#(tho this whole kerfuffle is exactly why this would have been better handled in private)

[chayannesegg]

There's a ton of analysis going on right now about what Fred's letter meant and whether Tubbo (and the audience) interpreted it correctly. No matter what, it was clearly more ambiguous than originally thought, but I want to caution people against assuming only one interpretation is possible. Fred's admin is not a native English speaker. That's a really important consideration when analysing where this miscommunication started, who caused for the misinterpretation, and what the letter was trying to say. Especially if you're a native English speaker consider that your interpretation might not be what the admin intended and that blaming them for the confusion can come off as unfriendly to non-native speakers! I think the main line causing the confusion is when Fred wrote: "For now, I don't think the...you know... mmm the letter exchange will be paused." A native English speaker's interpretation of this sentence would be to disregard the sentence fragment "I don't think think the..you know..mmm" (it reads as a unfinished thought) and conclude the only important part of that sentence are the lines: "For now, [...] the letter exchange will be paused." That said, I think the admin might have intended for only the middle part of the sentence to be ignored. In which case the sentence could be read as, "For now, I don't think [...] the letter exchange will be paused." This might explain why the admin was so confused Tubbo wasn't leaving letters (and seemingly "dropped" the lore). I don't know for sure that this is what they intended, but it makes sense to me with how confused/frustrated the admin seemed.

#qsmp #qsmp tubbo #qsmp fred #for the record I think Tubbo was perfectly valid in his interpretation and all the assholes can fuck off #and all the lore he's built shouldn't be retconned bc of a miscommunication (which happen in stories just life real life)! #but on the flip side I also don't like seeing people act like his was the ONLY correct interpretation after all #when we basically have confirmation that the admin intended SOMETHING different whatever that may be #we KNOW a miscommunication happened #and we know they are a non-native speaker #(tho this whole kerfuffle is exactly why this would have been better handled in private)