Karlie isn’t the Muse, it’s Dianna
I know; I know. I sound crazy. A week ago I would have thought that statement was insane. Then I saw the Taymojis, which were released AFTER reputation, and a lot of them linked obvious Dianna songs to alleged Karlie songs. Then I went to r/felldowntherabbithole on reddit. I have been speaking to @alex-chaser a lot, she has been so amazing and patient and answering all my questions. But it’s Dianna, it always has been.
Remember 2016 when Taylor and Karlie stopped interacting? And when she moved to Cornelia Street? It was late 2016-2017. Karlie was out of her life by then. They last interacted fall 2016, and then nothing until summer 2018, which has been rumored to have been staged.
I know I sound insane, this doesn’t feel real. But, as we often tell the Hetlors in our lives, give the theory a chance, look at allllll the evidence, and there’s a lot. On rabbit hole Alex has linked her very extensive and thorough Swiftgron master post.
I myself will be making a post soon about how her music post-1989 points to Dianna.
I want to add two things. The first being how Taylor has referenced Karlie vs how she references Dianna. The red and 1989 muse is called out for the bad things they did, but Taylor still claims to love them, come back, be here. I’ll love you forever and ever. I wish you would. She thinks Betty and James get back together. Cardigan is a disputed song amongst fans, either about Dianna or Karlie. If it’s about Dianna, then that means Taylor wants to get back together with her. If it’s about Karlie….OOF considering she claimed they got back together, then released closure and ITTG the next month.
https://www.glamour.com/story/taylor-swift-just-revealed-how-the-betty-james-love-triangle-ends/amp
Now look at how she refers to K in two songs that are clearly Karlie….”crook who was caught” and “fake and so unnecessary”. She pulled no punches there. Karlie did her dirty. Please stop wishing Taylor would go back to someone who clearly caused her great pain. At first I was confused about all the physical references Taylor makes to Karlie, like dressing up to resemble her, and I truly believe she’s still so hurt and betrayed by Karlie for the whole scooter thing that she intentionally references J&K to cast doubt on their marriage. Why constantly reference your ex, who you claim to love and want back, when doing so threatens their livelihood. J’s family are powerful people who allegedly don’t like Karlie to begin with, I don’t think Taylor would risk pissing them off if she indeed loved K still. No way. Not when, for a family that rich and powerful, they could have a nasty custody battle for her son, she would lose. 100%.
Also, Hits Different Taylor says moving on is easy to do, but it hits different cause it’s you. She wrote in her diary “love is a myth/not real” around the time of a Dianna breakup, she sings “love is a lie” in hits different! She has clearly referenced Dianna since 1989, she has NOT gotten over her. Plus, Katy Perry’s song “Never Really Over” released in 2019 is clearly about Dianna.
Long Story Short implies that Taylor didn’t stand up for the first relationship with her Muse. They were outed and ended it abruptly back in 2013. Her and Karlie broke down either over the Scooter drama, or because Taylor couldn’t let go of Dianna.
My second point is just this image above, from rep. Thanks again Alex for the graphic. Clearly, rep isn’t about a man. But the fact that Taylor says if there’s no picture it never happened? Past 2013 you get NOTHING between Taylor and Dianna until SNL, and nothing after that. 2014-2016 she was clearly with Karlie, we have tons of evidence. She was loud. The muse for rep clearly was hidden very well, so well no photographic evidence exists. Not only has Taylor masterminded hiding her wlw relationships from Hetlors, she’s hidden her Muse from most GAYLORS. Truly impressive.
I know not everyone will believe this theory, but again, head on over to rabbit hole and read the master doc, keep an open mind. Let’s stay nice and respectful, it’s what Taylor would want.
”every bait and switch was a work of art” in Willow, a Dianna song??
Cmon guys! It’s Dianna, always has been.
41 notes
·
View notes