To compare Moby Dick and Ahab from the point of the god angle is really interesting and something I haven't run into all that often! In most ways, Ahab and the whale are the same character: overly intelligent, overly aggressive, their unstoppable and unscrupulous persuit of one another's species, and alwas aiming to what will end in death and nothingness. The same goes for the god status; just as Moby Dick is surrounded by such rumors, Ahab is described by Captain Peleg as an "ungodly god-like man", and certainly works hard on presenting himself as exactly that, perhaps most prominently in The Candles during his outrageous sermon to the lightning, and both engages in and is surrounded by mysticism (the prophesy, Fedallah, dabbling in black magic). There is of course also the Biblical name reference. Additionally, it is worth looking at Ishmael struggling to find words worthy of accurately describing Ahab in The Specksnyder ("Oh Ahab, what shall be grand in thee, it must needs be plucked at from the skies, dived for in the deep, and featured in the unbodied air!")
The theme of the unknown as the source of fear is a striking one! I dare argue that the response to the unknown is one of the major factors contributing to Ishmael's and Ahab's oh so different fates. Whereas Ishmael faces his fear of the unknown as early as chapter 3 when first meeting Queequeg and accepting that "ignorance is the parent of fear", and subsequently finds healing and happiness in a nurturing relationship, Ahab allows it to fuel his anxiety and paranoia to the point where Ishmael claims "thy thoughts have created a creature in thee", later echoed by Mr. Monomania himself during the dialogue with Starbuck which you mention ("what nameless, inscrutable, unearthly thing is this..."), racing him toward what will become ultimate self destruction.
As you point out, the same is displayed in their respective sentiments regarding the ocean - Ahab holding an extensive monologue on it's horrors in The Sphynx (don't agree with him, but still think it's the most beautiful thing ever produced by humanity and kinda want the full quote tattooed onto my physical being), and Ishmael writing a several hundred pages worth love letter to whales after them having become his great passion in life, blissfully claiming them to be so magnificent they will survive the fall of civilization (Has the Whale's Magnitude Diminished - Will He Perish?).
All right, let this be it for now or I shall likely be banned for harmful babbling.
Someone mentioned in the reblogs of the last post about their preferred interpretation of Moby Dick and after seeing that I had a little personal thought discussion of my own in my brain and like ahahsjsjs it made me so happy
I just love looking at this book in a more serious way than I usually do so thank you to whoever that was :)
And speaking of, I think from now on Iāll give actual (only occasional!) literary commentary on Moby Dick for these Daily Dick posts because I cannot discuss this book with anyone else except the internet so yes. But for the sake of those who only want to see funky whale drawings I will keep them under the postās cuts!!
Plus if I didnāt the post would be ungodly long.
Today, I tried to draw a bit of the crew but then I remembered I suck at drawing humans so even more extremely and unnecessarily green shaded Moby instead. Didnāt have much time so I just gave that fella the Outlast camcorder filter treatment. Dw, the cameraman is fine. Donāt like how this turned out though :(
I want to draw whale skeletons tomorrow :D
Anyways, delusional whale ranting time. Be warned this is way longer than my last one and will contain spoilers for those who havenāt finished the book!
So the reblog tag I saw went along the lines of interpreting Moby Dick as not a god but to have the reader doubt that fact throughout the book until the end because of the descriptions we get of him and honestly, yes. I absolutely agree on that for the original novel. It gives us dread while reading!!
Although I will say that if we were to add/accept some kind of mysticism to Moby Dick and see him as not only a whale and as something else, he still wouldnāt be a āgodā. Yet at the same time he isnāt exactly a whale either. Or at least not a normal one (that much is clearly obvious I suppose). Like if thatās not a god then what is a god? And if thatās not a whale what is it? Itās all vague!!
One of the many messages or themes in Moby Dick is humanityās constant struggle against the unknown and the uncertain. We all fear the unknown in one way or another whether we realise it or not. Why else do we dread our future? Or what will happen tomorrow? Or what will happen after death? Because we donāt know.
With Moby Dick we understand that heās described as a massive white whale who is known to wreak havoc among sailors. But aside from that what else do we actually know about Moby? The only information we get about him all come from 3rd party sources (such as that other whaling crew they met at chapter 54) and then through Ishmael as our narrator. Like Ishmael himself has only encountered Moby Dick once. How do we know if the information he got from others is true?
And even if it was true it still doesnāt tell us a lot about Moby Dick. We donāt understand why he attacks ships, was he angry? Was he in pain? Was it his own form of revenge? Or was he genuinely just trying to mind his own business? We donāt understand how he became so intelligent, or whether it really was Moby Dick that they saw in the apparitions of chapter 51 or was it just a squid like we see in a later chapter? If it was Moby why was he following them?
The vagueness of Moby Dickās position in being either whale or something else makes him haunting. So in my own interpretation Iād say to keep the final verdict completely undecided. He appears, then disappears. As only one of the many horrors of the deep. Moby Dick isnāt a horror book by any means but it is about the ocean, the ocean just so happens to be scary because we havenāt truly discovered everything it has to offer. Who knows whatās down there?
Also, not only the fear or mystery he gives to us as the readers but to the crew in the story as well. Moby Dick took victory from doing what other whales the crew have hunted never do. He was āunpredictableā as described. That wraps back to the beginning where I mentioned humanityās struggles against the unknown and uncertain. But yet, even when we fear what we donāt know we are constantly challenging it still. Weāre intrigued by it. Ishmael does so by wanting to learn more about whales and go off on more voyages despite his experience the first time around, and the pequod crew or most notably Ahab does so by challenging Moby Dick.
Speaking of Ahab, he himself can also be compared to Moby Dickās unpredictability. He might not be vaguely god-like as Moby is, but thereās definitely something about him. Ishmael even quotes something about a mad man, a man who has let go of all rationality and morality, to be more dangerous than any beast. Why? Because he will become an unpredictable man. A man who will do anything to get what he desires even at the cost of others. Which is exactly what Ahab does. Humans are already dangerous enough when we understand them but when we donāt understand them? Even more dangerous no doubt.
Thatās why his crew feared him after all. They didnāt know and nor did they want to know what would happen if they disobeyed him. Even Ahab doesnāt understand himself as he mentioned in the chapter with Starbuck. Why does he do the things he do? For revenge? For glory? For gold? He doesnāt understand except the fact he knows (or feels?) he has to. And itās tragic.
In conclusion; aside from accepting differences, democracy, and the dangers of unhealthy obsession or copious amounts of whale anatomy, Moby Dick is also about the unknown and the uncertain. Thereās a lot of other instances like Starbuckās hesitation and Fedallahās entire existence but I donāt want to drag out the rant for too long and obviously Iām not the first person to come up with this.
But what do you think? And thank you to anyone who actually read all my crap frfr šš
9 notes
Ā·
View notes
Funny, these coincidences. š
captain ahab š¤ captain flint
unapproachable terrifying intelligent captains who are viewed as gods of the sea and who bribe their crew with the promise of spanish gold to achieve a years-in-the-making revenge scheme they're utterly obsessed with to the point of madness
47 notes
Ā·
View notes
One of my absolute favorite trauma studies of Moby-Dick and a theory I am a heartfelt supporter of.
His description of Mapple's actions in the deserted chapel, however, is a subtle sign of the narrative s movement beyond the frame of the character's perception. This movement occurs smoothly, with the focalization remaining on Father Mapple appearing to come to the reader through a narrator located among "all the people" (48), a nonspecific group that assembles for the sermon, then leaves the chapel and takes Ishmael along. Ishmael appears at ease describing both the details he recalls and those he imagines. At this point, prior to his trauma, he is capable of encompassing contradiction and invention without losing a sense of self: as a character, he revises his prejudices, and as a narrator, he interweaves imaginative details and memory without appearing to be troubled by their effect on mimesis.
Irreconcilable Differences: Voice, Trauma, and Melville's "Moby-Dick"
10 notes
Ā·
View notes