AO3 Etiquette
Alright, y’all, you already know what I’m about to say. But go ahead get some water, something to eat, take your meds, and whatever else you need to do as I go into this. Ready? Good.
I’ve seen far too many users on AO3 being rude and saying things that I’m not even sure they understand is rude.
If you’ve done these things, don’t sweat it too much. As long as you learn and do better, that’s what’s important. I don’t wanna make anyone feel bad, but I want to make y’all AWARE.
So let’s talk about some basic etiquette for interacting on AO3.
(Disclaimer: not every AO3 author is going to agree. Some are okay with some of these things, some aren’t. Let’s just play on the safe side yeah?)
Comment Etiquette
Listen, we’ve all left comments on fics we like. But here’s the thing, some of us don’t realize what comments are rude or not.
Comments that pass the vibe check:
Hearts
Something you liked about the story
Saying you enjoyed the story
Excited to see more from an author (not demanding an update, not asking for more, just genuine excitement for whatever the author has in store)
Anything that is genuinely nice
Theories on what you think will happen (not necessarily what you want or hope happens)
Comments that do not pass the vibe check:
DEMANDING an update
Treating fic authors like content pumps and not real people who do this in their free time
Critiquing the story
Saying how they should’ve written something different
Constructive criticism that the author did NOT ask for
Saying things that are purposefully antagonistic
Trolling
Anything that if someone said to you about something you worked hard on you would think was rude
Dogging on how a character was written
Comments that are WILDLY different from the tone of the story (i.e leaving a graphically violent comment on a story that does not feature graphic violence)
Any mention on how long it’s been since they’ve updated — you’re gonna make your wait longer
This one is more of a personal ick but any “want to see” comments, specifically on one-shots (I want you to enjoy what I’ve written, not talk about stories you hope I’ll write — unless author says that they specifically want those comments)
Honestly there’s so many comments that do not pass the vibe check I can’t even list them all. But I listed a BUNCH so, general rule of thumb is: If you’re not sure it’s rude, reach out to a friend and ask. Also, you can ask for people in the comment section to vibe check you if you’re unsure. And? If you know it’s rude and say it anyway, you’re an asshole.
ALSO: author’s will read your comments! They may not respond, but 9/10 author’s will read the comment so remember that you’re not posting into the void. And? People will call you out if you’re being rude. Don’t double down. Apologize, delete comment, move on.
Author’s talk, we will block you if you’re a raging asshole cuz we don’t need that kinda energy in our fics. And, sometimes we’ll turn off anon commenters cuz if you’re going to continue to be an asshole, and can’t even say it to our face, you din’t deserve to comment.
Bookmark Etiquette
This one is prolly gonna get a lot of people riled up and I simply don’t care. If you disagree, that’s fine, just know as an author and friends with other AO3 author’s we consider these sorts of things rude.
Bookmarks that pass the vibe check:
No comment
A nice comment with the bookmark
Private bookmarks (no matter what it’s tagged/commented with)
Nice/neutral tags
A note to self about where you left off
Bookmarks that do not pass the vibe check:
Anything rude for the comment/tag section of a bookmark — unsure what’s rude? See comment section above
Ranking the fic (see this way more often in bookmarks than anywhere else)
Unread bookmarks (not always a fail, it’s just weird? You can mark for later, why are you bookmarking my story without reading it?)
If your bookmark is private? It doesn’t matter how you tag/note it/whatever. But if it’s public? Author’s will sometimes go look at bookmarks because people will leave nice little comments that make us feel good. If you say something mean we can’t even delete it. But I can guarantee we’ll block you!
Yes, bookmarks are for the reader, but just because you didn’t intend for an author to see what you said doesn’t make it any less mean. If it’s public: shame on you. Make a bookmark that’s mean in private, then I won’t care.
Conclusion
Don’t be mean. If you don’t like a story, you don’t have to say anything. It takes more time to leave a nasty comment or bookmark something in a mean way than it does to just back out of the fic. I get it, you don’t like the fic. I don’t like every fic I read. You know what we do? We use the back button.
We’re all people, we all have lives and things going on. Just know 2024 is the year I’m no longer replying to nasty comments. I’m deleting them, blocking if I want to, and moving on.
If you have any questions, feel free to ask. Again, this post has a very aggressive tone because I’m sick of seeing mean comments on my friend’s fics. Will this stop those comments? No, but I hope it lessens them.
This truly is just about educating people. If you have any questions, anything you want to add. Feel free, pop off monarchs.
45 notes
·
View notes
Message to Fan Artists
Feel free to PM me if you think I got something wrong. I might be having one big miscommunication, but there's a lot bothering me about Tumblr/Twitter culture lately. To start, it's suddenly a huge deal that I'm posting other people's art from Pixiv/Twitter, even though blogs have been doing it since Tumblr started, and I reblog from several other blogs devoted exclusively to reposting. Some of it is retaliation for me complaining about furries/fetishes. Anyway....
-So you've decided to make fan art, and not just any fan art, but fan art of characters from a huge, worldwide fandom, such as pokemon. Chances are you genuinely love the characters you are drawing, but it's also true you are banking your future notoriety as an artist on characters that do not belong to you. It's possible you wouldn't get a fraction of the attention drawing other than. Lo and behold! Things are happening because of this, and some of it is stuff you don't like. The kiddoes are under the impression that these characters belong to everybody, and they want to spread your work far and wide.
-Not much you can do about it except create a really good watermark. People like me only want to post art with credit on a collection blog. Other shady characters might want to steal your work and make t-shirts or post on Pinterest without credit. The owners of the copyrights for popular characters don't gaf because it's all free advertising for their brand.
-But fan artists also have a brand, especially if they are taking commissions and have that $ tip on their posts. That's why it's ridiculous all these people on Tumblr/Twitter believe they can list a slew of criteria people have to follow to enjoy their work. This the internet, where terrorists are posting beheadings, and weirdos are posting their homemade smut videos. It's a free-for-all, and nobody owes anybody anything. A fan artist only has the right to be quietly adored and have their egos stroked from afar if others choose to give them that right. -But too many hide behind their supposed autism-spectrum to excuse their social laziness at best or antisocial snobbery at worst. They're all like, "You're not allowed to comment on my posts, reblog my posts with commentary, or interact with me if you are a TERF, pro-shipper, Trump supporter, etc."
Side note: I suspect a lot of people who are socially lazy due to autistic spectrum are middle to upper middle class white women who have enabler relatives who'd coddle them. I'll bet there's no autism spectrum in Mumbai, India. Want to know why? Well, because anybody who has been packed into public transit like a sardine in Mumbai has had the experience of a skeevy complete stranger jamming a finger up to their knuckle into their butthole. Once that happens to a person.....IT CHANGES YOU, MAN!!1! -Not that I've ever experienced that *darts eyes* but I'm able to put life into the proper perspective and not get uptight over a fucking quote tweet.
Moving on....
-So as I said, fan artists charging for their work have to sell their brand to make money. It doesn't matter if you are a die-hard Bernie Sanders fan who loathes capitalism, the laws of it still apply to you, and that means you have to work on your public image. You are a hotdog vendor selling hotdogs, and you aren't going to move as many if you alienate whole groups of people, such as pro-shippers or people who reblog your posts with comments. If you are popular, you might have to resign yourself to getting asks from weirdos and act gracious about it if people ask you the same questions over and over. IE: An artist drawing gardevoir will get asked the 'is her dress skin?' question ad nauseam. It might seem stale to you, but new people discover gardevoir every day, and it's fresh for them.
If you are a not-so good artist who isn't charging for work but does creepy fetishes for attention, what is this nonsense where people aren't allowed to criticize you? Maybe people don't want to see their favorite characters represented that way and will speak up. IE: Subway Boss Emmet, like everybody knows that one autistic guy who is a serial killer who fucks sheep and has his brother locked in his basement with his leg cut off. There's one in every town, right?
It's not just autism spectrum though, many fan artists excuse their bad behavior hiding behind gay/trans sjw bullshit identity. They'll screech 'oppression' if you give them a hard time. That doesn't always work. Look at Lily Orchard who is a popular transfemale YouTube personality who treated too many of her fans like garbage. A bunch of people shrugged off decades of gay crusader, trans-jihad brainwashing and said, "By golly...I'M GOING TO DARE CRITICISE HER!!" -Next thing you know, there are gossip blogs dedicated to discussing her MLP pedo comic or pointing out possible domestic abuse and/or gaslighting.
Don't ever pull the 'gay gay autism gay' oppression bullshit on me because I'll just say, "I am Kharmii, and I am above rules". A lot of people will block me for it, but enough will not. I've noticed that the really popular artists generally know the game and don't take sides in the pro/anti shipping wars. Aspiring artists should follow their example.
3 notes
·
View notes