#back in the ussr | Explore Tumblr Posts and Blogs

potuzzz · 1 month

Note

The Holodomor happened and Stalin could've avoided or stopped it at any time

Oooo, something I know a lot about!

Well, there is a half truth here, which is that, yes, yet another famine did indeed occur in Ukraine in the 1930s along with the greater Soviet region, as famines occured there repeatedly for many centuries, and this famine did indeed kill people.

This cycle of famine killed millions for hundreds of years under various tsars. And yet, less than a few decades after the Soviets took power, the cycle of famine was finally broken, and starvation in the region became a distant memory. The famine you call the "Holodomor" was one of the very last of these famines that the Communists worked diligently to prevent and alleviate--even during times of war and barbaric invasion and strangling siege from the world powers--and who the first finally successful in doing so.

So, how did this story get twisted from "the Soviets finally ended a brutal cycle of famine that the tsars did nothing about," to, "Joseph Stalin created a man-made famine to purposefully kill Ukranians in a campaign of genocide and terror"?

Let's talk about kulaks, international rightwing news, and then finish off with miscellaneous factors that exacerbated the famine and slowed Soviet response to it.

When the impoverished and starving masses of the Russian Empire and its colonies, led by the Bolsheviks, arose in a popular revolution a decade prior to seize society for themselves to build the socialist Union, there were many who fought quite viciously to stop this People's Government from coming to or keeping power. The remnants of the tsarist government, big corporations, fascists, white supremacists, the Orthodox Church hegemony, and opportunists all took money, weapons, training, soldiers, resources and other support from European and American monarchies/rulers and international corporations who had colonial interests in tsarist Russia and its own colonies; those who had a vested interest in keeping the Soviet people oppressed and suffering, from Russia to Ukraine to Kazakhstan, Belarus, Uzbekistan, Siberia, Georgia, Lithuania, and others. These counter-revolutionaries, this coalition of fascists and capitalists supported by or directly from the Western imperial powers, these people murdered civilians, minorities, and elected government officials in terror attacks, bombings, shootings, pogroms. They destroyed trains, granaries, farming equipment, factory equipment, tools, spare parts, buildings, homes, power grids, water pumps--this was a war directly on the masses, on the populace. This war on the life of the Soviet people themselves was most fierce in the civil war against the Whites (the tsarist remnants), and particularly in the genocidal Nazi invasion, but it continued for the entirety of the USSR's existence--and slowed but didn't stop even when the Union dissolved and the ex-Soviet states became capitalists or fascists themselves, up to this very day, manifest in NATO plans to balkanize and neoliberally colonize modern capitalist Russia.

One of the most despicable cases of this sabotage against the new, aspiring egalitarian society was the kulaks and what they did during these times of famine.

The Soviets had collectivized the land and the food, and began distributing it evenly to the peasants who had toiled in serfdom these lands for generations without reward; in essence, confiscating lands from wealthy slaveowners and giving the farmlands to the slaves, and ensuring those who were most vulnerable to starvation (such as during hard winter months, or famines) always had access to the bare necessities to live.

So, what did the kulaks do in response to this confiscation and just redistribution?

They burned their own crops. They killed their own cattle and horses and chickens and pigs by the herd. All to spite the new government of the people--and all leading up to and in the middle of this famine you reference as the "Holodomor."

So, we have a region that has historically suffered from famine repeatedly for centuries, and right when they are due for another one, a class of people that amount to slaveowners and landlords and those that aspire to be like them starts sabotaging a socialist government by destroying food en masse.

Sure enough, famine hit, and large amounts of people died.

See, and this is where rightwing news sources come into play.

As referenced, there were many monarchist, capitalist, and fascist interests involved in destroying the socialist experiment from its birth until long after its death.

One microcosm of this genocidal hatred was the fake news. Anybody with even a moderate grasp on history and the realities of the modern day knows that any leftwing governments, movements, or individuals are subject to lies and deceit of their rightwing adversaries. 1930s Eastern Europe was no different. Sourced that were dismissed unanimously at the time even by liberals and conservatives alike as rightwing tabloids--the Breitbarts and Stormfronts and Fox Newses and 4chans and OANs of the day--all began inventing stories of thousands, no, hundreds of thousands, no, MILLIONS, NO, TENS OF MILLIONS of dead littering the dirt roads of Ukraine--a claim quickly debunked by several verified reports at the time from independent journalists, diplomats, and travelers of various nationalities and political predilections at the time.

And yet, what amounted to flat earth conspiracy in the 1930s got a veneer of trustworthiness as its newspaper pages yellowed charmingly with age, and after urgings by the CIA, began to be used as legitimate sources cited in scholarly articles in Ivy League campuses. The Banderites, a sect of Ukranian Nazi collaborators in WW2 who joined the German Nazis in raping, pillaging, and murdering their own countrymen, also spent their every waking moment pushing for decades pushing these otherwise contemptible narratives riddled with errors and blatant fabrication, forgery, and theft--pictures used from completely different famines in completely different countries, tallies of dead that do not match birthrates and subsequent censuses by the tune of millions of people, completely invented and unverifiable names of imaginary interviewees, even the supposed TRAIN SCHEDULES of these supposed "journalists" have been debunked to the point of proving none of them even set foot in Ukraine SSR or anywhere else nearby.

Suddenly, what was correctly seen by all normal people as total BS in the 1930s, after a century of legwork, suddenly was trustworthy primary sources that were cited by Harvard professors, and then American diplomats, and then Wikipedia, and now everybody on the Internet who recounts the tale of Stalin's genocide on the Ukranian people--an idea alone that is complete nonsese when one considers the vast resources that leaders such as Stalin invested into ENDING these famines, developing Ukraine, and feeding ALL the people within the Soviet Union, all at the EXPENSE of the Russian body.

The repeated behaviors of the Soviets show them to be concerned with helping the masses achieve the basic necessities of living, they show a longstanding love and comraderie between Ukraine and Russia, they show intense efforts to end natural disasters such as famine. The repeated behaviors of the USSR's enemies show a bunch of cowards who will stop at nothing, lying and destroying to sabotage anything even remotely leftwing that threatens their colonial interests, such as a large unified Eurasian world power that refuses to allow multinational corporations to have a blank check robbing their people for cheap labor or resources.

To let off the gas pedal and reach a stopping point, I must pay homage to some other factors.

The experiments of Soviet scientist Lysenko, one of those tasked with ending such famines and industrializing agriculture to a scale that could quickly feed the entire Soviet people, were a failure, and likely contributed to the predestined famine that struck 1930s Ukraine. While many valuable lessons were gleaned from the failure of Lysenkoism, it is no doubt that its failure may have exacerbated the famine.

There is also the question of the struggling, newly born Soviet state to modernize in its early days. There was some telegrams, but most communication still had to be done by horseback mail carriers, and telephones were barely a thing at all yet. News traveled slow through the mountains, steppes, tundras and forests.

Finally, there is a legitimate question as to mid-level Soviet officials being negatively motivated to exaggerate or outright lie to meet their quotas. While early Soviet history is filled with comraderie, cooperation, bravery, justice, determination, and communal compassion, it is also simultaneously, due to the extreme pressure from international invasion, civil war, sabotage, and the like, an era of violence, mistrust, paranoia, disloyalty, volatility, and a lack of confidence. Many of this Soviet officials feared failing their country, they feared losing their positions, many even feared overzealous higher-ups would deem their failures to be intentional, proclaim them a traitor, and imprison or kill them--it was difficult to tell during this time who was collaborating with or sympathetic to the enemy, who was being paid by foreign agents, who was an opportunist enriching themselves, and in this confusion and militant attempt to keep the ship from sinking, there are tales of innocents whose lives were ruined or even stolen from them. Many mid-level Soviet officials assigned to keep track of the region misrepresented and padded their numbers to make it appear things were well on-par with Soviet objectives. Thus, grain was exported even when the famine was full swing, because the reality of the famine--especially when combined with the slow-travelling news--had yet to truly sink in to the Soviet leadership.

In closing, the following:

Mistakes were certainly made, and many people died--the true number is hard to determine. However, what is sure is that modern Western estimates are grossly distorted. The famine of Ukraine in the early 1930s was one of the last of its ilk due to the diligent work of the Communist government to destroy the cycle of famine, and they eventually succeeded, and not only Ukraine but the entire multinational, multiethnic Soviet Union and its hundreds of millions of people never suffered starving or food insecurity for the rest of the Union's existence.

4 notes · View notes