Tumgik
#this scene is such whiplash he's literally like Wow actually I love my mom so much she's the only one who's actually supporting me
me: -writing Touya being mean to Rei-
Also me:
Tumblr media
61 notes · View notes
saintobio · 3 years
Note
I- ….I mean…
Tumblr media
This how I be feeling after that chapter.
You are such an amazing writer I have to say. Like are you a magician?? The way you have my emotions flip flopping, hate emerging, then sadness, then happiness, then anger, then SADNESS. I’m about to get whiplash I swear.
Like damn I really want to hate Hoejo so bad. But that little whimpering, abandonment issues hoejo has me soft like WTF. 😭 then we she was like I won’t leave anyway… like I bet that tugged his heartstrings. Still. I’m more sad for y/n. Her suffering was so palpable this chapter. The loneliness. Feeling despondent. Ugh it gutted me. I’m glad we got a shimmer of happiness with Toji. Just like her I’ll take whatever crumbs I can get 🥺😭😭😭
Anonymous said
Okay first off I love how y/n finally stood up for herself that's amazing for her 🥺 but gojo can literally suck my ass 🖕but then I felt bad with the mom thing and then I remembered how he was thinking about fucking y/n while he was with sera so I got over it😌 and then the whole "you make it hard for me to hate you" bitch 😡😡 you make it hard for me to not want to claw out your motherfucking eye balls like bitch🤨 do you want to fight me. An when he had the audacity to be all clingy😑 just like Hayley Williams said " once a whore you're nothing more" . If he wants to make me happy he better eat her out till she's fucking crying 😫 and not because she's sad for once -🐚anon
Tumblr media
Anonymous said
GOD CHAPTER 6 WAS SO GOOD. I LOVED COLD Y/N LIKE THE POOL SCENE WAS IMMACULATE. I LOVED IT SO MUCH SEEING GOJO KINDA ANGY THAT SHE WAS BEING THIS WAY! 😭 I love your writing sm 😞 it’s so good like I feel pain but it also makes me so happy yknow? :) THANK YOU FOR WRITING SUCH A GOOD SERIES IM SO EXCITED ( but also scared ) FOR WHAT YOU HAVE FOR US NEXT! 💕:)
Tumblr media
Anonymous said
Wow, chp 6 had so much yet so little happen! I can feel the foreboding brewing up! That being said, that convo between (No name) and Hoejo (what a manipulative switching ass he is) has only shown they’re not making it to the end, only to be each other’s downfall. Like Gojo said he could’ve cover her expenses if needed and completely defying his father (what a bad move 🥴) she still kept that from him, who knows what else she’s hiding and willing to do behind his back. The same for Gojo still being with Y/N (like dude, that’s your wife 🤨) acting as if he’s gonna be put to death if he doesn’t engage in normal marriage things… this chapter also has given me some faith in y/n’s path, while mistakes are gonna happen, she’s starting to set boundaries with Hoejo (which’s she shouldn’t at all), getting pieces of the puzzle together and learning a lot about herself. She just need better allies and more confidence in herself, that’ll scare the unholy, unwanted duo no one asked for. I feel Gojo will see she’s more than meets the eye and actually fall for her, only to realize it’s a little too late…. Good job babe! And take of yourself 🥺🤩🥰
Tumblr media
Anonymous said
"i shouldn't have yelled at you and i shouldn't have blamed her." *GASP* IS THAT ACCOUNTABILITY I SEE? good job sera, you're learning 😊 but i will admit if i was sera i'd feel a lil hurt. still, she needs to understand mc's situation. like others have said before she and gojo are still very selfish.
"why did you hide hat my dad gave you ten million yen?" oop 🙊 we finally learned the truth. i felt like it wasn't for bad reason.
also i'm glad mc is being more defiant and cold with gojo. but she's still too nice 😭 i can't lie tho, i'm kinda like mc in that aspect. i just find it hard to be mean even if i'm treated like shit. so i understand mc on that level. also the moments with toji are so sweet 🥲 gojo's not gonna like this at all, i feel like he's gonna throw a fit 🤔
did gojo have a crush on mc when they were kids? at first i wanted gojo to find out mc is on birth control out of spite but now i'm like "fuck he's gonna be so mad 😭" i actually feel bad for taking it but he needs to be less of a bitch. i feel like he'll think reader is taking it so she could have sex with him and not because she wants him to be more genuine and loving.
Tumblr media
Anonymous said
That scene with Gojo and Sera together made me sick 🤢. It was traumatizing. They look so good together that they should rot in hell.
Y/n is too kind and understanding 💗 Ms.Mam should just leave Gojo's sick ass. I am so proud of her when she started distancing herself from Gojo cuz YES! THAT'S RIGHT! IGNORE THAT MF. Whatever Gojo's playing is going to bite him in the ass hard someday.
Thankyouuuu for today's update 💗 Take care, aiii ❤️ Just don't push yourself too much😽.
(u don't have to respond cuz we understand 💗)
Tumblr media
Anonymous said
nah cause what the PHAWK 😃 all gojo has is the mf audacity!!!! my resentment towards him is starting to grow more and more oh my lord 🥲
i’m glad mc is starting to get a grip but holy crap why does gojo feel like it’s necessary to make things SO hard for her 😐. like i get it mc may be the antagonist in his story but if he just took five, LITERALLY FIVE MINUTES of his day he would know better but no 🙃.
obviously everyone has some sort of fault in this but JEEZ gojo AND SERA wanna be the victims so bad. it dead ass feels like the two of them are trying to make a competition on who’s situation is more tragic. like newsflash buddy, the world doesn’t revolve around you ‼️
i think the only thing that made this chapter feel less angsty is definitely mc and toji interactions and i really hope there’s more bc now toji really is mc’s only escape from the hell she’s going through. although i don’t believe toji and mc will be endgame i still like to think about it here and there bc i love imagining how PISSED gojo would be 😌
anyway sorry for this long bit, I HOPE YOU’RE DOING WELL <3333
Tumblr media
Anonymous said
so well written as always
ngl sometimes I don't insert myself as yn just cause obviously a random author isnt going to write them like my personality. like up until now I've had zero patience for gojo and his antics. like if u wanna be w her then go tf lemme be happy w whoever ugh. but this chapter YUP YUP YUP YN WAS THAT B. IT WAS GIVING ROMAN'S REVENGE NEVER LET EM PLAY U GIRL.
but yessss i like where this is going bestie ahhhh
Tumblr media
Anonymous said
Why am I so like Y/N?!? All of my anger and hatred towards gojo suddenly disappears because of the microscopic crumbs of affection we get from him.🤡😖
Anyway hope you are having a great day! I'm soooo excited for the next chapter
-🍣( It's me againnn!!(≧∇≦)/, I'm not sure if you did get my ask last time but yeah I'm still shy and you don't have to reply to this ask hahshs)
Tumblr media
Anonymous said
Lowkey wanna see y/n lose it lose it. Like next time Gojo says some shit like “know your place” I lowkey want her to be like “bitch you know your place. I could legit ruin your life in a second by telling both our family’s about the affair. I AM IN CONTROL” i know she won’t cause she’s so nice and sweet but just imagine the satisfaction from seeing Gojo’s face
Tumblr media
publishing the messages for everyone to see !! i’m sorry i no longer have the mental capacity to provide lengthy answers gahah ai’s brain is tired :(( but thank you sm for sending these through !! AND YES i do love seeing y/n finally standing up to satoru, but ofc she will do it based on her personality. she’s not gonna do a 180 and suddenly be a baddie :D she does it y/n way and honestly i think that’ll hurt satoru more
41 notes · View notes
battlestar-royco · 3 years
Text
IT'S BEEN 84 YEARS. LET'S TALK ABOUT NETFLIX'S SHADOW AND BONE.
8.7/10 ⭐️
spoilers for everythingggg under the cut! i'll be discussing its merits as an adaptation vs as a show, characters and plots, and the overall aesthetic and magic/world.
SHOW VS ADAPTATION:
i say this as someone who knows all the books very well and has been in the fandom for nearly a decade, so i'm biased. but. s&b functions better as an adaptation than as a standalone show. alina's plot moves so well, and satisfyingly renders so many iconic scenes and sites from s&b. the worldbuilding is also pretty easy to fall into, with a forgivable amount of voiceover/infodump. and, hurting budget aside, i mostly liked this visual interpretation of the gv.
(sidebar: the in-universe racism... doesn't work. i tried to view it in good faith but imo it was very heavy-handed. if it was framed like, "wow it's a SHU WOMAN saving the world!!!" it might've been better, but it's just racism without recompense. and it's a terrible look to make other characters of color racist. i just. why?)
as for the crows, however... i'm just not sure how strong they'll be for new viewers? i totally understand why they were included, and i really like certain connections the show made between the two series. it was a great decision to introduce the druskelle in the first Cut scene, and showing nina as a ravkan spy.
the new crows stuff felt in character, but i think the show is at its height when it sticks to the books. the first couple episodes switching between tgt and proto-soc gave me whiplash, but luckily it got more organic as it progressed. if i didn't know and love all the crows before going in, i wouldn't be that invested in them based on season 1. aside from a couple fantastic scenes, it really felt like the writers were trying to make fetch happen for like 4 episodes before they figured out what to do with everyone. plus, ravka is such a different vibe from ketterdam--tonally, sartorially, technologically, etc they didn't totally feel like the same world. it was pretty jarring. although i prefer the duo to the trio, s&b is alina's story and she is That Bitch who walked so the crows could fly. so i didn't hate their inclusion but the shoehorned content did at times disservice both plots, imo.
CHARACTERS:
way too many, which is yet another consequence of smushing everyone into one season.
MAL/ALINA/DARKLING: first and foremost, and i PROMISE i'm not saying this just to be a hater, but there needed to be less malina. i'll be the first to say that show!mal really has what book!mal wants. the new pre-fold scenes were so good. li and renaux have amazing chemistry, and their laughter over stolen grapes was a highlight. his stag plot was also good. THAT SAID, there were way too many keramzin flashbacks and malina parallels like.. 🤢🤢why do they want us to love mal so much. for what. they only needed the teacup scene but they clearly thought they were doing something with micro-aggressions and that meadow shot they showed like 6 times. knowing mal's original character, and how they scrubbed his show counterpart almost to the point of flawlessness, he's just never going to be my fave even though i do respect what they did with him. also, why were there like 5 fake deaths for this dude? boring.
the darkling was great. ben barnes knows what the fuck he's about, and he funneled manipulation and charisma into every scene. as for the backstory: at first i really wasn't feeling it, but i eventually did warm up to it and i'm so glad they showed it because oh god the cut and the creation of the fold were SO FUCKING ICONIC. also, love love love the baghra development. WE LOVE TO SEE OLD WOMEN/MOMS WHO AREN'T "EVIL"/"CORRUPTED" BY THEIR MAGICAL POWERS!!!!!!! BITCH! it didn't have to be 12 minutes long though.
i honestly don't have much to say on alina. jml was excellent in her role and very true to the book. without her book narration she feels much more consistently written.
TRILOGY CHARACTERS: i really felt the lack of genya and zoya. genya's character and actress are perfectly layered and effective, even though their roles are relatively minor. i'm so looking forward to her razrushost moment, but i wish they'd laid more groundwork for it. (and i hope throw out the wig and just dye her hair next season.) also like. WHY KEEP THE IRRELEVANT MEAN GIRL/DARKLING THIRST PLOT FOR ZOYA??? AFTER ALL THE EFFORT THEY PUT INTO IMPROVING MAL? they sacrificed so much for malina at the expense of other characters. finally, it was interesting how they decided to kill marie. i love the tailor magic flex. but also they clearly just did that to emotionally manipulate us and connect the crows so. hm.
CROWS: speaking of! the crows storyline felt a little like filler. honestly i wish they waited to roll crows into later seasons. i'd prefer little foreshadowings about them, a la the druskelle cameo or the references to nina and matthias. introducing the crows so soon makes the ice court heist feel less special. the recruitment was super tight and pragmatic, so this felt a little fluffy/fanservicey. kaz also comes off as sooooo old again. especially without the vulnerability of his book counterpart, he just seems like a 40-year-old in a 20something body.
i was pleasantly surprised to find jesper my favorite crow. like wow.... second amendment rights for jesper fahey only!! i like all the crows but book!kanej are my faves by a long shot. they felt a bit stiff tbh, like the actors were a little uncomfy with each other and/or their exposition-heavy lines. however, the one scene that felt EXTREMELY kanej to me was when they killed that dude in the church holy fuck oh my god. WE STAN AN ANGSTY BATTLE COUPLE WHO ARE BOTH DEAD INSIDE. highlight for sure.
and i actually kinda loved helnik? i know helnik is controversial for very valid reasons, but i thoughy their dynamic was fantastic and they were among the strongest performers. it was much less overwhelming than the constantly interweaving kaz/inej/jesper imo. they need to fire their location scout though. those green screen mountains and beaches were um. interesting.
aesthetic and magic:
i really hope they get a bigger budget for costumes, cgi, and sets next season! the keftas are serviceable, but they look a little cheap at times. i will also never forgive ANY of the crows' hats. it's mostly just a personal aesthetic thing but god i fucking hate them. the darkling was best dressed, but in general i liked the ravkan look more than the kerch. why were the crows always in the most elaborate getups? why couldn't they just chill in their waistcoats??? they never seemed relaxed in the way alina and co did; the clothes never felt worn or broken in.
favorite sets: the darkling's room, the crow club, all the grisha tents, the matthias/nina ship, the church where inej killed the squaller, outdoor fountain where they told the story of the black heretic. the lighting was almost always right for each scene, and there was so much detail in every one of them.
THE MAGIC WAS SO COOL! my greatest beef is alina's light--it often looked so fake, and it washed out jml. oftentimes it was fluorescent or blue, and it was used as a forcefield or orb. it's supposed to be sunlight bro. what is so hard about that? the darkling's magic looked good, other than the fold. i've always imagined the fold more like a huge black fog rather than a literal wall. so that was a bit game of thronesy, but not terrible.
and can we talk about the amplifiers? amplifiers are my personal favorite gv lore but season 1 barely gets into them. they never mention the bear zoya slew, nor do they establish the unique strength of the stag, sea dragon, and firebird. BUT THE ANTLER COLLAR FUSED INTO ALINA'S SKIN WAS SUPER DARK AND MACABRE AND I KINDA LIKED IT? ALTHOUGH I HAVE TO WONDER HOW TF IS SHE GONNA SLEEP???
if you made it this far, thanks so much! that's all i have for today.
23 notes · View notes
ryttu3k · 3 years
Text
Okay.
I’m gonna do it.
I’m gonna watch the Star Wars Holiday Special.
Tumblr media
And we already have off-brand opening text. This is off to a great start!
Tumblr media
I’m a minute and a half in and the sitcom-style openings have already killed me. Oh Mark you poor fucker.
“Anthony Daniels as C-3PO! Peter Mayhew as Chewbacca! R2-D2 as… R2-D2!”
Fuck the actors playing Chewie’s family apparently, no credits for them!
Tumblr media
And let’s start off with this picture that isn’t even trying to be photorealistic. I mean you could have at least edited in some generic forest to the background or something. Made a model. Anything!
There are several minutes of cozy domesticity. Done completely in Shyriiwook. Kid is playing! Grandpa is grumpy! Mom is cooking! Mom wants Kid to take out the garbage! Its main saving grace is that there’s no laugh track!
Tumblr media
Look out, kid, you’re balancing on a matte painting!!
Why would you have a tiny holographic circus in pseudo-BDSM gear?
Tumblr media
Why wouldn’t you have a tiny holographic circus in pseudo-BDSM gear?
Tumblr media Tumblr media
*covers Lumpy’s eyes*
This legitimately reads like, “Well, we decided to show off our [assorted crew member]’s [generic family member]’s amateur gymnastics and tumbling squad, so let’s put them in brightly coloured body suits and pretend they’re aliens.”
Tumblr media
Well, they’re very brightly coloured, if nothing else!
Lumpy wants to keep playing but Malla wants him to dry the dishes! First the garbage, now this?! Inhumanity!! (Inwookieety?)
Listen I know Star Wars has its own visual identity when it comes to interface tech, so why does this look like it’s out of a parody of itself?
Tumblr media
Mark I’m so fucking sorry. And we know how he feels about this particular low!
Tumblr media
jfc his eyes are so wide it’s like he’s been dipping into Carrie’s stash XD;;
Bless his heart he’s trying his hardest but the script is............. not good.
Losing my shit at Malla trying to talk to a trader with an Imperial soldier in the background.
“Don’t say a word, ma’am, I know just why you’re calling! You’re wondering when that shaggy carpet you ordered will arrive at your home? Let me assure you, madam, it’s on its way! It’s being flown especially for you by a little old woman four planets away. She did it all by herself. In fact you might say she did it -”  Obviously raised eyebrows - “BY HANd. SOLO.”
STIR WHIP STIR WHIP WHIP WHIP STIR
STIR WHIP STIR WHIP WHIP WHIP STIR
STIR WHIP STIR WHIP WHIP WHIP STIR
The cooking scene is straight up ridiculous and is, so far, my favourite scene of the show. It’s completely unhinged on its own, but it’s also bookended before it by a scene with Vader and an Imperial officer being menacing, and goes straight into Han and Chewie trying to evade TIE fighters, and the mood whiplash is impeccable.
Oh noes! An Imperial blockade around the planet! However will Chewie get home for Life Day!
Apparently they have something called a Mind Evaporator. Which sounds... ominous.
“Why all the long hairy faces?”
Oh my god the trader guy brought porn for Itchy. To use with the... the Mind Evaporator. “It’s kind of... hard to explain. It’s kind of... wow. D’you know what I mean? Happy Life Day! ...and I do mean Happy Life Day!”
what the fuck
Is this why he’s called Itchy
What the fuck am I watching XD
I mean the song is very nice but the context... the context...
Man there’s just something... really off about Leia XD;;
Han made it to the planet, but oh noes! Imperials!
My god this is almost cringey. The trader/rebel is trying so hard to be suave and also sell his shit without letting on that he’s a rebel... and is now distracting an Imperial soldier with holographic Jefferson Starship.
Actually this song kinda slaps...
Just another day on a planet occupied by hostile Imperialism! *laugh track*
Tumblr media
Wow, this is the animation? That style... XD
Tumblr media
This thing is meant to be menacing.
Boba Fett to the rescue! ...wait, what?
So, uh, Chewie and the droids are teaming up with Boba Fett to find the cure to an infected talisman that only affects humans and forces a sleeping sickness on them, meaning they have to be tied up upside down to keep the blood rushing to their head. I repeat, wait, what?
Oh okay he’s working for Vader and trying to earn their trust. That works much better XD
At this point Lumpy yells in dismay over the cartoon he’s apparently watching about his actual real-ass dad and the Imperial comes over to investigate! Oh noes!
No it’s okay he pulls up some random game and the guy is like ‘oh okay you just suck at games’ and wanders off again. Back to Lumpy watching a cartoon about his actual real-ass dad because that’s something that just happens in this universe apparently.
Threepio casually reveals Fett’s plans and Fett is just like, “Welp, foiled again!” and jets off and like... that’s it. No problem.
Man the Imperials are just casually trashing Lumpy’s room that’s so rude. Just straight-out decapitated the stuffed bantha?? Rude??
Man bar staff have to deal with this shit all over the galaxy XD
Bea Arthur is singing to the Cantina song. That is all.
Chewie and Han arrive home, only to find a stormtrooper threatening Lumpy! Oh noes!
WILHELM SCREAM.
Tumblr media Tumblr media
Aww, Han and Lumpy’s interactions are adorable. He’s all, “omg he’s got so big!” and teasing him over his voice starting to change XD
Oh god please don’t make me watch Wookiees make out... oh thank fuck it was just a hug XD
And suddenly they’re in robes and floating through space in a procession while a solemn version of the Throne Room theme plays and Threepio wishes everyone a Happy Life Day (”WAAAARGKJHJDSAASDFJLKWAHH!”).
Wow I don’t know about Threepio wishing they were truly alive so they could celebrate Life Day too XD;;
And here’s our trio! For some reason, Luke is back in his Tatooine outfit?
Listen there is something not quite right about Leia passionately talking about their love for one another despite their differences while clinging to Chewie’s arm and gazing adoringly at him XD
“This is the promise of the Tree of Life.”
The what of what? Because that was literally not mentioned at any point before that.
Oh god the song. Oh god I don’t know if I’m strong enough.
That note did not work with the music being played!!
So that happened.
15 notes · View notes
camimoo · 5 years
Text
So, I watched the Heathers episode of Riverdale
K, so I’ve never watched Riverdale before (well like half an episode on tv once) but I heard there was a musical episode themed on Heathers.  
So I watched it…and accidentally started writing a really long play-by-play analysis:
Oh we’re really just gonna turn on a boombox and go. Ok.
Is KJ’s voice that high all the time? is that just the line they gave him? It’s so babie
Tiny girl  :((( so much autotune.
Oh gosh, that “whyyyyyyyyyyy” is too low for him. Otherwise the Kevin guy is probably their best guy singer.
Weird disorganized sometimes-choreography for background peeps. Like this row of desks will move, but the one next to it will be completely still
“Are all of you this miserable”  lol
The hair wooshy noises…this is only for this episode right? That can’t be in the regular run of the show right? It’s so loud
Oh heck, no harmony on Candy Store :( also weird bad cuts
Is veronica’s house always lit with crappy eerie blue lights?
Is every character selling drugs?  Like every single one?
Also is the plot that these kids have to stop their drug dealing moms?
“What are you gonna do?” “ I’m gonna take a bath.” *starts crying* lmao
Co director girl is so over acting.  Is she a regular character on this show?
Aw man lowering the big fun notes :(
Also can the Ram Sweeney guy actually act? Cuz based on what I’m seeing, imma go with No.
So, frequently, a disembodied voice is just singing and matches nobody on screen, like they don’t seem to concerned with getting the right person on screen lip-syncing at the right moment.
Also one of the jock dudes is suuuuper tone deaf
Again terrible edit cuts in the song.
I do appreciate that they are all indeed doing jello shots.
So we have the 3 heathers, and then we have … 3 more dark evil heathers?
Also this sometimes using riverdale-veronica as heathers-veronica but also not is confusing
Doing some Grease hand jive dancing?
There are some ridiculously loud sound effects in this. Archie’s jacket for one
I thought the neon lighting was just for promotional photos of Riverdale. But no. literally every scene is lit in neon red and blue (and maybe some yellow)
Ooh I like the “anything to share veronica”, that matches the musical where she has to blurt something out at the assembly
“my family’s always been unconventional.” Lol yeah your family is unconventional, (from the 5 seconds I’ve seen of them) your mother whose face never changes and she just wafts around, and your gravel-voice dad
Off-brand hostess cupcakes!
“He’s a real class act, that Sweet Pea”  how do y’all deliver any of this dialogue with a straight face when your characters have COMIC BOOK names??
“cuz your parents are splitsville” lol, way to be gentle
“I AM RED” and snaps and two replacement heathers come to back her up.  How many heathers are there in this show? We’re up to like 8
“Faux pink lady”.  So we are intentionally making these Grease references. Got it.
Lol she said Westerberg.
What’s the point of saying the one tiny girl is Veronica if Topaz(?) is gonna sing her songs
All hope is gone. Apparently these are the Highschool lyric changes.  Hmmm
I feel like they are mix and matching characters together willy-nilly.  I pick…you and …you! Yep threesome now.
Nuh uh.  Her name is PEACHES?!
The loud sound effects are killing me.  When you pat your thighs that doesn’t usually echo through a whole auditorium peeps.
Also why are we in the auditorium, you all clearly have neon lit mansions to go home to, why not use a more believable setting for seducing your friends?
So Tony/EvilHeather/Veronica is seeing visions of Cheryl/ActualHeather telling her she’s beautiful???
Oof that was a terrible record scratch noise.  Also whiplash! “Let’s make this beautifuuuul-STOP.”
Lol Fang.
What is ThE GaRgOyLe ChaMbEr?
Finally some harmony, it’s altered but still decent. :) Our love is god.
Are they having a secret gay cult wedding in a dungeon church?
The weird kinda half choreo the background cast does every once in a while.  Also specifically its only like the first row of extras in every case.  The back or outer rows never move..?
Do boxers really punch the air for practice by themselves in empty boxing rings?
k. I kinda hate the tiny girl’s voice,
so everybody is Veronica. Huh. Just takin turns.
I guess that’s just what KJ’s singing voice is. Ok.
Also when making cuts, why still have her say “well whoa you can punch real good.”  Just cut the “well whoa” and it will fit your scenario better.
Ok I actually super like the new harmony at the end of fight for me.
Principals are susceptible to cults. Got it.
Meet me at JUNKYARD STEVE’S??
Red scrunchie!
WAIT- did evil-heather and heather-heather used to be in love?
Wait they found the drug lab that quick?  Is this like a once-an-episode kinda thing? just gotta shut down the daily drug lab and move on
“and serial killer fathers” said in a comforting tone.
What even were those terrible piano chords as an intro to Seventeen?
But actually this song seems like a good fit for these traumatized children.  Help these babies :(
The voices of Cole and lilli (and most of them) sound like they were recorded so separately and in completely different ways, ones more breathy, others are echoey, some have autotune…hmm
Also someone pointed out that when you get to the “your eyes can’t we be seeeventeeeeeeen” line, Cole’s voice changes so drastically it has got to be somebody else.  I totally agree.
Sometimes the background music (not heathers) sounds like a western movie.  Like somebody just got challenged to a show down at high noon.
I want to crack an egg with a tiny egg hammer! And he didn’t even get to eat it.
Her dad sounds like a gravellier version of Misha Collins
She does really good at Lifeboat.
“I thought I was captain” diff lyrics.  Ok.
“drugs…terrible…what a nightmare”  delivered practically deadpan devoid of emotion. wow what quality dialogue.
“what is all over your faces?”  oh that’s just the drugs soot. No worries. Trashing meth labs always leaves me covered in soot.
Oof. “Martha are you free tonight?”  nobody answers. They all kinda glance around awkwardly.  Really? Why leave the name in at all if you aren’t including Martha, just change it.
When you burn down a building, shouldn’t you flee the scene of the crime? No? does being in the snake gang make him immune?
Also the pan out to make sure we saw the gas can in the back seat, cuz yanno I couldn’t’ve pieced that bit together on my own.
Also I’m assuming they’re drinking big gulps right?
Weird music edits
HOLD UP, is Tony dressed as Martha??? Wut.
Also none of their vocal styles go together, the transition from the others to tony is jarring. Tony is all sexy breathy poppy.
Hmm, interesting minimal interpretive dancing choreo
Ack, please blend in the tiny girl’s vocals.  Pls I beg you. At least I think its her.
Everyone else: *taking off clothes and jackets*
Jughead: *putting on his hat*
Hold up, I feel like from seeing the rest of the ep I can guess who most of the audience members are that are getting close ups/reaction shots, but I swear they added a new lady, heavily made up, and not Cole or Veronica’s mom...who…?
Oh and now we get creepy cult flash mob with hypnotizing claps. Ok.
 Overall:  pretty messy. No one really plays a specific character so it’s hard to gain any of the character growth that they get in the actual musical.  No one’s vocal style matches like at all.  The new lyrics and tons of edits were odd. The sound mixing was bad I think, like everything stuck out and didn’t match. This show is hilariously broody and they all have such funny names. Camilla whatshername is a good singer, actually the main 3 girls are p good, and the Kevin guy.  
Huh.
6 notes · View notes
jls1792 · 7 years
Text
13x01 Thoughts/Review
Okay, I know the episode aired 5 days ago.  I actually did watch it late Wednesday night and wrote down some random thoughts while watching it.  But I haven’t gotten around to posting it until now.  I’ll put it under a read more link since it’s very long and ramble-y 
Everything is happening so fast!
*whispers* Why are the cars arranged in the spots they were in before they got hit by the truck?
After seeing the sneak peek, I wasn’t sure how I felt about Garcia going out with Simmons as opposed to trying to help from the office.  But I actually liked that she went (it is her family after all) and I loved her rushing over to help in any way she could.  
Wow, I’m surprised they actually showed a body for Walker.  It wasn’t Damon, but they showed it so we saw a body and knew it was Walker without really seeing the face
Also: WALKER NO!! YOU DESERVED BETTER!
So, was Walker clearly dead? Like, did he look clearly dead? Did Luke check and see he was dead before he helped JJ?  Because Garcia is instantly sad and Luke is all “he’s gone”.  He had to clearly be dead since we didn’t see Luke check for a pulse or anything (unless he did it before).  
But man, poor Walker. It just sucks that it’s all happening like this.  HE DIDN’T DESERVE TO DIE!  Luke’s line could have been delivered a little better. I mean, he was basically “Yo, he dead”. I get everyone’s shaken up and everything has happened so fast, but I felt he could have shown a bit more sympathy to the fact that Walker (who was sitting in the backseat of the same car as him and was his teammate) is just dead now.
So JJ got glass in her scalp and can’t see, and Walker is dead.  But Luke is fine.  Luke’s side of the car was the one that got brushed but it wasn’t hit that hard.  How did JJ and Walker get the beating and not Luke? I can see Luke walking away fine, it does happen (speaking from experience) and it did look like it was more the front tire/side area that got hit, but did the car hit something on the other side that would account for JJ and Walker’s injuries?  
I hate myself, because all summer I’ve been thinking “watch them say Walker did of whiplash”.  And then Scratch tells Emily he died of whiplash.  Hell fucking no that is not an acceptable way to kill Walker.  Please tell me Scratch was being vague.  Because it looked like Walker’s face was pretty messed up/bloody?  But come on, whiplash is a terrible way to make Walker die.  I know it’s possible to die from whiplash, but I don’t think it’s that common?  Unless he really got tossed around so much that his head/neck snapped/turned really fast.  I just wish they would have gone into that a bit more.  
Rossi’s leg is injured, JJ can’t see, Walker is dead, Tara is going into shock, Prentiss is missing. Well, fucking shit!
Again, this feels so rushed. But it makes sense since that’s how stuff works in this situation. 
Reid got to the hospital fast.  But where is Morgan?  Is he with Reid’s mom?  Because how could Reid just leave his mom?  No way he found someone or a place for her that fast?  Is she just with other FBI agents? And Morgan was supposed to have breakfast with Reid.  Since the premiere picks up immediately after the finale, I have a hard time imagining Morgan and Reid already had their breakfast.  And if Morgan was with Reid, if Reid had to bail, Morgan would know what’s up since he was aware of what the team was doing.  But also, if Morgan did know, I can’t see him leaving knowing Prentiss is missing, JJ, Rossi and Tara are injured and one of the team is dead (I know Morgan didn’t work with Walker, but Walker worked with Morgan’s friends, so I could see Morgan staying for moral support, especially for Garcia). Also, isn’t it still night time?  Would Morgan have even stopped by Reid’s yet?  Like, did he show up but Reid wasn’t there?  Because again, Morgan knew the team was going after Scratch, so you’d think he’d put two and two together and at least call Garcia and see what’s up.  
So Reid called Will and JJ said someone needs to call Monica.  Is anyone going to call Hayden or Joy and let them know about Rossi?  
LOL ROSSI!  Rossi is in zero fucks mode.  
“You’re back on the team” “Did the director approve that?” “BITCH I’M IN CHARGE NOW YOU MOFO SO LISTEN TO ME YOU LITTLE PUNK!” Basically what Rossi was saying.
“Ass clowns” LOL! That needs to be a new phrase
Okay, so if Walker’s only purpose was to come in and catch Scratch, couldn’t he have just done case work from the office?  If he was only there to solve the Scratch case, why was he going out on cases with the team and not doing Scratch work? (Okay, he was, but we didn’t really see it). He could have spent more time focusing on Scratch if he wasn’t going out on cases with the team as well
YASSS HOTCH MENTION!! See, writers, they said his name and no one spontaneously combusted!  
But also, FUCK YOU SCRATCH!! What a dumb piece of shit.  You can do whatever the hell you want to Prentiss, she would NEVER give up Hotch’s location.  No one on the team would if they knew.  
Did I already say Stephen Walker deserved better?  Because he did.  I’m not ready for poor Monica.
Ohh, Reid caught onto the AH in the texts.
That’s right, Reid!  Hotch and Prentiss would never be dumb enough to easily expose themselves like that.
Yes Garcia, figuring out it was set up!
And yes, new guy for figuring out Walker was setting up the anonymous texts!
Reid ushering Garcia and Simmons out of the room and they’re like “Okay dude, wtf?”  Garcia was all “I’mma just grab my computer real quick, bro.”  
“He’s had a rough few months” YEAH YOU THINK?!  Y’all have had a rough year though girl!
So, is Tara still alive? Could someone mention her?  Is she in surgery?  I need to know!  
WILL!!!
UGH Walker gave JJ the front seat.  GUILT!!!  
But why does seat position matter?  HOW DID WALKER DIE??  Whiplash just seems so vague.  I mean, even if he sat in the front, he could have gotten still gotten whiplash. (Yeah, I know, JJ would still feel guilty because there’s always that “what if” scenario, but stil…)
Wonderful Will and JJ scene. LOL at Rossi telling them to get a room.
Aww, Will’s staying with Rossi while JJ goes to be with Monica and Luke.
But seriously, where the fuck is Tara?!?!
Aww poor JJ.  But I get Monica not wanting to be touched/hugged in that moment.  That’s exactly how I would feel.
Out of curiosity, does the team know Monica besides her just being Walker’s wife?  Have they ever really talked to her or met her before?
Wow, they’re showing a body again!  It’s not Damon though (obviously).  But I appreciate them actually showing something.  It makes it more sad than if they just showed the body bag but not actually showing the body (it would have been even more devastating if they actually had Damon)
Stephen Walker deserved better.
Monica talking to Walker was so sad!  Tracie Thoms nailed that scene!  From her wondering how to tell the kids to telling Walker she would handle it then the “see ya” before she pulled the sheet back over his head! UGH THE FEELS!  And then she broke down and Luke and JJ comforted her.
Stephen Walker and his family deserved better.  Just in case I haven’t already made that point.  
This episode should have been titled “Stephen Walker deserved better”
I’m literally crying. Criminal Minds, you better not kill JJ, Prentiss, Reid, Rossi, Hotch, Garcia or Morgan because Walker was only in 15 episodes and I’m FUCKING DEAD!!
Speaking of Morgan, WHERE THE FUCK IS HE?!?!  All I need is a simple name-drop (Is Morgan the new Hotch?  If you say his name the reaper appears?)
“Jack is 13.” Actually, if anyone bothered to do the math, he should be 12.  He was born in Fall 2005.  It’s Fall 2017 now.  2017-2005=12. Actually, he shouldn’t even be 12 yet, since this episode picks up right from 12x22, which I believe was May 2017, but I digress…
YASS EMILY TELL THAT FUCKER TO FUCK OFF!!! “I love Jack.  I’ve watched Jack grow up.”  THIS TEAM IS A FAMILY, GUYS!!  
I’m just so happy we’re finally getting Hotch mentions.  I get Thomas is gone, but I was disappointed when last season they really sort of forgot about Hotch after episode 6 and never really mentioned him.  I wasn’t expecting a name drop every episode, but come on.  He was their boss and friend and they knew him for more than a decade.  Just because he’s in Witness Protection doesn’t mean he’s completely safe (his wife did die after all…).  Even if he was totally safe, I’d still be worried about him and thinking of him. I suppose maybe enough time has passed that they feel they can talk about him again
Now I just hope they remember Morgan exists!
ANGRY REID!! Totally understandable! 
Scratch keeps asking where Hotch is.  Talk about obsessed *cues Mariah Carey’s song “Obsessed”*
Yeah, Prentiss is obviously not dead, but I’m still intrigued!
What the fuck is this scene with Garcia and Simmons?!?  It’s like naked church  yoga with gagging.  “So much for no creepy weirdness” Love you Garcia!
LOL at Rossi just using Luke instead of crutches :D 
Oh good, y’all remembered Tara exists
That’s right, Prentiss, catch onto Scratch and his tricks!  
Gah, of course Reid’s included in the text.  What you do that for, Garcia? “Reid’s not in a good place right now.” Yeah no shit.
HELL YEAH PRENTISS!! YOU BITE HIS EAR!!  That was fucking amazing!  She should have gone full Rick Grimes from The Walking Dead and ripped his throat out
So glad Prentiss made Reid stay with her.  I definitely think it was partly because she really did want a good friend with her after the ordeal, but also because she didn’t want Reid to have to deal with more stress
HAHA GOOD FUCKING RIDDANCE SCRATCH!!  
As much as I loved Luke just watching and letting Scratch fall to his death, I was really hoping for Prentiss and Tara and even Reid to be the ones to kill him.  It should have really been Emily or Tara.  But he’s dead so whatever.
Actually, you know what would have been a good way for Scratch to die? With the entire team shooting a thousand bullets into him.  They did this in the season 13 finale of NCIS with one of their bad guys.  See this for reference: https://youtu.be/tPnkug2rwIU?t=2m3s
LOL at Luke nonchalantly saying Scratch is down.  And then “He fell trying to escape”.  Technically not a lie
THANK YOU FOR LETTING HOTCH AND JACK BE HAPPY!!  I never understood the people who said Scratch couldn’t die because then they wouldn’t have a story for Hotch.  Umm, yes, they do.  I’ve said it along: catch/kill Scratch and say Hotch and Jack are out of the program and Hotch decides not to return.  I mean, in 12x06 they said Hotch sent in his resignation.  They just needed to make him stick to it, which he is.  
Funeral scene is sad. Monica is hugging JJ this time.  I love Monica!! I really liked her in 12x20 and thought she and Walker had a nice relationship.  It’s a shame we didn’t get to see more of it.  And it’s a shame we didn’t get to know Walker’s kids more or see Walker with them.  It’s a shame we just didn’t get to know Walker more.
I liked Monica saying Peter Lewis was the reason Stephen was dead, not Emily.  And her saying Walker can rest easy knowing he helped bring Scratch to an end.  UGH!! My feels!  Stephen Walker and his family deserved better (I don’t think I made that point yet ;D )
You know who should become friends?  Aaron Hotchner and Monica Walker.  And Jack and Eli can be friends.  That family has a lot of shit they can bond over.  Jack and Eli are probably around the same age, so it could be a thing!
Wheels up!!  That was a nice scene.  I liked that Prentiss said that phrase was what kept her fighting and made her realize the team was out there fighting.  And I also like to think it was a nice little tribute to Hotch.
As much as I liked the ending, I think that end scene would have made a good series finale ending scene
As glad as I am that we got Hotch mentions and he and Jack are doing well, it would be nice to know where they are.  Are they staying wherever they were in WitSec or are they returning to Virginia?  I mean, they would have had fake identities when in WitSec, so you’d think they’d have to move from there?  They can’t just be Tommy and Sam one day and then the next day be like “LOL JK those aren’t our names”.  Hotch and Jack could move back and Hotch doesn’t need to come back or be seen even if he’s in town.  But a little conformation would be nice.  Just like I also want to know where Morgan is living now and what he’s doing for a living.
Also, I know we can’t get TG, but I would love if they had Hotch and Jack move back to Virginia and we could see Jack hanging out with Henry!  I want to see teenage Jack!
Very good episode!  There were little things here and there that maybe could have been tweaked a bit, but it was still very good.  I do wish we could have gotten a bit more on Walker and his death.  I get though that they couldn’t really grieve Walker in the episode while Prentiss was missing since they had to try to save her.  And since the firing of Damon was sort of thrown at the writers, they probably did the best they could.
Again, it was a good premiere.  One of the better episodes in recent years.  I can be a bit hard on the writers sometimes, but they can actually produce some quality episodes.  Come on writers, you can make some really good episodes, so I’d like to see some more like “Wheels Up” :)
4 notes · View notes