Okay I have thoughts I wish to impart, praying (ha pun) this makes sense! Disclaimer that I was raised Protestant— Southern Baptist specifically— but no longer associate with Christianity as a whole so take this fairly loosely
“It isn’t the actions that condemn you, it’s the faith itself” WHOO BOY DO I GOT THINGS TO SAY ON THIS ONE. Bear with me here.
So Lincoln, as a character, believes himself to be already condemned. Fundamentally wrong. Sal says it in the end: “some men are just wired up wrong.” And Lincoln agrees. He believes himself to be one too. Not merely a sinner, but a condemned.
That is for many reasons.
He was born a bastard, with no father in the picture and a mother who couldn’t love him. Not that she didn’t, but that she couldn’t. In talking and working with a lot of foster kids in my neighborhood, there’s a common sentiment of believing themselves to be the reason why their parents/caregivers don’t or can’t love them. Not only born condemned, but born to bring that condemnation to others.
He’s done atrocious things, objectively speaking, including participating in the genocide of both Laotian and Vietnamese civilians. He’s killed a lot of people, some that likely didn’t deserve it. Every goddamn thing he’s done, he’s told FJ. And Father James loved him anyway. Until he himself is confronted with it.
He doesn’t feel like he belongs. This is heavily dependent on the context of the times, but religion was one of the few places that was meant to feel like he had a place. And even then, he wasn’t exactly a perfect altar-boy. FJ says he was “a good boy, a quiet boy”, a boy who didn’t want much and was happy with others. How true that is, however, is dubious as Father James had a tendency to view Lincoln as either the “good boy” or “bad man”. No one quite sees him as fully human. Military, home front, mob. Either good or bad.
Christianity, in my experience, does little to reconcile good and bad. They must always be separate. Sin. Therefore, Lincoln is bad. Tainted good is no longer good. (Note: confessions might change things here, I’m not 100% sure, so apologies on that front in advance. Again, not Catholic and was not raised around any.)
Your point of “not all good nor bad but all-seeing all the same” is probably the most solid belief Lincoln would hold. Yes, he’s Catholic, but he’s Catholic because his community is. On the whole, he’s deeply community-oriented, which serves to bite him in the ass when his “community” doesn’t acknowledge his humanity. He’s either a folk hero or a domestic terrorist. Good boy or bad man. He’s justified in the same way an angel is justified in wrestling a human, he’s just as a figure and not as a human.
He was condemned by believing things could be better. He was condemned for trying.
Tying Protestantism to white supremacy and extremism is very topical! Here in the US, at least. The main difference, to me, is that in the 60s, there was a counterpoint to Protestant fascism with Black churches leading several Black movements, such as the civil rights movement and Double V of World War II (FJ’s war)— frankly, it stretches back centuries. Nowadays, there’s less of a divide, so to speak. Remy is a symbol of KKK-twats of the 60s just as much as he is a direct parallel to the podcast bros (he literally has a fucking radio show called Native Son, which is the name of a book by Richard Wright— the plot is about a Black man in Chicago killing a white woman and what happens afterwards) and, more pointedly, white evangelicals that make up most of the alt-right movement in the United States. A key element to remember is that Mafia 3 was made during the height of Gamergate, which (this is VERY simplified) the alt-right radicalization of white teenage gamers online. It was a commentary on the 60s and the 2010s. And judging by the comments you can find on YouTube, the game was right! I’ll say it like that.
Honestly, I’m at least sort of happy they didn’t outright demonize Hoodoo and Voodou (please forgive any spellings), and got some aspects right, such as Hoodoo being the practice and Voodou being the religion. But, the way the game treated Haitians overall was frankly pretty gross, and that’s something that needs to be acknowledged at some point.
War and religion— might not know a whole lot on it, but I’m definitely deeply interested!
Agreed, I felt that there could’ve been more with FJ and Lincoln. We didn’t even get much with John and Lincoln outside of snippets and a very… debatable DLC, and Sign of the Times was supposed to have some, but it still fell flat. On that note, I did appreciate that they at least tried to show a cult. I have my own opinions on how Anna was handled, but the intent was there.
TLDR, I wish Mafia 3 played a tiny bit more with things, but I’m content enough with what we did get.
Also, short aside, I know Lincoln was directly based on the Punisher, but I’d argue he’s got some Daredevil influence in there. He might not have (traditional) Catholic guilt, but he sure as hell as Catholic condemnation! Also insert commentary here on how he was loosely based on Malcolm X.
the one thing you can't expect from me is good depictions of religious faith in my writing. yeah. they it's integral to the perception of m2 and m1 (one could argue they're essential to m3 but that's just meeee) however I don't have that catholic swag. And I like to think esp m2 is to turn it's back on humanity which isn't reflected in Catholicism per say, but I like the motif of betrayal by man to environment.
16 notes
·
View notes