#jamespotterxlilyevans | Explore Tumblr Posts and Blogs

heloisedaphnebrightmore · 4 years

Text

Lesson from a Prefect pt. 2|2 [Sirius Black x Reader]

Title: Lesson from a Prefect pt. 2 ➔ Lesson from a Prefect pt. 1, Here! Pairing: Sirius Black x Reader Word count: 4.4k Published: 15 June, 2020 Author: Heloise Daphne Brightmore Notes: The story contained almost 9000 words, therefore I decided to cut it in half, not to overwhelm anyone. Summary: Being a prefect meant you didn’t have a good relationship with the Marauders. However Sirius takes an interest in you after you give him a piece of your mind. You are tricked into going on a date with Sirius and you are dreading every moment of it, but he turns out to be more than a lost because. Harry Potter Characters Masterlist | Masterlists

If you enjoy my stories, please consider donating and supporting me on Ko-fi. Of course, it’s completely your choice, I will continue updating for free anyway :) Thank you <3

You were sitting next to the Great Lake with Lily, dipping your feet into the water. It was a rather quite and warm afternoon. You felt Lily's gaze directed at you, before you finally turned towards her.

"Why are you looking at me like that?" You questioned giggling. She acted weirder than usual.

"I'm sorry." She apologised, making you frown.

"For what?" You scooted closer.

"For not telling you that I agreed to go on a date with James." You chuckled at her guilty expression.

"It's fine. I actually got pissed of at myself for saying such a dumb thing to Black." You shrugged.

"I think you should just enjoy it. He can be arrogant, ignorant, obnoxious..."

"Which part am I supposed to enjoy?" You laughed at your friend's certainly not too convincing list of traits.

"Let me finish." She chuckled. "Overall, he can be a dumb 16 years old boy. But you do know, that he is also funny, charming, attentive when he wants to be. I think you should just go and have fun. You might just have a date that you enjoy and then forget about, or it could even turn into something good. He seems to be serious about you though. He follows you like a puppy." She smiled as she turned around. You followed her direction to see Black and Potter close in on you and take a seat on each of your sides.

"Speak of the devil and he shall appear." You grinned at Lily who returned your expression.

"Did you just talk about us?" Sirius looked at you curiously?

"Let's just say, you briefly came up in the subject somewhere between annoying creatures and dumb people." You grinned at him stupidly.

"You need to do more if you want to offend me." He scoffed, but his smirk didn't seem to want to disappear.

"I will try harder next time." You grinned before turning towards the lake just in time to see the Giant squid's tentacles disappear. You felt Black's arm being placed around your shoulder, causing you to turn towards him. "Do I look like an armchair to you?" You asked, causing him to laugh at your weird joke.

"I'd rather be one, so you could sit on me all day." He sniggered.

"You are disgusting." You hit him on the chest gently, but for some reason your smile didn't seem to want to disappear.

"But you liked it though." He winked at you and you just hid your face in your palm. You started regretting that you ever got involved in their little games with Slytherin. You weren't sure what you have gotten yourself into, but you were definitely scared of enjoying Black's company too much. You took your bag and placed your shoes inside, before standing up and heading back to your dormitory, barefoot. "Tomorrow 11am in front of the Entrance." Black shouted after you, but instead of turning back you just showed a thumbs up gesture in reply. "Dress pretty." This time however you couldn't miss to turn around.

"Just for you, I will look like a homeless person, who hasn't showered in days." You grinned at him.

"I would still want you like that." His smirk grew bigger, causing you to laugh at his stupid comment before turning around and walking away.

The next morning came fairly quickly. You took care of your usual morning routines as fast as you could and decided on wearing your black, ripped skinny jeans and white v-neck shirt with a white, waist length, faux leather jacket you got from your mom at the beginning of the year. You were not good with make up, nor did you care to apply any. You simply took your black, cross shoulder bag you had stashed under your bed and put your wand, a warmer hoodie and some money into it.

Lily was still getting ready and you planned to wait for her, but your loudly growling stomach decided otherwise. You walked to the Great Hall and took some eggs and toast with some ham on the side, while pouring yourself a hot cup of tea with milk and sugar. As you enjoyed the food, Black and Potter joined your table, soon followed by Lupin and Pettigrew.

"Morning Beautiful." Black chuckled, placing his chin in his palm, while looking at you with a gentle smile.

"Are you blind or something?" You asked as if you had seen a ghost.

"I'm not. My sight is impeccable." He shook his head. "You just always look beautiful." He smirked.

"If you are going to act like that, I will turn back around before you can even blink." You stated turning back to your food, before you lost your appetite.

"Why can't you handle compliments?" He questioned and unfortunately he did find one of your weakest points.

"I just don't like flattery." You shrugged, not even looking up at him.

"It's not flattery if I sincerely mean it." He stated and you agreed with him. However you were incapable of accepting compliments, because you just always thought them to be false.

"Yes, it would be a compliment if you meant it, but usually people don't. They use compliments to kiss up to someone and I find it disgusting." You explained, still not even taking a glance towards Black.

"So what do I have to do to make you believe, that I am being sincere?" He questioned you and you just looked at him with no answer to come out of your mouth. You never really thought about it that way. You just always assumed it to be false and because you decided like that, with your little stubborn head, you never took compliments seriously. "You see, even you don't know the answer to that. If people want to give you compliments, just accept them. Yes, there are people who use flattery, but it doesn't mean all compliments are fake."

"You know, I guess you are not always useless." You smirked playfully.

"I am unsure if I should take that as compliment." He grinned at you.

"Take it however you want." You replied before finishing up your last piece of ham and wiping your mouth with a napkin of any excessive food that could have been left over.

You and the boys were waiting for Lily at the Entrance of the castle. Only a few minutes passed by when you saw your bestfriend appear in a knee length black skirt and a red knitted shirt, accessorised with a red shoulder bag.

Potter immediately walked up to her and offered his arm to her, which she happily accepted.

"He is suspiciously gentlemanly." You stated squinting at his behaviour. Black let out a quite chuckle next to you, before replying.

"You judge us way too badly. We are not such awful people as you make us out to be." He turned towards you.

"And I am a dementor in disguise." You smirked before turning around and walking towards Hogsmeade.

"Well, I have to tell you, it's definitely a very attractive disguise." He grinned causing you to roll your eyes.

"Do you ever shut up?" You questioned without looking at him. You were completely fixated on the road ahead of you.

"Only when they kiss me." He laughed at his own smart comment.

"I guess you will be talking all day then. Lucky me." You giggled at your response.

"Well, at least now you know, there's always an option to shut me up." He winked at you as you glanced towards him with a bored expression.

"Not happening, Black." You shook your head, protesting.

As soon as your group arrived to the High street of Hogsmeade, you decided to separate from each other. Potter and Lily planned to spend their date at Madam Puddifoot's while Pettigrew and Lupin wanted to visit Honeydukes to buy some of their favourite sweets. Black turned towards you waiting for a decision, but you didn't say anything.

"Where do you want to go? Madam Puddifoot's?" He asked, but you just shook your head.

"Don't really plan on being in the same environment as Potter and Lily. Who knows when they plan to suck each other's faces off." Black chuckled at your grossed out response.

"What about the Three Broomstick?" He asked, trying to give you some ideas.

"The last encounter I have had with Madam Rosmerta, didn't go down so well, so we might just want to skip that place." You chuckled awkwardly. "What about the the Hog's Head Inn?" You asked looking up at him, waiting for a reply.

"Well, if you don't mind it being old and dirty and filthy and smelly..." He wanted to continue, but you cut him off.

"I didn't think Sirius Black was such a picky person." You giggled, but before you could have blinked, he placed his hand on the small of your back and gently started pushing you towards the Hog's Head Inn. "I guess we are going there after all." You chuckled.

"Aren't you just the smartest person I know?" He smirked.

It barely took you 5 minutes to get to the pub. You sat down at one of the tables, right next to the window. You cleaned the dusty table off with your handkerchief, before you realised the dust was building up once again. You even saw your footsteps on the floor as they disrupted the built up dirt on the wooden rows.

"What do you want to drink?" He asked as you were looking around. It wasn't your first time in the Inn, but it always surprised you how filthy the place looked.

"I think I will just drink a Butterbeer." You replied, completely ignoring his gaze. Black walked up to the bar, where an old man, looking quite similar to Professor Dumbledore served him with the requested drinks.

Black walked back to you, carrying the drinks on a wooden tray, which he placed down on the table, before taking a seat himself.

"Isn't it such a cozy little place?" You asked smirking, which caused him to grimace at your words.

"Sure, and I like sleeping in coffins." He retorted with a witty comment.

"Whatever suits your taste, Black." You chuckled before taking a sip from your Butterbeer. Silence fell upon you, but you didn't mind. You quite enjoyed the situation to be fair. However it didn't take long, as Black decided to open his yapper, just like you expected him to.

"Why didn't you want to go on a date?" He asked curiously.

"Come on Sirius. Don't get me wrong, you are a handsome, fun and smart person, but I didn't see a reason to." You explained casually, but you were still fixated on the interior of the pub.

"What's your problem with me?" He asked frowning and this time you decided to turn towards him with a gentle smile.

"Nothing." You replied.

"Well, clearly there is something, if you say that you didn't see a reason to go out with me." He tilted his head in confusion. You actually found this behaviour of his quite adorable.

"There is nothing wrong with you. I simply don't plan to be part of your fan club, nor do I wish to be a name on your list of girls you shagged." You answered looking straight into his eyes. You could have sworn you saw a glimpse of hurt in his eyes for a mere second, but it disappeared as quick as it came.

"So that's all you think of me?" He asked with an unusually low tone.

"Well, I can't really imagine you with a girlfriend by your side." You shrugged. "It doesn't mean you are a bad person though. I just think, you need a bit more growing up to do." You replied honestly.

"What if this time I am being sincere?" He asked and for some reason you didn't know what to reply. It wasn't often that someone made you speechless, but he seemed to have that effect on you. "I wasn't joking when I said I wanted to get to know you better. Don't get me wrong, I am not asking you to marry me or move in with me. I am simply asking you to let us get to know each other better." This time you felt like you saw a more mature side of him and for some reason you believed him.

"I guess, that wouldn't be the worst thing that could happen to me." You smirked.

"I love the enthusiasm." He chuckled at your response.

For the next few hours, you spent your time talking about yourselves and your family, filled with continuous laughter. Even at the saddest and most pathetic parts, you found something positive or funny to laugh about and you definitely felt at ease next to Sirius. After hours of nagging, you finally agreed to call him by his first name which caused him to feel even more cocky. For the first time though, you didn't mind at all. It was somewhat fun and interesting to you.

"So sweetheart? Have you been enjoying the date?" He asked, even though he knew, from the amount of laughter you have had, you indeed were having a good time. It was obvious.

"I guess, it wasn't awful." You smirked which made him laugh.

"Why am I not surprised, that you just can't be honest?" He asked rhetorically, but you still decided to answer.

"That wouldn't be fun and your ego would grow even bigger and we of course don't want that to happen." You tilted you head innocently.

"You are such an evil person. I poured my heart out to you and you just ripped it apart." He fake gasped.

"You really need to improve your acting skills." You giggled as you stood up, put on your jacket and pulled the strap of the bag over your head. "Are you coming, or you will be staying here alone and feeling sorry for yourself?" You leaned closer just enough for him to not be able to create a coherent sentence as he was fixated between your eyes and lips. You enjoyed the situation way too much as you never knew that you could have such impact on someone. "I guess, I will be leaving alone." You whispered, before turning away and leaving the pub. Seconds later however Sirius appeared next to you.

"That was mean." He pouted, but you just chuckled at his sulking behaviour. You walked in front of him and stopped. He was about to walk in to you, but luckily he stopped in the last second. He looked at you confused.

"It's not my fault that you looked too adorable." You grinned at him. His grey eyes now took a darker shade as he took a step closer to you and slipped his hands around your waist.

"So you do like at least one of my many traits." He grinned at you proudly.

"Could possibly be more than one." You replied causing him to lean closer. He bit his lips as his eyes were roaming between your eyes and now pulsing lips, longing for him.

"I could possible make it many more." He whispered on your lips. You just wanted to feel him as close as possible. You wanted to feel his lips, his touch...

"Oooh!" You heard a voice and you jumped away from Sirius, causing him to swear under his breath.

"Perfect timing, Prongs." He hissed to his friend, now glaring at him as if he was more of an enemy.

"Sorry, did I interrupt?" Potter asked innocently.

"Just remember, I will be there to ruin all your moments." Sirius growled, but his attitude changed as soon as you placed your hand on his shoulder. He looked down and he met a gentle smile spreading across your face.

"Let's go back. We can always have a second date." You winked before walking past James and interlocked your arms with Lily's, waiting for her story-time.

"What about a third?" Sirius ran to your side.

"I guess we will have to see if I am still interested after the second date." You chuckled which caused his lips to turn into an ear to ear smile of some sort.

"Did I hear correctly? Still interested?" He referred to your previous comment.

"Maybe?" You replied before quickening your steps along Lily to finally be able to get some details out of her.

For the next few days, Sirius was attached to you, which honestly didn't even bother you. You enjoyed his company and his funny comments, even if they sometimes made you want to facepalm yourself.

He was quite attentive. He couldn't keep his hands off you. Whether it was your shoulder, your arm, your waist. He was all over you. At first you found it surprising, you even asked him if his hands had a life of their own, but slowly you grew to like it. You liked it more than you thought you would, which did scare you. What if you liked Sirius Black. You quickly shook that ridiculous thought out of your head. You enjoyed his company, but you still didn't believe that there could be more than a few banters and flirty comments.

You were talking to James in front of the Quidditch pitch. He actually quite grew on you after he and Lily started dating and you were forced to accept that he was not as bad as you thought he was to begin with. He was a less attractive and less funny version of Sirius, but you enjoyed hanging out with him, Remus and Peter.

As you and James talked, Sirius appeared behind you, wrapping his arms around your waist, hugging you from the back and resting his head in the crook of your neck.

"What did I miss?" He asked curiously.

"We were just talking about you." James stated with a grin.

"And what was that about? My handsome features? My sharp brain? My good Quidditch skills? My charming personality? My attractive body?" He kept going on and on, making you want to glue his lips together.

"Just silence yourself, please." You almost begged him.

"You know what to do if you want to shut me up." He winked, which you barely saw from your peripheral vision.

"Yes, curse you, hex you, jinx you and enjoy a holiday away from your non-stop moving mouth." You scoffed.

"You wish they were moving against yours." He laughed at his own comment causing your eyes to widen in surprise. You had no idea how to respond to that. You wanted to oppose, but Godric did you really want to taste his lips. "Are you not going to deny it?" He asked with a cheeky grin appearing on his face.

"Nope. It doesn't even deserve a reply." You scoffed, but was it hard to play the uninterested role.

"Come on, we both know that you are interested in me." He whispered leaning closer to your ear. "And I like you. It's not a secret." He continued before hinting a kiss on your neck and letting you go.

"I will be going." You rushed away before he could have caught you, but you could still hear his laughter.

You were eating in the Great Hall with your friends when a boy with blond hair and a tall figure, wearing a Ravenclaw cloak appeared in your vision.

"Can I talk to you?" He asked looking at you. Before answering, you looked around and then pointed at yourself to confirm. He nodded in response.

"Sure, I guess." You stood up and followed the boy towards the Entrance of the Great Hall.

"You know, I have been interested in you for a while. You are very pretty, incredibly smart and quite funny and it caught my attention. I wanted to know if you would go on a date with me some time." He was playing with his hands nervously while talking. You didn't really know how to react. You did date before, you weren't necessarily inexperienced, but he definitely took you by surprise.

"You see it is very flattering and I am very happy that you think of me in such adoring way, but..." You wanted to continue, but you were suddenly interrupted.

"What's going on?" You heard Sirius' voice coming from behind you.

"We were talking, Sirius and you rudely cut me off." You replied as you felt his arm slipping around your waist.

"Oh, I didn't know you two were together." The boy replied looking at Sirius' hand around you.

"We are not." You replied quickly.

"But we will be." Sirius answered this time.

"Excuse me?" You looked at him dumbfounded.

"You are excused." He laughed at his cunning comeback.

"I think I have a say in it too." You shook your head in disbelief. "And if you don't mind, can I finish my conversation with him?" You asked rhetorically, but he didn't quite get it.

"Sure, go ahead." He replied, but didn't even move an inch. You removed his hand from your waist and turned towards him this time.

"I would like to finish the conversation without your presence." You hissed, feeling a slight anger coming to the surface.

"Not happening." He replied, placing his hand back on your back. You removed it once again and turned towards the boy, who was now awkwardly standing around, watching the scene between you and Sirius.

"Look, I am very sorry, I will talk to you later, if that's okay." You wanted to be polite and the last thing you could do, was to reject him when noone was there. You didn't plan to embarrass him, especially not in front of the school's playboy.

"It's fine. I get it. I don't plan on going after Black's property." He replied and you were debating to curse him or attack him physically.

"I am noone's property and you people better engrave that into your useless little heads." You swiftly turned away and walked back to the Great Hall, still huffing and puffing over the boy's response. You were noone's property. You were a bloody human, for Godric's sake.

"Hey, calm down." Sirius ran after you, getting hold of your arm before you could have reached your friends. "What's wrong?"

"I am noone's property and I have a say in what I want to do. We will be together? What does that even mean? I can make a decision without you barking into it and I definitely don't need you to protect me from a boy, who just asked me out. And what if I wanted to say yes, huh? Do you ever use your brain? We are not dating really, we simply went on 1, let me repeat that, one date. I definitely don't need you as a guardian angel of some sort." You kept on ranting, but Sirius had just a huge smile sitting across his face. "Why are you even laughing? For Godric's sake, you are getting on my nerves, Sirius." Your monologue turned into more of a sulking, than angry ranting.

"Am I correct to assume that the same option applies to you when you need to be shut up?" He chuckled seeing your confused expression.

"What are you talking about, again? You think it's funny? I don't find enjoyment in you getting involved in my personal life. Why can't you just behave like..." Before you could have continued, Sirius pulled you closer by your waist and attached his lips to yours. It's like your body was waiting for him all along, you started kissing him back the second his lips touched yours. There was nothing gentle about it though. It was passionate and hungry, as you tried to recover the lost time you didn't spend in each other's arms. As Sirius forced you to part from each other, you two were panting frantically, gasping for the air you cut yourselves off from.

"That was worth the wait." Sirius chuckled, but you were just standing there gobsmacked realising that the whole Great Hall went silent. Your only thought was; What's just happened? Sirius turned you around and led you to the table, back to the seat you previously occupied without ever taking your eyes off him. "Are you okay?" Sirius turned to you now with concern in his eyes as you sat down, but you still couldn't look away.

"I should be angry, you know?" You questioned, but as much as you wanted to get pissed off at him, for forcing himself onto you, you couldn't just deny how badly you were longing for that kiss.

"But you will not be." He smirked proudly.

"And why is that?" You asked with a raised brow, clear curiosity in your tone.

"Because you like me too much." His grin grew even bigger, if that was even possible. "And because you know that I like you a lot too."

"You always have to be right, don't you?" You smirked this time, grabbing his tie and pulling him in for another kiss.

"I don't have to, I just always am." He laughed as he planted a kiss on your neck.

"Congratulations, love birds." James smiled at your lovey-dovey behaviour.

"We can go on double dates now." Lily chirped happily.

"Let's just run away." You told Sirius causing him to chuckle at your idea.

"With you, anywhere!" He replied, planting another kiss on your lips.

You were glad that things worked out the way they did and even though you weren't sure that you made a completely sane decision, you just wanted to be happy and you definitely were in that moment.

Notes: If you enjoyed it, don’t forget to like and/or reblog the chapter. Thank you :)

If you enjoy my stories, please consider donating and supporting me on Ko-fi. Of course, it’s completely your choice, I will continue updating for free anyway :) Thank you <3

121 notes · View notes