We're Still Shit Out of Luck, Munson (pt. 2)
Eddie Munson x gn!reader
Part One Masterlist
Summary: After being snowed in with Eddie and accidentally falling for him, you two are left to figure out what this is and how to make it work – by any means necessary.
Word Count: ~8.6k
Warnings: Angst. Swearing. Fluff. More fluff. Eddie's a hopeless romantic.
A/n: Thank you everyone for the love I received on part one of this fic. I had no idea people would like it so much. Please let me know your thoughts! Love hearing from you all, and thank you for reading <3
And tip: you can listen to any song from Stick Season by Noah Kahan while reading
--
It hadn’t been enough for Eddie.
One kiss. That’s all he was able to sneak in before the most horrible and irritating people ever (read: friends he loved dearly) interrupted you two. Then you were gone from his grasp, leaving him cold all over again in that godforsaken cabin. At the sound of Steve’s voice announcing they had made it back, he couldn’t help pressing his mouth to yours before the moment came crashing down around him.
It had ended all too quick, the pulsing left on his lips aching to return to you. The taste of you left him intoxicated, crawling back for more if Harrington’s stupid grin and stupid hair hadn’t waltzed back with his arms wide. You offered an apologetic smile to him before turning to greet the group, his own feet trailing behind you.
And that was the last day there before the weekend ended, so he couldn’t even share the bed with you for real this time. With you in his arms… as someone who wanted to kiss him. They’d been in and out of the room even while packing, telling story after story of the motel and plows. You couldn’t blame them – you’d come along to spend time with them, not to fall for Eddie. Though that certainly wasn’t a horrible coincidence.
But in the spare moments between Robin asking if you’d seen her hairbrush for the third time and Jonathan trying to figure out the drive back on that outdated map, it’d been quiet besides the rustling of clothes being shoved back into bags. You’d wanted it all to be comfortable, to feel as easy as it had been just hours ago, but everything weighed over you. It lingered in the air, stealing the breath from your lungs until you rushed out in a whisper, “I’m driving back to college tomorrow.”
A hard swallow bit down your throat as you risked a glance to him, and you lost that gamble. You would’ve loved to look up at his soft eyes to find that adoration he had for only you; hell, even a hardset glare at this shitty situation sitting in front of you. But they were neither. His eyes had looked up at you in raw shock, betrayal almost at it all. Then they broke as they turned just a bit shinier.
“How long?” he asked, voice quiet as he continued packing things into his bag.
“How long… what?” The pit in your stomach refused to ease, even without him looking at you now. It just wanted his arms back around your body.
His labored sigh snaked through the room – not out of frustration, but because he feared for the worst. “How long is the drive from Hawkins?”
You paused, leaving an expectant pocket of silence threatening to swallow up everything in its path. You’d changed your mind, wanting him to meet your eyes again. Please look up, Eddie.
“I, uh… a few hours, a bit more. Three if you speed,” you told him, hoping he could tell that you were practically begging him to visit without you having to voice it. To be sure, you reached out your hand toward his. If anyone walked in, your body would block their view – and you’d almost pity them for missing out on the freckles that dotted the back of Eddie’s fingers, freckles that you rubbed over with your thumb like it could grant some wish.
Still, he hadn’t raised his eyes an inch, so you squeezed his hand and said, “Well, if someone wanted to drive there, they’d probably need the phone number of the student. Just in case, of course.” And his silent laugh brought a warmth to your chest you had missed.
“I suppose they would, wouldn’t they?” Eddie asked, tilting that lopsided grin your way. “So, sweetheart…”
“Yes?” you said, expression innocent and holding back a laugh as you waited for him to ask.
He sighed again, but it held no malice. “Could I get your phone number?”
You pretended to think about it, pursing your lips before saying, “Well I think it would only be fair if I got your number in return, wouldn’t it? Especially if I’m to make it to your concert.”
And he nodded, bringing your hand up to his lips to kiss your knuckles. “God, I got to kiss a genius. You come up with the best ideas.”
A laugh bubbled up your chest as you lightly smacked him. “Just because flattery works on you Eddie doesn’t mean it works on me.”
“Oh, so a genius and a liar…” he said, shaking his head. He brought a hand up to brush a finger against your cheek, his eyes unwavering this time. “Because I know exactly what happens when I call you the most beautiful person I’ve ever seen.”
Part of you hated he was right, like your heated cheeks and inability to form words. But the other part of you nearly damned it all to kiss that smug grin off his face. Though none of it mattered, as every part of you hated the approaching footsteps and dropped hands, especially the wave of cold they left in their path.
Nancy had come to announce that they’d be leaving soon, and you found it hard to hide your disappointment. The two of you couldn’t even convince the group to let you ride back with him in the van, insisting that Robin and Steve lived closer to Eddie than your parents did.
You’d wanted to speak up, to tell the lump in your throat and their judgments to go to hell. Eddie nearly did say that. But neither of you knew what existed between the two of you, and jeopardizing it by telling your friends was not on the table.
God, he wished you were on the table, him between your legs and mouth on yours.
His eyes blinked hard as he concentrated on the road again, playing your secret goodbye in his head throughout the whole ride back. Eddie dodged side-eyes from Steve and occasional questions from Robin about whether he was okay because he didn’t once complain about the terrible choice of music they picked.
You’d caught Nancy’s gaze in the rearview mirror a few times, knowing she had silent questions she wanted to ask. And you expected a call from her later when it’d just be the two of you, but she let you sit there quietly for now, planning all the different weekends you might be free to drive back here. For Eddie.
–
“Does next weekend work?”
“I’ve got Parent Weekend then. What about the weekend after? The… 16th?” you asked, looking through your calendar as you stood in your college dorm’s common area on the public phone.
The sigh coming through his end of the line had you chewing on your lip before he answered. “They’ve got me working a double that weekend, some dick called out.”
“I’m sure he didn’t do it just to spite you, Eddie,” you said, offering a small laugh.
“Well he did spite me by making me wait to see you again.” You could practically see the way he huffed, laying in bed at his place with those wrinkles set deep between his eyebrows and hand too tight on the receiver. “Okay, what about the 23rd then?” he asked.
You flipped through your calendar, the rustling of the pages filling the nearly empty room. As soon as you saw your writing there, your eyes squeezed shut, not realizing you let out a soft groan.
“No good, huh?”
“No,” you breathed out, hand coming to rub down your face. “Got a test and an essay due that Monday. Professor Quinn’s class, can’t fail it.”
“‘S okay,” he offered, but Eddie’s voice made your lips press together to stop you from saying something you might regret – like ‘But I miss you’ or ‘Come anyway, please.’ Instead, you let the static fill the space between you. When imagining him this time, you tried picturing yourself right next to him, laying against his chest as he read some book out loud to you or talked about some metal song and its meaning.
It shattered apart when he spoke again. “Guess I won’t see ya until our concert, then,” he said, his words flat and shoved through the line with a wince. ‘Corroded Coffin’ was written on the Friday after, surrounded by a few doodled hearts. You’d wanted to see each other sooner, but the universe seemed to have other plans.
“I know… I know,” you told Eddie, trying to offer some reassurance to unspoken words, but it felt as much for you as it was for him. “I’m sorry, but I’ll be there. Wouldn’t miss it for the world, Eddie.”
A soft hum came from him, followed by, “I like when you say my name.” Now that there was nothing to be done for these horrible plans, you were grateful he changed the subject.
“Yeah?” you asked, feeling a smile grow across your face. “Would’ve picked you as a ‘darling’ or ‘handsome’ kind of guy. Maybe a ‘super handsome Dungeon Master Eddie’ for special occasions.”
You hadn’t realized how much you missed the waves of his laugh until it kissed your ears against the phone. “Well now that you’ve said it, I could certainly get used to the last one, sweetheart. ‘S got a nice ring to it,” he said, his grin evident in his voice. “Really though, ‘Eddie’ sounds perfect coming from you.”
Thankful he couldn’t see the way your face lit up or stomach flutter from his words, you shut your eyes and just stood there listening to his soft breaths. Only when you heard someone come in to use the phone did you say something. “Gotta go, Eddie. You promise to write?”
“Course, I’ll see you soon,” he said, and you weren’t sure this call had made your body feel better for talking with him or worse because it reminded you that he wasn’t actually there.
Either way, you told him “Goodbye” with a sad sort of smile on your lips.
“Bye, sweetheart. Dream of me.” With that, he hung up, leaving you there for a moment listening to the dial tone before remembering the girl waiting there.
You nodded your head to her as you passed, taking your much too full calendar with you. And you did dream of Eddie, trying to hug him but no matter what you did, he slipped through your outstretched fingers like sand. The next time you spoke with him, you wouldn’t tell him that you woke up with tears in your eyes.
–
Eddie had tried, he really had. Harder than he’d ever tried at school, that was for sure. He’d pleaded with every one of his coworkers at the auto shop to take his shifts that weekend so he could visit you – he had promised to take double the shifts for them, had even tried bribing them with money, even though it’d only been $5.
And he got rid of one of them, opening up Saturday even if he had to be back on Sunday. But he’d get to be with you for a few hours. That was enough. When he’d gotten ready to make the drive and surprise you – hair clean, clothes unwrinkled, and a pile of your favorite snacks – his phone rang.
He regretted picking it up, fearing it’d be work. And he was right. His boss said the guy who’d promised to take the shift bailed, so Eddie had to come in or he’d be fired. Slamming the receiver down, he let out a guttural groan that burned his throat. Throwing off his nice clothes for his grease-stained ones, he couldn’t bring himself to even tell you about his plans at all, knowing you’d be just as disappointed as he was.
His grip on the steering wheel did nothing to relieve his anger – at his coworker, at his stupid job, at whatever sick and twisted universe was laughing at his misery. The only thing that got him through the weekend was picturing finally seeing you again. Toothy grin and warm touch wrapped around him, jokes that made him shake his head, and kindness he wasn’t sure he always deserved. But you gave it to him without question, and he counted down the days until he could have that again.
–
The week leading up to Eddie’s concert, the weekend you’d finally be able to spend time with him since those days trapped in the cabin together, you found yourself pacing more often, picking at the seam of your jeans, abusing your lip with your teeth as you thought of every detail the weekend held for you two.
You packed your bag with everything you needed well before you left, checking at least twice every day until Friday finally came. Maybe you were doing a bit too much, but you’d already made him cookies in the terrible dorm kitchen, so there was no going back now. You tried to keep most of this excitement down when talking with Eddie, not wanting to overwhelm or intimidate him with your feelings – but even with your worries, you knew he wouldn’t be, not with how much he talked about wanting to spend every minute with you while you visited.
After your final Friday class, your legs carried you through crowds of people as you grabbed your things and said a quick goodbye to your roommate before racing to your car under building waves of rain. The engine rumbled to life in the damp air that turned your deep breaths foggy, and as you turned out onto the street, you only hoped he felt just as excited to see you.
–
Eddie was losing it, practically shitting himself when Friday came. He’d spent more time cleaning his apartment than he had in his entire life, scrubbing things he had never known he had to clean. His clothes were folded, his fridge and cupboards filled with drinks and snacks he knew you’d like, hell, he even tucked in his sheets when making his bed. What were you doing to him?
He walked – no, floated really – through work, his palms constantly sweaty and body fidgety. His mind sat elsewhere while under the hood, nearly taking off his fingers when not paying attention one time. And though his feet were tired, he took a long shower after work to scrub himself free of dirt and grease. Because you were coming, just a few hours before his show at The Hideout, and everything had to work out, right? Right?
And standing in the middle of his apartment, looking out at the storm rolling in, Eddie believed, naively, for a moment. Until his phone rang.
–
You shoved your fingers under your arm, hoping to warm them up just a little as you stood in the phone booth. As it rang again and again, you pretended the water dripping down your cheeks was only from the rain you’d run through. You eyed your car on the side of the road dipping slightly to the side from its popped tire. The sun had started its descent now in the late afternoon, and the streets filled with more and more cars as rush hour grew. You were only halfway to Hawkins.
“Hello?”
Your bottom lip began to quiver, trying to focus on the way his sweet voice brought you into a safe hug rather than how it broke your heart.
“Hey, Eddie,” you whispered, not trusting your words quite yet. Though it didn’t matter to hide anything, not when it came to you.
“Hey, hey, what’s wrong?” he asked, worry instantly coating his words like suffocating sap threatening to drown you.
Glancing at your car once more, you swallowed down a hard lump in your throat and ripped the bandaid off. “I, uh, got a flat tire. So I’m stuck here for a little bit – I called a local tire shop and a guy’s going to hopefully get here soon to help.”
You heard rustling from his side of the line followed by keys jingling. “I can come get you, where are you at?” he asked.
With a shallow laugh, you told him, “I’m still an hour and a half out, Eddie. And it’s rush hour. You won’t make it back in time for your show.”
“Doesn’t matter. Where are you?”
You shook your head, more for yourself than him. The zipper of your coat clinked against the glass of the phone booth as you shifted, your fingers tightening against its hem. “I should still be there in time to drive over with you to warm up, okay?”
Your eyes shut at hearing his rough sigh. An aching erupted in your chest as you whispered out, “Sorry.”
“Don’t be sorry,” he told you. “Though, at this point, I have to ask. Were you some criminal in your past life? A murderer?”
“I don’t think so…” You let out an unsure laugh through your nose. “Were you?”
“Must’ve been, because it feels like we’re paying for something – some horrible destiny to make up for our past mistakes,” he said. And though he tried joking, the reality of your distant relationship and its obstacles weighed heavy in the miles between you.
You chewed on the inside of your lip, ignoring the pounding in your ears as you said, “Couldn’t be too horrible if I’m seeing you.”
His cheesy smile practically shone through the phone as he laughed. You imagined him covering his eyes with a hand, his cheeks dusted pink. “You sure know how to melt a guy, sweetheart.”
And rather than hang up, Eddie talked with you about everything and nothing while waiting for the tire guy. You’d long since dried, your cheeks warm rather than wet as you laughed at his story of him, Steve, and Robin getting kicked out of a movie theater for quoting all the lines of The Labyrinth and throwing popcorn at each other.
You used up all of your spare change to keep the call going, Eddie promising to pay you back despite your protests. But as the sky began to turn a darker shade of blue, the rain still dripping outside, a pit ate its way in your stomach when help still hadn’t arrived.
In a lull, you said in a weak voice, “Eddie…”
“Don’t,” he breathed, and you winced. “He has to be there soon. He has to, honey.”
“It’s getting late. I won’t make it in time to drive over with you.” It came out a whisper, your head leaning against the cold glass. With a smile that didn’t reach your eyes, you said, “Think we’re shit out of luck again, Munson.”
“You’re ridiculous, you know that?”
“Yeah…”
Eddie’s words felt as a plea that would break your heart to deny him. “That’s okay. Just meet me at The Hideout.” He paused, before saying, “Please.”
“I will.” And you wanted to say something more, even opened your mouth to tell him how important this was and how hard you’d get your stupid car to work to get you to him. But you were running out of minutes on the call, and with no more change in your pocket, you just said, “Can’t wait to see you. Good luck, Eddie.” You’d make it there, someway, somehow.
“Thanks, sweetheart. Be safe.”
–
When Eddie knew you’d hung up, he pressed the receiver down much too hard. His fingers pressed against his head, twisting around his hair. He’d see you. You’d come. It’d be okay.
But as he laced his shoes, grabbing his guitar and equipment, he couldn’t stop the disappointing possibility of coming back here tonight without you – his spotless apartment that felt much too quiet, too empty now. Maybe he’d make a mess before falling asleep just so it’d feel like you’d left your clothes there.
The slick roads reflected shimmering lights from street lamps. Rain drops flew past the headlights of Eddie’s van, thundering against its metal exterior. He tried drumming his fingers to the beat of whatever song played in the background, not that he really focused on it, but his tapping fell off rhythm, joining the cacophony outside.
Even when he pulled up to the back of The Hideout, his mind felt as foggy as his clouded windshield. He barely caught Gareth’s slight frown as Eddie just nodded to him, bringing his equipment inside without a word. It wasn’t until he’d readied everything and snuck a glance out into the crowd did his body start to come back online. You weren’t there. Checking his watch, he saw there were only ten minutes before they’d call the band out.
He bounced back and forth on his feet, shaking his hands out as if it could toss away his stabbing nerves… or maybe it felt like a sharp pain carved out by your absence. Eventually, Jeff came by, clapping a hand on Eddie’s shoulder.
“You ready, man?” he asked, adjusting his guitar strap as he did so.
Eddie nodded hard, sending his hair flying. Perhaps if he faked it hard enough, it’d somehow come true. “Yeah,” he breathed out, “We got this.” But he couldn’t find it in himself to say anything more. He checked his watch again, and a few more times. His head peeked out to the crowd, looking one more time for you – for those eyes that’d tell him it was all okay. For that smile whispering promises of better days together.
But he didn’t see either, and as Gareth let him know it was time to get into places, Eddie imagined whether you’d make it time for him leaving. That at home, he could strum on his baby for you, give you some sort of concert. Or if you were still stuck there an hour and a half away, he’d drop everything to make it there in 45 minutes – god, he’d really just let you stay there. He shook his head. He should’ve just left to get you, and his hand would be entwined with yours right now, your head leaning on his shoulder.
Even after that, Eddie began to plan other weekends that’d work for him. He’d make any of them work. Fuck work and his shitty coworker. He’d have you. And as Corroded Coffin walked out onto the small stage, a forced smile on his face and too shallow breaths falling from his lips, he took his spot to find you mere feet away – soaked from the rain and out of breath. But you were there.
–
You’d made the drive as fast as you could, but rush hour took mercy on no one. At least Eddie wouldn’t have to know how many times you nearly screamed at the other drivers for getting in your way, because you’d made it in time. Almost forgetting to even lock your car, you sprinted under the rainstorm into The Hideout the second a voice from the speakers announced Corroded Coffin. You squeaked out apologies to people you pushed past to get closer to the creaking stage.
The heat of the people around you made your damp clothes stick to your skin, the beads of raindrops plopping down around you. But you couldn’t find yourself caring too much when Eddie walked out, clothed in his leather jacket and red flannel tied around his waist. His wild hair spilled around his face in a halo, framing his eyes that immediately found yours. Eyes shining a warm brown in the stage lights, softening as you gave him a small wave, unable to dampen your growing smile.
He mouthed back “Hi” with the widest, toothiest grin you’d ever seen. And if you thought your hammering heartbeat couldn’t grow stronger, you were almost thankful to be wrong once they began playing.
You weren’t sure what to focus on – his hands as they effortlessly floated across his guitar, his veins visible as his fingers flexed. Maybe his legs. Eddie never seemed to stop moving, his thighs tight under his black jeans. You tried his eyes for a bit, but they rarely left your face, and you could only take his intense gaze for so long. So more often than you’d admit, it landed back at his mouth moving along to the words, though it often quirked up into a smirk at your constant staring.
But how could you not stare? You’d made it, and here he was. You swore your smile never left your face through the whole performance, not that you remembered much of it. It passed in a blur, your body only calming when the last note drifted into silence, a promise of Eddie coming out in a few minutes settling into your relaxing shoulders and deeper breaths.
Shuffling through the crowd, you planned to grab a drink when you heard the unmistakable sound of Eddie’s voice saying your name. You felt his hand brush up your arm before you saw him, his fingers wrapping around you and pulling you to him in a crushing hug. Your face pressed against him as a breath rushed from your lungs, shutting your eyes as you let reality sink in.
“Sorry, I’m sweaty,” he said, his voice next to your ear. Eddie tried pulling away, but you held him even tighter.
“Don’t care,” you whispered to him, feeling him smile against you.
You eventually let him pull back, and you couldn’t say you missed hugging him – not when you took in the hopeless look on his face, one that probably matched yours. “Wanna get outta here?” he asked, thumb rubbing back and forth along your arm.
“Shouldn’t I meet your bandmates or something? Are you sure you want to leave?” You furrowed your eyebrows, not wanting to make him leave if he enjoyed myself.
But that made him laugh. “You can meet them at a different show. We’re on limited time, sweetheart,” he said, entwining his fingers in yours and leading you through the crowd and outside. Thankfully, the rain had softened into a light drizzle.
He walked with you toward his van around back, which made you pause. “Oh, I parked over there.” You pointed to the other side of the lot.
But Eddie swung your hands forward and back, squeezing just a bit harder as he asked, “Would it sound too desperate if I said I’d rather just drive together? We could come get your car tomorrow.”
Your grin must’ve looked teasing because his face dropped, his mouth opening as if to say something to explain himself. But you couldn’t stop the fluttering in your stomach or the giddiness threatening to fall from your lips at his sweet words. “If the owner’s okay with it, then yeah. I’d love to, Eddie. But I have to get my things from my car.” You squeezed his hand back as he nodded before continuing, “I could meet you back at your van if you need to still pack up your things.”
“That’s alright. I’ll come with you,” he said, letting you bring him to your car. Though it was only a minute there and a minute back, you were glad he came along – even if to just ask you how the drive had been and take your constant compliments on how well he played. And that look reappeared like it’d always been there, the one that made it hard to think and look away from his gaze.
Eddie of course offered to carry your bag back, but you offered him the cookies you made instead. As he opened them up, you rambled. “Hope you like them. They’re chocolate chip. But if you don’t, blame my terrible dorm kitchen.” And you began to say, “We can make some together if they didn’t turn out–”
“Holy shit, are you Martha Stewart?” he said, disbelieving laughs coming out in between bites. “I can’t bake for shit, but I’d learn if you gave me this recipe. Here, have one.”
He held out a cookie in front of your mouth as you two walked, making you try to grab a bite while moving. But it was worth it because he wasn’t wrong. Your family recipe never did disappoint.
The cookies ended up in the front seat as Eddie loaded your bag into the back. He climbed in next to you, casting glances your way the entire time he drove the two of you back to his place. “You had dinner yet?” he asked.
“Besides one bite of a cookie, no. Didn’t get the chance – I was running late somewhere. Can’t remember where though,” you teased, nudging his elbow with yours.
He gave a soft smile, saying, “I hope it was worth it, whatever it was.”
“Oh it was.” Though your head leaned toward the window, eyes watching cars and buildings pass by in streams behind the rain, you rested your hand in your lap, his laying right on top. Never far.
“Okay, well even though I’m sweaty and you got soaked by rain – and it’s pretty late – we could go out to eat somewhere. I mean, I’d like to take you out somewhere. If you want… you did have a long drive and–”
“Yes,” you told him, stopping his adorable rambling and pretending you didn’t see the blush on his cheeks. “I want to go on a date with you.”
He nodded, making a turn into a parking lot as he said, “Yeah? Yeah, good.” And you could’ve sworn that under the soft storm, tires rumbling, and quiet music coming from the radio, you heard him say a celebratory “Sweet” under his breath.
Looking up, you saw the neon signs lighting up the windows of a diner that boasted its late hours, all of it making your stomach growl. Your smile at the promise of food wavered a bit at seeing Eddie’s unsure look, but you’d have no more of it. You nodded toward the door, telling him, “C’mon casanova. Swoon me on this date.”
–
And swoon you he tried. Eddie forgot to get your door, but he held the diner door open for you. His feet shuffled under him in quick steps as he tried to make it to the table before you, planning to pull out your chair… but you chose a booth. Not that a booth was bad – it was the best seating option available he thought, but you were making him think harder about ways to impress you. Not that it’d work because he always found thinking to be the worst task around you.
He could barely concentrate on the menu that had too many pages, so he just decided to get a burger and fries. Instead, he watched your eyes flit through, your lips moving to the words of the Queen song playing above as your finger traced across the menu items. And an image of you and him dancing to a song in his tiny kitchen from his beat up radio had him breathless for a few moments.
But all he could bring himself to say to you was, “So, how’s college been?”
Your eyes flicked up to his over the top of the menu, some sort of look on your face that he couldn’t quite decipher. You let out a long sigh though, bringing your gaze back down. “Sometimes, I really wonder whether this degree is worth it, you know?”
“It’s gotta be worth something, right?” he said, leaning forward on his elbows. “I mean, yeah it sounds like absolute torture, but I know you’re smart.”
You folded up your menu and set it down, making a flurry of emotion hit his chest. Your head cocked to the side as you said, “I thought you were too cool for school, Munson.”
“I am.” He pointed a finger at himself. “But you’re not. You’re too smart to give up on this. And that way, you can be the breadwinner, and I’ll get to be a gold digger.”
Eddie relished in the way you fought the giggles rising up as you shook your head at him. “I don’t have any money yet, Eddie.”
And he loved the way you began leaning toward him too. “Oh, but I’m playing the long con. In a decade, you’ll be making so much dough that I won’t have to do another goddamn oil change again.”
“Except for my car, of course,” you said, looking at him all sweetly like he’d ever deny you.
He nodded along. “Except for your car,” he said, “And mine, which I’m sure you’ll buy for me with your fancy job.”
“Oh, is that how it’s going to be?” Your smile had his own itching higher and higher. “Well, then I’m sure I’ll have to get you something your style. Volkswagen Beetle? Maybe a suped-up van to replace yours, get a nice airbrush design on the side.”
You raised your hand up to spell out the words. “‘Eddie Munson: Dungeon Master Extraordinaire’ in red and black, maybe Dustin will even get a place on it.”
He’d long since rested his head on his fist, trying his hardest to give you an unamused look. “Are you having fun there, sweetheart?”
You just nodded, a smug smile on your face, as the waitress came by to take your orders. Unable to resist giving you some sort of stereotypical date activity, he also ordered a sweet drink to share between the two of you. He would’ve dragged you to the photo booth too if he wasn’t looking so worn.
And though you’d come all this way, just for him, and were sitting in wet clothes – despite him offering his jacket and flannel – Eddie couldn’t help the doubting thoughts fighting through his mind. You’d calmed him from his panicky state before, but it wasn’t until a lull passed between you two, his eyes unfocusing as he thought, that you reached across the table to hold his hand.
“You know you have me, right?” you asked, and he saw the openness in your eyes. The sincerity you tried wrapping your words in so they’d reach his ears.
Still, he leaned back. “What?”
You gave him that soft smile, ever so patient with him. “You’ve already got me, Eddie. Get out of that head of yours,” you said, tapping a finger softly against his temple.
“Yeah?” he breathed out, catching your hand and bringing it to his lips.
“Yeah. I don’t let just anyone be a future gold-digger of mine. You’re lucky.”
The laughs he let out brushed along your knuckles before he kissed them. He couldn’t say his thanks to you out loud, not just yet, but he knew you understood he was grateful.
So through the meal and giggly drinking through two straws together, and even the drive home, Eddie held onto you tighter. Not because he still thought you’d suddenly change your mind and leave, but because he wanted to memorize the lines of your palm, the way your breaths moved your ribcage up and down, how quick goosebumps erupted along your skin after he touched you.
He wanted to know everything about you. And he planned to after cleaning up and changing. He let you go first – trying not to continue tidying up, though it kept his mind busy from wishing a bit too much that he was in there with you, even if it meant just washing your hair or face.
You came out in your pajamas, and Eddie had to keep his eyes from staring too much. Though he did say, “Like the Snoopy pjs,” as he gathered his own clothes. He meant it, but he mostly said it to watch you fluster under his attention. Before going into the bathroom, he said, “If you wanted to set up a movie, I’ve got some tapes next to the TV. And popcorn in the kitchen or other snacks and drinks if you’d like. Help yourself to anything.” And he shut the door, breathing in the steam leftover from you.
–
After stuffing your old clothes in your bag, you couldn’t help looking around. You did check out his movie collection, palming through it until you pulled out The Princess Bride. Setting the tape on the table to ask Eddie whether he’d want to watch that one, you strolled toward his music collection – a wide selection of records from Ozzy and Slayer to Black Sabbath and Iron Maiden. Maybe, one day, when the two of you had unlimited time together, you could spend the day listening to all of his music as it floated through his apartment.
Your hand brushed along the back of the couch as you walked down the hall to his room, bringing your bag with. A smile overtook your face as you saw how neat it looked. You’d already shared a room with him, you knew he wasn’t this neat. But the effort he put into making his bed and… did he dust too? You ran a finger across the various posters littering the walls, neck craning to look at them all.
“Just because you’re wearing Snoopy pj’s doesn’t mean you get to snoop, sweetheart.” Eddie’s voice came from the doorway behind you, making you jump and slap a hand over your mouth.
Turning toward him, you gently smacked his shoulder. “You have to stop scaring the shit out of me, I swear…” you told him, shaking your head but giving a begrudging smile. He was dressed in his flannel pajamas and black shirt as he had at the cabin, making you avoid his gaze or he’d catch your ogling. Not that you’d been hiding it much tonight.
“I’m sleeping in here, anyway. Thought I’d get a look around.” You hoped the joking would mask the pounding in your heart.
“Oh?” he asked, eyebrows raised and hands on his hips. “You think you just get to sleep in my bed? I haven’t even offered it to you yet.” The smirk hiding behind his teasing made your chest flutter for just an instant.
You inched toward him, eyes never leaving him. If he wasn’t going to let your heartbeat slow, maybe you could raise his. “Even though I baked you cookies?” you asked, voice softer now.
And it made him waver, words hesitating for a moment before he answered. “Even though you made me cookies. I mean, you can’t just expect…”
“Yes?” you asked from inches away now – eyes wide, head tilted to the side expectantly.
His eyes flitted between yours and your lips. “Stop that,” he whispered, all teasing gone now. He reached a finger to wrap around one of yours hanging by your side.
“Stop what?”
Finally, Eddie surged forward, capturing your mouth with his. A surprised noise came from the back of your throat before you relaxed into him, bringing your free hand to curl around his jaw. He pulled you in closer, closer, closer. You thought he wouldn’t stop until you two had somehow merged into one, the imprint of his fingers on your ribs.
But he pulled back, giving you both a chance to catch your breaths. He leaned his forehead against yours, whispering, “Been waiting for too long to do that.”
You just laughed against his mouth before kissing him again. The dripping of the leaky shower head or the feeling of the carpet below your feet, even your own goddamn name, all disappeared out of your awareness – Eddie’s mouth moving against yours the only thing keeping you grounded to reality.
Your hands braced against his chest as you leaned back just a bit, wanting to look into his dark eyes. “Hey, Eddie?”
“Yeah?” he said, voice soft as he refused to look away from you.
Breathing in, you told him, “I picked out Princess Bride to watch, that okay?”
And he let out a groan as he pulled you against him again into a tight hug. “I wonder if the whole world knows I’m the luckiest man to exist. Should I go tell them? I should tell them,” he said, dragging you along as he went to the living room and toward the window.
But you pulled him back, giggles erupting. “You are not going to scream out your window, you lunatic.”
Even his fake gasp at your insult didn’t stop him as he tried to open it with his one free hand. You pleaded with him. “I’ll make the popcorn if you keep that window closed.”
That made him stop, his body turning to give you a side eye as he considered it. “Okay… I think we have a deal. But I’m letting every person I talk to know about you, there’s no stopping me.”
“Fine,” you sighed, just happy to appease him for the moment. Though he didn’t even let you make the popcorn, just made you get the couch all comfortable while he made it – as a thanks for your ‘god-like taste in movies’ as he’d put it. Though you took it as a thanks for everything else this night too.
As he settled into the cushions next to you, the warmth of the freshly popped kernels washing onto you, you leaned into him under a blanket. The first moments of the movie came to life, the grandson’s coughing and his video game illuminating the room. Eddie couldn’t help quoting most of the lines from it, his impressions making you quietly laugh. And just like that, your whole body felt safe, your heart full in the way only he could make it.
–
Eddie lived for making you laugh, the sound practically music to his ears. So when he stopped feeling your shoulders shake after he made another dumb joke, he looked over at you. Your breathing had evened out, your eyes shut as you laid your head against his chest, his arm slung around your waist.
While he’d let out a long sigh when you missed out on the final scenes of the movie, Eddie couldn’t say he was all that disappointed. Waking you up to go to his room meant falling asleep next to you, something he’d often dreamt about these past months. Except, through the end credits rolling across his grainy TV, his own eyes grew heavier. And with your soft heartbeat pounding against his body, he didn’t stand a chance at sinking into sleep along with you.
His dreams as he drifted in and out felt like floating, swimming through the ocean or resting on a cloud surrounding him on all sides. He only slipped from it from your finger brushing his hair out of his face.
In a voice that sounded as sleepy as his mind felt, you said, “C’mon, we gotta go to bed.” Eddie let out a soft groan, rubbing his eyes before blinking open to find you with an arm thrown over your eyes, leaning against the back of the couch.
“Okay,” he mumbled, “let’s go.”
You nodded but didn’t move, making him give a weak laugh.
“What? Don’t want to cuddle anymore?” he asked, pressing his hands on his thighs before standing up.
And that got you up, even with hesitant movements as you lumbered into Eddie’s arms, shuffling to his room together. “I’m going to cuddle you so hard,” you grumbled, your eyes barely open.
“I’m sure you will, honey,” he told you, shaking his head through a soft laugh. He pulled back the covers on his bed, collapsing onto the mattress with you in his arms. Your head nuzzled into his chest before you let out a long breath that wavered through the air.
In a voice rid of any sleep, you muttered, “I had a nightmare.” Your fingers twisted into his shirt as your breaths began to shake.
His heart staggered for a moment as he opened his eyes, trying to find yours in the dark. But he couldn’t see you. He held you tighter against him as he asked, “Do you wanna talk about it?”
“I…” you started, your voice watery. It made his own throat tighten up. After a few moments that ate away at his insides, you spoke. “I lost you.”
Eddie could feel your lips tighten, as if holding back tears. He didn’t ask you any more questions. Bringing his hand up, he rubbed a thumb across your brow bone. “I’m right here, sweetheart. You didn’t lose me.”
Your body curled against him, pressing into him even closer still. But his arm wrapping around your back could feel you holding your breath. “Hey, hey. Breathe in and out with me, okay?”
He exaggerated the rising and lowering of his chest as he felt you copying him, your pounding heart beginning to slow just a bit. Eddie’s mouth dropped to kiss the top of your head, whispering against you, “That’s good, just like that.” Once you seemed to calm, he spoke again. “I hope you know that it’s pretty damn hard to lose me. You’re not getting rid of me that easy.”
The exhale of your soft laugh brushed along his arm. Your quiet sniffle filled the room, and he maneuvered to turn on the bedside lamp. He passed you the tissue box, which you took gratefully.
“Sorry, Eddie. Didn’t mean to keep you up,” you said, your eyes cast downward.
“Don’t worry about it. I mean it, or I will actually scream out the window this time,” he joked, pursing his lips as he thought. “How about I read something… out loud. Would that be good?”
His eyes caught your hesitance, like you were about to tell him that you didn’t need someone to read you a bedtime story. Which he knew, but everyone deserved to be cared for. So he held his hands up, saying, “No scary books, I promise. How about a little Lord of the Rings? Just the beginning.”
And that smile that grew across your face made it all worth it. He picked Fellowship of the Ring off his shelf, propping up his pillow so he could read and have you resting on his chest at the same time.
With a clean tissue crumpled into your hand, you wrapped yourself around Eddie as he opened up to the first page. He started telling the story in a quiet voice, but in the same way he narrated his D&D campaign, making you give a soft giggle.
“When Mr. Bilbo Baggins of Bag End announced that he would shortly be celebrating his eleventy-first birthday with a party of…” Eddie began, working his way through the first chapter. It was only once your eyes began drooping, your head growing heavier on him, that he strayed from the words on the page.
He skipped any talk of an evil power rising. Instead, he made up more tales of Frodo and his friends, of the eccentricities of wizards – happy, calm things you were too tired to notice weren’t from the words on the page. Once he was sure you’d drifted off, Eddie carefully shut the book, setting it on his nightstand. His eyes danced over you one more time, trying to sear it on his mind, before he reached over and shut the lamp off.
And he refused to leave you throughout the night, always an arm or leg touching yours. So that you knew you wouldn’t lose him. Not here, or ever.
–
You paid Eddie your thanks for that night all through the weekend, not that he would willingly accept it. But when you awoke the next morning, your face pressed against his back and arm around his waist, you knew he was the reason you felt so at peace – at home.
After laying there and listening to birds twittering outside the window, and sure that it was late enough in the morning for Eddie, you slipped from the bed. Grabbing his flannel from last night, you slipped it on and rummaged through his kitchen to cook up pancakes as quietly as possible. You brought them back into the room alongside syrup and a cup of orange juice (making sure to check the expiration dates first, knowing how Eddie was sometimes).
Your entrance didn’t seem to stir him, so you set the food on his nightstand, running a finger up his arm to tuck a stray strand of hair behind his ear. He seemed to lean into the touch of your hand, his eyes twitching before they peeled open. You watched the way his lips stretched into a smile as he saw you, his hand coming up to hold yours.
“Good morning,” he rumbled, and you couldn’t say you hated his morning voice. Not one bit.
“Good morning,” you whispered, picking up the plate. “Made you some breakfast, Eds.”
He’d begun to sit up but paused at your words, gaze switching between you and the food you held out for him. And you’d never seen the phrase “lovesick” so apparent as you did on his face, his whole body softening as he took the plate to rest on his lap. “Are you an angel or something? Did I sell my soul for this?” he asked before digging in and taking a large sip from the orange juice.
Sitting down on the bed, you let out a laugh. “You’re deserving of this, you know,” you whispered, eyes elsewhere since you couldn’t stand to look at him in your vulnerability.
But you didn’t have to. Eddie just took your hand and kissed the back of it. Then kissed you, putting all of his emotion into it before leaving you breathless.
“Thank you,” he said. He didn’t need to specify what for, you both knew.
That was how the weekend went – you and Eddie just understanding each other, moving together and leaving things unsaid but not unknown. In the spaces of these walls, you relaxed into him as no one else had allowed you to. He settled into a way of living that surprised both of you, one that ripped down any walls or performance he’d ever put up.
Outside of his apartment, he’d taken you around Hawkins, only visiting your friends for one dinner before returning back together. They’d given knowing looks when you two came in holding hands, and you both took the teasing. It all felt like how things had been, how they were meant to be.
And you knew he’d felt bad keeping you all to himself, but selfishly, you’d wanted the same. To take every minute he had so he could spend it with you intertwined.
You refused to let yourself think of Sunday, of having to pack your things. Because you’d be back, or he’d come to you. For now, you were together. Nothing really mattered past that for the moment.
While the two of you lazed together on the couch, sharing life stories back and forth and creating a story that belonged to both of you, he pulled you against his chest. You dropped your fingers down to play with his, drawing shapes and words across his skin like scripture. After moments of silence that never felt uncomfortable, you angled your head to look up into his eyes, swallowing down a breath. “You know… I almost didn’t stay back when all the others left on that beer run,” you whispered against him, reminiscing about the cabin trip.
He hummed, the vibrations from his neck moving against you. “I know.”
“But, Steve had told me to get to know you, so we weren’t strangers,” you told him, shutting your eyes. “I’m really glad you’re not a stranger anymore, Eddie.”
As the sun reached past its peak outside and the world ran on without the two of you, the corners of Eddie’s mouth rose. The way his head came down to rest on yours told you everything you needed to know about his thoughts, the weight of it filling your heart. His thumb rubbed along the skin of your waist, hand coming up to hold your body against his. To press into you like your curves fit into the dips of him – as they always would, wherever he was.
“Me too, sweetheart.”
–
Thank Christ for Harrington.
--
@tea-with-cream-and-suga
A/n: Thank you for reading, love you all <3
339 notes
·
View notes