Advanced World War I Tactics with General Melchett
We talk a lot about this in my house - you know, how the very last thing the enemy would expect us to do is to make the same stupid mistake over and over again... therefore if we do it again we'll really catch them by surprise this time!
General Melchett shares some of his wisdom en gives an insight in the life of a British general during the first world war. Behold as grand tactics unfold beneath your very own eyes and grasp you with this A-historic comedy. "He fails to understand or comprehend the basic concepts of modern trench warfare and is totally unable to come up with a new strategy that would suit it. Instead he continuously sends men to a senseless death with seemingly no tactics at all."
3 notes
·
View notes
Gallipoli: The End of the Myth by Robin Prior
Those interested in military history, in my experience, are prone to hyperbole. A while back, when I reviewed John Buckley’s Monty’s Men, I defended Field Marshal Montgomery’s reputation, for he is sometimes derided as a poor general. My defence was based on his strengths, but reading anything about Gallipoli reminds me of the other side of that coin - that there are many generals far, far worse.
It is worth clarifying what Prior means by ‘the myth’ in the title of this book, because one might initially think he’s speaking of ‘the Anzac myth.’ This isn’t the case. ‘The myth’ is that, had something gone differently, or had someone showed more gumption, or if the British troops had been less racially degenerate - yes, that’s a real suggestion that was made - the campaign might have been won. Prior responds very convincingly that it didn’t matter if the Dardanelles had been forced by the British Navy, or if the Sari Bair Ridge had been taken in the August Offensive - it would have made no difference, because the entire conception of the campaign was fundamentally flawed.
This book is a frustrating read, although this is not Prior’s fault. The constant failure of leaders - in the government, Navy and Army - to appreciate reality, the haphazard planning, the complete failure to regard the enemy, logistics, terrain, the capabilities of unsupported infantry and the complexities of amphibious landings is so prevalent - not just from Churchill but most his colleagues, Kitchener, Fisher, the Admiralty, Hamilton and his staff, Birdwood and dozens of others - that it reads almost like satire. One could imagine Blackadder’s General Melchett devising the Battles of Krithia. The few glimmers of competence, for example from Major Frankland at Helles and the inimitable Brudenell White during the evacuation, only make this circus of military ineptitude all the more infuriating.
In the process, Prior reevaluates some of the old scapegoats for the failure of the campaign. He notes Alymer Hunter-Weston - while he generally deserves his reputation as an incompetent butcher, Prior notes that Hamilton failed to show any control over him, and by the end of his time at Helles, he and his French counterpart were starting to change their tactics in response to the slaughters at Krithia. Suvla Bay, meanwhile, is evaluated in its proper context - not as any great strike across the Peninsula, but as an attempt to create a supply base in the north which, despite being conducted with little finesse, did ultimately succeed at its (ultimately pointless) task. Prior charges that General Stopford and his New Army men were in many ways a useful scapegoat for the failures of Birdwood down at Anzac.
Ultimately, though, Prior’s Gallipoli might be described as a Greek tragedy - not in the noble sense of Hector dying to Achilles at the gates of Troy, but in the squalid sense of the Greek army being slaughtered while Achilles has a sook in his tent. Ultimately, Gallipoli was a campaign that was an intensely pointless, intensely idiotic and intensely sad episode in the history of the First World War, and as Prior poignantly puts it, didn’t shorten the war by a single day. I would fully recommend this book as perhaps the archetypical example of how not to run a battle.
21 notes
·
View notes
Yuletide Recs
Eight recs from eight fandoms for Yuletide 2023.
Housekeeper in a Spin (2728 words) by Anonymous
Chapters: 1/1
Fandom: All Creatures Great and Small (TV 2020)
Rating: General Audiences
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Relationships: Siegfried Farnon & Mrs. Hall | Audrey Hall, Mrs. Hall | Audrey Hall & Everyone
Characters: Mrs. Hall | Audrey Hall, Siegfried Farnon, Tristan Farnon, James Herriot, Helen Herriot
Summary: "Mrs Hall's cross," Tristan told his brother. "I assumed it was your fault, but she doesn't seem cross with you."
"Why would she be cross with me?" Mr Farnon demanded. "When do I ever do anything wrong?"
Comment: Excellent Audrey POV fic that really captures the feel of the show: light and slightly comic domestic/local matters, but with deeper, stronger and more serious thoughts and feelings underpinning them, so that the serious thing, when it emerges, hits with a kick in the guts. But overall, the warmth between the characters, particularly between Audrey and Siegfried, is what shines through.
Major Opportunity (3092 words) by Anonymous
Chapters: 1/1
Fandom: Blackadder
Rating: Teen And Up Audiences
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Relationships: Edmund Blackadder/Kevin Darling
Characters: Edmund Blackadder, Kevin Darling, George Colthurst St. Barleigh, Baldrick (Blackadder), Anthony Cecil Hogmanay Melchett
Additional Tags: Yuletide Treat
Summary: After being presumed dead, Blackadder seizes his chance to escape the trenches, and hopefully avoid ending up actually dead.
Comment: Beautifully done Blackadder fic that would fit right into an episode - so of course it's full of memorable lines from everyone, up to and including General Melchett.
I Will Never Leave You (9396 words) by Anonymous
Chapters: 1/1
Fandom: The Gilded Age (TV 2022)
Rating: General Audiences
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Relationships: Ada Brook & Agnes van Rhijn, Mr. van Rhijn/Agnes van Rhijn, Ada Brook & Oscar van Rhijn
Characters: Ada Brook, Agnes van Rhijn, Oscar van Rhijn, Mr. van Rhijn (The Gilded Age)
Additional Tags: Pregnancy, Miscarriage, Infant Death, Implied/Referenced Rape/Non-con, Implied/Referenced Sexual Assault, Period-Typical Sexism, Period Typical Attitudes, Religion, Codependency, Dysfunctional Family
Summary:
There are few bonds deeper than sisterhood. Over the years, Agnes has always looked out for Ada...and Ada has always made herself available to Agnes.
Comment: A lovely, in-depth look at the strong and complicated bond between Ada and Agnes from early in Agnes's marriage up to the beginning of canon. It's Ada's POV, and the narrative is coloured by her perceptiveness and warmth, but I can really hear Christine Baranksi delivering every bit of Agnes's dialogue. The style is also very fitting for these characters and this time and place.
An Ingenue Looks at Seventy (1881 words) by Anonymous
Chapters: 1/1
Fandom: Only Murders in the Building (TV)
Rating: Mature
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Relationships: Loretta Durkin/Oliver Putnam
Characters: Loretta Durkin, Oliver Putnam, Mabel Mora
Additional Tags: Post-Season/Series 03, Character Study, old people fucking
Summary:
Maybe this time, Loretta will get everything she ever dreamed of. Or at least a bigger piece of it.
Comment: This was my main gift fic this year, and I've already posted about it, but I'm including it in my recs post as well, because I would want to rec it even if it hadn't been written for me.
This story is everything I could have wished for when I requested a Loretta-centric fic. It's a beautiful character study, set post-canon, with guest appearances by Oliver and Mabel. I love everything about Loretta's POV, and the story is chock full of great lines, but I also really like the way her relationship with Oliver is depicted, both in public and in private. The author also gets extra points for the tag "old people fucking".
Crepusculine Confabulations (2324 words) by Anonymous
Chapters: 1/1
Fandom: The Reluctant Widow - Georgette Heyer
Rating: Teen And Up Audiences
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Relationships: Francis Cheviot/Louis de Castres
Characters: Francis Cheviot, Louis de Castres
Additional Tags: AU, Character Death Fix, Yuletide, Gift Fic
Summary:
Two conversations, in twilight, to bracket the events of the novel.
That is: you didn't think that Francis was being wholly truthful, did you? Did you?
Comment: The Reluctant Widow will never be on my list of favourite Heyers, for a bunch of reasons, but the stand-out feature of it is Francis Cheviot - and this post-canon story focused on Francis does not disappoint. Full of nicely Heyer-ish language plus some VERY Francis machinations, this is overall an excellent portrayal of Francis.
A Case Report Regarding the Brick Lane Murders (5866 words) by Anonymous
Chapters: 1/1
Fandom: Rivers of London - Ben Aaronovitch
Rating: General Audiences
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Relationships: Peter Grant & Thomas Nightingale
Characters: Thomas Nightingale, Peter Grant (Rivers of London), Miriam Stephanopoulos
Additional Tags: Case Fic, Period-Typical Racism, Period Typical Attitudes, Series level violence, There's a Murder, Yuletide 2023
Summary:
A case NIghtingale worked in 1919 gives insight into a new murder investigation.
Comment: An excellent case fic that really captures the feel of canon. The case has links to another case Nightingale worked on in 1919, very, very early in his career, and the depiction of how he was in his late teens compared to how he is now, really makes this story stand out.
Little Intimacies (1344 words) by Anonymous
Chapters: 1/1
Fandom: The Wheel of Time (TV)
Rating: Mature
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Relationships: Moiraine Damodred & Lan Mandragoran, Lan Mandragoran/Maksim
Characters: Lan Mandragoran, Maksim (Wheel of Time)
Additional Tags: Mid-s2
Summary:
Two nights after Moiraine sends him away, Lan has a conversation with another Warder.
Comment: A beautifully written study of Lan at a very particular point in time. Moiraine is not physically present, but she is still present all the way through the story.
Yes, Lord President (4826 words) by Anonymous
Chapters: 4/4
Fandom: Yes Minister
Rating: Teen And Up Audiences
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Characters: Jim Hacker, Humphrey Appleby, Bernard Woolley
Additional Tags: Period Typical Attitudes, very loosely based on a true story
Comment: This story is brilliant and I love it. It is everything that anyone could ever want in a Yes Minister fic. The author has absolutely nailed Hacker, Sir Humphrey and Bernard, and the plot is administratively absurd enough to be an episode of the show. It is structured like the Yes Minister books, with excerpts from Hacker's diary and from official files, which also works really well. I laughed and laughed and laughed reading this - and there truly is no higher praise for a story based on a show that did likewise.
0 notes
What I think different Blackadder characters would use as a mask:
-Blackadder would wear a plain black one and say something about not needing to decorate the fabric keeping his bodily fluids to himself.
-George would have something with flowers. Probably yellow. Would come into the scene while Blackadder was giving his opinion on patterned masks.
-Baldrick would have one on the back of his head and say, “This way, people behind me can’t get me sick”. Or something of that nature. Probably a medical mask he found on the ground.
- General Melchett would have one with the plastic in the front, but only around where his mustache is.
-Captain Darling would have one that’s plain black as well, but it would have the plastic filter in the corner. He would also have it monogrammed. Blackadder would make fun of this customization.
-Lord Flashheart wouldn’t wear one and say, “Everyone needs a little Flashheart!” Then say something else sexual and ignorant. If he had to wear one, he would have a bandana. His mustache would as well be visible to a certain extent.
36 notes
·
View notes