Tumgik
#max wolf valerio
genderoutlaws · 9 months
Text
Tumblr media
Max Wolf Valerio, Matthew Rice, and David Harrison pictured together in 2023, with the photograph of them marching as the first FTM Pride contingent in San Francisco from 1994 behind them in the background.
899 notes · View notes
celluloidrainbow · 6 months
Text
Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media
YOU DON'T KNOW DICK (1997) dir. Bestor Cram & Candace Schermerhorn Lyle, Max, Michael, Steven, Ted, and James: a photographer who lifts weights, a cop, a mechanic, writers, an artist; one is gay, at least three are in serious relationships with women; one was in the seminary; one has three children from a previous marriage. All six are transgender men. They talk about childhood, deciding to transition, telling parents and friends and co-workers, testosterone therapy, surgeries, organs, embracing their histories, and how their lives are now. Friends, a parent, lovers, and two children also talk. All six men express joy at their new-found and more complete identities. (link in title)
59 notes · View notes
moviemosaics · 1 year
Photo
Tumblr media
Framing Agnes
directed by Chase Joynt, 2022
2 notes · View notes
awesomefridayca · 2 years
Text
Hot Docs '22: Framing Agnes obscures its own powerful premise and story
#HotDocs22 Review: Framing Agnes obscures its own subject.
In the 1950s and 60s, researchers at UCLA conducted a study into sex disorders. The resulting archive of data contains a cross-section of trans history in the form of interviews conducted with the study’s participants. One of the participants -a woman known only as Agnes- used the study to receive gender-affirming care and then seemingly disappeared. With Framing Agnes, director Chase Joynt…
Tumblr media
View On WordPress
1 note · View note
genderkoolaid · 2 months
Text
Rocco Kayiatos started to realize that he was trans as a teenager. It was 1999 or early 2000, he says, and Google didn’t really exist: “I remember searching on Ask Jeeves for literally anything related to trans men.”  He was living in San Francisco, and was part of the queer poetry scene, having toured with Sister Spit; he was able to meet trans people that way, and the poet Max Wolf Valerio became a friend. Still, Kayiatos says, he struggled to put himself together: “The reaction that I got was really rough,” he recalls. “I felt like I couldn’t really be a man, one, because of insecurity around my own transness, but then two, because culturally, I got so much pushback from people that I loved about how shitty men were and why would I ‘want,’ quote unquote, to be a man.” The trans men he read often seemed to be guilty or defensive: “I never read a book by a trans guy about their experience that wasn’t somehow written in a way that’s like, almost an apology for being a man.”  Then he read Green’s memoir. “It’s just the most profoundly gentle and loving and compassionate offering to healing masculinity, that’s so timeless,” Kayiatos says. “It’s still relevant and advanced in the present day … for me, when people are listing the must-reads about transmasculine people, places or things, if they don’t start with James’s book, I just think, ‘You missed it.’ Because his book is the starting point.” 
— How Jamison Green’s visibility paved the way for a generation of trans men by Jude Ellison S. Doyle (emphasis mine)
317 notes · View notes
transterrorweek · 2 years
Text
Tumblr media
We’re back! Trans Terror Week 2022 will run November 20-26th.
This year your mods are a bit stretched thin, so I would strongly recommend coming to our Tumblr for any questions or concerns, though everything will be cross posted to Twitter. You’ll get a quicker answer on Tumblr. Additionally, thank you so much to everyone who helped us with prompt ideas and graphics!
The rules are the same a last year, detailed on our FAQ page (for the mobile accessible FAQ go here). 
Rules and Reminders:
This event is for anyone who is trans, nonbinary or is currently questioning their gender. Our goal is to uplift trans content creators in the Terror fandom and we encourage cis creators to show their support for their trans compatriots.
There is NO restriction on type of content: art, fics, edits, playlists, videos, everything is welcome!
November 20th is also for Creator Spotlights, make a post highlighting your works and we’ll give you a boost!
Please tag your works #transterrorweek/#transterrorweek2022 and/or ping us @transterrorweek to make sure we see your stuff! This applies to both Tumblr and Twitter.
Fics can also be added to the Ao3 collection. Simply search for “Trans Terror Week” when posting your fic or follow the link on our blog. Our FAQ has instructions for posting anonymously.
Prompts:
This years prompts are following the theme of “In their own voices,” and quotes from the recently released letter book May We be Spared to Meet on Earth will be paired with the titles of memoirs by trans authors. We got a few trans memoirs in 2020′s prompts, but this is a whole new selection. The expanded prompt list can be found on our Prompts page.
Day 1: In From the Wilderness - David E. Weekley | “Read these two notes and tear them up” - James Fitzjames (96)
Day 2: Tranny - Laura Jane Grace | “any blue clothing you can put into the case” - Francis Crozier (33)
Day 3: We Both Laughed in Pleasure - Lou Sullivan | “the suffocating jab of delight mingled with the fearful anticipation of the dreary void” - Charles Osmer (136)
Day 4: A Lowlife in High Heels - Holly Woodlawn | “I was surprised to see him attempt anything so risky” - Edward Couch (148)
Day 5: The Testosterone Files - Max Wolf Valerio | “I have made my cabin very snug & found it best to be my own carpenter” - James Fairholme (105)
Day 6: Exile and Pride - Eli Clare | “occasionally some few rather irksome things occur” - Harry Goodsir (53)
Day 7: Something That May Shock and Discredit You - Daniel M. Lavery | “I am wanting a promotion and a quick return to England” - Henry T.D. Le Vesconte (55)
76 notes · View notes
zazzmaster5000 · 10 months
Text
got tagged by @zemascreams so fuck it we ball
last song: the one i’m listening to right this second is “When the Fire and the Rose Are One” by the great John Fahey
currently watching: Lost, Berlin Alexanderplatz, and Twin Peaks 
currently reading: The Testosterone Files by Max Wolf Valerio and The Beautiful Thing That Awaits Us All by Laird Barron
current obsession: haven’t really had time for one due to gestures at personal life but if i gotta pick, a dance show i saw based on Illinois by Sufjan Stevens 
i will tag @declanlikesmusic and @mx-pokirby in this :)
2 notes · View notes
moviepostersets · 2 years
Photo
Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media Tumblr media
24 notes · View notes
yourdailyqueer · 4 years
Photo
Tumblr media
Max Wolf Valerio
Gender: Transgender man
Sexuality: N/A
DOB: 16 February 1957
Ethnicity: Native American (Blackfoot), Spanish, distant Sephardi Jewish
Occupation: Poet, writer, actor
88 notes · View notes
Text
For Trans Day of Visibility, here are some brave trans men who have contributed to trans rights activism
Tumblr media
Reed Erickson (1917-1992) was an American philantrophist. In 1964, he founded the Erickson Educational Foundation, which researched transsexuality and medical transition, and provided resources for trans people and their families. He also funded many other LGBT groups in the 60s through the 80s.
Tumblr media
Lou Sullivan (1951-1991) was an American author and activist. In 1986, he founded FTM International an organization for trans men to help access resources and create a community. He had an immense contribution to the ftm community in the US.
Tumblr media
Jamison Green (1948-) is an American activist, author, and educator. He has been advocating for better legal and medical policies for trans people since the 1980s. After Lou Sullivan passed away, Green took over writing the FTM International Newsletter. He wrote the book Becoming a Visible Man, about his own transition and about the shared experiences trans men in society.
Tumblr media
Rupert Raj (1952-) is a Canadian activist and author, who has been active since the 70s. He is the founder of various trans rights publications and organizations, such as the Foundation for the Advancement of Canadian Transsexuals, the Metamorphosis Medical Research Foundation, Gender Worker, and the FTM Peer-Support Group.
Tumblr media
Max Wolf Valerio (1957-) is a Native American poet, writer, musician, actor and activist. He transitioned in 1989, and in 2006 published The Testosterone Files, a memoir about his transition and experiences as a trans man.
Tumblr media
Pepe Julian Onziema (1980-) is a Ugandan LGBT rights and human rights activist. He has campaigned against homophobic laws and coordinated pride parades. In 2013, he received the David Kato Vision and Voice Award, and was chosen as Stonewall's Hero of the Year in 2014.
14K notes · View notes
genderoutlaws · 3 years
Text
Tumblr media
The first FTM contingent at San Francisco Pride | 1994
L to R: Max Wolf Valerio, Matt Rice, David Harrison, Susan Stryker holding daughter, Bryn, Loren Cameron, Stephan Thorne, and Cole.
12K notes · View notes
dear-indies · 2 years
Text
Anonymous asked: Hi all! I know you have been asked about z*e kravitz alts, but it got me thinking can i ask for any jewish fcs of color? Any gender! Just trying to diversify some lists. Thank you!
Non-binary:
Mykki Blanco (1986) African-American Jewish / Unknown - genderqueer and non-binary - HIV positive - they/them. 
Tyler Ford (1990) Black and White Jewish - agender - they/hir. 
Rivkah Reyes (1992) Filipino / Jewish - non-binary femme and queer - they/she/siya - has bipolar disorder.
Emma Sulkowicz (1992) Chinese, Japanese, Ashkenazi Jewish - non-binary - they/them.
Chella Man (1998) Hongkonger and Jewish - deaf - trans, genderqueer, pansexual - he/him.
Zo Tipp (?) Japanese Jewish - non-binary - they/he.
Xemi Manibusan (?) Salvadoran [Pipil, Sephardi Jewish, Spanish] - non-binary two-spirit trans woman - she/her. 
Women:
Joanelle Romero (1957) Chiricahua Apache, Cheyenne / Mescalero Apache, Sephardi Jewish.
K.D. Lang (1961) Sioux, Russian Jewish, Icelandic, German, Scottish, Irish, English - lesbian - they/she.
Rachel True (1966) African-American / German Jewish.
Lisa Bonet (1967) African-American / Ashkenazi Jewish.
Michelle St. John (1967) Wampanoag, Kalinago, and Jewish.
Sophie Okonedo (1968) Nigeran / Ashkenazi Jewish.
Gabrielle Anwar (1970) Indian, Austrian Jewish / English.
Dana International (1972) Yemenite and Russian Jewish - trans. 
Bahar Soomekh (1975) Persian Jewish.
Tamara Podemski (1977) Saulteaux, Ojibwe, Lenape, Metis, and Polish Jewish.
Fay Wolf (1978) Ashkenazi Jewish / Afro-Antiguan.
Shiri Appleby (1978) Ashkenazi Jewish, Moroccan Sephardi.
Rakefet Abergel (1979) Moroccan Jewish.
Nafa Urbach (1980) Javanese / Dutch Jewish, German Jewish.
Rebecca Naomi Jones (1981) African-American / Jewish.
Melina Matsoukas (1981) Afro Cuban, Afro Jamaican / Greek, Ashkenazi Jewish.
Sarah Podemski (1983)  Saulteaux, Ojibwe, Lenape, Metis, and Polish Jewish.
Lauren London (1984) African-American / Ashkenazi Jewish.
Juliana Harkavy (1985) Dominican Republic, African, Chinese / Ashkenazi Jewish.
Jemima Kirke (1985) Iraqi Jewish, Ashkenazi Jewish / English, Scottish.
Joséphine Jobert (1985) Sephardi Jewish / Martiniquais, Spanish, possibly Chinese.
Jurnee Smollett (1986) African-American, possibly other / Ashkenazi Jewish.
Monica Raymund (1986) Dominican Republic / English, Ashkenazi Jewish - bisexual.
Meaghan Rath (1986) Ashkenazi Jewish / Goan Indian.
Danielle Keaton (1986) Peruvian of Quechua descent and Ashkenazi Jewish.
Tahounia Rubel (1988) Ethiopian Jewish.
Hailie Sahar (1988) African-American, Latin, Indian, Jewish, German - trans.
Lalla Hirayama (1988) Japanese / South African Jewish.
Medalion Rahimi (1992) Iranian, Mizrahi Jewish - she/they.
Margot Bingham (1988) Afro-Jamaican / Ashkenazi Jewish.
Lola Kirke (1990) Iraqi Jewish, Ashkenazi Jewish / English, Scottish.
Anna Shaffer (1992) Black South African, Unspecified White / South African Jewish.
Sky Ferreira (1992) Brazilian [Portuguese, possibly other] / Ashkenazi Jewish, Ojibwe, Cree, Chippewa Cree, Cheyenne, Scottish, English, Irish, French.
Sierra-Skye Ashkewe (1993) Mohawk, Jewish / Ojibwe.
Hannah Marks (1993) Muscogee, Egyptian Jewish, Italian Jewish, Polish Jewish, Irish, and English.
Sierra Ashkewe (1993) Mohawk Jewish and Ojibwe.
Lisa-Kaindé Diaz (1994) Afro-Cuban [Yoruba] / Venezuelan [Spanish, some Italian], Tunisian Jewish.
Natalee Linez (1994) Armenian, Peruvian, Spanish, Italian, Ashkenazi Jewish.
Naomi Diaz (1994) Afro-Cuban [Yoruba] / Venezuelan [Spanish, some Italian], Tunisian Jewish.
Kayla Maisonet (1999) Afro Puerto Rican / Ashkenazi Jewish.
Ava Allan (2000) Egyptian Jewish / Unspecified.
Xemi Manibusan (?) Pipil - non-binary two-spirit trans woman - she/her.
Jenny Marlowe (?) Algonquin, Mizrahi Jewish, French, Scottish, Irish, Cornish, Welsh, Ukrainian, and German.
Men:
Max Wolf Valerio (1957) Kainai Blackfoot / Sephardi Jewish, Northern European - trans.
Shaun Toub (1963) Persian Jewish.
Vincent Elbaz (1971) Moroccan Jewish.
Boris Kodjoe (1973) Akan Ghanaian / German Jewish.
Mark-Paul Gosselaar (1974) Ashkenazi Jewish, German, Dutch, Indonesian.
Taika Waititi (1975) Māori, as well as distant British Isles, possibly 1/16th French-Canadian / English, Scottish, Northern Irish, one quarter Ashkenazi Jewish.
Jérémie Elkaïm (1978) Moroccan Jewish.
Josh Keaton (1979) Peruvian of Quechua descent and Ashkenazi Jewish.
Eban Hyams (1981) Indian Jewish.
Daveed Diggs (1982) African-American / Ashkenazi Jewish.
Satya Bhabha (1983) Parsi Indian / Ashkenazi Jewish.
Jon Lee Brody (1984) Korean / German Jewish.
Cooper Andrews (1985) Samoan / Hungarian Jewish.
Aditya Roy Kapur (1985) Indian / Indian Jewish.
Oliver Jackson-Cohen (1986) Egyptian Jewish / English.
Karim Kassem (1986) Egyptian / Egyptian Jewish.
Marc Bendavid (1986) Moroccan Jewish / Belgian.
Pierre Niney (1989) Egyptian Jewish.
Jesse Rath (1989) Ashkenazi Jewish / Goan Indian.
Ryan Potter (1995) Japanese / Ashkenazi Jewish, Swedish, English, German, Scots-Irish/Northern Irish.
Jordan Daniels (?) Afro-Jewish - queer. 
Thanks to @antlerqueer for some of these suggestions too!
11 notes · View notes
forbescaroline · 2 years
Text
send me two characters or ships and i’ll make a gifset of the one i prefer!
below are a list of shows/characters/ships i would like to gif! (looking to gif things i’ve never gifed before or only gifed once)
atypical - casey, izzie, casey/evan, sam/paige
bridgerton - daphne, eloise, penelope, daphne/simon, colin/penelope
dickinson - emily, emily/sue, emily/ben
druck - fatou, nora, kieu my, cash queens, fatou/kieu my, nora/josh
elite - rebeka, nadia, lu, mencia, rebeka/mencia, polo/cayetana/valerio
euphoria - jules, maddy, kat, rue, lexi
ginny and georiga - ginny, max, max/sophie, ginny/marcus, joe/georgia
good trouble - callie/jamie, mariana/raj, callie/gael, malika/isaac, alice/sumi, evan/mariana 
grey’s anatomy - amelia, jo, addison, link/amelia, tom/teddy, meredith/nick, amelia/kai, levi/nico
hsmtmts - gina, nini, ashlyn, ej/gina, ricky/gina, carlos/seb
julie and the phantoms - julie, luke/julie, alex/willie
legacies - josie/finch, josie/landon, lizzie/sebastian, lizzie/ethan, kaleb/cleo, josie/rafael
legends of tomorrow - zari (both of them), ava, astra, spooner, constantine/zari, nate/zari, astra/spooner
outer banks - sarah, kiara, sarah/kira, jj/kira, jj/pope
schitt’s creek - alexis, david/patrick, alexis/ted, alexis/mutt
sex education - maeve, aimee, ruby, otis/maeve, otis/ruby, eric/adam, ola/lily, jackson/cal
skam espana - amira, viri, eva, nora, dani/amira, viri/hugo, eva/jorge
skam france - lola, lola/maya, tiff/max, bilal/jo
skins - naomi, pandora, freddie/effy
supergirl - brainy/nia, james/lena, j’onn/m’gann, alex/kelly
teen wolf - erica, isaac, stiles, scott, boyd/erica, corey/mason, liam/hayden, scott/malia, stiles/malia
the 100 - octavia/levitt, jasper/maya, finn/clarke, kane/abby, raven/shaw
the fosters - aj/callie, wyatt/callie, jesus/lexi, brandon/grace, jude/noah
the oc - summer, taylor, seth/anna, marissa/alex
the originals - freya, cami, marcel/rebekah, jackson/hayley, josh/aiden
the secret circle - cassie, melissa, adam/diana, adam/cassie, jake/cassie, diana/cassie, faye/cassie, diana/melissa
the sex lives of college girls - leighton, bela, leighton/alicia, whitney/canaan, eric/bela
the society - allie, elle, kelly, harry/allie, sam/grizz, helena/luke
the vampire diaries - bonnie/enzo, tyler/caroline, tyler/liv, stefan/rebekah
the wilds - dot, fatin, shelby, toni, nora, martha, rachel, leah, toni/shelby, dot/shelby, rachel/nora, toni/martha, fatin/leah, dot/fatin
yellowjackets - shauna, taissa, natalie, jackie, jackie/shauna, travis/natalie, taissa/van
1 note · View note
elleclairez · 4 years
Text
Fandoms (series) I write for
I will update this list once in a while 
My Masterlist
The Order 
Hamish Duke
Randall Carpio
Orbin
The Vampire Diaries / The Originals / Legacies 
Klaus Mikaelson
Elijah Mikaelson
Kol Mikaelson
Kai Parker
Lucien Castle
Sebastian
Lizzie Saltzman
Hope Mikaelson
Jeremy Gilbert
Ryan Clarke
Jed
Ethan Machado
Teen Wolf 
Stiles Stilinski
Theo Raeken
Nolan Holloway
Isaac Lahey
Brett Talbot
Peter Hale
Derek Hale
World on Fire 
Harry Chase
Tom Bennett
Grzegorz Tomaszeski
Chilling Adventures of Sabrina 
Caliban
Nicholas Scratch
Ambrose Spellman
Lucifer
The Letter For The King 
Prince Viridian
Tiuri
Supernatural 
Dean Winchester
Castiel
Sam Winchester
Jack Kline
Titans 
Dick Grayson
Jason Todd
Garfiel Logan
Pennyworth 
Alfred Pennyworth
Jason Ripper
Macgyver
Angus Macgyver
Medici 
Lorenzo di Medici
Giuliano di Medici
Francesco di Pazzi
Vienna Blood 
Max Lierbermann
Ragnarök 
Fjor
The Marvelous Mrs Maisel 
Lenny Bruce
A discovery of Witches
Marcus Whitmore 
Elite 
Guzman Nunier
Polo Benavent Villada
Samuel García Domínguez
Valerio Montesinos Rojas   
Shadowhunters 
Jonathan Morgenstern
Sebastian Verlac
Alec Lightwood
Once Upon a Time 
Peter Pan
Henry Mills
Gideon
Hansel/Jack/Nick Branson
Shadow and Bone 
Kaz Brekker
The Darlking
Nikolai Lantsov
Fedyor Kaminsky
The Umbrella Academy
Five Hargreeves
Fate : The Winx Saga
Riven
Sky
Sam
Blood of Zeus
Heron
Apollo
Hermes
Castlevania
Hector
Alucard
Attack on Titan
Levi Ackerman
Erwin Smith
Eren Jaeger
Jean Kirstein
23 notes · View notes
I continue to be frustrated by the lack of good trans man writing. There's Max Wolf Valerio, whose Testosterone Files continues to be the *only* good book on the topic Ive read. I've just discovered Daniel M. Lavery, who mostly blogs, and who really gets the mordant embarrassment and florid love of period literature down.
This is not an exaggeration. Fun facts but I once spent a year as a volunteer librarian for a trans community group, so I have read...a heck tonne of books about this. And with those two exceptions, what makes me feel most seen is books by cis gay men, and books by trans women. The cis gays seem to have the corner on "queer male angst and barely contained rage", whereas the trans girls sate my "trans people having extremely boring lives punctuatuated by moments of 'wow, I'm a transsexual' absurdity and gallows humour" quotient. I recommend Giovanni's Room by James Baldwin, and Nevada by Imogen Binnie.
A big part of the problem is that half our literature is written for cis people and the other half is for dykes. The first category are as follows: "Lawrence wasn't like any man I had met before. He listened. He knew what a clitoris was. I felt so safe with him". The second half is like: "I am twelve. A man looks at me. I am fourteen. I'm menstruating. I do performance poetry at our local women's collective. What is gender, really? Isn't it wonderful, all this fluidity and creativity? Drag kings are great. I am 22. Here's a piece on sexual assault. A love letter to femmes, although I'm not a butch." In the latter category, I'd put things like S. Bear Bergman, Ivan Coyote, J. Halberstam which just don't do it for me.
They're writing about a valuable experience, but it's not my experience. It's framing transition as an extension of experiences as gnc women and I...have never been one of those. The butch-to-trans or butch-to-????{still butch, but it's complicated}???? journey is real, but not my journey. They're coming out of a personal and literary feminist tradition, and can't quite jettison or distance themselves from it -perhaps because this is their preference, perhaps due to a political pressure/embarrassment about being an actual man now, possibly because these books are older. . Part of what's so good about Valerio is that he's constantly trying to reconcile his feminism with the new things he's learning about having a testosterone-dominant hormone system. He isn't trying to lurk in a "plausibly a kind of woman, and therefore a member of the good gender" space: he writes honestly about feeling lust in a different way, about how street violence has changed from sexual harassment to physical, about his feelings towards porn changing, and about the biological factors which make up gender.
(and I think the relatability of cis gay literature is in part because it's underpinned by a fear of feminisation, and an anger at being unable to claim the 'real masculinity' which is their right. It's the same rage: "I am a man. Why is everyone treating me as something defective?")
But there seems to be a real lack IMO of transmasculine writers writing about being men, or writing about being trans, in a way I relate to. Lavery's recent articles on "How I Intend To Comport Myself When I Have Abs" or his comic identification of forced masc narratives in women's fiction really grip something in me then twist. Try "Oh Bro! Oh No Bro! You Just Slipped And Fell Into A Vat Of Testosterone Cyprionate" for some painfully real feelings. Lavery, trying to tease out the difference between a wish to transition, and a wish to transition into Brendan Fraiser circa-1998. Don't we all have one of those? Mine is Robert Plant.
and that's what I want to read more of. Something that feels authentic, something that's absurd, something written by an actual trans man who identifies as actually trans and actually male and isn't trying to appeal to a queer women's audience, something which can be ugly or difficult or embarrassing, but primarily something I *recognise*. I guess it's not enough for me to be piggybacking on the literature of other adjacent groups; I want to read my own!
recommendations in the comments pls.
10 notes · View notes
trans-advice · 5 years
Link
this article has been copied & pasted in its entirety in case there’s a paywall. however, please try to read the article from the link first so that the journalist & newspaper staff get their wages. thank you.
The film "Framing Agnes" is set to debut at the Tribeca Film Festival this week. (Aubree Bernier Clarke)
Cindy Dampier
Contact Reporter
Chicago Tribune
Chase Joynt and Kristen Schilt might not fit your definition of swashbuckling explorers — he’s a filmmaker and post-doctoral fellow at the University of Chicago, she’s a U. of C. sociology professor.
But when the pair embarked on a research project that involved one of the seminal case studies in the study of transgender people, they found themselves digging in dusty boxes, sifting through reams of old paper stuffed into a dead professor’s unsorted archive, and finally peeking inside a rusty file drawer, Indiana Jones-style, to uncover a never-before-seen part of the past. “You can’t make this stuff up,” says Joynt.
What Joynt and Schilt discovered was a treasure trove of notes, part of the work of sociologist Harold Garfinkel, on one of Garfinkel’s best-known interviews with a research subject: a trans woman called Agnes, whom he interviewed in 1958.
Now, as part of a joint U. of C. fellowship, they have turned that discovery into a documentary film, “Framing Agnes,” that has snared a spot at the prestigious Tribeca Film Festival, where it will debut Sunday — and is turning a piece of history on its head.
“Agnes’ case is very well known in the field of sociology,” says Schilt, “and has been taken up in the same way that case studies by Sigmund Freud have been taken up, like the Wolf Man or Dora. And because it was such an integral part of sociology and the anchor of the first theory of gender in sociology, Agnes has always seemed very singular; she was one person being written about.”
The revelation in the rusty file drawer was that, in spite of popular perception, Agnes’ case was not singular. In fact, Garfinkel had made a study of eight transgender people in Los Angeles in the late 1950s — and his interviews revealed how those people were a part of a supportive transgender community, and how they interacted with the wider world of the medical establishment, workplaces and everyday life.
“When you encounter the set of interviews as a whole,” says Joynt, “you get a sense of what a world looks like for gender nonconforming people in L.A. in the 1950s. It really deteriorates the idea that people were living in isolation without any resources. While that was true for some, it reveals … this incredibly robust network of support and people who were navigating systems on their own through resourcefulness and creativity.”
Agnes, who had come to Garfinkel as part of her quest to undergo gender reassignment surgery at UCLA, was 19 in 1958. Born with a penis, she had always felt herself to be a woman, and had been living as a woman, with a job as a typist and a boyfriend who knew that she was a transgender person. “For sociologists,” says Schilt, “what the case represented is this idea that gender is socially constructed as opposed to being biological essential. What sociologists found interesting was that someone who was assigned male at birth could create this life as a woman. In 1958, that kind of blew people’s minds.”
As society became more open to recognition of transgender people, Agnes’ tale continued to hold great resonance. “For many trans studies people, Agnes is kind of the folk hero,” says Schilt. “There’s this excitement about this example of someone who was able to do this at 19 years old, and is able to get what she wants out of it. That was pretty rare in 1958.”
With the addition of the cases Schilt and Joynt discovered, layers of detail have been added to those experiences: tales of “parties with 200 lesbians in the Hollywood Hills,” everyday details of struggling to find or keep employment, and a surprising amount of support. “There was a whole network of trans women who would show up for each other in the hospital after someone had had surgery,” says Joynt, “and bring food and snacks, posing as sisters and cousins. They were saying that if someone is trans and lonely, it’s because they’re making a choice, because we’re here and we’re ready to show up. It really revealed how they built these communities.”
Schilt and Joynt, who had “made peace with the fact that we might not find anything” about Agnes in Garfinkel’s overflowing archive, were overjoyed when in 2017 they uncovered new accounts of midcentury trans life. “We went in the first time and thought, ‘We’re going to find something,’ ” says Joynt, “and then over time it was like, ‘Maybe we’re not going to find something.’ When we finally gained access to the drawer and saw what was inside, it was this overwhelming moment.”
“I probably screamed,” says Schilt. “It was like we had really won the archival lottery.”
The discovery changed how they saw their project, raising comparisons between issues faced by the trans community today and those faced by the research subjects, and sparking a new idea about how to present their work. Though they do plan to publish a book, “Conceptualizing Agnes: Exemplary Cases and the Disciplines of Gender,” the two chose to present their work in a 19-minute film that is a hybrid documentary style. “Framing Agnes” employs trans actors Zachary Drucker, known for work on the Amazon series “Transparent,” Angelica Ross of “Pose,” Silas Howard and Max Wolf Valerio to recreate the historical research subjects on screen. Joynt portrays the Garfinkel character.
The presence of the contemporary actors allows the film to focus on the juxtaposition between today’s trans community and the community Joynt and Shilt uncovered in their research. “We gave them character summaries and outlines of the people they would be portraying,” says Schilt, “but we really wanted them to embody these people and bring them to life. Watching them was a beautiful experience.”
Joynt hopes that the film, which is building up a healthy roster of upcoming festival appearances, allows audiences not only to discover a richer past, but shift their perspective on the stories of transgender people today.
“For so long,” he says, “the cultural landscape has been dominated by narratives about trans people that focus on the transition moment, that move from a sort of gender unrest toward a kind of gender resolve. And for us, ‘Framing Agnes’ is an opportunity not to ignore the transition but to say that trans-ness and stories about gender nonconformity are far more complex.”
Schilt agrees: “While social progress is not linear,” she says, “this is this really amazing moment where we get to think about the current context of trans-ness in culture, alongside these historical makings.”
And, she admits, for a sociology professor, it’s also a moment to take in her new career in film. “This was so out of my realm,” she says, “that it took a few weeks to sink in, ‘Wow, this is huge.’ And now I’m so excited, I just can’t wait.”
Twitter @csdampier
27 notes · View notes