Ch. 24: In A Blur
[Story Masterlist] // [Aitana’s Masterlist]
Fandom: Criminal Minds // Pairing: Spencer Reid x OFC
Taglist: @ocappreciationtag @arrthurpendragon @anotherunreadblog @maaaaarveeeeel @stareyedplanet @averyhotchner @foxesandmagic
If you’d like to be a part of Aitana’s taglist, please let me know!
Also available on Fanfic ○ Ao3 ○ Wattpad
The days after Emily's death passed by like a blur. The BAU seemed to sort of shut down for a while. They worked cases almost monotonously because it was their duty, but they weren't always together. Taking a few days had almost been a requirement for everyone, just not at the same time. Spencer and Morgan were the ones to take the most days out. No one batted an eye at the fact. Being short-handed wouldn't be a problem until later, but later was now.
Aitana didn't mind coming in early when Hotch asked her to. She'd taken it upon herself to work extra hard in the last week to cushion those who didn't have the energy to. Hotch, however, was the only one whose schedule hadn't changed. She admired him for that because she herself was struggling. He was the boss. He couldn't afford to do the same. He had to keep working.
"You understand that you were hired as a part-time liaison for the situation, right?" Hotch decided to start with first. It seemed so long ago now the day JJ came to him with the idea of who should take her job after she was gone. Aitana unknowingly thought of the same thing.
"Yeah," she whispered. "JJ gave me a landline. It's the first job after WP that I've been able to hold onto."
"And you've done it well. Not everyone has the skills to be a liaison. That's why it's a specific position." Hotch wanted her to understand that before he went into his next point. "You've been here a little bit more than 6 months now so you know that you're up for your probationary evaluation."
Aitana nodded. "I know."
"With Emily's passing, things have gotten a little backtracked but I need to warn you that it is happening."
"I figured," Aitana said. Strauss has already told her that the first time they met and she was not looking forward to having the evaluation if it was with her. "Is, uh, Strauss going to be—"
Hotch shook his head, a faint smile marking his face. "No, that's my job." He almost laughed when Aitana audibly exhaled. "She'll just see the paperwork."
"Okay." Aitana couldn't help the smile that made it to her face.
"As policy, the others are going to be subjected to a therapy session to see how they're handling Prentiss' death. You, however, as well as Seaver, are exempt due to your short term at the BAU."
"I sense a 'but' coming in soon…"
"Yes. I'll do the evaluation when I do the grief therapy. Give you time to process along the way."
"Thank you," Aitana said. She eyed Hotch curiously, trying to figure something out that she wouldn't exactly be hiding either.
For that matter, Hotch would move straight into the real reason she was called in earlier. "Strauss wants me to hire a new profiler, preferably an experienced one. Seaver is just about to graduate and having a probationary Agent wouldn't exactly be ideal under these circumstances. I am going to see my options but being frank, I would rather take over as a part-time Liaison with Garcia and simply change your position to a full time profiler." Aitana's eyes widened but she didn't say anything straightaway. "Strauss won't get off my back until the position for a profiler is filled and, thinking like JJ, a familiar face is always better than a new one. Especially when that familiar face does her job well. Is that something you would be interested in?"
"Umm…" So many things ran through Aitana's head that she couldn't answer quick enough. "I think...what would that...entail, exactly? I mean up until now I've done half and half…"
Hotch agreed. "Yes, but because of your liaison duties, it's kept you from the field at times."
"Right." Aitana's mind immediately went to the last big stunt they pulled which had been rescuing Emily. She had stayed behind to secure the area from civilians.
"We could afford it because there were plenty of other agents we could count on but now that…" Hotch trailed off as Aitana began to nod. The numbers had changed drastically. "Seaver will most likely move on and even if she doesn't, she still needs to gain experience before she could officially join. You had your experience before entering WIP and the following year when you got out. These months you've spent with us definitely helped you out too. If you're interested, the position would be yours...if you're interested in remaining here at all."
Aitana's eyebrows raised. "Come again?" The words blurted from her mouth. "At all? Do you think—"
"It was just a saying," Hotch clarified. "At the beginning you weren't very convinced about staying here. If that's still the case, you are more than welcomed to make a transfer request. I would write you an outstanding recommendation for whatever department you'd like."
"Oh," Aitana blinked. The idea of being free to transfer to a different department hadn't even crossed her mind. She's been so focused about getting her current job right that she hadn't even considered that maybe transferring to a different department could do her well too. It would definitely help ease her schedule.
"Would you like some time to think about it?" Hotch asked even though he already knew the answer. He understood it was a lot to take in and process. He had no qualms when Aitana admitted that she did need a few days. "You can talk it out with the others, if you'd like. Look around other departments if that's where you're thinking."
"Thank you," Aitana said, rising up from her chair to leave. She would really need a few days to think about the options she was presented with.
~ 0 ~
In order to get a feel of just what she could do with her career, Aitana made herself scarce in the BAU for a couple days. Penelope straightaway noticed the lack of her partner and though she wanted to ask about it—because she knew it wasn't personal days taken to mourn—she managed to keep her mouth shut. She went on presenting cases on her own. Slowly, the team started coming together again to try and be how they used to be, if that was even possible.
On the day that Aitana would need to return due to what seemed like a big case, she would be at home going over potential vacant positions. Her best friend, Elia, was with her trying to help organize the positions for Aitana's sake.
"You're kind of a slob," she crinkled her nose as she placed a new pile of papers on the floor.
Aitana was on the floor, cross-legged, as she read over one position. "I'm not a slob just because I refuse to move my puzzle," she said ever so calmly.
Elia sent a glare at the half finished puzzle on the coffee table. She'd made the mistake of pushing one corner of the puzzle to place some papers earlier. Aitana nearly chewed her head off with 'That's my puzzle! I'm going to finish it!'. "How Angel lives with you, I don't understand."
Aitana lowered the paper from her face to shoot Elia a smirk. "Just stay away from my puzzle and you won't get yelled at anymore."
"Right," Elia playfully rolled her eyes. As irritated as she portrayed herself, a huge part of her was so glad to see her best friend acting more like her old self. Working for the BAU really seemed to do the trick, and for that matter she was a little on the fence about Aitana changing departments. "Are you...are you sure you want to leave the BAU?"
Aitana didn't look up to see Elia's worried face but her tone was enough to know about it. "I'm not sure, El. That's why I'm looking. When all this started, I didn't have options. I was getting on people's nerves quitting and then taking up a new position. Nobody trusted that I could hold onto a job. JJ did and now that I've been at the BAU for a while—doing press conferences—my doors are opening again."
"So...you want to leave?"
Aitana shrugged her shoulders. "I don't know."
"It's just...I know I haven't really met your team except for Emily and Spencer, but...they sound nice. I wouldn't want you to have to start all over again with new people that you might not even get along with!"
Aitana paused before she read from a new paper. She raised an eyebrow at Elia, staring at her until she began to fidget. "Elia...something on your mind?"
Elia pursed her lips together. She wasn't planning on saying anything for fear of upsetting Aitana but if she was asking…?
"Elia?" Aitana asked again.
Elia sighed. "It's your job, it's your life, but as your best friend, I don't think you should leave." Aitana hummed but because she didn't say anything, Elia panicked. "I mean—I will completely support you whatever decision you make!"
"Calm down, Elia," Aitana laughed.
"I'm just saying—you've been doing so much better since you joined the BAU and I wouldn't want to see you regress."
"I won't," Aitana said, smiling softly at her. The fact she could believe in what she said showed her just how much better she was doing in comparison to the previous year. "The BAU is where I started getting better but my health is not dependent on it."
"Of course, of course," Elia nodded fairly fast. She didn't want Aitana to think that she thought the BAU was the only place she would be healthy.
"Elia, seriously, calm down. Whatever's on your mind, just tell me. I won't get mad."
Elia pulled in a breath before she would explain. "It's just hard to forget the people that cared so much about your possession when you guys knew each other for a few days. That to me spoke volume of their characters."
"That...that was a complicated thing…"
"I know, because of the whole snoopy reading and stuff but I'm talking about how much they cared enough to search for someone you knew and give the journal to them...me," Elia pointed at herself with a big grin on her face. "It's hard to find co-workers like that, trust me."
"I know," Aitana nodded. "But it's like I said, I'm just looking. I want to see the options."
"Have you told any of them about it?" Elia deduced the answer before Aitana even said anything.
"No," Aitana released a breath. "It's been too much of a mess for obvious reasons. And the one time we took off from mourning was for Seaver's graduation ceremony and I obviously wasn't going to say anything there." It'd been a bittersweet gathering anyways and it had been about Seaver. She wasn't going to say anything and ruin Seaver's day.
"You thinking about doing it soon?" Elia asked cautiously.
Before Aitana could say another 'I don't know', her cellphone vibrated on the table. She reached over for it to see a text from Penelope.
Big case. Urgent. Need you in.
"Is it them?" Elia curiously wondered.
"Yup," Aitana sighed as she sent a quick text back to Penelope. "I have to go."
"Of course," Elia nodded, gesturing for Aitana to go. "I'll leave this organized for you."
Aitana was already getting up from the ground. "Thanks, El." She would have to get her go-bag together again. After a while of not traveling, the bag had found its spot in the corner of her room.
~ 0 ~
Most of the team were already at the round table. Seaver was accepting a box of cupcakes when Aitana walked in.
"Woah, where'd those come from?" the brunette asked, curiously trying to take a peek over Seaver's shoulder. "And who did not spell right?" Because instead of saying 'Congratulations Graduate', it was missing the 't' and 'e'.
Penelope groaned from her seat, causing a small chuckle from Morgan and Spencer. "Don't remind me. Kevin is going to get an earful."
"Kevin?" Aitana and Seaver exchanged the same looks between themselves.
"Oh!" Penelope blinked. "Kevin, my boyfriend."
"Your what?" Aitana made a gesture of 'how the hell do I not know this?'. "Penelope, that's the type of information you share upfront! What if I actually flirted with him?"
"Not your type, Spicy Sprinkles," Morgan smirked as he grabbed a seat beside Spencer. "Trust me."
Penelope waved him off before he said anything else. "If you come by more often, I'll be happy to share more of my life with you," she said to Aitana instead, meaning each of her words in a playful tone.
"Sorry," Aitana still felt the need to apologize. Things were hard enough without her having to go missing for a few days. "I've been...looking."
"For what?" Seaver asked out of sheer curiosity. She grabbed her own seat and started passing the cupcake box towards Morgan and Spencer.
"Oh, you know, positions and whatnot," Aitana shrugged her shoulders casually but it was a failed attempt from the start. She was measuring each of their reactions.
Penelope, unsurprisingly, was dumbfounded. Seaver merely raised her eyebrows. Morgan was more puzzled and Spencer seemed to be calculating her instead.
"I'm sorry—what?" Penelope snapped out of her trance first. What seemed like disbelief and a possible irritation flashed across her face. "You're leaving!?"
Aitana's mouth opened several times but the right words were failing to come out. "I-I mean...I wouldn't...I'm not…"
"You're seriously thinking of leaving?" Spencer had joined Penelope with the same expressions. His head tilted to the side. "Now?"
"I just…" Aitana suddenly regretted ever opening her mouth. "Hotch was talking to me about my options now that...well…"
"Now that Emily is gone, you want to leave too?" The way Spencer finished that sentence was never the way Aitana would view things like. It caught her off guard, especially coming from him.
"Not like that," Aitana said quietly, her lips nearly forming a pout. Why was he spinning things like that against her?
"Then how else?" He challenged her to come up with a better answer.
The laugh was definitely not something she planned on doing but she had never been spoken to like that from him. She couldn't quite believe it, honestly, hence the laugh. "I am so confused right now..."
"Yeah, so are we," Spencer muttered. He could feel Morgan's burning gaze on him asking him what the hell he was doing. He didn't quite know.
Whatever Aitana would say next—because she didn't exactly know how to respond to that—would be interrupted by Hotch and Rossi coming in last. Aitana silently sunk into her chair beside Seaver who, due to the circumstances, could only give her a reassuring smile. Penelope would present the case but she would make her points later.
"Ok, we're going to Portland, Oregon, and it's not for a dead moon concert. So, Jay Johnson, a DJ, was cutting through an alley on his way home after leaving a club when he was bludgeoned by a pipe and then stabbed 31 times. His watch, his cell, and his computer were stolen. That was 2 days ago." Penelope brought up a picture of a woman on the screen for them. "Now, early this morning, Karen Heywood, a 30-year-old nurse, died during a home invasion. She was stabbed 40 times, but first she was bludgeoned with weapons of opportunity. Eight different ones, to be exact."
"That's too many weapons for one person," Seaver said at the top of her head.
"There was a left- and a right-handed killer according to the m. E. report," Penelope added.
"Yeah, but 8 different weapons…" Morgan reminded, "So we're looking for a group."
"And the left-handed wounds were deeper than the right."
"Maybe a woman was involved?" Aitana theorized. "Or a weak man."
"Anything taken from the house?" Spencer asked almost immediately after her as if she hadn't even asked anything in the first place. Aitana shot him a look, still incredulous he was going in this direction. He, however, didn't even afford her a glance.
Penelope hated that said missing glance was on her instead. Still, the job demanded her to answer. "According to a neighbor, just some random stuff: a computer, some jewelry, a framed picture of a Lily. And pawnable items."
"What do we have, serial-killing crooks?" Rossi looked over the hard copy in front him. "Sounds like a musical. Similar victimology... young professionals killed 3 miles apart. Is there a gang situation in Portland?"
Penelope shook her head. "Minimal."
"This seems more like desperate people in need of quick cash," Seaver thought logically and it did have some sense in it.
"But why kill them if it's just for the money?" Morgan challenged her, giving them something new to think about.
"That's what we have to find out," Hotch said, concluding the meeting. "And we've got 8 hours till nightfall. Let's go."
As everyone prepared to leave, Aitana lingered with her hard copy file. She was aware of the quick way that Spencer left the room. At least Morgan seemed to follow him to hopefully aid her a little bit.
"Did I do something wrong?" Aitana scratched her head.
"I think it's just the grief," Seaver said, trying to ease her nerves. She wasn't too fond of the mock-frown on Penelope's face. That certainly wouldn't help.
"It most certainly is the grief," Penelope 'hmphd' as she gathered her belongings. "After everything we did to find you and then these months we've worked together, you're just going to get up and leave?"
"No, of course not, I mean...I was just looking," Aitana said, feeling like a broken record the many times she'd said that already. "Hotch was asking me what I thought about becoming a full time profiler and he mentioned that he was willing to write me a recommendation if I wanted to transfer."
"But why!?" Penelope was all but stomping her way up to Aitana, her lips forming the most dramatic pout Aitana had ever seen. Not even her nephew did that.
"I'm just weighing my options, Penelope. I'm allowed to do that."
"Of course you are but wouldn't you rather stay with us instead?" Penelope turned her pout into a grin in record time.
Aitana's eyes moved towards the open door. "I don't know, maybe somebody's already wishing I was gone."
Penelope flipped her head in the bullpen's direction, eyes narrowing on Spencer already by his desk. Morgan was already trying to probably coax out an explanation from him. "Oh you leave Boy Wonder to me!"
"I would rather we not further push," Aitana admitted, now mostly out of fear for what Penelope might come up with. Behind her, Seaver snickered.
~0~
At the local precinct in Oregon, the evidence boards were already being made when the team arrived. The lead detective had passed the case's information to the conference room for them.
"That is a lot of stab wounds…" Seaver remarked with slightly widened eyes at the unfortunate pictures they had of their two victims.
Two very different spots served as the crime scenes yet the bodies both contained a similar overkill.
"The house too," Morgan directed her and Spencer to the home of their second victim which had been completely trashed. "It's a disaster."
"But according to what Garcia said, nothing of real value was taken," Spencer said as he went over the list she had compiled during their plane ride. "At first glance the responding detectives saw a television intact."
"Alright," Aitana strolled into the room with a paper in hand. "I got the names of the last people Jay and Karen supposedly talked to the night they died. I've got the club worker for Jay and a supermarket employee. Hotch and Rossi are going over Karen's house so we should just divide and conquer between us."
"Seaver and I can take the night club," Spencer was up and ready to leave with the Agent he chose.
Naturally, Aitana blinked in surprise when he came over just to pluck the paper from her hand. His eyes did a quick skim of the information then he handed it back to her, never once looking at her. "Ready?" He found Seaver and motioned her to leave with him.
The blonde agent was reluctant to go, her gaze crossing with Aitana's. "Uuh…"
Spencer wouldn't wait for her response. "I'll meet you at the car."
"Spencer?" Aitana called after him in vain. She turned to the remaining agents with a helpless look. "What the hell? Did I really piss him off that badly?"
"It's not you," Morgan said, intending on comforting her. He himself had yet to get a concrete answer out of Spencer so he was simply going by what he thought.
"You can go instead," Seaver offered but Aitana shook her head.
"No, I'm afraid that I'll mess it up even more. You go."
"Are you sure?"
"Yes, completely."
Seaver had no choice but to go catch up with Spencer. When she was gone, Aitana met Morgan's gaze. A sour smile crossed her face. "Are you willing to come with me?"
Morgan smiled genuinely at her. "You know it, Spicy Sprinkles."
~0~
Together, Seaver and Spencer went through the last location of Jay Johnson.
"So Mr. Johnson exits the nightclub through the back door to get to his car…" Spencer took the lead out from the backdoor of the club. He held the door open for Seaver who walked out into the alley.
"Maybe one unsub can watch from over there and the other from back there," she reasoned, eyeing the dumpsters lining both sides. It wouldn't be that hard to hide and scope. "Then when he gets here, another unsub hits him with a pipe and it's game on." Her eyes soon landed on the ground that were littered with all types of drug tools. "Look at the vials, Reid. This is a drug corridor."
Spencer would agree. It was easier to find the single spots of ground that weren't covered with drug vials. "That would explain why there's so much overkill."
"Maybe they were on something," Seaver said. "On the jet I did some research into the club. A year ago, someone O.D.'d inside. Since then, new management's clamped down on the partying."
"Which means the unsubs most likely fit into this area," Spencer nodded. The geo-profile he presented earlier was not that off then.
"Well, if you can't party inside, then you come out here," Seaver made a gesture to the alley. It would work as a party scene for drug users. "They're probably all the same age."
"Yeah, mid-20s," agreed Spencer.
"We should communicate that with the others."
Once more, Spencer would agree but he made a subtle request for Seaver to do the communications.
"Reid, you know that Aitana has every right to work where she wants, right?"
Spencer nodded. He started heading out the away for their car. "Of course. She has every right to do whatever she wants."
Seaver raised an eyebrow behind him. She followed slowly. "Then why are you giving her the stink eye?"
"What? No I'm not!" Spencer's lips rightfully formed a frown.
"Yes, you are, and it's very unlike you." Seaver felt like she had a right to say that because in the months she'd worked with him, she'd never seen him act in any kind of rude way. "If you're upset—"
"I am not upset," Spencer snapped, only acutely aware of it after doing it. He wasn't upset; he wasn't angry. It was the fact that nobody understood him that made him mad. Of course he knew that Aitana could get up and leave whenever she wanted to. As Seaver said, that was her right. Why she would want to leave was beyond him. With Emily gone, shouldn't they stay together? Help one another out? Had they...not helped her enough?
He liked to think that they, as a team, had helped Aitana slowly reconstruct her life. They didn't hold her hand but they offered a shoulder to lean on whenever she needed it. In doing so, she'd become a part of their team. Losing her was just another way to throw the team a curve. More losses, more change? His stomach churned at it.
~0~
It was uncanny how Aitana and Morgan finished their phone calls at the same time. Morgan had gotten a call from Hotch with a theory that they may be looking for just one unsub instead of a group like they initially thought. Aitana finished conversing with Seaver about the potential age of their Unsub(s).
"So we might be looking for one Unsub who could be in his 20s," Aitana related the phone call now that they they nearing they grocery store.
"Was that it?" Morgan asked, hoping there was perhaps a few more details she may be forgetting.
Aitana had to unfortunately squash that hope. "Yup. The Unsub is most likely in their 20s, possibly a drug user. That's what Seaver said."
Morgan didn't miss the emphasis and the subtle message behind it. He side-glanced the brunette who was walking with a grim face. "Hey now, don't worry too much. It'll pass."
"Yeah, but what did I do?" Aitana couldn't comprehend why looking into options was so...terrible?
"You look just as bothered," Morgan noted.
Aitana's lips were almost scowling, her freckles stretching as her cheeks puffed. "I am!" She admitted. "It's actually bugging me a lot!" It was almost startling, really, how irked she was about it. "I didn't say I was leaving. I was just looking to see what's out there. Why is that so bad?"
"It's not," Morgan confirmed. "And it's not that Reid thinks it is-"
"Then why is he so goddamn mad?"
"Well," Morgan shrugged. "At first glance, he doesn't like change and there's been some heavy changes lately." Aitana stayed silent at that. She did, however, stop walking. "JJ was forced to leave at the beginning of the year and now…" Silence cut through. It was still hard to say it out loud. Emily was gone.
Aitana exhaled a breath. It was hard to hold onto her frustration. "Dammit. That actually makes sense—but I don't have to like it!" She pointed a warning finger at Morgan. "And I don't have to stand for it!"
Morgan bobbed his head. "Yeah, but maybe you could talk?'
"Why should I? He's not exactly talking to me right now."
"Alright, maybe you should just let him cool down and maybe do the same for yourself." Morgan patted her shoulder and continued walking to the grocery store. He heard Aitana grumble under her breath but he decided not to comment. If Spencer wasn't talking to her then the least he could do as a friend was to let her vent.
They eventually found the employee from Aitana's list and pulled him aside to converse about Karen's final hours.
"You're sure you didn't see a group here that night?" Morgan asked the young man.
The man shook his head, looking pretty sure of himself too. "No. Just that woman and a few other people, but no groups. Look, if our cameras worked, you could see for yourself."
Aitana spared a glance at the cameras on the ceiling. They were up there as decoration. "Well, is it possible there was a group out in the parking lot?"
Once more the employee shook his head. "It's a ghost town. Nothing happens here that late."
So far, things were turning out to be like Hotch had suspected.
"All right, tell me where you saw Karen first," Morgan prompted the man to show them.
The man pointed to a few cash registers down from them. "She was buying cookies, and then she went to the register."
"Any other customers there?"
"There was one at the other checkout." The man watched as both agents' face scrunched with no doubt the same confusion.
"Why would you have 2 registers open that time of night?" Aitana was the one who eventually inquired. It seemed like a waste and every business always sought to minimize costs with their employees.
"There was this weird guy, mumbling to himself and swatting the air like someone was bugging him," the man explained, even now looking perturbed by the customer he described.
"What did this guy look like?"
"Regular white dude. Greasy. He was buying salt, bag of chips, water."
That could be who they were looking for.
"Did this guy and Karen interact?" asked Morgan.
"He said something to her, but she blew him off."
"Just put her head down and said something dismissive back?"
"Yeah, that's it."
"Yeah. We tend to do that when strange people talk to us. Unfortunately, it can backfire."
"Especially for women," Aitana remarked, already half guessing how things could have gone down.
Shortly after leaving the grocery, Morgan called Hotch back to let him know what they learned. "Yeah, Hotch. You were right. He was by himself, but he was acting strange, like he was being followed."
"Reid and Seaver said that the first victim was killed in an area of high drug use…" Rossi said from the background, "If he's hallucinating, it could be pcp. That would explain why he stole random things from Karen's place. He was out of it."
"And the erratic patterns in the stabbing," Hotch added, "The adrenaline rush from the drugs is probably behind the overkill. Get in touch with Garcia about the missing items."
"On it," Aitiana assured. Morgan led her back to the SUV and took the driver's seat while she called Garcia for the update.
"Okay!" the blonde chirped over the speakerphone. "Ok, I checked all the local pawn shops to see if any of those stolen items had shown up there. I'm coming up empty."
Aitana tilted her head, pondering for a moment. "Maybe he's trading the goods for drugs. Wouldn't be the first time."
"What do you mean, 'he'?" Penelope replied, puzzled. "We're talking about a group, right?"
"No, we think it's a solo addict who's hallucinating that he's not alone," Morgan explained.
"Wow. That is a game-changer!" Penelope said, her finger wiggling as she pulled up new searches.
"Okay, call us back if you find something," Aitana instructed and was about to hang up when Penelope called a sharp 'wait!'. Aitana blinked at the phone and once with Morgan.
"Can...can you take me off speaker for a second?"
Morgan smiled out of bemusement. She had a way of asking for things.
"Sure." Aitana couldn't help the amusement either. She brought her phone to hear and promised that the call was just between them now. "What's up?"
"I just...wanted to apologize for before," Penelope started off slowly. Aitana was almost sure that she was pouting. "I may have come off as nosey and...maybe a little selfish…"
Aitana chuckle relieved Penelope more than the former would've thought. "Pen, I'm not mad. I promise."
"I just didn't want you to leave but if that's what you want then of course I will support you 100%! I will make the visits, the phone calls-you and I are friends for life!"
Aitana couldn't help the second laugh. "I got the memo."
"We could make movie nights!" Penelope went on, her mind already scheduling out what days they could set it up. "What's your favorite movie!? I feel like you're a Disney gal!"
"Umm...yeah, I guess I am. I like Lilo and Stitch…"
Morgan snorted. "What?" Where, oh where, had this conversation gone?
Aitana rolled her eyes at him and pointed up ahead. "Eyes on the wheel, nosey."
"Oh!" Morgan exclaimed, feigning his offence.
Penelope snickered from the other end of the line. "He is, isn't he? But I love either way!"
Aitana mused over that relationship. If she left the BAU, she was sure that she would never find anyone like those two.
~ 0 ~
After another unfortunate victim crossed their paths, the team had grasped a pretty good idea of what kind of Unsub they were dealing with. which led to their presentation of the profile for the precinct.
As usual, Hotch began the profile for the group. "We believe our unsub is a white male paranoid schizophrenic who suffers from hallucinations. Since schizophrenic breaks usually occur in your early 20s, we believe he's around this age and that he lives nearby."
"We think this unsub is hypervigilant, and in this condition, he's unable to travel very far from his home. He kills at night and is extremely violent," Morgan took over, though a lot of the time his gaze wasn't on the attentive detectives but instead on Spencer. The young doctor sat pensively on the table behind them, eyes staring hard at the floor.
"During the day, he's most likely a loner," went Rossi, "Someone in this state probably can't keep a job. We believe something happened to our unsub in his childhood. "Childhood voices are telling him to kill, or he's misinterpreting them as doing so."
"Our unsub has probably been coping until now, but a recent stressor brought him back to that childhood incident and is causing him to act out," Seaver added, "Our unsub spends his days wandering, trying to fight the desire to kill, yet he feels trapped by his hallucinations. No matter what he does or tries to do, the hallucination's power is greater than his own."
"Because of his limited social circle as a child, it is our belief that the incident involved close friends or family," Aitana said, "Now, once we figure out what happened when he was a kid and the stressor that recently triggered a relapse, we'll be that much closer to narrowing down the killer's identity." She ended purposely so that Spencer could introduce the zones that he thought the unsub would most likely be. Instead, silence fell. She turned her head towards the man, surprised—and perhaps a little worried—that he had spaced out on them in the middle of the profile. "Um, Reid?"
At the call of his name, Spencer startled. He looked up to see everybody staring at him, waiting for his input. "Umm…" He looked around him for the map he'd been working on and pulled it off the table. He turned it around for the detectives to see. "We need you all to start searching in this area." He made a weak gesture towards the deep red circles he'd draw over the zones. "Based on previous kills, we know that he strikes at night and will not retreat until we find him."
Nobody would comment on his languid presentation, at least not at that moment.
Aitana had actually paced back and forth a good fifteen minutes before working up the courage to talk to him again. She couldn't help wonder if his behavior was because of her. She never wanted to affect his work, even more when she knew just how good he was at it. She ventured out to find him and was lucky to catch just as he was about to go into the men's restroom.
"Spencer! Could we talk for a moment?" She was hopeful that he might be more open to a conversation.
"I'm not really in the mood..." He started and unknowingly squashed her hope with those six words already.
"Please!" She clapped a hand against the restroom door, effectively keeping it shut. "The way you were earlier with the profile—" She startled when he scoffed sharply at her.
"The profile," he muttered.
She blinked at him several times. "Um, are you upset with the profile?" Had their disagreements come to affect even that? "Because, really, the profile was a team effort. I didn't come up with it."
"I know," he said, settling a look on her. "It's a bit misleading, don't you think?"
"Well...I don't...I don't really think so…" Aitana admitted, her eyes slightly wide. It wasn't like him to say anything like that about their profiles. "I thought it was pretty spot on."
"That profile kind of makes it sound like schizophrenia leads to serial killing!"
"What? That's not—we would never imply that! Why would you even think that?" She frowned. "Just because you're mad at me—"
"This has nothing to do with you, Serrano!" he snapped. It startled Aitana again. He never called her by her last name. He turned for the restroom but sighed when her hand remained against it. "Could you move, please?"
Not wanting to further provoke him, Aitana pulled her hand off the door. He went inside without so much of a glance her way. She didn't know how long she stayed outside, or if she had even stayed long enough, but she stiffened when she saw Morgan coming her way.
"Don't take it personally, sprinkles," he said, letting her know that he had everything.
"It's a little hard not to," she swallowed hard. God, why was this affecting her so much? She had pissed off so many people before ever meeting the BAU, for God's sake! She snapped out of her thoughts when Morgan placed a hand over her shoulder. She looked up to see him offering her one of his best, possibly charming, smiles.
"This case just got a little more personal for Reid, but it's nothing to do with your issues. Once he comes off it, he'll come back to talk to you."
"Will he want to?" A humorless laugh slipped out of her. "Because it seems like every time I open my mouth, I make it worse."
"Hey now," he playfully bopped her chin, "I'm not quite sure I like this pouty Aitana."
"I am not pouty," she said with all the maturity in the world. "I just don't like it when my friend is mad at me."
"Mm, 'friend'," he smirked.
She rolled her eyes. "Not like that, Morgan. I just really don't like it, alright?"
"How's about I go and talk to him, huh?"
"I'm honestly afraid…"
Morgan deadpanned her for a second, raising a finger to warn her to watch her words. Still, in the end he flashed her a smile and went into the restroom. It was no surprise to find Spencer throwing water at his face at the sinks.
"Okay, Pretty Boy, what are you doing out there?" Morgan jerked a thumb over his shoulder as if Aitana would still be on the other side of the door.
"What?" Spencer's response was slightly muffled by the paper towels he was dragging over his face.
"Don't 'what' me—you're doing a very good job messing with Serrano over there."
For once, the glare Spencer sent Morgan wasn't one the latter would want to be under. "I am not doing anything," he muttered and threw the paper towels at the trash. He didn't care that half of them hadn't made it to the trash.
"Okay, it's the profile too, I know," Morgan said, letting his head hang low to catch Spencer's gaze. "But she doesn't, right?"
"No," Spencer agreed, "She doesn't know my mom has schizophrenia."
"Okay, so you know it's not very fair to take out your frustration over this on her, right?"
"Of course," Spencer mumbled. "But this profile we gave, it—there are many different types of schizophrenia."
"I know that," Morgan nodded.
"Catatonic, disorganized...just because someone suffers from inability to organize their thoughts or they can't bathe or dress themselves, it doesn't mean they'd stab someone in the chest 30 times postmortem."
"Of course," Morgan agreed. "And I'm sure that Aitana agrees with that too."
"Our unsub's hallucinations aren't fractured like a typical schizophrenic. They're vivid and clear, leading me to believe that we're missing an important variable. Rather than making crazy conjectures, I think we should be trying to figure out what it is."
"Ok, listen to me." Morgan stopped Spencer from trying to leave, at least for another minute. "I know this is a scary age for you. It's when schizophrenic breaks happen. Have you talked to anybody about this?"
"Not really." Spencer squared his shoulders as if trying to shake off the turmoil he was feeling inside. He was more than halfway through his 20s, if any symptoms would appear the time would be now. It was needless to say that he'd paid extra attention to himself over the past years and he was unsure whether or not to be afraid that nothing of the sort had happened yet. He was anxious each day, wondering if this day would be the day the symptoms started.
"Have you considered talking to a doctor?" Morgan tried.
"I have visited a few just to make sure," Spencer admitted. Nothing had turned him towards the doctors except for his precautions. "They all say I'm fine. Perfectly healthy."
"Then why don't you believe them?"
"Because predicting one's chances of developing a genetic condition are like finding a penny in an ocean. It's next to impossible. I have to take it day by day and hearing profiles like that does not help. Knowing what could wait for me, it's...it's…" Spencer had no way of finishing that sentence, nor the desire to. His hands tangled together.
"Kid, keep calm," Morgan instructed, "As far as you know, you are healthy. The only things you have going on right now is grief for Prentiss and a disdain for change. Serrano does not deserve that last one."
"I know," Spencer said, inwardly sighing. He despised change and Emily leaving them was a huge change for the team.
"Then why don't you go and explain yourself to her, hm?"
"Because she might just get angrier knowing my reasons." They weren't exactly the best reasons, much less reasonable since he was basically blaming her.
"Something tells me that she won't," Morgan winked. "Work the old rapport you had with her three years ago."
Spencer tilted his head at him, expression falling flat. "Not funny," he pointed, truly hating the teasing laughter that came out of Morgan.
"It was funny then and it's funny now. Go get her, Pretty Boy," Morgan winked again, prompting Spencer to leave in a hurry. He was not interested in another.
~ 0 ~
After a bit more digging, the team came to realize that perhaps the unsub was trying to take care of himself by performing a sort of exorcism. It wasn't much to go on by but it was enough to acquire more possible witnesses.
"He came here in duress about...2 hours ago," the priest was able to answer Morgan and Spencer almost on the spot. They hadn't even had to describe the man for the priest to know who they were looking for. "He said voices were blaming him for a fire, and he needed me to get rid of them."
"You're right. He thinks he's haunted," Morgan mumbled to Spencer.
"Did he ask you for an exorcism?" Spencer asked the priest.
"Yes. He claimed his mother had taken him to get one when he was young."
"And what did you tell him?"
"I couldn't do it. Throughout history, people have confused possession with mental illness. Some still do. Nowadays, most churches turn people like him over to medical professionals."
"I'm assuming he didn't take your rejection well," Morgan said.
"He was very angry."
"But he didn't attack you? He didn't threaten you in any way?"
The priest shook his head. He didn't even appear harmed either.
"He's probably gotten help from the church before," Spencer deduced. The unsub was a violent one and he'd proved it. "Was there anything else about his behavior that you found odd? Like something he maybe said or did?"
"No. I told you everything. Oh…" the priest made a pause, "Um, there is one thing. He had a stutter."
That was certainly new.
"Psychogenetic stuttering begins in the area of the brain that controls thoughts and reasoning," Spencer was saying in a fit of thoughts once he and Morgan left the church. "It's most commonly associated with mental illness."
"We checked with the supermarket guy and the lady at the building, but neither one of them heard stuttering," Morgan said after checking the text he'd gotten back from Aitana to confirm their original suspicions.
"Which means it's either caused by the schizophrenia medication or maybe it's situational," Spencer said.
"Well, the presence of it along with the fire information should help Garcia narrow down her list." Morgan had faith that Penelope would come through for them.
There would just be one more murder before she could do it.
Aitana was the one who called it in. The precinct had alerted her early in the morning the day I got a new victim. There is no doubt that it was from the same unsub due to the overkill on the corpse.
"I already took a look," she told Morgan and Spencer as she led them into the house. "It's bad. Detective Colbern's talking to other neighbors to see if they heard anything."
Because once the pair of agents were led in the room and they were able to see the corpse, they would think that other people had to have heard this woman screaming for her life. She was on the ground with so many stab wounds all over her. A pool of blood was right beside her, staining the carpet.
"I'll go see if Colbern needs me outside and leave you two to make your own assumptions," she said to the pair, though her eyes lingered more on Spencer when she spoke.
"What?" Morgan sent her an odd look. "No, we need you here."
She smiled so strained that both men had to wonder if it physically hurt her. "Believe me, I get it. Personal space," she said, eyes directly on Spencer, "I got it." Her smile dropped and she turned to leave.
Spencer absolutely hated the way Morgan looked at him as Aitana walked out of the room. "You know you had that one coming-"
"Yeah, I know," Spencer cut him off sharply, preferring not to look at him for the moment. He'd already messed things up terribly with Aitana, he did NOT not need the commentary too. He would rather focus on this case first and then see how he could redeem himself to Aitana later.
He moved around the corpse, eyeing the different stab wounds. "This victim's a lot older than his other ones, Morgan. She must represent something to him."
"Maybe his mother who had him exorcised," Morgan theorized. "Now that he can't get one, he's taking his anger out on a surrogate."
"Aitana said the EMTs didn't do anything so why's there a body imprint next to her?" Spencer gestured to the print beside the corpse. The more he studied it, the less it appeared to belong to an EMT. They would lie down.
Morgan came to the same conclusion and nearly shuddered. "Why would the unsub lie down next to a person he's just killed?"
"He slept here," Spencer reached the conclusion first. "Look at the number of stab wounds."
Morgan had. "There's gotta be over 50 of them."
"71," Spencer corrected. "Do you know how physically exhausting it would be to stab someone 71 times? It's hard enough to stab someone 10 times, but 71…" He did the hand movements against his thigh, thinking about each stab and the energy the Unsub would have to use.
"He'd be completely worn out," Morgan trailed over the stab wounds. "He's accelerated wound counts, which means he does it intentionally."
"Wait, that's it," Spencer blinked, "If you add the increased number of stab wounds and the fact that he slept here to the vivid hallucinations and the unexplainable onset of stuttering, you get the missing variable. This guy's an insomniac. Just as adrenaline makes a person love the feeling of killing, once it leaves the body it makes them tired."
Morgan had a hard time wrapping his head around it but not out of disbelief. He'd seen much odder things. "He does this all to sleep…"
"The insomnia is what makes the hallucinations so clear, and sleep is the only release that he has from them." That was what they'd been missing all along. Spencer dashed out of the room first, prompting Morgan to quickly follow.
They grabbed Aitana on the way, rather harshly that the brunette was left stumbling a few steps. "I'm not as tall!" she complained in their run. On the back to the precinct is where she would learn why they'd rushed back.
~0~
Garcia was quick to find their potential Unsub now that they had refined their search.
"Ben Foster has a prescription for thorazine and ambien…" she started saying and unknowingly helping to connect the last of their pieces.
"It's likely he uses the money from the stolen items to buy the pills he needs," Seaver said.
"What's his background, baby girl?" Morgan bad to ask if only to truly confirm this was their guy.
"He moved to Portland 3 years ago. A month ago he was in an apartment fire, after which he got a sleeping pill medication because his insomnia began again. Oh, my…" Penelope paused, only the sharp intake of her breath leaving a noise, "When he was 10, he was questioned during an investigation about a fire that killed 3 people."
"It could be part of the homicidal triad," Morgan remarked, waiting for the others to agree with him. They did.
"I'm looking at the police report right now. It turns out 2 months before, his mom had a local minister perform an exorcism on him, and the 3 people who were killed in the fire helped perform that exorcism."
"Was Ben charged?" asked Hotch.
"No. He was acquitted in juvie court."
"Do you have an address?" Rossi said.
"2627 Halden way!"
"Thanks, Garcia," Hotch hung up the call then turned to the team. "Alright, let's start planning."
The others agreed and while they started, Aitana rushed around the precinct gathering the detectives. Once they were all together, they settled on the best extraction plan.
They headed off for the house of Ben Foster, hoping to surprise him. The easiest way to capture him and avoid any incidents was using surprise as an element.
Hotch was at the head of the group, leading both Seaver and Morgan towards the front of the house. Rossi and Spencer would take the other group around the back while Aitana and Detective Colbern spread the remaining detectives around the block.
Of course their element of surprise wouldn't last long. Hotch burst through the front door, his group flooded the living room.
"He's going out back!" Morgan exclaimed over the comms., prompting Rossi and his side to take over.
They headed for the back only to catch a glimpse of Ben making a dash for it through the back gate.
"He's going through the back street!" Rossi yelped through the comms.
"We're on it!" Aitana exclaimed, making a sign for the others to go around. One way or another they would trap the guy.
Hotch and Morgan separated to take each end of the street while Aitana crossed through the middle. Being smaller allowed her to slip in-between two gates of buildings.
"I see him!" She exclaimed, pushing herself to go quicker. She glanced back to see Seaver sprinting to a stop at the entrance between the gates. "No, go around the other way!" Seaver reluctantly nodded and turned back.
"I'm after him!" They heard Spencer say. He was currently chasing after Ben with a couple other detectives.
Aitana soon made it to the other side and saw Ben coming in her direction. She saw Spencer and the other detectives at a distance behind him. Though she came out in a stumble, she raised her gun on the man. "FBI! Stop!"
Ben did no such thing. All Aitana saw was the wave of his knife coming at her. She fired once but with his arms flailing, she missed. Instead, he came up with an attempt to punch her. She had to duck and in doing so, turned slightly on her side. Coming up, Ben took the opportunity to jab his knife on her exposed lower side. She yelped, eyes widening on Ben who couldn't seem more frazzled. Just as easily he had plunged the knife into her, he yanked it out of her.
"Wait—" She tried reaching for him but he took off, pushing her in the process. She stumbled and eventually fell to the ground. Her breath was ragged and shaky as she tried to see her wound.
"Aitana!" Spencer skidded to a scrambling stop beside her, falling to his knees. "Y-you're hurt—"
"I'm good! Go!" She waved a hand at him, though because it was the hand on her injured side, she groaned out of pain.
Spencer motioned for the other detectives to catch up with Ben. "I need backup; there's an agent down! Aitana, here…" He tried raising her body only slightly but stopped when she let out a yelp.
"No! No! Just go!"
"I am not going anywhere! You're hurt!"
"It's a scratch—ow!" Aitana lurched forwards with a particular strong jab.
"You need to apply pressure!" Spencer moved her hands over the wound, pressing enough to stop some of the blood flow. He could see her blood beginning to stain his hands. He panicked. The blood seemed to be coming out faster? He couldn't tell if it was just his imagination or if it was really happening. All he knew was that this was the way that Morgan had found Emily in that warehouse and no matter how much he tried, Emily had still died. He didn't get to say goodbye to her and now if something happened to Aitana-an idea that was already scaring him to the bone-the last things that happened between them were arguments. More change and more pain.
"I can do it, just leave me!" Aitana was in no position to push his hands off her but she still tried. "Go catch the guy!"
Spencer refused and kept his hands right over her wound. He could feel her hands weakly wrapping around his wrists emptying to get his hands off her. "I'm not leaving—"
"GO!"
"YOU'RE NOT DYING TOO!"
Aitana stared at Spencer with widened eyes. Her hands let his wrists go completely. He was too frantic with himself and he only just now realized it. He couldn't help it. This had to end differently than it had with Emily. He couldn't let her leave this way too.
"I-I'm not dying," Aitana said slowly, swallowing down a groan to make her case. "I'm...it's just a scratch." She should've known that this would go deeper for him. Maybe that's why this whole thing started in the first place and she missed it! What kind of profiler was she—no, what kind of friend was she if she couldn't see it?
"It's not just a scratch!" snapped Spencer. "It's a stab wound! You're not…" He couldn't even finish the words. This was a similar way to what led Emily to her death and he was not going to let Aitana go down the same road.
"I'm not, I promise!" Aitana exclaimed. "It doesn't even hurt that much, go! Go get Ben!"
"Aitana! Spencer!" They heard Seaver who was running towards them.
"Go get Ben!" Aitana ushered Spencer to get up. He shook his head stubbornly. "I said GO!" she yelled, immediately regretting it. Spencer hesitated even when Seaver came to their side. Aitana gave him an encouraging nod. "I'm good, it doesn't hurt."
"We got her, Reid," Seaver promised him.
He was absolutely against the idea of leaving but given the situation, he forced himself to do it. "Just...just take care of her," he told Seaver. "I'm—I'll be back, Aitana."
"Mhm, I'm good," she said with an obvious strain to her tone. She waited for him to finally take off and when he did, she grabbed Seaver's arm, pulling the woman towards her. "I lied—this hurts like a bitch!"
Seaver would have laughed if the situation hadn't been this bad. She only nodded and promised her they would get her some help.
8 notes
·
View notes