duskwood had brought me nothing but problems so far.
I snarked back at some of the strangers’ messages and when Dan accused Jake of running, I bit my tongue to prevent saying that the Hacker had started running before any of this started. I knew the accusations had the potential to become a real issue for me eventually, but why fight it? Jake was the only one who could do anything, and he’d decided to have nothing to do with me.
It’d take a while to become an issue for me anyway. Lilly didn’t know anything about me outside of my name and number and I wasn’t sure how long it would take for a video from a girl in Germany to make its way to the Mid-Western US but I suspected it’d be a bit, if at all. If she hadn’t linked the video in the chat, there was a chance I wouldn’t have seen it before I started getting attacked.
I was pretty surprised she knew Jake’s name though. Maybe he really had been Hannah’s lover, if her sister knew about him. Guess that would explain why he’d think it’s wrong— flirting with a random chick while investigating the disappearance of your secret girlfriend was impressively gross.
I distantly appreciated Richy’s attempts to cheer me up and Jessy asking for time off for a surprise. I played along despite myself, letting him think it was helping while thinking about how I’d have to get Jake to turn off spy mode at some point, I wouldn’t need it anymore. I didn’t really want to read about their lives once I was no longer involved.
When he did log on, I was distracted from asking him to do that by my surprise that he didn’t already know. Guess avoiding me extended as far as reading my chats. He agreed to take care of it, and that was that. Professional, cool, just like he wanted.
I felt my first real emotion since I’d cried my heart out to Annie, and it was rage. It swept over me with a force I didn’t know was possible. After everything, everything that I had given and done, for him… he told Lilly something about himself. Something he refused to share with the rest of the class.
I knew, what? That his hair was black, and he liked his islands to have internet. I’d thought knowing his name was special but apparently fucking not. And now, she’d thrown us under the bus to protect her friends and because of that, she got to know something I didn’t.
I couldn’t help myself, demanding he tell me. After all the time I’d spent making myself do little more than gently prod, teasingly, and accepting it when he’d deflect. I could barely see straight as I made it clear I was done waiting.
And though I didn’t tell him this, when he admitted he was wanted, part of me wasn’t at all surprised, considering it felt like the most obvious thing in the world. Nothing else fit his behavior, really, unless he really was a 17 year old Edgelord with a V for Vendetta fetish.
Despite the fact that I, on some level, already knew what he was telling me, the confession tamped down on some of my rage. Unfortunately, that only made room for the fear that his disappearance would cause. I didn’t know if it was fear for him, for me, for Hannah. But dread had settled in my chest, and I suspected it would stay for a while
___
Asking Dan about Jennifer was either a really good, or really bad idea. Only time would tell which. But I had my reasons. He’d proven to me with his drunken ramblings that he at least cared— giving me the info on the bracelet, admitting to helping Thomas get into Hannah’s apartment. He was bored enough at the hospital that despite his protests, I knew he’d make time to talk. Finally, he was the least likely to pull his punches. Jessy might be less likely to lie to me, but more likely to be careful about how she said things. Dan probably wouldn’t think before he talked.
He didn’t know much, but since he mentioned it as being a long time ago, similar to Hannah, I figured that for anyone who didn’t have the same level of trauma she seemed to have surrounding the event it was the first time they’d thought about it in ages.
I didn’t know if I believed that the killer wasn’t from Duskwood. It seemed to me a bit more likely that the decision was made out of discomfort, the same way that the news of the body had been tucked away in the paper.
Hannah would be too young to have likely been capable of murder, especially of an adult. It seemed more likely to me that her guilt stemmed from hiding something— maybe she’d witnessed it, or even helped cover it up.
Other than knowing for sure that Jennifer was dead, I didn’t get much to go on. Still, Dan seemed to enjoy the ego stroke of being the one I asked, so it wasn’t totally pointless. He was a big part of why I’d been allowed to stay, after all.
Richy trying to keep us from confronting Thomas about his toy trampling rage was either really sweet, or really suspicious. I couldn’t really decide which. Either way, Thomas definitely seemed to be losing it a bit. I was worried that confronting him might just make it worse, especially considering he’d already voted against me with Lilly. If he was even half as destructive as she was, it wasn’t worth the risk. Besides, I could definitely empathize with the desire to lose it right about now.
I couldn’t hold myself back from confiding in Richy and Jessy about the calls. I knew it was stupid, those should be something I keep close to my chest since I didn’t want to tip off the culprit that they were getting to me, but I just wanted some damn sympathy already. Jake had his reasons for not taking them seriously, and I knew that, but I needed someone to talk about Poor MC for a minute and let me whine.
Jessy, as always, was a superstar about it, immediately supporting me. And the solidarity from Richy made me smile, even if Jessy didn’t appreciate our coping methods.
Still, the fact that she immediately picked up on the fact that the caller was one of the group was surprising. She was by no means dumb, just a bit oblivious and I was surprised to see her doubt her friends unprompted. I’d wondered before if her willingness to believe the legend was at all related to the hope that no one she knew was guilty, so I hadn’t expected her to acknowledge any proof that implied otherwise.
Still, I didn’t know if letting that slip was a good idea, so I was mildly glad that Richy seemed to reject the idea. Not because I agreed, but because I’d been trying to keep the group from splintering and this would risk those efforts.
Dan’s attempts to deny responsibility for his accident got under my skin, but I clamped down on that and considered my response carefully. Of course I didn’t believe him, his story didn’t fit the M.O. in the slightest. There were no ties to the legend, no stalking or markings. So far, the kidnapper had been more direct, kidnapping Hannah, dumping the unknown body. They risked no ambiguity and took responsibility for their deeds-- at least behind the mask.
Still. I’d barely just started to make leeway with Dan. Did it make sense to feed into us delusions, let him pretend he didn’t make a stupid choice that endangered others and he was lucky to survive?
As a “friend”, and a person who generally cared? No, not at all. As an investigator, though. And with Jake gone and not reading along, I had to play both roles, so I bit back my more sarcastic retort and forced myself to smile at my phone.
“I believe you, Dan.”
And my BS came in handy, since not long after that he gave me Jennifer’s last name.
___
Annie had been managing the impressive feat of both avoiding me while somehow hovering. It was like being followed by a ghost— she said very little to me, maybe afraid of another emotional outburst, but always seemed to be keeping an eye on me.
Frankly, it was making me want to pull my hair out. I nearly snapped at her to leave me alone several times, but whenever I caught sight of her face—very worried and tense— I’d sigh and let it go.
So I was pleasantly surprised when she let me know she was going out one Wednesday afternoon just as I logged out of work. She explained it away as an appointment and errands, and I smiled in a way that probably didn’t reach my eyes as I waved her away with promises that I’d be fine.
Not twenty minutes later, it became clear why she’d been okay leaving me alone as a knock on the door pulled me from my podcast and mindless doodling. Opening the door without looking resulted in the air rushing out of me completely and a pair of sunglasses knocking me in the forehead before they fell off the top of my sister’s head.
“Em Em!” She cried excitedly, and my eyes widened in shock.
“Paige? What are you doing here?” I automatically moved aside to let her in, noticing the suitcase and extra large purse. We lived a bit far apart for a day visit, but the sheer size of her luggage made me suspicious.
“Can’t a girl visit her big sister?” She teased, batting her eyes as she set down her bags and retrieved her fallen sunglasses. Plopping them on the top of her head to push back her hair in a way that showcased her effortless beauty, she ran an appraising eye up and down my body. “You look like shit.”
“Gee, love you too, P.”
She shook her head and waved her hand dismissively at me as she started into the living room to get comfortable on the couch. “You know what I’m saying.”
I raised an eyebrow at her, not yet moving from my place by the door. “Right, not like you’ve ever insulted my looks before.”
She had the grace to look chagrined even though I’d been harassing her about it for years. She’d been rather tactless as a teenager, and had once asked me whether “all sisters considered themselves the ‘pretty one’” or was it just her. It was still something I thought about when I felt insecure, but I’d forgiven her for it long ago.
“You’re lovely,” she assured me. I knew I wasn’t grotesque, but I was far more plump than conventionally attractive, without the defined waist she’d been blessed with, and rather plain features. My most remarkable trait was my pile of curly brown hair that I considered a nuisance, but Paige had always envied compared to her fine, sleek hair that refused to hold a curl no matter how hard she worked at it.
Rolling my eyes, I finally moved away from the door and busied myself making tea rather than coffee since it was late enough in the day to make the latter a bit risky for mere mortals like her. “You’re not distracting me, flattery only gets you so far. Let me guess, Annie called you?”
“She was worried,” she grumbled by way of admission. “She said you’ve been down and acting weird. I’ve barely heard from you in weeks, and Dad said the same.”
I waved my hands in annoyance, the teabags flapping in the air with the movement. “How would he know? He replies once a month. If that.”
She shrugged. “Right, but you usually try.”
Despite knowing she was right, I felt irritation flash across my features. “Well excuse me if I got tired of my own father ignoring me. He’s off doing who the fuck knows what, and you’re not the most reliable at responding either you know. Why should I reach out if it’s pointless?” I snapped hotly.
She came over and wrapped her arms around my waist from behind, pushing up on her toes slightly to rest her chin on my shoulder. “M. It’s not like that.”
“No?” I asked. “How often do you reach out first if it’s not to ask for help with something?”
“I’m sorry. I know I should try harder. It’s just…”
I knew what it was. In her teen years, I’d become a weird mom-sister hybrid. Even once I’d moved away, she still saw me as something of an authority figure despite our three year difference starting to mean less and less in terms of the disparity in our life experience. Between that and her busy schedule, I mostly heard from her when she crashed her car or needed to find a doctor for something, as well as the occasional drunk dial when she was trying to avoid calling her ex.
In the last year, she’d finally been able to move from working at a makeup counter and doing prom looks to getting more gigs around her real passion. She’d landed a few low-budget indie films, some photo shoots where she’d been given more creative control, and local plays with larger audiences. That meant her work hours were pretty chaotic, and since I normally had the sleep needs of your average 80-year-old, it made it hard to find time we were both available. I usually tried to text something every now and then for her to see when she woke up, and she would send me pictures of new looks she was experimenting with.
In her off time she wore little-to-no makeup herself, quoting an airy “if you’re good at something, never do it for free,” but I knew that really it was at least partially because she much preferred techniques that were dramatic rather than pretty. When we were young, she’d always whine until I let her do my makeup for any costume party, silly event or Halloween, and as we got older it went from face paint whiskers to dramatic interpretations of sea creatures and mystical spirits. They weren’t always very nice looking, one or two could even be considered grotesque, but they always impressed at the parties I went to.
She’d also fooled my dad into letting her skip school several times using her “pale and drawn” look, which subsequently had become one of her most practiced by the time she graduated.
I, meanwhile, was still working on keeping liquid eyeliner marginally straight.
I was proud of her, how could I not be? But I’d often been jealous of her passion, and how easily she’d found what she wanted to do with her life. Getting there was hard work, but figuring it out had been simple. I’d so far only discovered what I didn’t want to do, and a couple of things I didn’t totally hate.
The tea steeped as we stood there together, and once I snapped out of my reverie and decided it had brewed enough, I moved both mugs to the counter and pulled up a bar stool. She grabbed herself the milk and sugar and mixed her tea to her liking as I began to sip mine plain.
She let me muse into my tea as long as she could— she was the only person I knew who was worse at silence than I was. “I planned for a week visit if that’s okay with you. Annie already ok’d it, I asked when she called since I knew you guys used to fight about her having people over too much.”
I raised my eyebrows. I don’t think she’d spent a week with me total since I’d moved nearly ten years before. What had Annie told her?
“I also promised plenty of gifts to bribe her with. Some makeup samples, booze, some random autographs I planned to use as Christmas gifts when I felt like being cheap.” She grinned at me, knowing that my roommate was easily swayed by fashion and men.
I snorted and rolled my eyes, thinking back to the times she and Annie had gotten drunk together over the few visits she’d made out here.
Seizing on that tiny crack in my mood, she ran over to my side of the counter and took my hand with a mischievous glint in her eye. “Come on, I want to try a new look your coloring is perfect for.”
Leaving no room for argument, she dragged me out of the kitchen.
___
I should have figured there was some kind of ulterior motive, because as soon as I was seated and she’d set up all of the products she wanted me to use, she started in on me.
“So you gunna tell me what has Annie all worked up?”
I tried to look away but she grabbed my chin and pulled me back into the correct position as she started rubbing something onto my skin.
“I’m just stressed Paige,” I said, knowing she’d never believe it if I tried to say nothing. “Work is rough lately and I don’t know, I just haven’t been in the best mood.”
“Right but she said you cried. Breakdown level cried. Are you still taking your meds? What about therapy?”
I had to mumble to talk without moving my jaw as she painted on something to “sharpen my lines”, whatever that means. “Meds, yes, therapy, no,” I answered briefly to keep my movements to a minimum.
She backed up for a second and eyed her progress at different angles. “Think you maybe should do therapy again?”
I shrugged, earning a small tap on my shoulder in reproach. “It’s situational. I cried once, Paige. I’m not having a crisis.”
“Aren’t you? Look, you don’t have to tell me if you don’t want. I’m just… worried, okay? I remember how you got back then and I know how easy it would be to go back there.”
“I’m older now, and stronger. It’s nothing I can’t handle.” Even to my own ears it rang false.
She closed her eyes for a second and sighed— it looked like she was trying to steady herself. “MC. I’m not calling you weak. But I know you. You complain more when you’re healthy, it’s when things are bad that you hide. I know you think of me as a kid. Hell, I act like it sometimes. But I can take it, please.”
I searched her face. My heart broke at the sadness and hurt I saw in it. There was fear there, too. I hadn’t realized that my bad depressive episode had impacted her that badly. I’d thought she was too young to really grasp it at the time, but she was right, I had always seen her as a kid. And she hadn’t been for a while.
Looking up at my beautiful, impulsive, creative sister and finally seeing an adult, I carefully started speaking.
I glossed over some things, especially where Jake was concerned, just saying that the guy I’d been working closely with had been put in danger by the video and he had to stop investigating for a while. I downplayed some of the threats I’d gotten, too, not wanting to scare her too much.
But I told her about Jessy and her ready acceptance of me. Of how the rest of the group regarded me with suspicion even though they’d brought me in, but she took almost no time to befriend me. I told her about the flirting with Jake, how it started mostly teasing but I got attached. How it seemed like he felt the same but said it wouldn’t work. I attributed it to the distance and the case, but the sting of rejection still rang clear in my voice.
I told her about Hannah, and the things I’d found (luckily she didn’t ask how I’d found them, tech wasn’t her thing either) and how I felt like I was learning things she never wanted anyone to know. How I felt like she was taking over my life but I was too invested to stop now. We went over Dan’s accident, Richy getting marked, Cleo being harassed. By the time I finished, my mouth was dry from talking so much, and she’d stopped working on my face to just stare at me with something akin to horror.
Her concern was palpable, and I couldn’t blame her. Saying everything out loud only made it more clear just how deep I’d gotten myself, and how little sense it made.
“They have… police… in Germany. Right?” She asked haltingly.
“Well, yes,” I acknowledged. “But there doesn’t seem to have been any progress for a while, and her friends are really worried. If I can help, why shouldn’t I?”
She knelt down in front of me, compassion filling her eyes. “MC, I mean this with all of the love in the world. But why should you? There are thousands of missing women in the world right now. Millions, maybe. You can’t save them all. You probably can’t save any of them. It’s wearing you down, and you know it.”
“I’m too far in for that, P. I know how it looks. And I should have left when it started, but I didn’t. It’s too late now.”
She wanted to argue more— we spent our teen years doing little else beyond fighting so I’d probably seen that look on her face more than any other at this point— but something in my tone, or maybe the set of my jaw, made her shoulders sag in resignation.
She picked her brush back up instead. “Alright, then. Let’s get you finished here and we’ll chat about the guy instead.”
___
It took another hour to finish, though at least some of that was because she had to stop more than once to laugh at me (or him) for just how bad we were at it.
“What the hell happened to you, M? You’ve always been awkward, but this is just a whole new level.”
I shrugged, my eyes closed to keep them safe from the setting spray she was spritzing. “I think I got worse at it as we went, actually.”
She turned me a bit and started twisting my hair into something that almost looked like a braid. She didn’t work with hair professionally, she just hated my constant messy bun. “You know, that makes a lot of sense for you. Originally you didn’t give a fuck. That’s when you’re most charming. Remember Andrew?”
I felt my face heat up under what seemed like the amount of makeup I normally wore in a year. “I THOUGHT WE WERE KIDDING!” I nearly shouted.
She chuckled at my embarrassment. “I know, and yet you ruined that poor boy. He still asks about you sometimes.”
I’d have buried my face in my hands if she hadn’t tightened her fist into a death grip around my hair when she felt me start to tip my head down. “Don’t you dare!” She scolded, tying off the ends and doing a final once-over to make sure she was pleased. She must have been, because she stood me up and turned me toward the mirror.
I gasped as I looked at myself. True to norm whenever she was able to do what she wanted, no one would ever be able to call the look pretty. But it was breathtaking. She’d somehow managed to make my normally round, chubby features look sharp, harsh. The only overt references to the ice motif she’d planned were two small snowflakes she’d drawn, one over my left eyebrow and one on my jaw, just below where the right side of my lips ended.
The majority of the makeup was various shades of white, including my lashes, but my lips were a metallic silver. I was shocked to see that my eye makeup transitioned between a dark blue into jade, rather than the lighter blue or silver I’d have expected.
She saw me inspect the eyes and grinned. “I did some research on icebergs. In Antarctica they’ve found green ones. They think it has to do with the amount of iron in the area. It changes the way the ice absorbs different colors of light.”
“So I’m the nerd, but you just… research icebergs for fun?”
She laughed and nudged me with her hip. “Do you like it?”
I nodded. “It’s amazing. I don’t look anything like me, I have no clue how you do it. But didn’t you say my colors were “fall and earthy” or some shit? Why am I perfect for this?”
She smirked. “Mainly because you never leave the house or get sun, so I had to use less of the base on you.”
Smacking her arm lightly, I reached for my phone to take a few pictures. She took it out of my hand and started trying to pose me how she liked it best, adjusting the lighting to get the shadows to cast the way she liked.
Once she was finally pleased with the pictures she got, she sent some to herself for her portfolio and handed me back my phone, which I used to order takeout. We got along much better than we used to, but all it took was one of us becoming hangry to reduce us to squabbling teens again, and I suspected Annie wouldn’t be amused to return to a WWF match.
While we waited for the food, we sat on the couch and I turned on some music. We mainly scrolled on our phones, but it was nice to not be alone.
“It needs a lot of work,” she grumbled, looking at the pictures for the fourth time in the last ten minutes. “It really only works in print right now, since the shading on your jaw and cheekbones isn’t dynamic. If you move, it completely destroys the effect.”
I shrugged. “Most of your models will also have the jaws and cheekbones to make it more convincing. I’ve just got a baby-face. Though at my age I’m pretty sure it’s not baby fat anymore no matter what Mom said…”
“Sure, but the part I like is the transformation.” Her eyes sparkled as she flipped through her picture to show me more examples, many of which I’d seen on her professional account already. She had a modest, but rather faithful following, myself included. I’d long since stopped being her main model, but I did still pop up in some progress posts or the occasional Throwback Thursday. “It’s not just about the end result, it’s about how dramatic the difference is.”
I jumped up at the knock on the door, but couldn’t resist a retort over my shoulder. “You always were all about the drama.”
She snorted. “Am I the one in love with a literal stranger who I maybe know what country he’s in?”
The moment was temporarily broken by the alarmed look on the poor delivery driver’s face. It took me a moment to realize it wasn’t at Paige’s words, but my face. I’d forgotten that I hadn’t washed it off yet. “Sorry,” I mumbled as he quickly retreated with one last glance over his shoulder.
“Guess people don’t usually answer the door in costume when it’s months before Halloween,” she teased.
“You didn’t remind me on purpose!” I accused while I plopped the pizza box on the kitchen counter.
After that, we were mostly quiet for a while as we ate. She occasionally tutted at me when I’d get pizza on my face and come away with makeup on my napkin, but other than making fun of me for eating like a child, she didn’t say much else.
It wasn’t until I was rinsing the dishes that she spoke up. “His name is Jake, then?”
I whirled around and gaped at her. “What?”
She held up her phone, showing a still of Lilly’s video. It wasn’t on YouTube, but I didn’t recognize the site she was on. Someone must have downloaded the video before Jake convinced her to delete it.
“You said she included your number, and the missing girl’s name was Hannah. Made for a pretty easy search, really.”
“Since when are you a detective?” I grumbled.
“I could ask the same of you, M.”
I guess I couldn’t argue there. But it was disturbing how quickly she found it. I’d thought having it taken down would be a bit more like it hadn’t happened. Richy had said that the views were up to 4k or so, and as surprising as it was that it got that many that fast, that was still a small number. But things on the internet were sticky, and it only took one person to keep it alive.
“Right, well. Yes. His name is Jake.”
She arched an eyebrow. “And he’s clearly involved in some… stuff. He sounds a bit different here than you made him seem.”
“I mean, I sound pretty different through Lilly’s eyes, too. Look. I wont say he’s nice, or that he’s not weird, or even a little creepy. And yes, some of the things we’ve been doing aren’t the most… legal. But it’s not like it’s the first time that’s been true.”
“MC, this isn’t smoking some pot and running around after curfew. Have you read some of the comments on this?”
I cringed. “I tried not to after the ones on the original video. But I imagine the ones about him are about as accurate as the ones about me. I apparently run an international prostitution organization, you know.” I tried to say that one casually, since that had been one of the more ridiculous accusations I had thrown at me.
“Right, but several of these are saying he’s wanted. And you told me yourself he’s disappeared because of the video. You said it put him in danger.”
I blanched. His wanted status being publicly discussed probably wasn’t good. And not just because my sister was staring at me like I’d grown an extra head. I glanced at her out of the corner of my eye as I decided that I may as well wash the dishes now.
“You knew,” she accused, coming over to the sink. “You knew he was on the run.”
“Only after the video,” I admitted in a tiny voice, not looking up from the sponge in my hands.
“I thought you were done with this,” she exploded, and I stared at her in shock. “It made sense in high school, okay? Running around with the bad boys in combat boots and Mohawks. But do you remember the shit you got into sometimes? Now you’re involved with a fugitive and you can’t even pretend you don’t know better!”
“We’re not involved!” I yelled back. “I told you he rejected me. Well, this is why. He said it was too dangerous.”
She huffed, crossing her arms over her chest. “Well at least one of you might not be a total idiot, then.”
I bit the inside of my cheek as I scrubbed circles over the over washed plate. My eyes blurred with tears and I tried to blink them away.
“MC,” she started again, but was interrupted by me bursting into tears without warning. Forgetting her anger, she walked over to me and took me in her arms, muttering soothing words as she led me away from the sink.
___
She was playing with my hair, my head in her lap, when she finally spoke up. “I can pull some strings, if you want. It’d take some convincing, I’d owe a few favors. But I still talk amiably enough to some of my old clients. We could fight fire with fire, post a response video.”
I thought for a minute. It’d feel great to fight back. I hadn’t realized just how angry I was at Lilly until I saw her video again and heard about what people were saying. I hadn’t felt this type of impotent rage since our mom had been diagnosed.
“No,” I said finally, not fully keeping the hesitation out of my voice. “I think at this point that would just make me look more suspicious. Right now, her accusations look ridiculous to anyone with half a brain. She has no proof. She doesn’t even know where I am, exactly. But it would just draw more attention to the first video and probably make things worse for Jake.”
Her eyes narrowed when I brought him up. “He can figure his own shit out. I’m talking about for you.”
“I know, and I love you for it. But I care about him too. I feel bad enough that I told you all this about him, I can’t risk making his life harder.”
She scratched my scalp, then twisted a lock of my hair around her finger. “You didn’t tell me shit, to be fair. She did. Which is part of why I’m worried about it.”
“You don’t have to worry about me.”
Her laugh was humorless. “Yeah, sure, okay. Look, I won’t pull the trigger yet, but I’m going to reach out to a few people I think might be willing to help. I won’t tell them anything other than I might need a favor. If it gets worse, you need to tell me, and we’ll figure something out. If this gets too bad, you could lose your job. It doesn’t have to be true, just has to make them look bad.”
I didn’t respond, just closing my eyes and enjoying the affection. Despite my rather prickly personality, I had always enjoyed physical contact with the people I was closest to, and that was something I couldn’t get easily from behind a screen.
“I want to meet them,” Paige announced, startling me from my light doze.
“Who?”
“The group. Maybe not Lilly, I’d rather not join you under that bus if I can help it. But the others, at least. I want to have some idea who I can tell the police to talk to if you go missing next.”
I bit my lip. Much like fighting back, it was tempting. My sister was better at people than I was, and it would be nice to get help while Jake was gone. But Jake would also never approve of bringing someone new in. Not to mention, I couldn’t risk her getting the same calls I was or putting her in danger.
That was the part that made me refuse her offer.
“I can’t put you in danger too. Jake thinks it’s one of them and I’m not sure I agree, but it’s hard to totally deny with the timing of things.”
Her fingers stilled. “You’re knowingly talking to a kidnapper, too?”
“Well, not knowingly. I just said we don’t know for sure.”
“But probably!” Her voice had become shrill, I guess she’d finally reached her limit of my bullshit. “This is insane, MC, you’ve gone insane. I get you’re safer because you’re not there, but that’s not safe. It would be expensive for them to get here but not all that hard if they have a passport. And look.”
She typed my name and number in to Google and scrolled to the third result. And there it was. A “people search” website with my address, and a couple of past ones, too. My age, some old phone numbers. Worst of all, under the “related person” section, links to my loved ones: My parents, Paige, even an ex I’d lived with for a while.
“Oh,” I muttered, scrolling through in horror.
I knew these sites existed. Hell, I’d used them years ago, to find contact people for the funeral. But the idea that a murderer with a vendetta could be using them didn’t really occur to me until now.
“You can opt out of these things, right?” I started searching the page for anything related to removal, my hands shaking as I did so.
“MC, MC, calm down!” She took her phone from my hands. “You’re fine, it’s fine. We’ll work on that tonight, and you can ask your hacker boyfriend where else to look.”
I scrunched up my face and mumbled “not my boyfriend” as she locked her phone screen and set it aside.
“I can’t stop you from doing this,” she sighed. “And I know you won’t stop. But please, take care of yourself, okay? And don’t push me away.”
I nodded, and she put her arm around my shoulder, then exhaled dramatically. “Shit, is being the mature one always this stressful?”
I laughed, pushing her away from me. “You mean like the time you got high and were convinced Mrs. Ruth’s bushes were fluffy enough that you could jump off the roof into them and be fine?”
She groaned at the memory and then stuck her tongue out at me. “And yet you’ve managed to out-stupid me with this one. Never thought I’d see the day!”
___
True to her word, once I’d calmed down a bit, we sat on my bed with a bottle of wine and spent the entire night purging as much data as we could. I left my social media mostly alone, since I’d stopped over-sharing personal stuff on those ages ago and had deleted a lot of the old stuff. But anything with addresses, or detailed location information had to go.
My employer was a national company, but I disabled my professional profiles, too, figuring I could always reactivate those when I started looking for a job next.
Paige had decided to take the opportunity to scrub her name, too. She would always need to have a larger online presence than I would, since a lot of her gigs were based on word of mouth and networks, but I felt better knowing that she’d be less at risk now that she knew more about the danger.
She hadn’t brought up wanting to meet everyone again, and I still wasn’t totally sold on throwing her into the line fire. But at this point, I felt confident enough that the culprit was a man that I figured she could probably meet Jessy. Cleo, too, since we’d been getting more friendly.
So I made a new group chat. I’d had enough wine by this point that the idea of naming the chat amused me, but had also had enough that coming up with something clever was difficult. So that was how I ended up making a group chat titled “All The Single Ladies” and adding Jessy, Cleo, and Paige.
Jessy is online.
Jessy: ?
MC: Sooooo
MC: My sister found Lilly’s video.
MC: You can imagine how hoppy she was.
MC: *happy
MC: She wanted to meet you guys.
MC: I decided to only show her the best of the group to start
Jessy: 🤭
Cleo is online.
Cleo: Hello, MC’s sister.
MC: Oh, she has a name.
MC: It’s Paige.
Next to me, Paige snorted.
Paige: Hello, MC’s internet friends.
Paige: I’m glad to meet at least some of you.
Jessy: Wait 😤
Jessy: Why are we the Single Ladies??
MC: I mean, aren’t we? 🤣
Paige: 🤦♀️
MC: I never said I was good at thinking of things.
Paige: I’m sure the wine isn’t helping that. You’ve had, what, 4 glasses?
MC: YOU POUR SO LITTLE IN.
Paige: That’s how you’re supposed to drink wine.
Cleo: Wait, are you two together?
MC: Yep! She came to visit!
Feeling silly, I took a picture of us and sent it to the chat.
Jessy: Hi Paige!
Jessy: I do have to go to work though, so I can’t talk much.
With a jolt, I looked over at my clock and realized it was 1am. Time had flown way faster than I’d thought.
MC: Shit, I have to start work in like 6 hours guys.
Jessy: Ooooh you’re gonna be cranky.
Paige: When isn’t she?
MC: Hey! I’m great.
Paige:😒
MC: ANYWAY. Go do your days guys, I just wanted to do this before I forgot. ❤️
Cleo: Good night!
After downing my glass of wine, I took a quick shower, leaving my hair unwashed. Paige was the morning-shower sort, but I hated waking up earlier than I absolutely had to, even to get clean.
While I was brushing my teeth, I couldn’t get away from the thought that my sister was right. If I was going to spend a chunk of time trying to clean up my information, it didn’t make sense not to ask for advice from the resources I had. I hadn’t wanted to worry him since he had problems of his own, but I could just ask, right?
MC: Hey so my sister knows about Lilly’s video. It’s fine. I mean okay not fine, she’s pissed, but she’ll deal. Anyway we spent the night trying to get rid of my address and stuff online. Those people search sites are bullshit. Anyway I thought you might know what else I could do, since I don’t know how much googling “how to hide from the murderer who is mad at you” would get me. No rush. Thanks!
I hit send and immediately regretted it. Not only was it the longest piece of word vomit I’d sent him by far, it made almost no sense. Hopefully his flaw would keep him from noticing whatever the mess of emotions was that had gone into that. Especially as I couldn’t even decipher them, myself.
I had time to lean over and spit before he replied.
Jake: I will take care of it.
MC: Oh no, I know you’re busy and stuff. You just know the internet a tiny bit better than I do so you might have advice.
Jake: MC. I’ll take care of it.
I had no idea why a silly grin spread across my face at that, but it stayed through the rest of my washing up. Even Paige’s suspicious glances as I crawled back into bed couldn’t get me to fully smother it.
___
I was surprisingly coherent the next day. Getting out of bed took longer than usual, but once I was up, I found myself less drained than I would have expected. Even having Paige there helped me focus on my work a bit better. At least, she could keep me updated on the Single Ladies chat enough that I wouldn’t feel the need to constantly check my phone.
I had the most productive morning I’d had in a long time, working to the soundtrack of my sister’s sarcasm and laughter. She told me stories of her life, ranted about something she found online, and occasionally pestered me just to remind me she was the little sister. Any time I wasn’t actively listening to a call, she filled the silence and it wasn’t nearly as annoying as I normally would have found it.
An hour or so before lunch, she made an excited noise in the back of her throat and turned to smile at me. “Those sites work fast!” She announced. “They already took down your profiles, I can’t find a single one!”
I bit back a smirk and acted surprised as she showed me the missing search results. Hers, too, were gone, and I felt a flood of gratitude at the effort he must have put in, even above what I’d asked.
When she looked away, I typed a quick “thank you”, knowing he’d understand.
___
The rest of the week dragged on a bit more. She mostly worked for herself at this point, so she made her own schedule, but she couldn’t totally vanish or risk missing future jobs. So the more convinced she became that I wasn’t on the verge of a breakdown, the more time she spent on her laptop or taking calls, and in the evening I often ended up covered in makeup again to keep her profiles active.
Unlike Annie, she knew better than to try to force me to go out of the house, but she tried to keep me busy regardless. We cooked, despite neither of us enjoying or being any good at it. We watched movies and played games. The truth is, I hadn’t thought about just how much I’d missed her. We’d had a rocky relationship as kids— we were very different people in ways that had seemed so important when we were younger, and the stress of our chaotic adolescence and there never being enough money to afford enough space for us both had added a lot of tension to our interactions.
But she really had grown up, and even though I was still prickly and unpleasant and she was still a lot more outgoing and loud than I was, we’d learned to read each other better in the intervening years enough that we could have fun.
“Alright you guys, so tell me about this hacker,” she demanded loudly to Jessy and Cleo, whose faces appeared on my tablet, as she blended something on my forehead.
I jumped a little, she hadn’t actually mentioned him in days and I’d been hoping, foolishly, that she’d forgotten.
Out of the corner of my eye, I could see Cleo screw up her face while Jessy giggled at mine.
“Why would we talk about him?” Cleo asked, bewildered. Right. I guess it had just been Jessy that I’d had that humiliating conversation with.
Paige laughed, pinning her hair back on top of her head to keep it from sliding in her face as she bent over me. “If my sister’s going to be pining after him, I want to get some opinions first.”
“What?!” Cleo shouted, her eyes almost comically wide at the idea.
“Thanks Paige,” I groaned, biting the inside of my cheek to fight the overwhelming urge to hide my face in my hands. Louder, I spoke to the whole group. “I’m not chasing after him. I expressed an interest, he said no, I accepted it. Now we’re just friends, if you can even call it that. We talk about Hannah.”
I could have continued rambling, but Paige chose that moment to take my chin in her hands and hold my face steady enough to work on.
“Accepted it my ass,” she teased, taking advantage of my inability to fight back.
Meanwhile, Cleo’s befuddlement continued. “Wait, he rejected you? The Hacker? The one who took over the group chat just to keep you in it? He said he didn't like you?”
I pulled my jaw from Paige’s grip for a second to reply to that. “You guys read way too much into that vote thing, he’s just put a lot of effort into the investigation and didn’t want to risk having to do it alone if none of you would talk to me anymore. And it wasn’t like he said ew cooties gross. He just made it clear it wasn’t happening.”
Jessy chimed in there, “I’m still pretty sure he’s 60 or something and that’s why. He sure talks like it.”
I rolled my eyes at her, but didn’t bother interrupting or annoying Paige to reply to that one.
“Has he ever even said how he knows Hannah? MC, he had to tell you, right?”
I made a loud noise that I hope sounded enough like “no” to be understood. Luckily, they seemed to get it.
Jessy gasped. “Wait what were the initials on the bracelet? J.H., right? That’s why you asked me? Didn’t Lilly say his name was Jake? MC, what’s his last name?”
Another noise, this time to the tune of “I don’t know”. Then I looked at Paige. “Are we almost done?”
I guess understanding that particular unintelligible murmur was a necessary skill in her trade, because she nodded and started putting away most of the bottles and powders in front of her. “Almost.”
I sighed, and turned back to the video call to take advantage of my temporary freedom. “I don’t know his last name, but honestly, I’m not sure I think he’s much of the wooing-with-jewelry sort.”
Paige nudged me over to face her again. “Good thing you hate jewelry then, huh?” She blotted and spritzed my face with a bit more of a flourish than she’d used in our past sessions, then looked me over with a grin.
I started to stand up to look, but Paige shook her head. “Nu uh, pictures first!”
I eyed her suspiciously— that had never been the process before. Still, I obediently smiled the way she told me and glared at her as she looked over the pictures with a critical expression.
“One of you two should make sure this Hacker guy gets that, see if he regrets saying no!” She exclaimed with a mischievous glance in my direction.
“What??” I squeaked, grabbing my phone to see what she sent.
If I weren’t so annoyed about her underhanded tactics, I’d have been more impressed by what she’d managed to achieve with my face. We’d taken long enough that I’d expected to be a unicorn or something like that. Instead, it actually barely looked like I was wearing anything at all, at least if you didn’t know how I usually looked. My skin tone was unchanged, just smoothed out and brightened the tiniest bit. The lipstick was subtle, but plumping. The most dramatic part was my eyes, but even that mainly just made them pop and look more vibrant than normal.
I wasn’t beautiful, but it was a hell of a lot closer than I usually was.
Jessy’s excited squeal confirmed it for me. “MC, you look so good! But Paige, we don’t have his number or anything. He always just contacts us.”
“That’s right!” I said, relieved. “I’m probably the only one who can message him directly, and no way in hell am I sending him a random picture of myself in full makeup just to sit around my house. I will never be that desperate.” I hoped. But I kept that unsaid.
Cleo chimed in, amused. “You’re assuming he hasn’t already seen it. What was it he said? Be aware that all of your digital activities are monitored and recorded by me.”
Sure enough, he was online. Then again, if he were reading, or even worse, listening, this was the kind of thing he’d definitely have logged off to avoid already.
“He doesn’t bother with personal stuff. There’s no way he’s spending his time reading a chat called All the Single Ladies, okay? He doesn’t care that much about us gossiping.”
Paige stared at me for a long moment as if assessing more than my makeup, and then sighed loudly. “We really need to work on your daddy issues, you know that, right?”
“PAIGE!” I shouted and started hitting her with a folded towel, brandishing it like I would a pillow at a sleepover. She just cackled as she put her hands up to protect her face.
I never did tell her that I took a handful more pictures before washing my face. I couldn’t let her win like that.
___
Paige left the next morning, and Annie was still gone, having tried to make herself scarce during the visit to give us time. I took the day off work to let us hang out before she went, but ultimately found myself unnerved by how quiet the apartment seemed now that she was gone.
I turned on music and cranked it up as loud as I felt comfortable with considering the neighbors, and danced around as I cleaned up the evidence of our irresponsibility over the last week. It was amazing how much of a mess we could make.
When Cleo texted me directly, rather than the group chat, my heart sank. I’d asked her and Jessy both to try to keep Paige out of the scarier parts of the investigation, and while she’d been nosy enough to pull some information out of the group, they’d mostly obliged and kept All the Single Ladies light and teasing, mainly at my expense.
So if she didn’t include anyone else, I knew it wasn’t good. She told me about the ransom-style letter her mother had gotten, and my initial reaction was to roll my eyes. Sometimes it felt like I was dealing with a child imitating a criminal.
Then she sent the pictures that were included.
Those pictures made my heart drop. Paige’s visit had done a lot to make me feel safe and normal, but now the truth came screaming back to me. Neither was true. There was still a kidnapper, still a missing girl, still a dead body.
This was the second time he’d gone for Cleo.
Of course her mom couldn’t just ignore them. The culprit has played dirty here, and hit on the right button. No mother would be willing to risk their child like that. My own would have locked me in the basement if she’d found out about a single one of those calls, let alone received pictures.
Cleo herself seemed more worried for her mother than herself, which I could understand. Wasn’t I more worried for Hannah’s friends, and even Paige, than myself?
While telling the group about the canceled search, I was nearly knocked off my feet by the fact that it was Dan who came to the conclusion that Hannah was in the forest. I’d been underestimating him for a while, it seemed. It wasn’t a hard conclusion to make, necessarily, but I hadn’t even realized he was paying enough attention to see the forest thread. Maybe I’d need to start involving him in things a bit more often.
I put a pin in that to examine later. While he was exonerated from the more recent happenings, he was probably the most physically capable of an abduction of the group. Or had been before he flipped his car, at least. Now he probably couldn’t pee without multiple people knowing, let alone hurt anyone. That made it a bit easier to trust him.
While texting with Jessy, a roller coaster complete with hearing her wish we’d met in another way, then accuse Jake, then get mad at me for keeping his secrets, I found myself retreating back into that numb detachment from before Paige’s visit.
It was an addicting place, I knew from experience. The emotional equivalent of a blanket fort, where the monsters couldn’t get you. Oh, I’d been in therapy long enough to know it for what it was— my brain’s reaction to extreme stress, a protective cocoon to keep me safe from the inevitable breakdown I was flying towards. I’d been given tools to recognize and stop it years ago, after hearing enough times about the dangers of disconnecting like this for long.
As an adult, I’d stopped letting myself risk staying there for any real length of time. Maybe for an hour, enough to get through a difficult confrontation, or hold myself together until I could get somewhere that it was safe to cry. I knew this place was what had some people scrambling to stay high or drunk. Blessed nothing was a godsend to those who felt too much, and it took a will stronger than mine to let it go once it started.
And today I couldn’t bring myself to walk away from it. I tucked the vulnerable parts of myself into bed— the parts that cared, and felt, and hoped— and gave it a small kiss on the forehead. A promise that the rest of me— logical, rational, and disinterested— would take over and keep away the demons.
I could remember where this had led in the past, but with a small, exhausted yawn, the side of me that cared fell asleep and the rest trudged forward.
Luckily, after Jessy had left me with that final plea to keep myself safe from Jake (done, I told myself. Just not how she meant), no one needed anything else from me for the day. As day bled into evening and I felt confident that everyone I knew on the other side of the world had gone to bed, I straightened up my room to clear the mess that my focus on the case— and just general irresponsibility— had left in its wake.
After that was done, I sat at my desk and logged in to work. Office hours were long since over, but I wasn’t tired yet and if I put in some time today, I’d be able to reclaim some of the PTO I’d wasted recently on self-pity and sadness.
I got a lot done compared to usual, without my phone or drifting thoughts I was moving through my tasks faster than I had in ages, almost completely clearing the backlog I’d accumulated over the last several weeks.
I forgot how much energy giving a fuck took, I thought dryly, snorting out loud despite being alone.
The notification lighting up my phone was almost masked by the flicker of my monitors as I powered everything down.
Joe: Hey
Joe: been a while, how’s it been?
It had been a while, long enough that the unexpected text almost jolted me out of my safe place. I closed the imaginary door just in time and recovered quickly.
MC: It really has. Work has kept me busy, and my sister was in town this last week and just left today.
Joe: Annie said that this weekend. Are you free tomorrow?
Joe: dinner, maybe?
I considered his offer silently, tapping the fingers of my right hand on my desk as I stared at my screen. Truthfully, I had reasons enough to both say yes and no. On one hand, he was nice enough. We hadn’t spent a whole lot of time talking overall, but enough that I had some kind of picture of him. At least I could picture him, I mused. We didn’t have much in common that I’d found so far, but we’d mainly discussed unimportant, surface things.
On the other, life was currently complicated enough, and adding someone new would just make it worse. But it also might be nice to add someone whose motives I didn’t have to question beyond knowing he wanted to get his dick wet.
Before I could reply and say yes, he sensed my hesitation and continued.
Joe: Annie said you’ve been hung up on some guy. I’m not gunna try to get between that if there’s something. Or if you just don’t want to.
Joe: just seemed like you were maybe into it at one point so I should ask
I was really going to have to talk to Annie about what she was discussing with people behind my back. But still…
MC: No, um, I thought there was but he made it clear that there wasn’t.
MC: I’m still dealing with it a little, though
Joe: totally get it we’ve all been there.
Joe: not pressuring you or anything. Just think you’re cute and want to see you again. No expectations
Joe: take your time and let me know
He was right. We had all been there. Maybe the circumstances surrounding Jake and I had been somewhat unique, but “girl likes boy, boy can’t/doesn’t want/won’t do anything about it” happened all the time.
Sitting around, sad and pining, didn’t help anyone and just made it that much harder for us to focus on the investigation. The best thing I could do at this point was to do something to clear my mind and make it easier to move on.
MC: You know what? Dinner sounds nice. How’s 7?
___
The work I’d done the night before made my day surprisingly easy, especially for a Friday. By lunch, my queue was clean, I’d organized my inbox, and stared at my screen for a while.
I’d spent so long glued to my phone that my hand strayed over toward it several times while I looked for things to do. I wasn’t avoiding it, exactly, but trying to take the opportunity to just be uninvolved with Duskwood for a bit. It had been quiet since the letter, other than Dan sending memes to everyone and the smaller chat with the Ladies, and I’d avoided engaging with either so far today.
Maybe part of me felt guilty about that, or didn’t know what to do without corpses and mystery hanging over my head, but either way I ended up turning off my music and swapping over to one of my true crime podcasts. I’d been staying away from them ever since my life became one, but I really had always enjoyed them. Getting back to them might make me feel more normal again.
I gave up on pretending to be productive for a while and wandered to my room, getting a head start on deciding what to wear. I had no idea where we were going other than “dinner”. Depending on how much Annie had told him about me already (other than apparently everything), it was possible he knew enough already to avoid taking me anywhere fancy. It wasn’t a “not like other girls” thing so much as generally not being at home in more formal environments and never wanting to go on a date somewhere that I couldn’t comfortably pay my way. The takeout and booze increase over the last week had made that wiggle room a bit smaller, though I would be able to put it on credit if I had to.
My first thought was to message Jessy the way she had done before her date-that-wasn’t, but while I knew Jake was far too busy to read my personal chats right now, I couldn’t be sure he wouldn’t go back through the ones from the Duskwood group to see if anything relevant had happened.
So instead, I went with Paige, knowing she’d get a kick out of my cluelessness at least.
MC: PAAAAIGEEE HELPPP
MC: I have a date
MC: A real one with a man I can see
She replied surprisingly quickly, and I realized she was probably still a bit worried and relieved to hear from me.
Paige: That’s great!
MC: Except not, work from home means I have nothing to wear
Paige: Where are you guys going?
MC: Food.
Paige: What kind of food?
MC: …
Paige: Why are you so bad at this?
Paige: Do you have a little black dress?
MC: Not that fits my ever-expanding ass, it’s from before shutdown.
Paige: I doubt it’d be the ass that’s the issue. Your boobs might be a bit more of a challenge if they decide to pop out.
MC: 🙄
MC: Not helpful
Paige: Fine, dark jeans?
MC: Yes!
Paige: Heels?
MC: Please.
Paige: Flats?
MC: Better.
Paige: What color?
I sent her a picture and she walked me through picking a shirt to match. The sun had started setting later and later and I tended to be warm so we picked a dark green top with loose sleeves and an empire waist that I’d gotten a few months ago for the rare days in the office. However, Paige tried to talk me out of wearing the silk cami I usually wore under it to make the rather low V neckline more work-friendly.
MC: I thought we were trying to avoid my boobs escaping?
Paige: Sure, but your cleavage looks great in that kind of neckline with the right bra.
MC: Why are you checking out my cleavage?
Paige: Easy, Lannister, I promise it was totally innocent. I helped you get ready for that wedding last year and they were in my face enough that I’d have to be blind.
MC: Not my fault you’re short.
She wasn’t that much shorter than me, but I’d been wearing borrowed heels at the time to pretend I wasn’t just over 5 feet, and she was a couple inches smaller than me to begin with.
Paige: Not my fault you’re stacked.
MC: it’s one of the few perks of being fat.
MC: Can we stop talking about my tits?
Paige: How are you so vulgar with everyone else and such a prude with me?
MC: You're my sister. And 12.
Paige: Only in your head 🙄
MC: Oh shit, makeup.
Paige: You’re fine, your skin was clear so just do some eyeliner and mascara, maybe some gloss. He might as well see what you’re normally like. No dark lipstick, you don’t know what you’ll order and you eat like a heathen.
MC: Last time he saw me I was super done up, I’d let Annie take control.
Paige: Wait is this not a first date?
Right. Guess I’d forgotten to mention my night out while she was here. Just have gotten lost in all of the kidnapping and fugitive talk. Weird how that worked.
MC: Last time we didn’t exactly plan to meet up, I went out with Annie and we went out after.
Paige: How dare you not tell me??? But that means he saw you without makeup in the morning right?
MC: Not exactly?
Paige: WHY ARE YOU SO BAD AT THIS?
MC: Stop being so supportive, my ego might explode.
Paige: ❤️
Paige: But this makes it easier I think. Sure he only saw you done up, but he’s also seen you naked. If he stuck around, he wants to at least do that again.
I wanted to argue with that, but I couldn’t think of anything to say. It wasn’t that I fully believed her, but I also couldn’t pretend he hadn’t gone out of his way to get my number, seemingly asked about me, and spent weeks being patient. That was a lot of effort just to now run because I suck at doing makeup.
MC: I guess.
Paige: If you look that bad, doggy style is a thing.
MC: Nope, not discussing this with you. I’ll send a picture before I go and you will not mention a single sex position, private body part or innuendo for the rest of the day.
Paige: Spoil sport. 😘
Since picking an outfit took much longer than expected, or was reasonable, I decided to hop in the shower early and do some extra conditioning. The humidity lately made it take even longer to tame my curls than usual, and I’d rather it not stand straight up with frizz.
I was surprised to find I wasn’t nervous. Maybe a bit flustered, but that may have been more from Paige than worries about Joe. I was still fragile from Jake’s rejection— that I was going on this date at all was evidence of that. I could only assume it was a symptom of the continuing detachment that I able to keep myself cool-headed.
I used as much product as I normally would in a month (admittedly, that was still less than Annie had the last time I went out) getting my curls to lay more or less the way I wanted. They still expanded and frizzed a bit as they dried, but I was at least okay with the end result.
The makeup was a bit harder, but I tried to take my time with it. I was still a bit ahead of schedule since I’d logged off so early, so I even plucked my eyebrows a little. I was probably just burning time at this point, but it couldn’t hurt, right?
It was six by the time I was fully dressed and had tracked down a purse that wasn’t cat-themed or large enough to double as a grocery bag, and when I checked my phone I was surprised to see that Joe had offered to pick me up at 6:30. On one hand, I hate feeling trapped if I have a bad time, but on the other I also hated driving and Uber existed. So I agreed and sat down to wait.
It was 6:25 when the message I’d been half hoping for, half dreading finally came.
Jake: Hello, MC.
___
Almost immediately, the sweet sense of detachment I’d maintained started wavering. I had to lock my phone and take a few gulps of air before my pounding heart began to slow.
I had plans, which would be here in just a minute. I didn’t have time to talk to him right now, and it wouldn’t be fair to Joe or Jake if I gave either of them half of my attention. I hadn’t opened the message yet, just saw the notification. It wouldn’t show as online until I opened the app, so I could swipe it away and reply later.
This was the logical way to do things. Jake had made his decision clear. I had to respect that, and it freed me up to date anyone I wanted. Joe knew I was interested in someone else. There was no moral ambiguity here, I wasn’t doing wrong by either of them. Ignoring Jake’s message was normal, he’d been too busy to reply to mine several times. It happened.
Still, I made sure not to open the app when Joe messaged to tell me he was out front. Instead, I stood up, put my phone in my purse, and went out to meet him.
___
I was relieved when we pulled up to a pub that looked just on the nicer end of average. He, too, was dressed in what could be considered business casual, with well-fitted jeans and a button-down in a teal color that looked good on him.
On our way to the table, I took my first sober look at him from the corner of my eye. He was probably closer to Annie’s age than mine, but not enough of a gap to make me feel uncomfortable and predatory. He was tall, though after a certain point I stopped being any good at guessing heights since it was just “taller than me”. At least, he’d definitely had to stoop more than I’d realized when we’d kissed on our way to his house last time we'd met.
Once we sat at our booth and were promised a visit from the server shortly, he flashed me a grin that almost didn’t reveal the nerves I’d noticed in the subtle tapping he’d done against the steering wheel as he drove us here. When I returned the smile, he relaxed a bit more.
We chatted lightly while we looked over the menu, pausing only to put in our orders. He told me about work, and I gave a highly edited version of Paige’s visit. He laughed as I showed him some of the pictures she’d taken, lingering a beat longer on the picture she’d taken to send to the chat with Cleo and Jessy.
Neither of us ordered alcohol, since he was driving and I’d had more than enough alcohol for a while. We split our meals— I’d been torn between two and he said they both sounded good and ordered the one I didn’t— and while the table was quieter than it had been before we got our food, we kept a steady conversation going. Paige was right, I realized now that I looked at it more objectively. I was way better at flirting when I wasn’t invested.
The food was good, and we both cleared our plates and then lingered a bit longer. I ordered another iced tea to keep my hands busy, and he fiddled a bit with his napkin but rarely took his eyes from me.
The drive home was less tense than the one there, with a lot less nervous fidgeting on his part. Things got more flirty as we went, and I even giggled a couple of times, which shocked me.
We pulled up to my house, and I tried not to panic when he turned off the car. I hadn’t thought far ahead enough to decide if I was inviting him in or not. It had certainly gone well enough to, it was the best date I’d had in a long while. But it was hard to forget how I’d gotten just seeing Jake’s name on my phone earlier.
He didn’t get out, though, just turning in his seat to face me with an earnest look. “I have a confession. I know our first time didn’t show it, but I’m not like that. I don’t want you to get the wrong idea. Annie’s boyfriend is a friend from college. I got out of a relationship right before we met and all of my friends were our friends. Steve took pity on me when he heard and started bringing me out more. I’ve heard you aren’t a partier, Annie’s ranted about her hermit nerd roommate before.” Here he flashed me a shy, apologetic smile. “I don’t hate that scene or anything, but this has been really nice. You’re really nice. And you look great tonight. I don’t think I said that yet, sorry.”
His honesty threw me off balance. After spending so long pulling teeth for any degree of connection, I barely remembered how to handle a guy putting so many words together at once, let alone being so open. It took me a bit to find my footing.
“Joe, I…” I searched for the right words for a moment, then pushed forward. “I’m not sure where I’m at right now, to tell you the truth. The other guy, well, it’s weird with him still. We’re still working together on a project for a while longer, and I don’t know how long it’ll be, and every time I talk to him it just makes it complicated...”
I hesitated and sighed loudly, then reached my hand over for him to grab if he’d like. He took it, eyes searching mine for a moment. He seemed to sense I wasn’t done, and waited, his thumb brushing over my knuckles.
“I had a good time, too. You’re right, I don’t do clubs or parties or anything like that. I mean, I did when I was younger, I definitely had a wild phase, but I kind of grew out of it. I haven’t gone home with a guy I just met in years. But I’m just not in the place to start something right now, you know?” I laughed without much humor and let my head fall to the headrest behind me. “If you didn’t seem like such a good guy, I think I’d really like letting you distract me for a while, but that’s not fair.”
He chuckled a little, his smile turning a bit wry. “You’re right, I’m not great at not getting attached. Though I’m a bit tempted to try right now.” I saw his eyes flicker down to my neckline for a quick second before he pulled them back to my face, blushing. It was strangely charming, and I leaned forward slowly to kiss him on the cheek, being sure to give him time to pull away or turn in if he preferred either option.
He didn’t move right away, but after my lips left his cheek, he chased after to capture them in a kiss. It was searing, and I felt my stomach flutter as I put the hand he wasn’t currently holding behind his head.
When we finally broke apart, his eyes were half-lidded and I was sure mine looked the same. My thumb caressed his cheek gently as we watched each other silently.
“I’ll walk you to the door,” he whispered, voice a bit rough. Then his brain seemed to catch up and he looked away shyly. “Not to come in, I just think it’s proper after a good date.”
I gave him a reassuring smile. “I’d like that.”
The walk was quiet, and our hands brushed against each other but neither of us moved to link them. Still, at my door, I lingered a second, deliberately turning towards him as I opened my purse for my keys.
Before I found them, he’d pulled me toward him again and I kissed him back, tangling my fingers in his hair with a groan. Standing, our heights made it harder to navigate, at least until I was nudged back a step until my back met the door. He didn’t lift me, but the support from being sandwiched between them made standing up on my toes easier, and he seemed happy enough to lean down the rest of the way to meet my lips.
Eventually, I needed to come up for air and I gently pushed his shoulders to end the kiss. Breathing heavily, I rested my head on his chest for a second and then groaned. “Go, before I change my mind on that distraction thing.”
He chucked, stepped back, and pecked my lips gently when I looked up again. “Probably a good idea,” he said in a voice that told me it wouldn’t have been hard to convince him to stay. But we both knew it was wrong.
When he was halfway down the walkway, I called out, “hey, let me know you got home okay, alright? Drive safe,” and quickly opened my door to slip in before he could reply.
I was ridiculously glad to find Annie still out, and I took another quick shower to wash off the makeup, keeping my hair out of the spray. More than a small part of me regretted letting him leave. Even if Jake changed his mind, we were still half a world apart and he was on the run from the government. He’d never be able to come here, and while I technically could get there, it’d be impossible to do it often enough to really have a relationship without raising suspicions and getting stupidly expensive. Joe was here, interested, and a really good kisser.
My sister said it best— I’m really bad at this.
Once I turned off the water and toweled off, I walked to my room without bothering to get dressed since I was alone. I sent Paige a text telling her that I was home, in my own bed, alone, and promised her details later. I didn’t let myself check to see if Jake was online.
Instead, I opened the message from Joe that I’d gotten while I was in the shower.
Joe: made it home
Joe: and I meant what I said by the way, I had a great time.
Joe: I hope he realizes what he’s missing out on soon, for his own sake.
Joe: goodnight.
I pulled the flat sheet up to my chin, and drifted off slowly.
___
The next morning, I knew I couldn’t put Jake off any longer. I’d enjoyed my night, a lot, but I knew he didn’t get many chances to be in contact at the moment, and we still needed to focus on Hannah. Plus, as much as I didn’t want to, I missed him.
Biting my lip, I gathered my courage and replied. The discussion about what we’d discovered in our time apart went well, straightforward enough, and I was glad I’d waited till morning since we jumped on the phone records right away and calling people at midnight—or worse— wasn’t the quickest way to endear yourself to them.
I needn't have worried on that front, though, since no one probably lived at the garage to be woken up. Still, it would have raised some eyebrows the next morning, even if the people who saw the call were well-used to my bullshit by now.
I hadn’t meant to admit I missed him. I knew I shouldn’t say it even as I sent the message. It was dumb, and just opened up old wounds when he said the same back before logging off without giving me a chance to say anything more, as usual.
Confronting Thomas about having called Hannah the day she went missing went in a direction I hadn’t expected. It made sense that being the main suspect in his own partner’s disappearance would wear him down, but with how little he’d shown, I hadn’t considered it.
Blaming me for our lack of contact was frustrating, though, considering he’d just voted to kick me out. Of course I wasn’t buddying up to him after that. The fact that I was speaking to him at all was a small miracle, guy didn’t realize just how good I was at holding a grudge.
Once the floodgates were open, though, it seemed like he just couldn’t stop them. The way he described Hannah was so different from anything they’d said earlier, much more in line with the woman I’d investigated than the one I’d been introduced to by the group.
I hurt for Thomas, but it was yet another time I felt connected to Hannah. Secrets, hiding, shutting down around someone you love. Wasn’t that exactly what I was doing now? Had done whenever my demons crept back up and the emptiness lurked at the edges of my thoughts.
Whatever it was that had happened, whatever triggered this, it seemed like she was losing the fight with it. I hoped again, for Jessy and Jake’s sake, that we found her soon. If she hadn’t done this to herself, that meant she was out there alone, unmedicated, trapped in her own mind. That was a special kind of hell, I knew.
The bracelet was pretty, I’d always loved emeralds. I was surprised Thomas told me about it with so little prompting, and sent the picture as confirmation. Maybe he was just done. It sounded like he’d been exhausted even before she went missing, so maybe he was just relieved to tell someone.
Even though I had no reason to suspect Jessy had anything to do with it, I mentioned that her initials matched. I couldn’t admit to myself that I was avoiding exactly what Thomas followed up with— pointing out Jake’s name. He didn’t make the same connection I’d been continuing to purposefully ignore— that the H could mean Hannah— but it still hung in the air somehow.
I let myself be distracted from that fear that for a moment by listening to how different Hannah sounded the day of her kidnapping. If Jake hadn’t seen the abduction, that would have actually made me more nervous. People tended to relax once they’d decided to give in to depression, the same way I felt so much better when I let myself close off.
I promised to try to find out if Jake was Hannah’s lover regardless of the churning in my stomach the idea caused. After last night, I had no right to even care, but I couldn’t help it. There was no way I’d ever give Thomas his last name, but if it could get us both the truth, I knew I needed to bring myself to ask.
I didn’t know for sure if I was happy or not that Jake wasn’t online, but pushed myself to message him anyway. He needed to at least know what I’d learned.
I’d never let myself send him that many messages in a row before, and I got more desperate with each one. I hated how pathetic I knew I was coming off by the time I said that I hoped it wasn’t him, so I was the tiniest bit relieved that he stayed offline through my barrage.
___
The security footage I found in the cloud next felt like a nightmare to me, again striking me in that deep place of fear that was aware of just how vulnerable being a woman could be at times. The idea of having something, or someone, coming so close to you in the dead of night made me shiver and wrap my arms around myself. I sent it, as always, but almost cried with relief when Jessy quickly provided a distraction from my dark thoughts.
Her tour idea touched me more than she could know, more than I ever would have expected. The fact that she also seemed angry at Lilly only soothed me, and for the first time in a while I felt my hold on my cold mask loosen considerably.
That sense of affection grew as she sent pictures showing off the town that I knew she wanted to leave, but at the same time seemed to want me to love. And I did feel a pull to it, despite seeing nothing but quick stills of buildings and fountains. I couldn’t picture myself there, but it was so central to my life lately that I couldn’t help but feel connected. I imagined that even if they all stopped talking to me after we found Hannah, I’d want to visit. Maybe I’d bring Paige, we could stay at the motel. Maybe Jake would leave the map on my phone before he, too, left once my usefulness had ended.
Even the man who picked then to harass me didn’t dampen my urge to see it, though it did remind me that Lilly taking down the video hadn’t kept it from continuing to spread, which left my mind a moment to drift to Jake.
But it didn’t last long, and when Jessy showed me the lake, I swore to myself that one day I’d picnic there. Even if it was alone, one day I’d dip my toes into the water and close my eyes with my face to the sun. I wanted to feel the good in this place that had been haunting my nightmares. I wanted to face it and prove I was stronger than the legends it held.
Her story about her mom broke my heart, and I was tempted to tell her about mine but clamped down on the urge. Once I opened that door, there was no way I’d be able to pull back into the peace I was determined to return to shortly. So instead I asked about her brother, and when that only worked for bit and she asked for news, I forced myself to open that can of worms again and show her the bracelet.
I wasn’t expecting her to recognize it, and even less to find out it had been in a pawn shop. Would a lover have gotten a bracelet from there, in such a small town where it would almost certainly be recognized by whoever had pawned it?
Maybe it was from someone she’d used date and she’d pawned it before, but gotten sentimental. Thomas had never seen it before because it’d been hidden, then pawned, but he’d seen it before she was able to hide it again.
But even without knowing enough about it to know the whole story, it made me feel lighter to know that it was unlikely that it was from Jake, at least in the recent past. I could handle them being exes, even though I couldn’t honestly say that I would put so much effort into keeping one of my exes safe. Especially not considering what it was costing him.
Before I could go any further with that thought, Phil messaged Jessy to say that Thomas and Cleo had joined forces in their mission to break into every building in Duskwood, and I raked my hand over my face.
Stop. Being. Stupid. Please. Hannah, help me.
The fact that Phil even gave them a chance before calling the cops didn’t really match up with anything I’d heard from him. I don’t know for sure I’d have waited, but I guess they were his sister’s friends so that could make things a bit different, I supposed. Still, between the discoveries showing Hannah wasn’t the person I’d been told about, and now this, I wondered if maybe Phil was really the bad guy I’d thought.
Maybe I’d need to see if Jake could get ahold of his number soon and get his thoughts on this all.
Jessy requested a call, and I felt a wave of guilt about her being out this late because of me. Here she was trying to cheer me up, when it was her friend missing and her town hiding secrets. I was safely tucked a world away, pitying myself because my crush was unrequited. Man, sometimes I was the worst.
I chatted with her on her walk, happy to help her feel safe. At least until I caught sight of someone walking behind Jessy in the dark, dodging to avoid being seen. I called out a warning, but it was too late. I could only scream as I watched her fall to the attack. The mask man turned the camera to let me see him, and I spit out curses, telling him to come find me instead. Red flooded my vision as he propped the camera up in a way that made it clear I was supposed to watch her suffer. I sobbed loudly as I begged her to get back up. Even when she did, ending the call, I couldn’t stop the tears.
NEXT
8 notes
·
View notes
Okame’s Underbelly - Explanation |5th|
(ShinsoxOC)
Katsumi’s POV (localvillageidiot#0870) and Shinso’s POV (hecker#8339)
Warning: Contains arguing, name-calling, smoking, swearing, slight misuse of quirk, and Denki and Mina supremacy
Preview (Katsumi’s POV):
| “Shinso,” I said, turning to him, “you like poetry too, right?” I said, giving him a small, inviting smile.
“No, not my thing.” he grumbled, not even turning to answer me directly.
I felt my eye twitch. I am trying. So hard. To be nice.
“Oh really? I got the feeling that you might since I think we met briefly at a poetry house once over the summer.” I said pleasantly, clenching my jaw in secret.
“Did we? Well, even if we did, I don’t think I’d remember you.” he said dismissively.
Okay, now you're just trying to piss me off. |
Unknown source for artwork. (Please let me know who’s it is if you know)
1st Chapter - Anticipation
(Katsumi's POV)
The smell of day old frying oil greeted me as I walked into Marley’s to meet up with Mina. She had asked me to grab a quick bite to eat with her before we went to a party that a friend of hers was having. She knew I would never turn down a good time nor would I ever turn down a Marley’s date. I scanned the room to find my favorite tuft of pink hair waving wildly at me. My smile morphed into shock when I saw an equally wild blonde waving at me as well. I hurried over to the table to greet them but when I arrived I saw Edgelord sitting with them as well. His head was stuck in a menu, apparently trying to seem indifferent about my arrival. I felt a strange mix of anger and anxiety rushing out of him, pushing me back towards the door. It irritated me but I decided to ignore it, focusing my attention on those who were happy to see me.
“Denki, hi! I didn’t think I’d see you so soon.”
“Fate must be bringing us together.” he avowed, comically suave.
I laughed. “It must be. Can’t say I mind though.”
I hugged Mina, who had gotten out of the booth when I walked over.
“Why didn’t you tell me you had friends coming too?” I asked.
“I thought you’d like the surprise!” she beamed.
“You know me, the more the merrier!” I said as we settled into our seats. I slid into the booth next to Edgelord, who still hadn’t said anything. I took off my leather jacket and tucked it into my backpack between my legs.
“Hey Shinso.” I said casually.
“Hey.” he replied gruffly.
Well this is going to be an awkward meal. He’s already on my nerves. I don’t get why he’s acting like this. I let him sleep on my couch and he can’t even muster up a decent hello? Is he trying to hurt my feelings? ... Just play nice Kat. He’s Mina’s old friend and Denki’s roommate. You can do this. Just pretend like he’s not being weird, or better yet, pretend like he’s not even there. Don’t let it get to you. I took a mental deep breath and smiled at the two across from me. The three of us chatted for a while about nothing in particular, just a little small talk about this and that. At some point, Mina mentioned something about a high school memory, which reminded me of how they all knew each other.
“Denki, you went to UA too, right? Your quirk must be really cool.” I said.
“Wanna see how it works?” He raised an eyebrow and smiled mischievously.
I looked over at Mina who smiled encouragingly at me, albeit a bit too eager for my liking.
“Uh, sure why not?”
“Give me your hand.”
I complied, placing my hand in his. He took it and flipped it so my palm was up. He dangled his fingers over my hand dramatically, like a magician about to say their magic words.
“Are you ready?”
I nodded, a bit intrigued. He placed a finger in the middle of my palm and activated his quirk, sending a small zap into my skin. A strange noise came out of my mouth when I felt the slight pain and surprise hit me. The noise sent Mina and Denki into a fit of laughter.
“What- what was that noise?” Mina choked out between giggles.
“Shut up, that hurt!”
“I- I’m sorry! It was just too tempting!” Denki wheezed.
I rubbed the slightly tender part of my palm and glared at them.
“Come on, I’ll make it up to you. Let me kiss it better.” He held out his hands to me.
I looked at him skeptically.
“I won't do it again, promise.”
I gave him my hand and he leaned down, placing an electrified kiss on the same spot as before.
“Ow!” I cried as I pulled my hand back.
Mina and Denki bursted out laughing once more, this time joined by a scoff from Shinso.
“How gullible can you be?” Shinso said under his breath.
I shot him a look but before I could say anything back, our food arrived.
We ate and the three of us continued to chat. Mina and Denki told me stories about their time at UA together. It was so cool to hear what the pro heroes that I was covering were like when they were students. I took some pretty good mental notes, not that I would ever use any of the personal information I gathered in any of my posts. That just felt like an invasion of privacy, but it did help me understand the dynamic I captured between certain heroes in my photographs. It always struck me odd how Dynamite and Deku looked when they fought together. Their relationship vexed me but pulled me in at the same time. The same applied to Dynamite and Red Riot. Hearing that one pair had been childhood friends and the other had become super close in their first year at UA shed some new light and perspective on the scenes that I had captured before.
Some of the stories were just outright hilarious too. Denki was an absolute riot and the way he and Mina played off of each other made my mission of ignoring Edgelord’s attitude super easy. He hadn’t said much of anything since our food had come to the table despite Mina and Denki trying to involve him in their storytelling. He just hummed or gave an unenthusiastic “yeah” whenever they asked him something. I didn’t need to use my quirk to feel the irritation and discomfort rolling off of him. If you don’t want to be here, then leave. I couldn’t help but feel like I was the reason he was so annoyed. I walked myself through my memories trying to figure out when exactly I ran over this kid’s cat. I really was nothing but nice. I practically saved his life, not that he knows that, but still! I bared those emotions for him! It took me forever to claw my way out of that depression hole. On top of that, I gave him a place to sleep it off and helped him move all of his shit up the stairs into his room. Why is he getting under my skin this much? Why do I even care? Everything about this is pissing me off.
“So Kat,” Denki said, interrupting my thoughts. “What do you like to do in your free time?”
“I like to take pictures and I write sometimes.” I said, covering my half full mouth.
“Well duh, you’re a photojournalism major. That doesn't count.”
“Umm,” I thought about my response as I swallowed. “Actually, I used to spend a lot of time at some hole-in-the-wall place near campus. I listened to people perform poetry and stuff like that. I went every Friday at one point to listen to a particular person. The stage name was Okame, but once they stopped performing I kind of lost interest” I checked my watch. “If Okame was still performing, I’d probably be getting ready to head over right about now.”
I felt Shinso tense up next to me. His anxiety was tugging at my quirk like toddlers aggressively tug on a parent’s sleeve. Wow, his anxiety just shot through the roof... You good kid? Maybe I should bring him into the conversation? Is that what this is about?
“Shinso,” I said, turning to him, “you like poetry too, right?” I said, giving him a small, inviting smile.
“No, not my thing.” he grumbled, not even turning to answer me directly.
I felt my eye twitch. I am trying. So hard. To be nice.
“Oh really? I got the feeling that you might since I think we met briefly at a poetry house once over the summer.” I said pleasantly, clenching my jaw in secret.
“Did we? Well, even if we did, I don’t think I’d remember you.” he said dismissively.
Okay, now you're just trying to piss me off.
“Oh yeah? Well I definitely remember you. You were outside. If memory serves, you were having a pretty rough go of it.” I turned to fully face him, shooting him a challenging glare.
I knew the irritation showed on my face, but I honestly didn’t care enough to hide my emotions anymore. He met my glare with his own. The message was clear, he wanted me to shut my mouth and drop it. But why should I? He just continued to stare me down, waiting for me to change the subject, but I had a few questions for him. Mina must have seen me ready to blow a gasket because she decided to jump in to defuse the situation.
“Well, what does it matter where you were or what you're into?” she chuckled nervously. “Kat, have you been writing anything interesting lately?”
“Or do you have any of your professional-grade photographs on your phone? I’d really love to see them! I’m sure they’re amazing!” Denki chimed in, following Mina’s lead.
“I’m gonna head out for a smoke.” Shinso said, looking at me to move.
I got up to let him out. I watched him walk out with his hands deep in his pockets. I was drilling holes into the back of his head and I knew he felt it because his frustration was overcoming his anxiety as he reached the door, but I wasn’t done with him yet.
“I’m actually going to take a step out too.”
Mina gave me a look that said Girl what? You don’t smoke. But I ignored it and followed after Shinso.
(Shinso's POV)
God must be playing some cruel joke on me, either that, or I was a shittier boyfriend than I originally thought and this was my sweet karma. I just can't seem to escape that night. I managed to stifle the buzz in my head for the most part but it keeps manifesting itself, or rather infesting, my present. Time for some more shitty coping. I pulled out the pack of cigarettes from my jacket and pulled one out. It was a bit mangled but it was my second to last one. (I imagine his last cigarettes always end up this way bc he always smokes when his mood is erratic so he just manhandles tf out these ciggies)
"It's in poor condition but it'll have to do." I muttered under my breath.
I swiftly placed it between my lips and raised the lighter to it, but the flame was quickly extinguished. Shit, why does it always have to be so windy today? I hovered my other hand over the flame to block the harsh gusts, as I furrowed my brows in concentration. I was failing miserably to light my damn cigarette. I groaned in frustration before two small hands appeared around mine. My hands jerked back, startled, extinguishing the flame immediately. I looked down and realized it was the little brunette. I composed myself with a sigh and went back to trying to light my cigarette, choosing not to pay her any attention.
"Do you want help lighting your cigarette or not?" she questioned, irritated.
I looked down at her, a stubborn expression on her face. Pick your battles, Shinso. I reluctantly leaned down towards her.
“So...” she said after the cigarette was lit. “I mean this in the nicest, most polite way possible, but what the fuck is your problem?” she interrogated.
Her sudden abrasiveness caught me off guard. "Uh...what do you mean?" When did this become an interrogation all of a sudden?
“I mean, why do you treat me like I ran over your cat on your birthday?
Her absurd question also took me aback but I was quicker to adjust this time. "I don't even know who you are?” Why am I lying? Fuck it I already said it, let's go with it.
“Oh really? So that's why you act so out of pocket any time I bring up the night we met when I found you drunk and ugly crying-”
"Okay okay, fine. Just please stop bringing it up." I interrupted hastily. "Jesus fuck." I muttered under my breath. Why does she insist on bringing it up?
“So you do remember?” she asked with mock surprise. I just looked ahead of me hoping that she would run out of steam and drop it.
“Say it.” She demanded, her volume raising this time.
"Yes." I confirmed begrudgingly. Why the fuck does she have to be so loud? She's a pro at being annoying. "But I can't say it, because I genuinely don't remember your name." This was intended to be a slight jab but I was being honest. I probably could remember it if I wasn’t actively trying to forget it.
“Not like Denki and Mina haven’t said it a million times today. It’s Katsumi.”
"Ooooh right. Kat." My voice was just short of being completely monotone.
“Kat...so you do remember. Asshole.” She rolled her eyes. She has no problem insulting me. It kind of amused me but my aggravation overshadowed it.
I shrugged at her. What does it matter anyway? It's not like we're gonna be best friends. We can barely tolerate each other as it is.
“Listen Edgelord, I think you still owe me an explanation. I’ve been nothing but nice to you. So what gives?” she insisted.
"I don't know what you're talking about. This is how I always am." I technically wasn't lying. I tended to rub strangers the wrong way, either that or I was easily forgettable.
“So you're always a total douche?” she challenged, staring me right in my face.
"Funny. Guess so." I said carelessly with a hint of a smirk at her additional loving nickname for me. Wonder what else she'll call me?
“I know you’re not though. You turn sour as soon as I come around and it bothers me. So fess up. What’s your damage?” Her expression twisted into a scowl at the end of her sentence.
That last question irked me a little more than it should've. My damage?
"Hm I don't know, maybe you being a constant reminder of one of the worst days of my life." I stated with a tinge of bitterness at the end of my words.
This seemed to catch her off guard. She took a moment to configure a response. She was either being very careful with her next words or didn't know what to say at all.
“Oh, okay, yeah. That tracks... Well I’m sorry, but I really couldn’t just leave you there.” Her tone was slightly softer than before.
"I know." I admitted reluctantly. "That's what's so frustrating." I muttered, barely audible. What made her care so much about a complete mess of a stranger? Now we're attached by that occurence and it's so embarrassing.
“Frustrating? What’s so frustrating?” She caught part of it.
"Nothing. I just- I hate that you saw me like that. It's fucking weird. I like to deal with shit on my own."
“It’s really okay, Shinso. I didn’t think about it when I saw you. I was just happy to catch up, because we got along really well that night. It wasn't until you started avoiding me like the plague that I started thinking back to remember where things went wrong.”
"Yeah, I get that. But you're always bringing it up so casually like it's the weather or some shit."
“It was the only thing that got any sort of response out of you. What else did you want me to do? Besides, It didn’t make me think of you in any type of way.” she assured me.
"I just don't get why you care." I said more to myself than to her.
She seemed to genuinely consider this for a second.
“Me either, if I’m being honest. You’re so grouchy. I almost never put up with your type. But here we are.” She shrugged and dropped her arms to her side, comically defeated.
That sentiment actually drew a chuckle out of me. It didn't seem like the most appropriate response for the situation so I tried to stifle it as best as I could.
"Yup. Here we are." I confirmed.
“So we’re friends now.” she asserted, sure of it.
"Uh...I didn't say all that." She really is bold. She keeps catching me off guard.
“But I did.” she doubled down on it.
There was a brief stare down, her amber eyes were unwavering on mine. I guess it doesn't mean much. We're just gonna have to play nice when we're around each other from now on.
I shrugged. "Okay cool." I put the cigarette to my lips again only to discover it is nothing but a dying butt now. All that annoying back and forth made me forget about one of my last cigs. "Fuck, really, Kat?" I complained with a hint of playfulness at the very edge of my tone. I'm due for a pack on Sunday so I'll just have to hold out for a day or so. I pulled out the last one and lit effortlessly. Of course now it lights with no problem.
“Blame your own stubbornness. If you had just given me an answer the first time I asked, you could have smoked until your lungs gave out.” she retorted.
There was a moment of silence as I took my first drag. I could see her eyeing my cigarette, with disgust, if I had to guess.
“Gimme one of those.” She pointed to my pocket where the now empty pack was.
I shot a look down at her, my eyebrows raised. I chuckled in surprise. I didn't take her for a smoker with the way she talks about it. I guess she's one of those self-loathing nic addicts. Kinda same. I'm just not as loud about it.
"A little too late, this is the last one." I took another drag, staring mindlessly at the horizon in front of me.
“And?” she insisted as if that was a dumb response.
I gave her another weird look before it registered. Oh...okay.
"Fine." I gave her the cigarette I was smoking.
She grabbed the cigarette, maneuvering it awkwardly in her hand before settling it between her pointer and middle finger, the typical form. She brought it to her mouth and inhaled with a pained expression. She was barely a second in before she began coughing. Yup, she doesn’t actually smoke. Her sad attempt was endearing in an odd way. It was actually kind of cute. What am I thinking? She was intolerable a second ago. Stop that, brain. You’re being weird. Scolding myself inwardly distracted me from the fact that I was laughing at her outwardly. She rolled her eyes in response, annoyed at my amusement.
“Listen, people seem to smoke when they’re stressed and well, you stress me the fuck out so I thought I’d give it a try. Show me how to do it then, since you wanna scoff at me.” She handed the cigarette back to me before crossing her arms. I followed up her request with another chuckle, shaking my head at her.
“Are you sure you wanna be my friend? I’m already teaching you bad habits.” I teased, a smirk pulling at the corner of my lips. But I obliged and raised the cigarette to my lips obnoxiously slow and inhaled. I blew the smoke in her general direction and she swatted it away with a grimace.
“Tada…” I concluded sarcastically.
“Gross...you know what? Nevermind.”
We laughed in unison. It was followed up with a moment of quiet.
“Well, Edgelord, I’ll see you at the party. Try to smile a little when you’re there. It suits you way more than your resting bitch face.”
“I’m starting to think that you don’t remember my name either. Keep it fresh and switch it up once in a while. Try...I don’t know...buzzkill next, or something.” I criticized, a smile in my voice.
She tilted her head to the side as if to say “good idea”, before I put out my cigarette and headed inside with her.
33 notes
·
View notes