Tumgik
About
Privacy Policy
Removal Request
Visit Blog
Explore Tumblr blogs with no restrictions, modern design and the best experience.
Fun Fact
Hackers stole 65M passwords from Tumblr in 2013.
#the Woodvilles' marriage prospects clearly reflected their status (and 'place') in society: EW herself had first married a knight and all
wonder-worker
·
28 days
Text
people really do not know what they're talking about when it comes to Elizabeth Woodville's social status, huh?
#yes Elizabeth was without a doubt considered too low-born to be queen
#no she was not a commoner and nobody actually called her that during her life (so I'm not sure why people are claiming that they did?)
#Elizabeth's social status was not a problem in itself; it was a problem in the context of queenship and marrying into royalty
#Context is important in this and for literally everything else when it comes to analyzing history. Any discussion is worthless without it.
#obviously pop culture-esque articles claiming that she was 'a commoner who captured the king's heart' are wrong; she wasn't
#But emphasizing that ACTUALLY she was part of the gentry with a well-born mother and just leaving it at that as some sort of “GOTCHA!”
#is equally if not more irresponsible and entirely irrelevant to discussions of the actual time period we're studying.
#Elizabeth *was* considered unworthy and unacceptable as queen precisely because of her lower social status
#her father and brother had literally been derided as social-climbers by Salisbury Warwick and Edward himself just a few years earlier
#the Woodvilles' marriage prospects clearly reflected their status (and 'place') in society: EW herself had first married a knight and all
#siblings married within the gentry to people of a similar status. compare that to the prestigious marriages arranged after EW became queen
#Elizabeth having a lower social status was not 'created' by propaganda against her; it fueled and shaped propaganda against her
#that's a huge huge difference; it's irresponsible and silly to conflate the two as I've seen a recent tumblr post cavalierly do
#like I said she was considered too low-born to be queen long before any of the propaganda Warwick Clarence or Richard put out against her
#and the fact that Elizabeth was targeted on the basis of her social status was in itself novel and unprecedented
#no queen before her was ever targeted in such a manner; Clearly Elizabeth was considered notably 'different' in that regard
#(and was quite literally framed as the enemy and destroyer of 'the old royal blood of this realm' and all its actual 'inheritors' like..)
#ngl this sort of discussion always leaves a bad taste in my mouth
#because it's not like England and France (et all) are at war or consider each other mortal enemies in the 21st century
#both are in fact western european imperialistic nations who've been nothing but a blight to the rest of the world including my own country
#yet academic historians clearly have no problem contextualizing the xenophobia that medieval foreign queens faced as products of their time
#and sympathizing with them accordingly (Eleanor of Provence; Joan of Navarre; Margaret of Anjou; etc)(at least by their own historians)
#Nor were foreign queens the “worst” targets of xenophobia: that was their attendants or in times of war commoners or soldiers
#who actually had to bear the brunt of English aggression
#queens were ultimately protected and guaranteed at least a veneer of dignity and respect because of their royal status
#yet once again historians and people have no problem contextualizing and understanding their difficulties regardless of all this
#so what is the problem with contextualizing the classism *Elizabeth* faced and understanding *her* difficulties?
#why is the prejudice against her constantly diminished & downplayed? (Ive never even seen any historian directly refer to it as 'classism')
#after all it was *Elizabeth* who was more vulnerable than any queen before her due to her lack of powerful foreign or national support
#and Elizabeth who faced a form of propaganda distinctly unprecedented for queens. it SHOULD be emphasized more.
3 notes
·
View notes
Last Seen Blogs
silvanei-executivo-amakha-p-blog
Sem título
honeisweets
honei
durbalau
Untitled
latteromanoff
silk chiffon
naruto-of-pictures-mydude
Annoying