Who should play Professor X in the MCU?
Despite multiple X-Men movies with multiple bad interpretations of classic X-Men characters, Professor X is a character that has been adapted to the screen fairly well.
With Patrick Stewart portraying in multiple X-Men films and even all the Wolverine films (yes post credit scenes count), and James McAvoy playing a younger Charles, both felt like the same character but in very different parts of his life.
With the X-Men on their way, it's nearly impossible to imagine them without a Charles Xavier, even just to begin with. So I will be my darnedest to cast a Charles who feels fresh but can live up to both these outstanding actors.
Before we look at who we should cast. We need to answer a few questions.
What can we learn from past portrayals?
As with all my castings (check out Flash and Lex Luthor here), I will briefly go over what came before and what I loved about them to look ahead, starting with:
Patrick Stewart as Charles Xavier
I mean, he's a legend.
Patrick Stewart is most people's definitive Charles Xavier and it is easy to see why. He's charming, calm, and a strong steady presence for his X-Men.
Stewart portrays a wisdom mixed with sincerity that I quite like. You get the sense he genuinely believes humanity, even when it fails him.
I do want a that genuine nature, but my only fault with this version is he is not arrogant enough. We get glimpses of it in X-Men the Last Stand, but Charles can be and should be wrong in many of his decisions. Unlike most mutants, Charles views all come from privilege, and that should be reflected through mistakes.
James McAvoy as Charles Xavier
While I'll admit Stewart feels more like classic Charles, James McAvoy's version is still my favorite.
While he still contains that half glass full hope that Stewart has, McAvoy mixes it with this arrogance, charm, and wit of a young man I just love.
McAvoy was able to lean into the flaws of Charles, making him more relatable and sympathetic. I think he was a standout of the First Class, and was able to hold his own with the likes of Hugh Jackman.
This should be more of the blueprint for me, someone who guises their poor decisions with a calm intelligence and logic that often lead the X-Men into more trouble.
Where does Charles fit in the MCU?
In my mind, Charles will not be the leader of the team for long. I think a well-intentioned Charles could die within the first two films, leaving the X-Men to find a new leader and continue his legacy.
This gives us enough room to get an actor who maybe wouldn't normally do a role like this and leaves the X-Men in an interesting place to elect a new leader. Perhaps Storm, Cyclops, or even Magneto.
What ethnicity/race should Charles be?
Charles has been exclusively white through media, particularly British.
While I don't think he needs to be white, British is a staple of the character and I think adds a barrier of "I'm better than you" to others that I want to keep.
I do think it is interesting that for a team that is meant to be a metaphor for racism, there is hardly any people of color on the X-Men.
While I think there is value to keeping Charles white, as he is the embodiment of privilege leading the X-Men, I will say a person of color can still nab this one.
Any other stipulations?
Yes, a few.
We want an actor old enough to feel like an equal to a Magneto and an elder of the team. While we don't have a clear view of how the MCU would do a Magneto, I think over 50 is a safe bet.
Given we had Stewart and McAvoy, we have some wiggle room to get some big name actors. We should go for names only.
I don't like casting people who have already been in superhero media. It's not entirely off the table, but most likely I will look elsewhere.
Bald is cool but not a dealbreaker.
Let's get into it.
3. Jude Law
I know I just said no superhero repeats, but he is just too good.
Jude Law is known for roles like Dr. John Watson, Dumbledore, and Yon-Rogg, Law has an intense presence that cannot be denied.
While he is a bit younger, just on the cusp of 50, I can see Law playing a very flawed version of Charles, picking up right where McAvoy left off.
My main concern is he has played a role within the MCU before, as Yon-Rogg.
While he was wasted here, it was a noticeable role, and MCU fans aren't soon to forget.
I also don't know if Law is a big enough name to helm the X-Men or take over for the great performances that came before.
I think he's got a solid shot, but there's a few more I like a bit more.
2. Daniel Craig
Arrogant. Smartest person in the room. Cool smooth British man. Daniel Craig has done it all.
Known for James Bond or Benoit Blanc, Craig has been known to part of big franchises, (although he seems less excited about it these days.)
While he was apparently rumored to play Balder in Multiverse of Madness, Craig has not been in a part of any Marvel or DC Comics.
I think this role suits his resume quite nicely, and depending on the writer/director, this could be the best Professor X we have ever seen.
If it weren't for his history being anti Bond, and his love for Benoit Blanc, I'd say this would be a slam dunk. But because of the uncertainty, I have to leave him at number 2.
1. David Oyelowo
Known for roles in Selma, Rise of the Planet of the Apes, Nightingale, and The Butler, David Oyelowo may be the only name on this list you don't know.
Oyelowo is best known for playing Martin Luther King Jr. in Selma, where he was nominated for several awards.
Charles Xavier is often seen as a stand in for MLK in the X-Men Universe, so casting MLK as Charles can be kind of meta, and we can play with expectations.
Oyelowo has played unlikeable villains, heroes of Civil Rights, even a redeemed empire soldier (watch Star Wars Rebels it's really good).
This Charles can go in any direction we want, and with an actor who won't take us out of the film for their name.
While he is the youngest actor, at 47, Oyelowo can play older believably, and can easily play a mentor to the X-Men.
And as a person of color, I believe this will help the metaphor of the X-Men and racism feel improved.
If we want a dramatic force with room to see where this Charles leans, I think Oyelowo is the way to go.
Thank you for reading! If you'd like to support me, you can:
Follow me at www.facebook.com/romancomicsnews
Follow me on Twitter @diegoleonroman
Follow me on Threads @romanleondiego
Help me pay my student loans by donating!
7 notes
·
View notes