Talk about Many Goodbyes?
This is for the Director's Cut fanfic meme, so I'm going to start this out with some info about the fic and then dive into commentary.
Many Goodbyes is a Doctor Who/Thick of It crossover fic I wrote back in 2014. It's 2,507 words, rated PG-13 for content but R for language (I put up two ratings because people can get snippy if you don't make these things clear). The summary reads, "The Doctor did not anticipate running into a former companion when using the chameleon arch to create Malcolm Tucker. Jamie MacDonald never anticipated the Doctor would return under a disguise. The reveal does not go well." I posted it to AO3 here
This post got stupid long so I'm going to insert a read more cut. I'm surprised I had this much to say about the fic.
I tried to pull in varous recurring TTOI headcanons into the fic that crop up in a lot of other fics I've had. I was also influenced by character dicussions I'd had with various people at the time. Like how Jamie seems like he probably has kids and is likely divorced and how he likely is the youngest of a large family. The idea that the little boy we see peek through the curtains at Malcolm's house in series four is actually related to Jamie is one of the various headcanons I have for who the boy is. I think that in series four Jamie's the person Malcolm mentions meeting with and that now that the stress and strain of politics isn't between them anymore in canon, they've managed to patch their friendship back up, shipping aside. I also pulled in some DW headcanons like the Doctor being a bit skittish about affection because perhaps something had gone wrong during regeneration and it hurt him physically to have others touch him (this was of course back during series eight). I mention Bearsden because historically that's where the seminary was in 1980's Scotland. I learned that researching for another fic I wrote before this one.
I decided to go with the Malcolm/Jamie pairing because I found the dynamic between them interesting. My brain just kind of kept returning to the pairing during this time period because of that and also because I would get a decent response when I wrote fics with that pairing. I wrote a lot of TTOI fic during that time period because not only did I know people would read it and give me kudos, but TTOI provided a good way for my brain to take breaks from the novel I was writing at the time. It was this vast three part world building dystopian thing full of characters who were fundamentally decent people, so when I needed a brain break from it, TTOI was a good contrast. I ended up setting that novel concept aside a couple years ago because I'd accidentally made my main villain a Trump-like figure and so I decided it was time to rethink it or at least put it off until he's out of office because it was getting too stressful to have something paraelleling reality.
Why couldn't (wouldn't?) Jamie realize Malcolm was the Doctor since Jamie traveled with the Twelfth Doctor? That is a great question I just thought of and I'm not completely sure. Then again it's not uncommon for people to have extremely similar faces but be unrelated. Also the change in personalities and levels of profanity and so forth probably lent to that. I think at the time I was running with the assumption that unless Jamie knew about it ahead of time, he would not be able to detect a chameleon arch since he's just a human.
Why was the Doctor Malcolm Tucker? I'm not completely sure anymore. He was hiding from somthing apparently. Might also have connected back to whoever Malcolm took the fall for in series four.
The reason Sam is mentioned at the end of the fic is because she's Twelve's current companion. It makes a lot of sense, they're a team, he treats her better than the others, and she seems to know exactly what he needs her to do and she does it properly (which is honeslty why I think Malcolm treats Sam as well as he does in canon because most of his frustration is from people being incompetant, which Sam is not). I mentioned the Brigadier because Jamie likely encountered him frequently since he would have been a companion from the 1980's, which means the TARDIS would have kept returning to roughly that time period frequently trying to take him home or whatnot. Jamie probalby doesn't know who's running UNIT in the 2010's.
If you have any specific questions I can answer those. This is all the self-generated things I can think of to say about this fic.
1 note
·
View note