Tumgik
About
Privacy Policy
Removal Request
Visit Blog
Explore Tumblr blogs with no restrictions, modern design and the best experience.
Fun Fact
Users from the US are the majority of Tumblr visitors.
#But emphasizing that ACTUALLY she was part of the gentry with a well-born mother and just leaving it at that as some sort of “GOTCHA!”
wonder-worker
·
27 days
Text
people really do not know what they're talking about when it comes to Elizabeth Woodville's social status, huh?
#yes Elizabeth was without a doubt considered too low-born to be queen
#no she was not a commoner and nobody actually called her that during her life (so I'm not sure why people are claiming that they did?)
#Elizabeth's social status was not a problem in itself; it was a problem in the context of queenship and marrying into royalty
#Context is important in this and for literally everything else when it comes to analyzing history. Any discussion is worthless without it.
#obviously pop culture-esque articles claiming that she was 'a commoner who captured the king's heart' are wrong; she wasn't
#But emphasizing that ACTUALLY she was part of the gentry with a well-born mother and just leaving it at that as some sort of “GOTCHA!”
#is equally if not more irresponsible and entirely irrelevant to discussions of the actual time period we're studying.
#Elizabeth *was* considered unworthy and unacceptable as queen precisely because of her lower social status
#her father and brother had literally been derided as social-climbers by Salisbury Warwick and Edward himself just a few years earlier
#the Woodvilles' marriage prospects clearly reflected their status (and 'place') in society: EW herself had first married a knight and all
#siblings married within the gentry to people of a similar status. compare that to the prestigious marriages arranged after EW became queen
#Elizabeth having a lower social status was not 'created' by propaganda against her; it fueled and shaped propaganda against her
#that's a huge huge difference; it's irresponsible and silly to conflate the two as I've seen a recent tumblr post cavalierly do
#like I said she was considered too low-born to be queen long before any of the propaganda Warwick Clarence or Richard put out against her
#and the fact that Elizabeth was targeted on the basis of her social status was in itself novel and unprecedented
#no queen before her was ever targeted in such a manner; Clearly Elizabeth was considered notably 'different' in that regard
#(and was quite literally framed as the enemy and destroyer of 'the old royal blood of this realm' and all its actual 'inheritors' like..)
#ngl this sort of discussion always leaves a bad taste in my mouth
#because it's not like England and France (et all) are at war or consider each other mortal enemies in the 21st century
#both are in fact western european imperialistic nations who've been nothing but a blight to the rest of the world including my own country
#yet academic historians clearly have no problem contextualizing the xenophobia that medieval foreign queens faced as products of their time
#and sympathizing with them accordingly (Eleanor of Provence; Joan of Navarre; Margaret of Anjou; etc)(at least by their own historians)
#Nor were foreign queens the “worst” targets of xenophobia: that was their attendants or in times of war commoners or soldiers
#who actually had to bear the brunt of English aggression
#queens were ultimately protected and guaranteed at least a veneer of dignity and respect because of their royal status
#yet once again historians and people have no problem contextualizing and understanding their difficulties regardless of all this
#so what is the problem with contextualizing the classism *Elizabeth* faced and understanding *her* difficulties?
#why is the prejudice against her constantly diminished & downplayed? (Ive never even seen any historian directly refer to it as 'classism')
#after all it was *Elizabeth* who was more vulnerable than any queen before her due to her lack of powerful foreign or national support
#and Elizabeth who faced a form of propaganda distinctly unprecedented for queens. it SHOULD be emphasized more.
3 notes
·
View notes
Last Seen Blogs
sailor---saturn
破滅の星
jazzimin03
JazziMin
beeqlass
ellíott–lee.
murcielaguitos
taylorsamalia
raylla supremacist