re: baldur's gate's setting limitations: I've read a Lot of shit set in the Forgotten Realms and yeah, I agree. I mean I think it's interesting with the Legend of Drizzt (which are objectively bad although I love them dearly) to see an author clumsily *trying* grapple with sociological cycles of violence, and even that's being really deprecated out of more modern D&D to make it brighter, shinier, more Marvel, and more approachable. Like that's certainly the more marketable approach and in a [1/2
setting increasingly dictated by TTRPGs as played by people who expect videogame logic, /or/ parasocial slice of life, it's not surprising - it also avoids a lot of the pitfalls of "what the fuck were you thinking" that LoD itself is a great example of when it comes to clumsy allegory and sexual assault played for titillation - but honestly I prefer the clumsy trash that contemplates gore and consequence happening on a human level than something that wants to be approachable and friendly but [2/
[3/3] has no problem with the concept of ontological evil which is always more fundamentally regressive than clumsy allegory tbh. But I mean we both prefer DA and DA started /as a reaction to/ the fundamental limitations of the Baldur's Gate series, so it's not surprisingly that a game that sort of ignores the entire DA-digression, and the risks it took with form, doesn't have that spark.
haven't read LoD but agreed, my clumsy allegory tolerance is probably /too/ high but do ontological good and evil at face value & i'm right out
i think what hits weird for me about bg3 is almost some version of the uncanny, like on the one hand it's trying to do psychological realism in a pretty earnest way, but it's also set up this world where like. a character's hair changes from black to white when she chooses Good. yknow. there's some lovely sensitive character writing, but it rests on this substrate of world-logic that's just fundamentally not how people work. ahistorical, like you've said before. so you can only drill down so far before it rings hollow or just comes off kind of pat
what i meant to explain in this post when it got away from me, is that new deities/demigods are sometimes brought into existence/given great power through mortals' belief in them. this was more common when the world was still young, when it wasn't hard at all to believe in the birth of a new god; sunna and all of her children so loved to create and nurture. mortals rarely or never realized that they themselves were willing beings into existence by simply believing in them.
an example, which i don't think i've mentioned on this blog yet, are sindri, the goddess of stars, wishes, and hopes. the story goes that sindri places a star in the sky for every mortal's wish, dream, and hope so that they will keep their head up and never lose sight of those hopes. a falling star is seen as a good omen as it means someone's wish is coming true -- maybe even yours. this story circulated until sindri came to be, and she is one of very few deities who are allowed to frequent the mortal realm due to the nature of her duties.
if kind deities like sindri can be born from the power of belief, then so can terrible beings. but that's a subject for a separate post.
while bronwyn isn't a goddess, she has obtained a demigoddess status due to her age and the numerous people who believe in her so strongly. this, rather than her unusual origins, is why she is so hard to kill and such a powerful sorceress. her magic and body are imbued with a strength that comes with being worshipped or at least respected as a higher being.
i think a lot of who i am today can be explained by the fact i spent hours a day in forth and fifth grade reading erotic vampire novels and trying to figure out which of my friends were secret vampies
tbh i feel like the glitches in 3 add to the experience like. yea sometimes the textures glitch out of existence. in one cutscene hailey n usapyon just stare at each other for like five seconds (with the different emotion symbol thingies still appearing normally above them) without saying anything and then it ends. you can clip through a wall to open a gate of whimsy. none of it's game-breaking so it's just amusing-
Well here's my propaganda for @smallartistocbracket's Bracket
Also the black/dark blue lined character is one of his friends. (kind of i guess?)
Transcript under the cut, since i feel like the timing is off and you might not be able to read most of it. (and a long needless explanation in the tags)
Frais: Why should you vote for me in the small artist OC bracket? Well...
I'm very cute and funny and the strongest guy in my friend group! Also I have a hardness of 9! I'm a first class gem! I won the annual GCT (the junior league) and didn't even break a sweat! Also i'm literally neurodivergent and a minor.
[Camera is knocked over and picked up by Shitagida]