Stuck Between a Jock and a Metalhead
Summary: Nancy, on a whim, decides to visit Steve at Scoops Ahoy, which leads to her overhearing confessions from Steve that leads her to think about the decisions she's made. A few days later, she decides to come back. She finds him being hit on by the town freak. What's a girl to do? Oh, get stuck in a freezer with the both of them.
18+ MINORS DNI
A/N: Yeah, when I got the idea to make El genderfuid, I just ran with it. Also, at the end, there's a little bit of smut, which was supposed to be mostly implied, but my fingers ran away from me. Also, there is no teen pregnancy for Nance. They've already got kids to take care of. Just had to put that out there.
@nightmareglitter
Chapter One - Chapter Two - Chapter Three - Chapter Four - Chapter Five - Chapter Six - Chapter Seven - Chapter Eight - Chapter Nine - Chapter Ten - Chapter Eleven - Chapter Twelve - Chapter Thirteen - Chapter Fourteen- Chapter Fifteen
Chapter Sixteen
Steve’s POV
Steve grinned as he watched Eddie score the winning point, and he laughed at Eddie's stunned face.
"Holy shit, I did it," Eddie said. "I won the game! Here I am, Hawkins! Eddie the Freak Munson has conquered the sport of basketball! Fear me!"
Steve laughed again and stared at his raised arms before smirking. He snuck up on Eddie's side. He knelt to pick him up and tossed him over his shoulder. Steve laughed as he spun him around. Lucas and El, who they had been playing against, started giggling.
"I like basketball," El decided.
"Steven! I'm going to toss my fucking cookies. Stop it!" Eddie shrieked.
Steve laughed and lowered him into his arms. Eddie wrapped his legs around him and kissed him deeply.
"So?" Steve asked.
"Okay, so basketball isn't that bad," Eddie said. "I really loved it when you started narrating it like you were a dungeon master."
"Yeah, we call those guys sports announcers or sports casters," Steve said.
"Tomato, potato," Eddie paused. "So, am I forgiven?"
"Definitely," Steve grinned and set Eddie down, slapping him on the ass. "Hit the showers."
"You heard him, lady and gent, hit the showers!" Eddie exclaimed.
"I am one of the boys today," El said seriously.
"Ah, okay. Remind me to make you special pins again," Eddie said.
"You always tell me to remind you. I think you need pins to remind you to make me pins," El replied.
"Oh, very funny! My little brother, the comedian!" Eddie exclaimed and paused. "Although, it's not a bad idea."
"Nancy said that you would forget your head if it was not screwed on," he said.
"Nancy's cute, but yeah, she's usually right," Eddie grinned at his brother.
Surprisingly, it was Steve and Eddie who were out of the showers first. Eddie collapsed on the bench next to Nancy and Robin, laying his head in Nancy's lap.
"What are you ladies doing?" Eddie asked.
"Filling out college applications," Nancy said as she set her notebook aside. "You were really good out there."
"Oh, yeah, how do you think the other jocks would react if I signed up to join the basketball team this year?" Eddie asked.
"Not very well," Nancy giggled.
"I would pay to see that," Steve said.
"I am not looking forward to school tomorrow," Eddie groaned. "Another year of hell, but I am determined to graduate this year. No one can stop me, not even Principal Higgins."
"If I have to threaten him too, I will," Nancy said. "You're walking across that stage with me."
"I love it when you defend my honor. It makes me feel like a princess," Eddie said.
"You are a princess, our princess," Steve teased as he leaned against Nancy's legs to kiss Eddie.
El and Lucas finally came out of the shower, making their way over to the group.
"El had a great idea. Let's grab some dinner," Lucas said, and then he paused. "Hey, I just realized. . . Why aren't Mike and Dustin here?"
"I told them they needed to come up with a really awesome one-shot to audition for Hellfire," Eddie said. "They didn't realize I was fucking with them so they're working on it right now."
"Nice," Steve said, rolling his eyes.
"Hey, I'm actually invested in seeing what they come up with," Eddie said. "Might be fun."
El opened his mouth to suggest what they could possibly eat for dinner, and Eddie immediately sat up to glare at him.
"You can't eat waffles all the time, El," Eddie said. "I love waffles as much as the next person, but we can not have them for dinner for a third day in a row."
"Aww," El said.
"I could definitely use a break from these college applications," Robin said. "My hand hurts."
The group headed out. Eddie and El went to Eddie's van. Lucas, Robin, and Nancy followed Steve to his car. Steve was about to open his car door when he heard the sound of footsteps behind him, and he tensed up immediately when he saw Nancy scowl. Steve whirled around and came face to face with Tommy H.
"And just when I thought the rest of my day was going to keep looking up," Steve sighed. "What do you want, Tommy?"
"Just curious if your daddy knows about how public you are with your affections?" Tommy asked.
When Steve tensed up even further, Lucas and Robin moved to his side.
"You saw me with Eddie," Steve stated.
"Well, he kissed you in the school gym. You guys weren't exactly subtle," Tommy said.
"My dad knows about me, but he doesn't particularly care for others to know," he said and paused. "Are you planning on telling him?"
"You wouldn't like that, would you?" Tommy asked.
"No," Steve scoffed. "What do you want?"
"To warn you to be more careful next time, Harrington," Tommy said.
"Are you threatening him?" Nancy asked, moving in front of Steve protectively.
"What? No!" Tommy exclaimed, his eyes wide.
"Well then, what are you doing? Because you sure sound like you were threatening him," Robin said, scowling at him.
"I, uh, I guess it did sound like that," Tommy said, rubbing the back of his head.
Steve tilted his head to the side as he watched Tommy. He had known him most of his life, considering their fathers worked together. There were only a few times when he had seen Tommy look vulnerable like this.
"What's going on?" Steve asked softly.
"They're okay with you?" Tommy asked.
"Yeah, they're my friends. Of course, they are," Steve said.
It was then that Eddie approached with El, the both of them looking concerned. Tommy stepped back, his hands in his pockets.
"Is something going here?" Eddie asked. "Hayes."
"Uh, actually, it's Hagan. That's the other Tommy H," he replied.
"Right," Eddie said. "He's the asshole who used to come after me and Hellfire. Lot more blond and a lot less freckles. You're Steve’s former friend who swarmed around Hargrove like a pilot fish."
"I was trying to make Steve jealous," Tommy said. "Honestly, kind of hated the guy."
"What?" Steve asked.
"I'm gay, Steve," Tommy replied.
"What? But you and Carol - " Steve said.
"I was the one who made up that rumor about me and Carol having sex in the seventh grade. Honestly, we only did it a couple of times before I realized I was trying to be someone I wasn't. I was an asshole for a long time because of it. You know, just because I was struggling with who I am, though, doesn't exactly give me the right to act like that. I guess, if I seemed miserable, it's because I was. I treated you, Nancy, and Barb like shit. I talked shit about everyone, too. I guess it was easier to do that than to face the truth about myself," Tommy shrugged.
"There he is," Steve grinned. "There's the Tommy that I remember."
"Thanks for allowing us to be there for that, man," Eddie said softly. "I do have a question. You said that you were trying to make Steve jealous?"
"Uh, I was in love with him for a long time," Tommy winced. "That's sort of why I hated you, Nancy, but I'm no longer in love with him. I actually have a boyfriend!"
He pulled out his wallet and pulled out a small photo from the folds. He handed it to Steve.
"Oh, wow, he's cute," Steve said.
"His name is Walter. He just finished his first year at the University of Indianapolis. I'll be going there in a few days," Tommy said proudly. "My mom took that photo."
"Your mom knows?" Steve asked.
"Yeah, I decided to tell both of my parents. Of course, my dad didn't take it too well. Tried to beat it out of me. My mom took my old baseball bat to his head. She actually deafened the bastard. He's in jail now," Tommy shrugged.
"Damn, way to go Carmen," Steve said.
"Yeah, she's more than okay with it. She loves Walter," Tommy said.
"Hey, we were about to grab a bite to eat. Do you want to come with us?" Eddie asked.
"I mean, I was going to shoot hoops in the gym one last time, but if it's alright with Steve and everyone else, I'd like that," Tommy said.
"Of course," Steve said and pulled Tommy into a hug.
After so long, it felt nice to have his old friend back. Robin did make sure that Tommy wasn't just going to slip back into his old role, that the position had been filled. She told him she was a lesbian and then patted his cheek before slipping into the back seat of Steve’s car.
"You should know, though, that I'm not just with Eddie either," Steve said. "I'm back with Nancy."
"And they're both okay with it?" Tommy asked.
"We're all dating each other," Nancy replied.
"Are you happy, Steve?" Tommy asked.
"Happier than ever," Steve shrugged. "I've got an amazing boyfriend and girlfriend as well as an amazing new best friend. Kids who look up to me. . .I have a family who actually cares about me more than my parents ever did."
"Sounds like we both got to a better place," Tommy said. "Somehow."
"Sometimes life surprises you," Steve shrugged.
"You think that there's a spot for me in your better life?" Tommy asked.
"Of course, Tommy," Steve said. "What about me in yours?"
"I kind of always left the door open even if I didn't let you know," Tommy said. "I missed you, man."
"I've been missing you for a long time," Steve said. "It's good to see you again, Tommy."
"It's good to see you, too."
As they sat around the largest table in the restaurant, missing Dustin and Mike, Steve realized that he realized that a part of him had been yearning for Tommy to be a part of his life again. Later that night, he lay in bed in his newly furnished apartment in between Eddie and Nancy, Steve couldn't stop the wide grin from spreading on his face. All the furniture he had taken from his parents' house, jumping the gun on moving into the apartment and so ready to leave his biological parents behind. The only thing he really needed now was a new stove and new supplies for downstairs. His real parents had chipped in for an AC unit as a welcome home present. So, he had packed up all of his things, what little he had there, left a message on his parents' machine about their house getting robbed, and left the house for good.
"Whatcha grinning about, Stevie?" Eddie asked.
"Just thinking about how insanely happy I am right now," Steve said and paused. "Are you alright with Tommy being back in my life, Nancy?"
"Of course, I actually like this Tommy," Nancy grinned.
"Well, this is the Tommy that I befriended when I was younger," Steve said. "I really missed him."
"Then I really glad he's back in your life," Nancy said.
"By the way, Nance, how did you get your mom to let you have a sleepover with your boyfriends on a school night?" Eddie asked.
"She trusts us. I mean, it turns out I wasn't exactly as sneaky as I thought I was when you both snuck into my room. She knew you were there. I think she'd rather I'd be honest with her if I'm just going to do it anyway. She also knows how happy we are together," Nancy said. "And Holly absolutely adores the both of you. As does Mike."
Eddie grinned as he got up and pulled a book out of his overnight bag.
"Okay, so where did we leave off?" He asked.
"Actually, Nancy and I were talking. . .we were hoping to have sex but if you want to read instead. . . " Steve said.
"Okay, Munsons do not throw books," Eddie said and carefully put the book back.
He jumped back into bed, kissing Steve deeply. Steve laughed and broke the kiss.
"So, you don't want to read?" Steve asked.
Nancy laughed and rolled her eyes. She tugged at Eddie's shirt, lifting it above his head.
"Nancy and I say no to that," Eddie said.
Eddie kissed Nancy, leaning over Steve to do it. He tugged at Nancy's shirt and slid his fingers under the material. He continued to kiss Nancy, unbuttoning her sleep shirt and sliding it off her body. He broke the passionate kiss to appreciate the fact that she wasn't wearing a bra. Nancy peered at him, her eyes dark. She tugged at Eddie's pajama pants.
"Off. Now," Nancy demanded.
Eddie was quick to obey, getting rid of his pants and his boxers. Nancy did the same and shed the rest of her clothes. Steve could only watch, mesmerized as they kissed over him again. Eddie broke the kiss with Nancy, chuckling.
"I guess we're the only ones who will be naked, Nancy," Eddie said.
"I guess so," Nancy said in amusement.
"Oh, right!" Steve exclaimed, blushing and quickly stripped.
The three of them fell into bed, laughing, as they pressed themselves together. Their hands and mouths explored every inch of each other as they danced together, rolling around on the bed. They grinded and thrusted in perfect unison but arriving on their own time in perfect ecstasy. It ended with Nancy in between them both as they fucked into her, filling her up from both sides and stuffing her full as she took them in hungrily. Nancy's nails clung to Eddie as Steve spilled into the condom from behind Nancy. Their sweaty naked bodies were spent as they pulled away and collapsed against the sheets. Steve bit his lip and tried not to say it. . .trying not to ruin the moment that was so perfect. He needed to say it.
"I love sex," Nancy gasped and then paused. "What I meant to say was I love you. . .I love you both, and I love having sex with you."
"Honey, there's nothing to be ashamed of. A woman is allowed to have healthy sexual appetite and to enjoy it," Eddie said with a chuckle and ran his fingers across her skin. "It's only been a couple of months but fuck, I love you guys, too."
"I love you too," Steve said. "Both of you."
"Shit. I think my condom broke," Eddie cursed. "Of course, mine is the one that breaks."
"I'm on the pill. Are you clean?" Nancy asked.
"Yeah. Very."
"Then I think we're fine," Nancy chuckled.
After they cleaned each other up, they collapsed back onto the bed again. Nestled safe in their arms, Steve was unbelievably happy, and in that moment, he believed nothing could go wrong. As he drifted off to sleep, he tried not to think about Eddie's dreams and what they might mean for them. No, right now they were together and they were happy. Nothing was going to get in their way, not if Steve could help it.
Chapter Seventeen
43 notes
·
View notes
ID: a set of 28 images in 14 pairs. each has one image of the listed regretevator character, with a white outline in front of their corresponding flags, and a second image which is a blank flag splice. END ID
Bive from Regretevator is an intersex transnull transentien fessivoia animinsequikenic paralurdarean oculagoric masc futch demiboygirl womanthing who is bisexual and demiromantic! She uses she/it and nameself pronouns! It suffers with PPD, bipolar-2, insomnia, nightmare disorder, agoraphobia, anthropophobia, and tokophobia!
Dr. RETRO is a hypergender hyperfeminine hypermasculine genderdoctor gendermedic gendermedical optiminihilismic lifemitres rotlace imagifriendic evclardette cat-thing catgirlthing who is aromantic bilechen and lesbilechen! Mew uses mew/she/it/that pronouns! She has C-PTSD and several charges of aggravated assault against it but we don't talk about that!
Gnarpy is a genderless stellavenostalgic alienthing cat-thing who is canonically aroace! They have delusions of grandeur and mythomania!
Infected is a genderfluid bigender emorosboy emothing scenething frutiaexplosion metalheartexplosion oldtechexplosion gendertoxic genderthmpk lovirium pinkthing guything who is a lithsexual gay guy! He uses he/it/O_o/XD pronouns! It is a nonhuman otherkin, specifically catkin, sparkledogkin, zombiekin, skeletonkin and robotkin! O_o has depression, separation anxiety, BPD, autism, nyctophobia, autophobia, and chronophobia!
Lampert is a luxthing deminonbinary demiman who is panromantic and orchidsexual! He uses he/him pronouns! He has intermittent explosive disorder, autism, and cyclothymia!
Mannequin Mark is a genderqueer butch gay man! He uses any pronouns and suffering from major depressive disorder!
Party Noob is a xenogender pasteinbowin rainbowfleuric confettigender cakegender birthdayboy birthdayspike sillyaean bubblexplosion strortcakexplosion funfettiexplosion cakexplosion sprinklic cakecoric kandigender confettium nonbinary partyboything! They are acrisexual and toric and use they/he/it/🥳/✨/🎉/🪅/🎈/🎊/🍰/🎂 pronouns! He has autophobia, atychiphobia, ADHD, and autism!
Pest is an intersex genderless agabless agender transnull adexsexual gay bugthing! He uses he/it/one pronouns! It has ASPD, PPD, BPD, bipolar-1, hypermania, and hypersomnia!
Pilby is a heehoogender clowngender sweetnsillygender kidcoric clowncoric xenogender sillygender clownish asclownbunplushic nonbinary bug! They use they/zhe/clown pronouns and are pansexual demiromantic! Zhe has social anxiety, autophobia, atychiphobia, equinophobia, hypomania, and seasonal affective disorder!
Prototype is a transentien genderless xenogender bubblegender computerthing who is also laimoromantic and caedosexual! He uses he/they/shi/bubble pronouns! They suffer with mild dysmorphia!
Split is a dessertgender cakegender gxrlfluxthing womanthing bambi lesbian! She uses she/her pronouns but also doesn't mind any other pronouns being used for her! She has BIID and BPD!
Spud! is a caedorose genderless being who uses any pronouns! They suffer with PTSD, anger issues, and insomnia!
Unpleasant is a binary abinary rosboy azurgirl bigender demiboy demigirl nonbinary genderfuid genderqueer xenogender genderweird sceneg3nd3r hypermasculine hyperfeminine zoomiegender faggit genderexplosion queerweirdo! It uses any pronouns and is bi gay! Xey are alterhuman, foxkin, wolfkin, zombiekin, and godkin! Shi has klazomania, egomania, mythomania, dermatillomania, hypomania, bipolar-2, and depression!
Wallter is a cis gay man who uses he/him or any pronouns! He suffers with PTSD and depression!
For 🎀 anon!
5 notes
·
View notes