my forever theory is that the reason 5sos was (and still kinda are to a very small few) considered a boyband wasnt just cuz they toured with one direction (and thus became associated with 1d's boyband image), not just because they started young, not just because they're all attractive--but because everyone in 5sos sings. (and by sing, i mean having an isolated part of a song, like a dedicated verse or bridge. i dont mean vocal ability or backing vocals.) even ashton sings, and you dont see drummers of bands getting their own vocal parts often.
in typical bands i've noticed, only the frontman sings, and the other members just play their instruments, maybe do some backing vocals. 5sos is unique in this way that they do it all.
like obviously 5sos gaining a lot of publicity in part to 1d is definitely a factor of the boyband label, but i really believe it's because they all sing. every member singing in one song is a boyband staple. you just don't see that in regular bands. 1d was considered a boyband, all the male kpop groups are kind of considered boybands. they all have dedicated verses.
and i know early 5sos didn't like being referred to as a boyband, but i think that being the public's image of them ended up helping them gain traction, especially in the era when boybands were the hot thing. and since all of 5sos sings, it was easier for the public to accept they were a boyband (when they werent).
i also believe that all of 5sos having vocals on their songs is one of the biggest reasons why each member has a pretty even amount of stans behind them. a fandom having a favorite member is something you primarily see in boybands--like 1d or bts and "which member is your favorite/bias?" compare this to the 1975 where only matty sings. while adam, ross, and george have their stans, matty has the most of the fandom favoring him. when i see people online sharing that they like the 1975, i never see someone get asked who their favorite member is, because it's assumed matty is. (i think with the 1975 fandom the stans love the other members, but still really love matty. i could be wrong though. not knowledgeable in the 1975 lore.) with 5sos, 1d, and kpop groups, i see people being asked who their favorite member is all the time.
anyway, the point is that i can see why the public saw 5sos as a boyband back then. its a lot of different factors, but im so solid in it mostly stemming from the fact that they all sing.
1 note
·
View note
So much of Garak as a person starts to make sense once you know his childhood was a fucking gothic novel. His main playground was a graveyard and he'd play pretend by perfoming improv eulogies to an imagined audience. For a long time his main touchstone for most important figures from recent history is 'oh yeah I know about that guy my dad buried him. great flower arrangements for that one'. He finds out later his 'parents' are actually a brother and sister who had to get married to avoid the utter shame and social devastation of having a child born out of wedlock, and they live in the basement of his biological father's house. (the madwoman in the attic vs. the tiny elim in the basement.) His biological father calls himself his uncle and locks him in a closet whenever he fails to live up to his insane and unpredictable expectations and everyone just has to act like that's normal and expected, and his will hangs over everything at all times, unseen but always felt keener than anything else. The father who actually raised him grows the world's most beautiful (and as it turns out, most poisonous) orchids and keeps the mask of a god hidden in a box in his work shed. Everyone in the house is choking down secrets like it's the only air they know how to breathe anymore.
What I'm saying is that right from the get-go this guy never had the faintest shot at turning out normal, so I'm glad that by middle age he's found a way to get a bit silly with it as he continues to be deeply deeply not normal about anything ever <3
1K notes
·
View notes
The interpretation of Rise Raph as a 'perfect responsible soft boy uwu' is so BORING I'm sorry, Raph is a rowdy adrenaline junkie with anxiety and I won't take this slander any longer
Raph secretly kept an enemy soldier in their actual literal house as a sparring partner. Raph glued his brothers together and dragged them out to fight crime. Raph once asked Leo to punch him in the face to prove he 'takes damage like a boss.' Raph tried to lift a school bus, twice. Raph offered to help his favorite wrestler beat his little brother up. When Leo suggests evacuating Bullhop, Raph says no bc the best defense is a good offense babey. Raph's idea of a 'friendly chat' with April's upstairs neighbor is to put on a black ski mask and go stand menacingly at their door. It takes Raph 10 episodes to conclude that they should MAYBE start training. Raph's plan to get a potentially priceless (and potentially FRAGILE) museum artifact is to punch a car in the middle of a busy street and also cut it in half with his brother still inside.
Raph's never met a problem he wouldn't try to punch in the face and does not know the meaning of the words 'excessive force.' He roughhouses with his bros and drags them out to fight villains and thinks any plan that doesn't involve an all-out brawl is boring and lame. He'll do anything to protect his family from harm and be a hero, but also he eats wet salami off the floor and once single-handedly destroyed a library.
I just adore how, at his core, Rise Raph is such a classic Raph—impulsive and stubborn and caring and passionate. He is a very sweet, strong, honorable guy who has a very powerful sense of personal responsibility... and he is also the exact kind of jock who throws you in the pool at a party without checking if you have your phone in your pocket first.
2K notes
·
View notes