I said I wasn't going to get started on the topic of Aveline ruining Carver's chances with the guard but I lied okay, it's Carver Hawke defense hours.
Here's the thing; it doesn't matter if you believe Carver was or wasn't fit for the guard. That's a different debate that I'll get to. What matters is Aveline's in no position to tell the guard not to accept his application. Why does she think that's her right to judge whether or not he's fit?
Carver should've had the chance to prove himself one way or another. If it turns out he's not a good fit, then let him fail. Let him learn from it.
"Oh but failure could mean lost lives-"
Aveline doesn't get to talk shit about failure and the people. Plenty have died on her watch yet she still believes she's a good guard and Guard-Captain.
"maybe Aveline's protecting him, Carver could die while on patrol-"
Carver could die working in the Bone Pit, or serving as a templar, or when he's running around with Hawke. Carver could trip and fall down a set of stairs and die. In fact, he can die in the Deep Roads, somewhere he wouldn't have to go if the Hawke's weren't desperate.
Either Carver fails as a guard, or more likely, he succeeds and proves himself worthy of it.
But let's be real, Carver probably kept getting rejected due to being a Fereldan with a past of smuggling/mercenary work and Aveline only reaffirmed the decision, either because they asked her what she thought or she stuck her nose in unprompted.
But what irritates me is that she admits to telling them not to accept his application, and then has the balls to call Carver too proud to take up a trade or find another line of work.
Carver tells her, "And who would take on a Fereldan apprentice? Maybe in another year I could work my way up to pissboy." He has a good point here. Aside from the guard, the only other place Carver could work and use his skillset is with the Templars. Or go back to mercenary/smuggling work.
And Aveline doesn't even have a real answer for him. No suggestions, no encouragement, nothing. Just "Fine, let's crawl down some holes. Good bloody luck for your sake."
Also, if you do the Mark of the Assassin DLC in Act 1-
Aveline: You should see if any of the noblemen are looking for new men-at-arms.
Carver: Are you trying to get rid of me?
Aveline: It's a role with some autonomy. A good fit with your training and... tendencies.
Carver: After serving King Cailan? You want me to suffer some poncy git who needs two servants to wipe his own ass? I'll find my own way, thanks.
Aveline: I wish you would.
You wish he would?? Aveline, he was trying to find his way into the guard, a position he'd make a good fit for, and you helped deny him of it because YOU didn't think he would be good enough, I just-
If I haven't made it clear yet, I firmly believe that Carver would've made a great guard. He wants to help people, to be a protector. He's loyal, and despite what Aveline claims, he can follow orders and take his duty seriously. We see him do incredibly well with the Grey Wardens, after all. If he were a guard, he wouldn't have to go down into the Deep Roads with Hawke, and I think he would've been okay with that! He's so hurt and bitter when you leave him behind because that effectively tells him, "I don't need you." Carver's spent the whole first act telling you he wants to go on the expedition aka that he wants to be needed.
But if he were a guard, he would be needed elsewhere. He'd be in training as a recruit. He'd look after Leandra while you go. He wouldn't be backed into a corner with no income and only the templars left as his chance at forging his own path and providing for his family.
He doesn't get that opportunity, though.
By the way, if he becomes a warden, you can get this banter:
Aveline: I'm glad you found a place with the Wardens.
Carver: Well, it's not the city guard, but it'll do.
Aveline: Carver... it wasn't the place for you.
Carver: No, it's all right. It is. It cost a lot, but I get it. I really was a bit of a tit those days, wasn't I?
Aveline: Well...
This banter makes me want to scream.
Aveline's just... she's so insistent that she's right. She's someone who will double down rather than entertain the idea that she's wrong and it's not just with Carver and the guard, it's with everything. The "my beef with Aveline" list gets longer and longer every time I replay da2, I swear.
Say what you will about Carver, whether you think he would've been a good fit or if Aveline's right and it wasn't for him, he was denied a chance and it cost him so much in the end. He either dies, or he joins the templars where he deals with Chantry's bullshit trying to brainwash him with "mages aren't people" and "magic is a cancer in this world", or he's infected with the blight and becomes a Grey Warden, forced to serve the rest of his life fighting darkspawn, tormented by voices and nightmares.
I will never not be bitter about this.
823 notes
·
View notes
Sibling Rivalry - DA2
I'm probably not the only person to wonder the degree to which Bethany and Carver's approval score affects their disposition toward Hawke in the game. So I got it into my head to search the game files to see every instance in which the game checks their approval score and... it's not much!
A couple things.
There's always a small chance that there's some other line of dialogue in the game that's been coded in some fuckstupid nonstandard way that my search didn't catch, but this should be everything.
Unlike the game's full companions, which have major milestones at 50 and 100 approval points and can sometimes behave accordingly, Bethany and Carver are always at a flat check to determine if their approval is either above or below zero. There's no further benefit to changing their approval more than +-1 point from neutral.
Approval scores for Bethany and Carver really only ever come into play in Acts 2 and 3. There are basically no approval checks in Act 1, and none in the base game.
There's not a lot of approval-related dialogue in the base game, and it's all for warden siblings -- in the Act 2 climax and in the optional Act 3 sidequest Finding Nathaniel. Templar Carver and circle mage Bethany do not have any approval-specific dialogue in the base game... and the majority of approval-specific dialogue in the DLC still goes to their warden counterparts.
I'll be posting additional posts with the dialogue from MotA and Legacy in separate posts, to keep the length manageable, which will be found under the #sibling rivalry tag. Here's the base game dialogue:
Act 2 - Demands of the Qun (Warden Bethany)
Blue Hawke: [Are you all right?] Are you injured? Are there more of you?
[friendly]
Bethany: This is everyone. Thank you.
[rival]
Bethany: We're fine. Everyone's here.
---
Purple Hawke: [I live here.] Last time I checked, you'd moved on from Kirkwall.
[friendly]
Bethany: I'm a Warden now. We go where we're needed.
[rival]
Bethany: We're here on Grey Warden business.
---
Red Hawke: [You're welcome.] A "thank you" might be in order, don't you think?
[friendly]
Bethany: I must say, it's less painful than the last time you saved my life.
[rival]
Bethany: I knew you didn't go to so much trouble to save me, just to throw it away now.
---
Hawke: [You're leaving, Bethany?] But you just got here.
[friendly]
Bethany: You gave me this life… I'm just doing the best I can to live it.
[rival]
Bethany: I've been here for six days.
---
Hawke: [Bethany, Mother's gone.] Wait—I need to tell you about Mother.
[friendly]
Bethany: I know. When we got the news, the Wardens helped me hold a wake. I'm… glad you were with her. In her final moments.
[rival]
Bethany: I know what happened. I waited and waited for you to tell me yourself. Did you hold a funeral, or was there not enough left?
Act 2 - Demands of the Qun (Warden Carver)
Blue Hawke: [Are you all right?] Are you injured? Are there more of you?
[friendly]
Carver: I'm good, but we're not the help you need.
[rival]
Carver: I'm fine. We're fine. And no, this is all of us.
---
Purple Hawke: [I live here.] Last time I checked, you'd moved on from Kirkwall.
[friendly]
Carver: Things change. But… I can't stay.
[rival]
Carver: We're here on Grey Warden business.
---
Red Hawke: [You're welcome.] A "thank you" might be in order, don't you think?
[friendly]
Carver: Sorry. A bit distracted by all the friends you've made since I left.
[rival]
Carver: Pardon my manners. You save me so often I sometimes forget.
---
Hawke: [You're leaving, Carver?] But you just got here.
[friendly]
Carver: Another time, perhaps.
[rival]
Carver: I've been here for six days.
---
Hawke: [Carver, Mother's gone.] Wait—I need to tell you about Mother.
[any]
Carver: I already know what happened. I'm sure you did your best.
Act 3 - Finding Nathaniel (Warden Bethany)
Hawke: Bethany? Is that really you?
[friendly]
Bethany: Why would you come back here if you didn't have to?
[rival]
Bethany: Are you here to "save" me again?
---
Blue Hawke: [Are you all right?] You don't look well, Bethany. Are you injured?
Bethany: Injured? I have the darkspawn taint forever in my veins, barely held in check by the Wardens' rituals.
[friendly]
Bethany : I'm sorry. You did the best you could.
Hawke: I wish there'd been a better way.
[rival]
Bethany: I will never be well again.
Hawke: Where there's life, there's hope.
---
Purple Hawke: [Cheer up, Sis.] A little smile for me, Sister? It's been years. I've missed you.
[friendly]
Bethany: If I let myself miss you… and Carver… and Mother… I couldn't go on.
Bethany: It's better not to feel.
Hawke: I, ah, won't try to cheer you up, then.
[rival]
Bethany: I have kept track of your doings. I'm glad you've done well for yourself, though perhaps too late for Mother.
Bethany: But I am a Warden now. We have no families.
Hawke: They say it's always darkest before the dawn.
---
Red Hawke: [Pull yourself together.] You're not dead yet. Shake it off! There's work to be done.
[friendly]
Bethany: You never change, do you?
Hawke: Enough, Bethany. We need your help here or we'll all die.
[rival]
Bethany: You sound just like Ser Fenley—before the Children devoured him.
Hawke: Enough, Bethany. We need your help here or we'll all die.
Act 3 - Finding Nathaniel (Warden Carver)
Hawke: Carver?
[friendly]
Carver: Well, just like old times.
Carver: Still coming to the rescue after all these years? I have it under control, but thanks.
[rival]
Carver: What are you doing here?
Carver: Just like always, no cause is too small for you to stick your nose in. I have this under control.
---
[friendly]
Blue Hawke: [I'm glad you're doing well.] It's good to see you. I hope the years have been kind.
Carver: I can't say that. The Blight is long over, but the threat never really goes away.
Carver: I don't know if you can understand that. Maybe someday.
[rival]
Blue Hawke: [I'm glad you're doing well.] It's been years, Carver. We can't be civil?
Carver: I almost died in your shadow. I don't appreciate you showing up to take my thunder.
Hawke: If my shadow made it down here, you brought it.
---
[friendly]
Purple Hawke: [Why are you down here?] Don't you have Archdemons to hunt or something?
Carver: There's a considerable gap between Blights, you know. Apparently, just long enough for people to forget.
Carver: We Wardens don't have that luxury, though.
[rival]
Purple Hawke: [A little thanks, maybe?] You know, the average person saves a life, they might expect some gratitude.
Carver: I've seen too much of the world to be impressed by this.
Carver: It's just kind of sad.
Hawke: What is?
Carver: That your world has stayed so small.
---
[friendly]
Red Hawke: [Still hold a grudge?] So, do you still blame all of this on me?
Carver: Do you still expect me to? I'd like to think we've both changed.
Carver: I guess we'll have to wait and see, won't we?
[rival]
Red Hawke: [Still angry, Carver?] Nothing's changed between us after all these years?
Carver: I've seen a lot, Brother. Our little squabble, it doesn't matter.
Hawke: Your tone says otherwise, Warden.
80 notes
·
View notes
You ever think about how in spite of knowing their exact locations, the game never gives any indication that templar Carver has reported his mage sibling, Merril (a blood mage) or Anders (an abomination) to his superiors?
I do think about that a lot, even though I tend to ignore the Templar Carver route because I know Warden Carver to be true in my heart and soul... but I totally get the appeal of Templar Carver within DA2's narrative, y'know?
It's so fascinating, really. I've never played a run with Templar Carver, I just can't bring myself to do it, so I know I'm missing out on smaller details of it. From what I do know, this drives me crazy in the best way possible.
Deciding whether to bring him or not to the Deep Roads is such an important choice, not only because it affects his fate, but how it affects his relationship to Hawke. He tells you that he wants to go, he makes it very clear that it's important to him that he goes, too... and Hawke can just leave him behind and it hurts him. I don't think that registers enough with some people just because of how Carver is, like it doesn't matter what Hawke's motivations are [staying behind for his safety, not wanting to bring him, thinking someone should stay with Leandra, etc] it still hurts him because it tells him that Hawke doesn't need him, and Carver wants to be needed.
And yes, there are other contributing factors to why he joins the templars, but it doesn't matter what your relationship is to him, it doesn't change the fact that he doesn't turn Hawke or his companions in.
Sure, the meta reason is it's a video game and you're playing the main character. You're never in any actual danger of being captured by templars, and you're not going to lose your companions to them that easy.
But if we look at it through the narrative and Carver's character, that's when it gets interesting. You can max out his rivalry and be an utter asshole to him [there's a point where you can call him a brat and mock him for being stuck in your shadow, like Hawke can be real cruel about it] but it doesn't matter, you're still his sibling. He even makes a remark about how you might not know what that means [referring to leaving him behind] but he does. He refuses to kill Hawke in the end when Meredith makes the order, too.
Which can I just point out that Hawke has the option to let Bethany die in the end if she's with the circle and they side with the templars? Just saying, Carver NEVER does that no matter what, but Hawke has the option to betray Bethany like that and it's fucked and interesting and it makes me want to eat my chair-
As for Merrill and Anders, I think he knows that if he turns either of them in, then the chances of Hawke being brought in as well skyrocket. They're all friends, they're in the same group... bring one in, and you'll probably get the other two.
I also think Carver just genuinely likes Merrill. Yes, I'm a Carver/Merrill shipper, so I have a bias, but even if you remove anything romantic from their dynamic I believe that's true. Of all the companions, Merrill is the only one who doesn't make fun of him, or find him annoying, in party banters. He never snaps back at her, like he's never defensive with her, he's just a little awkward and nice.
Like, HE'S SO NICE TO HER! He tries to find common ground with her! She asks him about "swording" and he's taken aback by her saying he's good at it, but you KNOW that if someone like Anders asked him the same question, he's be all, "shut up, you're stupid, stop talking to me >:["
Think back to that banter Carver can have with Aveline post-act 1 where they're talking about how the guard wasn't the right place for him [hard disagree with you there, Aveline] and Carver says he was a bit of a tit, wasn't he.... and every companion will agree except Merrill. She doesn't say anything, whereas other companions like Anders will be like "ugh maker YES" and if you have a purple Hawke, they'll go on to other ways Carver was a tit like?? I think Carver and Merrill got along and he doesn't want to turn her in because she was nice to him! And she's a blood mage! He knows what will happen to her if the templars get ahold of her! He doesn't want to see her made tranquil or killed!
At that point, he's witnessed what bad blood mages can do, assuming you've brought him along for those quests, but even so. He knows Merrill isn't like that and he likes her, so of course he's not going to turn her in despite that being his literal duty.
Then there's Anders who Carver doesn't like. If you're in a romance with him, Carver will tell him that's why he doesn't turn him in but c'mon Carver, you know that's not the only reason. My theory is Carver may not like Anders and he knows the man's got a spirit of justice inside of him... but Anders also runs a free clinic. If he's ever taken in by templars, then so many people [including a LOT of Fereldan refugees] will be without free health care and will suffer for it. I think in Carver's eyes, Anders might be irritating but he doesn't more good than harm. Carver knows first hand how shitty refugees and poorer people are treated in Kirkwall. Anders' clinic is the one place they can go for help and actually get it, and he's not going to be the one to take that away because the templars say "magic bad."
So yeah, I'm not as informed about the Templar Carver route, but I do think about how if I did do that route, he wouldn't betray Hawke or their companions no matter what and what that says about him.
33 notes
·
View notes