Rings of Power Galadriel actually makes sense.
I'll die on this hill and maybe I'll die alone but that's not the point, if I hear another Tolkien “““loyalist””” piss and moan about her I will throw hands.
“She's not like in the movies!”
My dudes, so was Arwen when PJ replaced Glorfindel with her. That argument is hypocritical. And since when is PJ the measure for the fandom, as some of the haters even hate on these movies, despite them being masterpieces.
“She's so stubborn and rude!”
My fucking DUDES ... Her Elven name is literally 'man maiden'. Would you say the same about a male elf on a quest for revenge?
“Her lore is wrong!”
Well, the showrunners couldn't buy the rights for other writings of Tolkien than The Hobbit, The Lord of the Rings and the appendices. The Estate is ...well, the Estate. I wonder if Tolkien would like the way things are handled at all. If you have to worm your way around protected lore, you gotta do it.
“Tolkien's canon is fixed.”
Holy crap, the dude wrote on toilet paper and revised so many things. At one point you just gotta say fuck it and roll with what you like. Are we going to argue about Gil-galad's canon too? Oh wait, Tolkien left that out. Conveniently. He left as many things unclear as he revised previous statements. Over and over. And over. I'm getting whiplash from it frequently.
“Her character/personality is butchered.”
No. Just no. Again: Her literal Elven name is “man-maiden.” Tomboy. Did I stutter?!
That's what you call butchery is a character arc for an amazing heroine who has yet to learn and unlearn. Her ambitions and her hatred are obstacles on the way to become the wise and fair Lady of Lórien. Again: character arc. You should look it up.
She'll have her share of experience, change of heart, desires and hopes. She will change in the series, I would swear on the precious.
You're welcome. I did the work you should do to understand the character instead of being a crybaby about the changes you don't personally approve of. Prime doesn't need your approval. What you gonna do? Piss and moan even harder?!
Also, if you hate Haladriel, don't ever come to my doorstep whining about it. Exactly the kind of ambition Galadriel shows would let someone weaker than her fall in Sauron's hands. Take his hand in marriage. Rule. (and be ruled.)
Actually that ship is worth exploring. Galadriel isn't a bad person, at best she's misled by her thirst for vengeance.
And as an encore since the fanatic crybabies love to demand that every single word written by Tolkien ever has to be met with a 1:1 transfer into other media:
The movies and/or movies doing that would be unwatchable monstrosities and no one would have the patience for that. Same stupid reasoning as in WoT. Also: would be a monstrosity and also... some things you don't want to be seen through a modern media lens...bc then your straight white male “demi god” of an author would be considered racist or sexist or homophobic... Do you really want that? I don't think so. You don't have to embrace changes blindly, but having a hissy fit like a damn toddler about each and every inconsistency/discrepancy just makes you look like a fool.
30 notes
·
View notes
Had a terrible day, feeling very vindictive, so I'm gonna vandalise a page in my "Goodnight stories for rebel girls" book on JK Rowling
Got a sharpie. What could go wrong
Also I'm gonna document this process
9 notes
·
View notes
This post has imagery that are considered potentially compromising for people with photosensitivity. Proceed with caution.
One quality the Starchildren and Wishweaver collectively have is that there'd be a form of otherworldly pressure imposed upon others by their mere presence alone, with afflictions ranging from uneasiness, nausea, the feeling of dread, and other varying reactions. What the current Folktale regarding the Starchildren and the Wishweaver obfuscated was the fact that this was the initial reaction the Ancient Spirans had over them, especially the Starchildren.
After all, it is natural to fear what you do not understand, as the fear of the unknown is ingrained on every living being. The worship only followed some time after the First Starchild aided the people of ancient Spira the first time. However, said otherworldly, unnatural pressure vary from each of them, of course.
The Second Starchild's presence is at least anomalous at best, with most of the eldritch pressure contained, albeit still there. It is enough to make one feel uneasy in its presence, anything else. This is also partly thanks to the Champion of Spira's bond with it via the Starlink Phenomenon. However, when under threat, or agitation, said pressure would increase in potency, and thus would be enough to strike terror towards those who are unable to with the increased exertion, though such occurrence is far in between.
The Wishweaver's eldritch pressure is mostly subdued, as it is mostly asleep, 'dreaming', in a state of being between 'alive', yet 'not alive'. Its pressure is only enough for one to exercise caution, as even if it is in such a unique limbo state, it is still well aware of its surroundings, and would defend itself when needed. However, if it were to awake via regaining its energy naturally, which takes many, many generations' worth of years, or via gathering a mix between cosmic energy and the wishes of the people unto itself, it is a conjecture that its eldritch presence would mostly exert reverence to those around it.
Its eldritch pressure would only really reach its absolute peak when it has gathered enough power from the wishes of the people of Spira in order to amplify Doom Desire's strength.
As for the First Starchild?
After having its full potential realized via a paradoxical self-symbiosis thanks to the SYM Project, SYM-09's eldritch pressure has exceeded what has been expected from it. The First Starchild, under Team Celestial's reports, has caused feelings of terror, reverence, and hopelessness towards those who are within an approximate of twenty meters in radius.
So far, the only ones that can resist such overwhelming pressure are the Team Celestial Admins with the help of meteorite fragments in their accessories taken from both Anomalous Crater and Meteoric Crash Site, as they can help alleviate such overwhelming presence to some capacity, and Team Celestial's Leader, due to the fact that he and the First Starchild are bonded together in a similar fashion to the Starlink Phenomenon.
Though it can also be argued that individuals who were touched/chosen by Legendary Pokémon or have had similar encounters with the cosmic weirdness (Ultra Beasts) would also be able to resist said overwhelming pressure at some capacity as well.
2 notes
·
View notes
AnF is a story about many things. One of the things is silence. The sparse use of internal monologue at critical moments leaves the reader aching for some kind of speech from the characters. Touma’s main struggle is against the externally-imposed silence he must live in. Masumi wants to be silent and can’t decide whether it’s cowardice or actual desire. Mami speaks loudly and speaks all the time, but she’s so thoroughly stonewalled that she may as well be silent. Futaba speaks quietly, she triggers the series by choosing to exit silence and start communicating.
And Taichi lives in a more universal, suffocating silence of the self. He doesn’t just hold back in talking—sticking to pleasantries, avoiding topics, letting himself hide in implications or small talk—he can’t even communicate with himself. He doesn’t have the vocabulary to understand what it is he thinks. He can’t connect his feelings with words. His internal monologue trails off constantly as he comes close to making A Connection and then spooks.
So Ao no Flag is partly about how hard it is to not be able to speak. The characters’ minor problems are magnified by never being able to acknowledge them or talk about them, they’re constricted, cut off, isolated by the lack of words they find inside themselves OR the lack of willing ears outside. One of the things AnF sets out to do is to have people communicate as reasonably and rationally as possible, and the way it manages to make a good story out of this is that there are just things people can’t say. Under any circumstances. It doesn’t matter that Mami or Taichi or Touma is trying to talk things out before anyone gets hurt, because the things that need to be said are inaudible. They can’t be said. Even if they are spoken out loud, the concepts that they’re trying to convey don’t exist in the lives of people around them. Taichi lives in utter silence for ten chapters trying to come up with a response to a statement that he doesn’t have the words to process.
3 notes
·
View notes