do it. gimme the Izzy straight-coded meta 👀
I feel like I need to preface this by saying that Actually, Izzy Is Straightcoded would be the inflammatory clickbait title I'd give this if it were written to draw traffic & ad revenue to my shitty website. So don't take that term too seriously.
There has been a lot of ink spilled about Izzy thinking he's in a story where one can only be subtextually queer. Some even by yours truly, but the more I think about it, the less sense it makes. What would be the purpose of queercoding Izzy?
In general, villains* aren't queercoded to show that men being attracted to other men is bad. It's often the outcome; but it's not why the trope exists. It exists because cishet people tend to be (and are encouraged to be) profoundly uncomfortable with gender nonconformity, and so, making a character gnc becomes a quick and easy way to make him appear twisted and untrustworthy. If he** can't even obey the fundamental rules of his own gender (rules that are inherent and unchangeable!) what other rules does he disobey?
Or: If a man is insufficiently masculine, he can't be trusted to have morals. The villain isn't gnc because that's an evil trait to have; rather, the gender nonconformity is a symptom of his evilness. Being evil is what enables him to embrace his feminine side, and embracing his feminine side is what others him and marks him as a villain.
This only really works when he's contrasted with a hero (or heroine) who is Doing Gender Correctly. The villain is foul to highlight how good the hero is. The Hero will be honest and straightforward, brave, physically powerful; the Queercoded Villain treacherous, cowardly, and physically weak. The hero is a Proper Man, a Good Person. The villain an Improper Man, and therefore, a Bad Person.
Of course ofmd fundamentally rejects this. The shorthand wouldn't work, because ofmd simply doesn't think effeminacy is creepy. It's uninterested in moralizing self-expression; it just lets people be how they are. There's a wide range of expressions of masculinity on this show, and none of it is inherently bad. People are allowed to be hypermasculine, flamboyant, and anything inbetween, can express their gender in whatever manner they want, and it's all fine - as long as they are authentic about it. Be however you are, but be yourself, and this is what Izzy fails at. The repression marks him as a villain. The strict adherence to what he thinks a Real Man Pirate ought to be like. He's very preoccupied with enforcing a traditional (and toxic) masculinity on himself and others. It's no coincidence the characters he antagonizes the most - Stede and Lucius - are also the most effeminate ones. And I know, I know anglophones have a much more casual relationship to twat and cunt, those don't nearly feel as uncomfortable for y'all as they do for me, so I don't want to assign too much significance here, but he is the only character who constantly uses this kind of language, and also the one who uses the most gender&sexuality based slurs (as far as I remember).
All of this while being clearly, obviously queer himself! I do not feel like I need to explain this; his flustered reaction when Lucius asks him if he's ever been sketched speaks for itself. The fact that he meets Stede and immediately slices his shirt off of him, speaks for itself. And so on.
Izzy isn't straightcoded in the sense that the story wants us to believe he's exclusively attracted to women. Much like a queercoded villain doesn't need to be shown to be attracted to men (and can even be shown to be attracted exclusively to women!) to still be queercoded. He's straightcoded in the sense that he's a stand-in for restrictive and toxic gender roles that society enforces on people. He buys into the idea that there's a way of Doing Gender Wrong, and this is presented as a tragic character flaw. Something he has to overcome to be able to do the thing that actually marks a hero in this show: express himself authentically.
Part of why I found his death so moving is because it enables him to set right the toxicity he spread. His rehabilitation arc was about himself; about finally allowing himself to be, accepting love, accepting community. His death was about taking responsibility. About fully recognizing the hurt he caused. Looking death in the face enables him to finally abandon the last shreds of that toxicity, to apologize and be granted forgiveness. In the end, he was not beyond saving, and the harm he has done will be healed.
*Izzy is introduced as an antagonist to both Stede and the central romance of this romcom. I'm not gonna debate this; if you disagree, fine, but you clearly have such a fundamentally wrong different view of the show that it's pointless for us to try and convince each other.
**of course Queercoded Female Villains exist s well, but they are a whole different can of worms and less relevant to this discussion
154 notes
·
View notes
ok i spent entirely too long on this so i present to you under the cut:
georgia companion swap dialogue
Georgia: Hey, Codsworth, while I’m out, could you water my plants for me? Thanks, hun.
Codsworth: Of course, ma’am. Our geraniums were once the envy of Sanctuary Hills, you know.
Codsworth: I’ll be sure to point sir/mum in the direction of any interesting books while we’re away, Miss Georgia.
Georgia: Aw, thanks, honey. See you later, Codsworth.
---
Georgia: Aw, c’mon, Dogmeat, that’s not fair. Put those puppy-dog eyes away!
Dogmeat: (Sad whimper)
Dogmeat: (Bark)
Georgia: [Cutesy voice] Bye-bye, little baby boy. [Regular] We’ll play fetch when you get back, alright?
---
Georgia: Stay here and hold down the fort for me, will ya? Wouldn’t trust anyone else.
Preston: I could say the same of you. You have fun out there.
Preston: Anything interesting to report since we last talked?
Georgia: [Excitedly] Oh my goodness, Preston, you would not believe--
---
Georgia: If I see anything story-worthy out there, you’ll be the first person I tell.
Piper: Oh, Georgia, you know just what I like to hear. My eyes and ears in the Commonwealth.
Piper: Hey, Specs, my treat at Power Noodles for that last piece you helped me with. It got looots of people talking.
Georgia: Ooh, lookin’ forward to it, Piper.
---
Georgia: Sorry to take your spot, Mr. Valentine. Hopefully I’ll be just as effective in your place.
Nick: With that attitude, you’re already halfway there. Take care.
Nick: Guess it’s my turn to take a spin. We can finish our talk another time, Missus Tate.
Georgia: I’ll make sure to mark it on my calendar.
---
Georgia: Hey, Shades. Don’t wait up, yeah?
Deacon: See you later, Teach. Go have some fun for me.
Deacon: Huh, if it isn’t Blast From the Past Two: Electric Boogaloo.
Georgia: I’ll just pretend like I know what that means, Deacon.
---
Georgia: Looks like it’s my turn for a loop around the Commonwealth. Talk to you later, Hotshot.
MacCready: Try not to get hurt out there, alright? See you later.
MacCready: Hey, Georgia, got any extra credit I can do for you?
Georgia: Well, now that you mention it...[Laughs]
---
Georgia: Hey, Hancock, if there are any books you want me to keep an eye out for while I’m gone, you just let me know.
Hancock: Hm...Surprise me, won’t ya?
Hancock: Hm...you seem like a Mentats girlie. Favorite flavor?
Georgia: [Nervous laugh] Oh, you must be mistaken, I don’t really do chems.[Pause] ...Orange.
---
Georgia: Sorry, Danse, looks like a more delicate touch is needed right now.
Danse: Hopefully you'll be up to the task, civilian.
Danse: You keep staring. Is there something you need?
Georgia: ...It’s nothin’, you just remind me of someone. Stay safe, Danse.
---
Georgia: Huh, wow, are you sure you want to take me over the strongest woman in the Commonwealth?
Cait: Aw, you’re flatterin’ me, sweetness.
Cait: I doubt there’s much you could teach me that experience hasn’t already.
Georgia: I dunno, Cait, there’s somethin’ to be said about sittin’ down with a good book.
---
Georgia: Finally wanna travel without people chasin’ you around with pitchforks and torches, huh?
Strong: Strong fast. Strong chase back.
Strong: This squishy human weak. Make good food for Strong’s brothers.
Georgia: Oh, that’s not threatenin’, no, not at all...
---
Georgia: Oh, bye, Curie! Guess we can finish catchin’ up later.
Curie: Au revior, Mademoiselle Georgia. I look forward to our future conversations.
Curie: Mademoiselle Georgia, please do be careful, I think I may have spotted a few large insects on our way in.
Georgia: Oh dear. Thanks for the heads up, Curie.
---
Georgia: Hi, X6. Bye, X6.
X6-88: From her, that was quite the efficient greeting.
X6-88: Remember you’re traveling with the future of the Institute. Do not let personal feelings get in the way of that.
Georgia: If that ain’t ominous...will do, X6.
17 notes
·
View notes
I feel like people underestimate George’s season so much. I don’t see much appreciation for the megadrive he did in Austria with the car he had bc of that first lap clash, and that is truly not fair. He always seems to try his best and never give up even when he (partially…) fucks up and yet, all I see is people downplay his results or ignore them entirely and only highlight his mistakes. Why? He has so much potential ffs, why can’t anyone see that?
yeah it's a shame that austria flew under the radar so much (and i still think that the penalty he got there was complete bullshit lol but anyway), it was one of the best drives of his season for sure
but i think plenty of people can see george's potential! yeah this year was a massive roller coaster in every possible sense of the word lol (and yes you're always gonna get the trolls, and some of the twitter toxicity etc) but usually he's still considered to be at least the 4th best driver on the grid. and i think most people are aware that he's only going to improve. this was his first year at a top team, which for the first time in years was underperforming (relative to their previous success) AND he's going up against lewis, which is a tough and complicated gig on and off track, for many reasons. and i think he handled the situation as good as he could this year, and people who have a clue about the sport and aren't just spewing unnecessary hate have no problem acknowledging this + his talent, work ethic, potential etc
what i'm incredibly happy about is that he got the win in brazil, because especially after the singapore/suzuka/austin weekends he really needed it + just like the first pole, he finally got it "out of the way". and it's just a great thing that he could go into the winter break like this
9 notes
·
View notes