(body image tw)
it is almost dizzying how ugly - in the sense of both aesthetically and also. in a general way, slightly repulsive and weird-looking - I've been feeling lately, and yet seeing 1 picture of disha patani, a woman i look nothing alike if not for our prominent features, has made me feel bizarrely soothed
4 notes
·
View notes
The PJO series casting announcements have gotten me thinking about adaptations & why people are so intense about being “book accurate.” Long post ahead.
Okay so first off obviously a lot of the people who are upset about Annabeth’s casting are just being racist (not everyone — if you simply imagined her differently in the books and are not being a dick about it this is not about you, though I do think that people saying things like ‘I’m sure she’s a great actress but I just can’t see her as Annabeth’ should maybe think a little harder about why that is). I don’t want to take away from that conversation, but it’s been getting me thinking about adaptations and the concept of “book accuracy” in general.
A lot of people are obviously really hellbent on having every aspect of an adaptation being exactly like the original. I was certainly like that when I was younger. Little 11 year old me was mad as hell that Daniel Radcliffe had blue eyes instead of green, and I certainly get why people care about physical features - you’ve envisioned this character a certain way for years and years and you want that character to come to life exactly how you imagined. But that’s just not realistic in an adaption. Everyone has different ideas of how characters look in their head, and besides, an adaption is not going to be a copy/paste of the original! There are always going to be aspects of an adaptation that don’t line up with how you imagined it.
I think that part of wanting to have things exactly the same is just an inherent desire to see your own imagination come to life, but I honestly have started to think that part of this fear of any sort of change in an adaption comes from having so many disappointing, bad adaptions. I think that a lot of people have conflated bad writing that disrupts the story at its core with having any changes from the original whatsoever.
An adaptation will always have changes because of available actors, set & CGI limitations, and because some things just work better for a visual medium vs a written one. A good adaptation will change things in a way that keeps the characters and story intact, but it will still have changes. Often, it actually needs changes to be effective in the new medium (a good general example is animated to live action adaptations that attempt to keep the same physical expressions - animated facial expressions are generally more exaggerated on purpose, and trying to replicate that exactly in live action usually just ends up looking goofy).
I’ve been looking at the His Dark Materials series lately as a pretty good adaption. Without going into too much detail so as to avoid spoilers, there are certainly things that I still didn’t like (particularly some of the dialogue and worldbuilding in s1) but there are some major changes that I think really worked, like introducing Will in season 1 instead of at the beginning of 2 like in the books. Lyra and Will also look nothing like their character descriptions - Lyra has curly blond hair and her and Will are supposed to look enough alike to pass as siblings, but none of that is the same in the show and none of it matters. I have no trouble seeing them as Lyra and Will - they embody the characters perfectly imo, and I am saying that as someone who was originally pretty disappointed that Lyra did not look like how I imagined her and was concerned I wouldn’t be able to see her as the character.
Anyways, this is a really long rambling post but I just think that people should try to be more open-minded about changes in an adaption, especially one that’s coming out over 15 years after it was originally released. Things are going to change and that’s good! That can be exciting if you let it be. I understand wanting an exact replica of what you had in your head, but that’s not really what an adaptation is for. I think that if people viewed adaptations not as an exact replica of the original, but as a new version of the same characters and stories, they might have a better time. Sometimes change is actually a good thing.
3 notes
·
View notes