Secret Fifth Token! (no I'm not dragging Sam into this like he's just another ST character; I just didn't know who else to pick for this part of the audio)
Thinking about Mariah Hallett (I’ve seen her name spelled numerous ways and like this one best) and deciding to have her as Sam’s friend and amiable ex in Reunion AU. Cape Cod legend casts her as a witch, and at the very least Sam fully believes it. And thinks it’s unbearably cool.
The Whydah and Revenge crews meet up at the Republic, and Sam is happily telling Izzy about a letter he received from Mariah. It doesn’t happen too often, but every now and then he’ll make port in Nassau and there will be a letter from Mariah waiting for him at a tavern he frequents.
“It’s like she knows when I’m going to be here. But she is a witch, so I suppose she would.”
Izzy just frowns. “What’s the date on the letter?”
“What?”
“Wouldn’t it make more sense that she writes when she wants to and sends the letters ahead knowing you’ll be there eventually?”
Sam looks between the letter and Izzy, trying very hard to keep his expression neutral. “Suppose it could either be that or the witch thing.”