This Love Is Alive Back From The Dead
Summary: The last time Feyre and Rhys saw each other was senior year when she abruptly decided to end things between them. Ten years later, they meet again at their high school reunion.
Rating: Explicit
Warnings: none
Read on AO3 from the beginning or continue with Chapter 2
@officialfeysandweek2023
Chapter 2
One day earlier
Rhys could not believe he was doing this. When Mor told him about the high school reunion and how it was going to be a revival of their prom, he had needed about four shots before he felt ready to unpack that plan and all its implications. Prom was part of the pile of thoughts he had shoved to the very back of his mind and absolutely refused to think about.
He had promised Mor he would go, but with each mile closer to his hometown, the stitches of an old but still aching wound had started unraveling at a fast pace.
Rhys was mature enough to admit he was nervous. The person responsible for that nervousness was the only one he’d ever loved, and he was also mature enough to admit he still loved her.
He knew she hadn’t dated. There had never been anyone else. So why had she ended things with him?
He stepped through the door of his unsurprisingly empty childhood home, tossing the keys on the small table next to the spiral staircase. He didn’t bother calling his father—the man either never picked up or was always busy. The two of them had what one would consider a purely professional relationship, that of a CEO and CFO, and once Rhys took over as CEO, they would stop having a relationship altogether.
His phone pinged, the screen lighting up with a message from Mor, asking him to meet in an hour. With no one to talk to and precious free time on his hands, he showered, dressed, grabbed his watch from where he had left it on the dresser, and stopped short in front of the middle drawer, where he put everything he didn’t want to see.
The drawer of emotional baggage, as Mor liked to call it.
He pulled it open, grabbing the only picture frame inside and turned it around. The faces staring back at him were full of love and joy, and unsuspecting of what was going to happen in just a few weeks.
You were unsuspecting, said a small voice. She wasn’t.
Shaking his head, he put the frame back inside, face down, and closed the drawer. He wasn’t ready to unpack that just yet.
Heading to their meeting place, he saw Mor, sunglasses on, soaking the sun. Sunshine was the only way he could describe her, though she become vicious to protect what was hers.
“Hey stranger,” she said, hugging him. “Long time no see.”
He raised an eyebrow, only turning his attention away from her to order a coffee. “You saw me yesterday.”
“That is an awfully long time. How did you manage to get through the last 24 hours without me?”
“By getting many things done, since I didn’t have you to annoy me.”
“Oh, Rhysie,” she pouted at him mockingly, lowering her sunglasses to give him her best impression of a hurt puppy. “You and I both know that is not true. Anyway, there is a reason I called you here.”
Rhys had been aware of that the moment she had messaged him. “Color me surprised.”
“So, you know how the reunion will be a revival of our prom, right? And everything has to be perfect.”
Rhys nodded. “Yes, the perfect part of it is an especially fitting revival of my experience with prom night.”
Mor conveniently chose to ignore him. “Yes, anyway, we need outfits.”
“Really? We need outfits? You want me to believe you waited until the day before to choose one?”
Waving him off, Mor went on. “There’s this new atelier I’ve seen with these amazing dresses, they’re so perfect you wouldn’t believe. Come with me? Please?”
He considered it for a second. He truly had nothing else to do with his time. He was not looking forward to locking himself home, and Az and Cass weren't going to arrive for another couple of hours. He certainly didn’t miss this town enough to go for a stroll. Nodding, he finished his coffee and paid for his and Mor’s drinks, tipping the waiter generously.
An hour later, he found himself sitting on a brown chair, in an atelier decorated in every shade of cream known to mankind, with pops of earthy tones here and there.
Mor was twirling in front of a floor to ceiling mirror, examining her red gown. “What do you think?”
He thought he could feel an approaching headache but wisely kept that to himself. “I think you look beautiful-”
He never got to finish that sentence as the front door opened, revealing a man with long red hair tied in a low ponytail and a familiar pair of russet eyes. “Rhys?”
Rhys stood, smiling slightly. “Hello Lucien.”
Rhys and Lucien had shared the same space several times over the past few years but never went beyond a casual exchange of greetings. Rhys had known Lucien almost his entire life but wasn’t sure where they stood after what happened in high school. He had the feeling Lucien felt the same way.
Lucien greeted Mor; Rhys wasn’t sure if they had met each other in the years since. Pleasantries and small talk were exchanged, Lucien helping Mor find a gown for the reunion and Mor in turn telling Lucien how Rhys didn’t have a proper suit for it.
A total lie, of course. He had plenty of suits. He just didn’t have one fancy enough to meet Mor’s standards. He also wasn’t exactly thrilled at the prospect of going to the reunion but wisely kept that to himself as well.
“Oh yes. I have just the thing for Rhys.”
He looked at them at the sound of his name. “What?”
Mor grabbed his hand, following Lucien into the private area of the atelier and dragging him behind her.
“This is where I keep my one of a kind works. Things that are single pieces, sometimes inspired by certain people, the designs of which are shredded after they’re brought to life. Consider this a peek into my midnight creations.”
Mor looked like a child on Christmas Eve. “Holy shit Lucien, this is amazing.”
Lucien smiled at that. “Thank you. These two pieces are my last creations. We finished them yesterday. This,” he said, placing his hands on the sides of a mannequin, “screams your name, Rhys.”
The tuxedo he was looking at was a black so dark it looked depthless. It was easily the most beautiful piece of clothing he had seen, and he had grown up with Mor. The lapels were ever changing, depending on the angle you looked at the suit from—from the front, a shimmery black and from the sides, a striking silver. The same detail was applied to the bottom edge of the jacket and the edges of the sleeves. The pants were the same depthless black with black satin stripes, but without the silver lining.
Next to the suit was a nearly translucent gray sleeveless gown bedecked in crystals, giving the appearance of a turtleneck while having a very revealing backside, and a high slit on the left side. Both pieces complimented each other in a way Rhys could not explain.
Like the dress was the stars to the tuxedo’s night.
The words were out of his mouth before he could reconsider it. “I’m getting it.”
Lucien’s smile rivaled the Cheshire Cat. “It’ll be delivered to your place later today. Are you staying at the house?”
Rhys nodded. “It’s just for a day, and the house is empty anyway. Might as well put it to good use.”
Lucien nodded, then his expression turned thoughtful. “Rhys, there’s something you should know about Feyre.”
Rhys froze at the sound of her name. He couldn’t remember the last time he had heard someone say it out loud, his friends walking on eggshells around him when it came to her. “What about her?” he asked cautiously.
Lucien grimaced. “You might want to sit down for this.”
He did as was told, making himself as comfortable as he could, all things considered. Mor did not look curious at all, and he filed away that bit of information to reassess it later.
“So back when we were in high school, you got approached by several Ivys thanks to your perfect academic record. And we were all happy for you, Feyre more than anyone. But then she broke up with you, telling you that she didn’t see a future for the two of you after high school.”
“I remember,” he said, trying not to let his annoyance show. How could he forget?
“Well here’s the thing… Feyre did see a future after high school. She had always seen it, you were the love of her life, but one day she overheard you tell Cassian and Azriel that you were going to turn down every Ivy, that you would instead stay here, and go to community college with her. She could not accept that, refused to let you sacrifice your education and future and be tied down to her. So she broke up with you.”
Rhys had stopped breathing about three sentences ago.
When he didn’t respond, Lucien continued, “You didn’t understand where it was coming from, so you didn’t give up, and so on prom night, Feyre came without a date. She knew you’d go to her, try and patch things up. So she called in a favor with Tamlin, aware of the animosity between the two of you, of course. And when she saw you approaching her, she kissed him, giving you the impression she was leaving you for him.”
The silence in his head was deafening, and had he been standing, he was sure his knees would have given out. “What are you saying?” he half whispered, scared of saying anything more.
Lucien looked at him sympathetically. “I’m saying it was all a ruse, Rhys. Feyre wanted you out of this town, somewhere new, where you could get a proper education, where you wouldn’t be forced to spend the rest of your days with her and not experience the world outside this town.” He gestured around. “She never stopped loving you. She still loves you. And she will never forgive me for breaking her trust but I cannot keep quiet on this anymore. It’s not fair to either of you.”
Mor hadn’t uttered a single word so far, yet when Rhys looked at her, she didn’t seem surprised. “You knew?” he said.
“Yes.” She sighed. “Lucien and I met a couple of months ago when I walked in here, needing a dress. We sat down for lunch, we talked about life in general, then we talked about you and Feyre, and he told me the whole thing. That’s when we planned the reunion—Lucien has been planning it with me the whole time. But Rhys,” she said, grabbing his hand, “I couldn’t tell you, that had to come from Lucien.”
Rhys nodded, more on autopilot than anything else. “So what now?”
“Now it’s up to you.” Lucien said, smiling. “I will not tell Feyre we met. As far as she knows, we haven’t seen or spoken to each other in years. She’ll come to the reunion tomorrow, and you can do with the truth as you see fit. But I’m done seeing her hate herself every moment of every day.”
Rhys nodded again, the only thing he could do at the moment. He did not know what to do with himself, his thoughts, or his feelings. He paid for the tux, thanked Lucien, and headed home in a daze.
The moment he was back in his old bedroom again, he opened the drawer and pulled the picture frame from earlier, looking at his younger self and Feyre. He had his arms wrapped around her from behind, his chin resting on her head. Feyre’s smile was contagious, her eyes bright with the kind of starlight that had made him fall in love with her in the first place.
Years. They had lost years because she had made a decision alone for both of them, had thought she knew what it was he needed and wanted. He had only ever wanted her. He didn’t know which emotion to feel first—he was angry she had taken this from them, disappointed she had not trusted him to know what he was doing, relieved she still loved him. His beautiful, stubborn girl had put him above her own feelings and needs, wrecking not only him but also herself in the process.
There was a new ache in his heart, born of heartbreak and something else, something he recognized as very fragile hope. She still loved him, and God knew he had never stopped loving her. But would that be enough to put the past ten years behind them and start over?
Smiling fondly at the happy teenagers they had been, he decided the frame was not going to go to the drawer of emotional baggage anymore. He found a spot on his dresser and placed the frame there, a reminder of what they could have if he survived the anxiety that had been tormenting him for the past several hours.
He could only hope this didn’t backfire on him.
He arrived with Mor the next day, already finding a small group of people present. Mor—and he guessed Lucien—had decided the party was going to be held at their high school’s gym, where the original prom had been.
It was weird being back. Everything reminded him of Feyre, the places they had laughed, the ones where they had kissed a hundred times, the ones where they had fucked each other senseless, the places where they’d made so many plans for the future. He was trying to keep an open mind. Feyre would come, he would see her, approach her, gently start small talk with her, stilted as that was going to be, and then he’d tell her he knew her secret.
He felt like he was going to be sick.
“Relax,” Mor whispered next to him. “She’ll come, and you’ll talk, and then you’ll see where that takes you. One step at a time. I’ll approach her first and then you can gently ease your way into the conversation.”
He nodded, physically present but mentally elsewhere.
He hadn’t told Cass and Az yet. He needed to talk to Feyre first before he told anyone else. Needed to hear her side of the story, and where her mind had been at when she stole a decision from him.
“She’s here.”
He nodded, hearing Mor leave and resisting the urge to look in their direction, lest his feet start walking of their own accord and take him to Feyre. He counted to one hundred, then repeated the process one more time before taking a deep breath, squaring his shoulders, and turning around.
What he saw took his breath away, and he didn’t know whether he wanted to kiss or kill Lucien.
Feyre was wearing the dress from Lucien’s private collection, the one he had looked at and admired the previous day, the one next to his tuxedo.
The stars to his night.
He took in the expanse of her back, the back of the dress open to the base of her spine, dimples showing. He took in her arms, arms that had previously been too thin and were now toned. She wasn’t skinny and malnourished anymore. The person standing a few feet away from him was healthy, clearly worked out regularly, and had sunkissed skin.
He cleared out his mind, repeating his personal mantra for the day.
Be normal. Don’t freak out. It will be okay.
He caught the end of their conversation about her dress and added “One of a kind, if Lucien is to be believed. Inspired by the very person wearing it.”
He saw her freeze, taking small breaths she thought no one could notice.
“Hello, Feyre darling.”
He could mentally kick himself for using his old term of endearment, knowing it probably brought back too many memories, but at the moment he also couldn’t give a fuck.
Mor said something about him being dramatic but Rhys wasn’t listening. He could smell Feyre from the small distance between them, and the familiarity of the scent left a lump in his throat. She had always smelled of lilac.
She turned around, her gray blue eyes meeting his, sparkling like stars, but with a faint something else that he couldn’t place, like melancholy but not quite.
Her eyes felt like coming home.
He catalogued every detail, every inch of her, starting from the way her hair spilled down in curls, to the red lips that made him want to kiss her, to the dress, to that damned dress, clinging to her so perfectly, like it was made for her and only her, which he supposed it was.
Lucien, that sly fox, had known exactly what he was doing when he sold Rhys that tuxedo yesterday.
His eyes traveled down, down to that slit, her long leg showing. He shoved down his rising lust, more than aware the chances of anything happening tonight were slim to none.
Despite everything, looking at her now, he knew he loved her still, with the kind of madness that threatened to consume him entirely.
He tried to make small talk, but all he could think of was the last time he had freely touched her, held her. She was nervous, he could tell. He could still read her like an open book.
Could she hear his heart pounding, threatening to leap out of his chest, just so it could run to hers? Could she see how she still affected him, with her eyes, and the hair he longed to touch, and that stupid dress that had been brought to life just for her.
She asked him if he had come alone, and just because there was a part of him that needed to see that she still cared, he said “No.”
Her answer came simply in the form of an “Oh” so small and quiet he would have missed it had he not been attuned to her voice. Oddly happy to see her so obviously upset, he quickly put her out of her misery by telling her he came with his friends.
Unexpectedly, she blurted “I’m sorry but why are you being so friendly to me? We didn’t exactly part on good terms.”
He cocked his head to one side. So they were doing this? Alright then . He tried to come up with the most neutral answer he could think of. “We’re adults. I thought we could both put the past behind us, especially one with a plan as well thought out as yours.”
Feyre blinked in confusion. “What do you mean?”
He smirked, and she looked like she was… relieved? Like the idea of him smirking was something she took great comfort in. “That little plan of yours back when we were eighteen. Break up with me and have me catch you kissing Tamlin.”
She paled, her face losing several shades of color, and for a moment he thought she was going to be sick. Perhaps being direct had been the wrong move.
“Rhys, I-”
“To be fair, I’m mad at you,” he said, interrupting her. “Livid doesn’t even begin to describe it. But I’m trying to think rationally here and give you the benefit of the doubt. So, Feyre. We need to talk.”
33 notes
·
View notes