I have seen Gavroche the Musical and maybe that's why I can't sleep
Spoilers under the cut though this is NOT a coherent review post , it's gonna be long and confusing like the musical itself HEYOOOOO and somehow have spoilers so. here we go
this show...is definitely a show
seriously all the songs are very "Musical! The Musical!!" you know?
The Thenardiers are running a welfare scheme
ignoring that this is genuinely straight up right wing propaganda about how welfare works, yeah ok they would run any grift but
their whole "fraudulent scheme" consists of trying to convince ...canon era social workers? Aid for Dependent Children? IDEK-- that they are Super Poor and have children to feed and they need help
And ?!? they ARE super poor! They DO have children to feed! Their welfare scheme is just applying for welfare that they definitely need
They do this by kicking Eponine and Azelma out so the Social Services People...of 1832...will only see the momes
which if anything means they are applying for less welfare than they are entitled to
but the song is in minor key and the Ts are transparently bad parents so this is supposed to be Evil somehow , and we're all supposed to cheer when the cops arrest them and then do not help the kids at all
It's hare to tell because the costuming in the version I saw was very haphazard but I think the cops?? were only posing as social workers? So they could arrest the Ts for a totally different crime? But we're still supposed to cheer when they arrest the parents because haha , they were poor and bad! Who do they think they are, asking for *checks notes* financial aid they are entirely entitled to have?
the cops are the good guys?? sort of?? they keep showing up to arrest the Ts and the show always frames it as a good thing
the revolutionaries...are also the good guys
I was very unclear on how the revolutionaries died but hilariously they ALL die, even Marius , because there's no Valjean in this
oh yeah, there's no Valjean, no onscreen Cosette, and no named Javert, though there are cop characters who could be Javert
there IS Mabeuf, and Eponine goes to him for info about Marius, but the show seems to think he's called "Father" Mabeuf for religious reasons, oh no
I was also unclear about what they were fighting for, which is an absolute trip when this was an uprising with an exceptionally clear and direct purpose ("MONARCHY BAD, REMOVE MONARCH BY FORCE IF NECESSARY")
I was VERY clear on the momes naming themselves Grizzly and Croissant
I am not gonna forget that possibly ever , my loved ones will gather round me and I'll murmur " but those names...are so bad...they aren't even easy to use in...a song" and Perish and my last thoughts will be of frigging Gavroche The Musical , a dire fate
Azelma and the momes live and go to America alone?? and have a great life?? does anyone remember what happened in the book. Does anyone remember what was happening in the US in this time period?? certainly THIS musical does not!
It is pretty directly stated that Grizzly and/or Croissant came back to Paris to tell his family's story--which, I gotta say, he has no way to know since most of it happened when he wasn't around and no one survived to tell him about it -- and became the tour guide in the first scene
but the tour guide in the first scene showed them the Gavroche statue
..that statue went up in 1904
This is Love Never Dies levels of Timelines Happening
Gavroche the Musical 2 is gonna be about Gavroche running an amusement park on coney island
ngl I'd watch that
I haven't covered HALF the things About the Show
I gotta apologize to action movies for making fun of "well THAT happened" dialogue because truly. It IS an emotion, and it's the one I'm feeling now.
102 notes
·
View notes
2023 fantasy challenge update
babel (r.f. kuang), 5☆
particularly liked the etymology bits as a vital part of worldbuilding and narration
when the angels left the old country (sacha lamb), 5☆ *
the friendshipTM made me cry multiple times and the writing is simply delicious
the priory of the orange tree (samantha shannon), 5☆
re-read? more like treat! shannon just knows how to write fantasy
a day of fallen night (samantha shannon), 5☆
pure joy to dive back into the roots of chaos universe and meet new characters (I might even like this one more than priory). I'm gonna need to cuddle an ichneumon real soon please
* fyi, I only put this down as romance subplot bc i didn't know where else to put it for this challenge but I wanted to mention it because I Loved it so much and there is indeed a romance that is very much a subplot not a second plot or anything. the focus is very much on friendship, what makes a home, standing up for yourself and an angel and a demon being awesome
26 notes
·
View notes
Spinning Silver || Naomi Novik || 466 pages
Top 3 Genres: Fantasy / Retellings / Young Adult
Synopsis: Miryem is the daughter and granddaughter of moneylenders, but her father's inability to collect his debts has left his family on the edge of poverty--until Miryem takes matters into her own hands. Hardening her heart, the young woman sets out to claim what is owed and soon gains a reputation for being able to turn silver into gold.
When an ill-advised boast draws the attention of the king of the Staryk--grim fey creatures who seem more ice than flesh--Miryem's fate, and that of two kingdoms, will be forever altered. Set an impossible challenge by the nameless king, Miryem unwittingly spins a web that draws in a peasant girl, Wanda, and the unhappy daughter of a local lord who plots to wed his child to the dashing young tsar.
But Tsar Mirnatius is not what he seems. And the secret he hides threatens to consume the lands of humans and Staryk alike. Torn between deadly choices, Miryem and her two unlikely allies embark on a desperate quest that will take them to the limits of sacrifice, power, and love.
Finished: April 2nd, 2023.
2023 Reading Progress: 1 book read.
My Rating: ★★★★★. [5/5]
My Review: [Under the read more - NOT SPOILER FREE]
It’s actually been about a week since I finished this and I’ve been struggling to find the words to write for a good and proper review! I’d been reading it since like… November, and so much has happened in those five months that it is extremely difficult to remember thoughts while reading from that time, let alone specifics.
I know I absolutely loved the ending, though. I know I loved the story and the intricacy and the character development, and the characters themselves, and that unexpected romance between Miryem and the Staryk king made my heart WEAK oh my god. And I loved the worldbuilding and the many, many different ways female characters could be strong and clever and said “fuck you” to their planned destinies to create their own – wow wow wow I loved this book.
I’ll admit, part of why it took me so long to finish was just because I didn’t want to leave the world lol.
There’s got to be more that I can say than that. There’s got to be, this book was entirely too good for this to be it.
It might be, though. I think of this book and all I can think of are cartoon hearts floating around my head, instead of anything actually helpful or respectable. So I guess that’ll have to do? This book. Cartoon hearts. I loved it, oh my god. I might need to go hug my copy again.
14 notes
·
View notes