Tumgik
#he's only doing it because he doesn't want frodo to be alone in this
thefreakandthehair · 1 year
Text
"You can trust us to stick with you through thick and thin — to the bitter end. And you can trust us to keep any secret of yours — closer than you keep it yourself." Eddie quotes at Steve, poking him in the chest. Steve watches as Eddie sways, just a tiny bit but it betrays the facade of sobriety he'd been trying to hold.
Eddie’d once had a better tolerance but he couldn’t drink throughout his recovery and everyone was finding that Eddie is a tactile, Lord of the Rings-quoting type of drunk as a result.
They’re alone in the corner of Steve’s living room, their arms wrapped one another, and it mustn’t be shocking because no one is looking their way. Only their closest friends are present and they’re left with plenty of room to touch without strange looks.
"But you cannot trust us to let you face trouble alone, and go off without a word. We are your friends, Frodo." Eddie finishes and flashes a warm smile at Steve and sure, Steve is a little less than sober himself but it’s the same smile Eddie’s been tossing him for fucking months and Steve is just tipsy enough to catch it.
“You tryin' to tell me something, Munson?” Steve asks, reaching one arm out to steady his friend. Yeah, sure, just a friend, his mind teases.
It’s been a solid six or so months since they’d been victorious against Vecna and shut down the Upside Down for good. And okay, he and Eddie have shared a bed more nights than they haven’t since then and it’s perhaps been a lot more than just friendly to Steve, but he’s learned not to make assumptions.
People don’t always feel about him the way he feels about them, and he can handle that. He can. At least, he can until Eddie starts drunkenly quoting the Lord of the Rings at him after a few shots at his New Years Eve party leading into ‘87. He’s got one hand wrapped around the back of neck, absently tugging on the hair at the nape, and Steve is trying to sober up enough so he doesn’t kiss his friend and read this all wrong.
“You were Frodo, Steve. And I was Sam. And I love you.” Eddie says, giggly but genuinely with both his hands digging into Steve’s waist now. The grin is real— it touches his glossy eyes and spreads across his face easily.
And I love you bounces around like a rogue ping pong ball in Steve’s chest. Steve sees that Eddie’s drunk— he can tell from the giggle, the tight grip on his skin, the glossy eyes. And Steve is heartbroken. He’s been head over heels for the man in front of him for at least the three months, consciously at least, and here he is, reminding Steve of everything he can’t have.
“Man, don’t say shit like that if you don’t mean it, alright?” Steve tries to make it joking, tries to laugh and smile in the way he thinks he should because Eddie's drunk but shit, if he hasn't daydreamed about Eddie saying those words to him. 
Eddie though? Well, Eddie might be drunk but goddamn it he knows Steve. And he means it. He loves Steve so much, it feels like it's trying to claw its way out of his body. He's just tipsy enough to finally tell him.
“Stevie, I do mean it. I mean okay—”  Eddie readjusts his Zeppelin shirt beneath his leather jacket and stands taller, fingers threading their way through Steve’s belt loops. “I may not be completely sober but I’m like, completely fuckin' in love with you? How dumb is that?” He laughs and ducks his head against Steve’s chest, wrapping his arms around back Steve's waist where this all began.
“Not dumb at all, Ed. Not dumb at all. Ball’s gonna drop soon, wanna watch it?” Steve feels Eddie's laugh against his chest where he holds Eddie tighter, suddenly afraid of beginning a new year. Eddie clings to him and Steve's brain begins a hysterical loop of questions like What if Eddie suddenly doesn't want to be this close when it's not 1986? When it's not the same year that we'd met and fought demons together? What if this fades, like everything else has?
"I dunno, do you love me? Be a hell of a way to ring in a new year, gettin' kissed by the one and only Steve Harrington!" Eddie's question throws a stick into the wheel of his looping brain, screeching it to a halt.
Steve knows this isn't the time and he knows Eddie probably won't even remember this in the morning but he does it anyways. He pulls back, takes a look around the room where all of their friends are cheering and counting down.
Robin had started the countdown at 60 seconds, just a touch too early, and they're only at 47 when Steve runs both of his shaking hands up and down the length of Eddie's arms. The last time they approach Eddie's shoulders, he keeps them there and inches closer, searching Eddie's wide, beguiled eyes for hesitation and finds none. Just finds what he always does: warmth, joy, comfort.
"39!"
"38!"
"37!"
"Ed, stop me if I've got it wrong."
"36!"
"35!"
"Definitely not wrong, Steve."
"33!"
"32!"
It's still 1986 when Steve Harrington finally kisses Eddie Munson. It's soft, gentle, close-lipped and tender without pushing for more. Eddie's fingers go numb and his toes curl in his boots, and Steve sees colors in a new way when they pull away and open their eyes.
"I do love you, Eddie." Steve says, breathless and happy in a way he hasn't been in years. He's still afraid, but even if he only gets this one moment, he's going all in for it. "So fucking much."
One palm comes up to rest on Steve's cheek, warm metal against his skin in the way of Eddie's rings. "It's not even the new year yet." He says with a laugh and a smile with his bottom lip between his teeth.
"19!"
"18!"
"Couldn't wait. I'll do it again in 1987, if you'll let me?"
"Any year, any dimension, Steve."
The countdown is getting closer and Dick Clark is yelling on the television when Steve grabs Eddie's hand and pulls him to join their friends, one arm slung over his shoulders and Eddie's around his waist. Steve gets a beaming smile and cocked eyebrow from Robin and his nod is all she needs.
"7!"
"6!"
"5!"
People start pairing off, and Steve's sober enough to realize that none of this would have made sense to him just a few months prior. Robin pulls Nancy closer with the hand not holding an obnoxiously loud noisemaker, Argyle smiles meaningfully at Jonathan, and Steve finds himself being spun back to face Eddie.
"Ready?"
"3!"
"2!"
"1!"
It's 1987 when Eddie Munson finally kisses Steve Harrington. They don't join the chorus of Happy New Year's! around them because it's Eddie's turn to kiss Steve, and he fucking does. A little harder, a little more tongue, a bite or two when Steve returns the same eagerness and impatience. It's Eddie who breaks the kiss, lips shiny and swollen.
"Gotta good feeling about '87, Stevie. Got a really good feeling."
870 notes · View notes
anneangel · 26 days
Text
When I try to explain why 'I love' and 'don't love' The Hobbit, trilogy and book:
Peter Jackson, screenwriters, Warner Bros executive directors: Do you like The Hobbit Trilogy?
Me: oh, yes. I love 90% of it. And the cast is wonderful and the soundtrack incredible. I love 'movie Smaug', and I find interesting that the dwarves gain more prominence than in the book, transforming them into more central characters in the plot.
Peter Jackson, screenwriters, WB: What are your criticisms about it?
Me: There are many good scenes from the original plot that were changed for the movie without need because were already good in the book, many tense scenes in the book were transformed into 'action scenes', such as the escape from the Misty Mountains, Mirkwood and the escape in the barrels. And why revive Azog when just Bolg would be enough? And you guys shit on the character Beorn. And, well, the name of the movies are 'The Hobbit', there should be more Bilbo in this, right?
Peter Jackson, screenwriters, WB: So you like the book that much?
Me: oh, yes, I love 95% of it.
Peter Jackson, screenwriters, WB: Do you even have something honest criticisms of book?
Me: well, there could be SOME female participation, and I could follow Gandalf's journey to the White Council and Dol Guldur, both happen, but in the plot of the book it 'll not be narrated to us because the focus is on Bilbo and only him. And Thranduil doesn't even have a name, he's just called the 'Elvenking' of the Forest, let alone his son Legolas. Radagast is underused and only mentioned once. I would like more to be 'narrated' than 'told' to us. Understand? More dialogues actually describing what they went through, and less summarizing as 'after much deliberation they decided', it's something told. Maybe if the book was more 'narrated' than 'told', then it would be much bigger than it is. Well, It would be interesting to see the narrative from more perspectives.
Peter Jackson, screenwriters, WB: but that's exactly what we try to deliver in the movies! We gave you Galadriel, Tauriel and gave you Bard's daughters, hey, there's your female representation. And we gave you the White Council and Dol Guldur, we gave you more Elrond, and Radagast and even Saruman. We even gave you a badass and handsome Thranduil and we even gave you Legolas. Fuck you, we even gave you Frodo!
Me: Correct. I like the fillers created for the trilogy, nothing against them, the intention was great, the actors play their characters very fine and everyone did wonders with what they had, truly cool, the problem is that I don't like the PLOT of the fillers. Only that.
Peter Jackson, screenwriters, WB: So, in your opinion, the problem is our bad writing plot for fillers?
Me: oh, that's right. Exactly. With the exception of this, everything else was very good.
Peter Jackson, screenwriters, WB: But you can't just blame us! Others also failed miserably in this production, right?
Me: Oh, but the costume designers did relatively fine, cinematographers and art directors too, with the exception of Beorn's design, everything else is tolerable. Even if it wasn't faithful to the book on some aspects, but that's why it's called 'adaptation'. Including the CGI was 'ok', which many complain about, but I think it's an excessive criticism because it's reasonable compared to other current Worldwide Box Office movies similar to The Hobbit Trilogy.
Peter Jackson, screenwriters, WB: So, for you, what really left something to be desired was the plot written of the fillers and plot of changed scenes? Is it?
Me: Oh, yeah. I wouldn't be so critical of the 'need' for to be three movies, if the filler plot and new scenes was better written. But hey, I still like a lot about The Hobbit, whether it's the book or the movies. For example, now just talking about The Hobbit makes me want to read my favorite parts of the book and watch my favorite parts of the trilogy! Haha! Understand now?
21 notes · View notes
emblazons · 11 months
Note
what are your favorite byler headcanons?
—I never get asked this question, so thanks for being the first lmao. (I did write my “S5 hopes” before, but these are different I think?) Anyway. Hmmm.
While they both love Tolkien, Mike likes the Lord of the Rings trilogy books more, but Will enjoys the Hobbit best. Mike loves the depth of the lore and complexity of how Tolkien describes things in the original trilogy because they help him when he’s coming up with campaigns, but Will enjoys the straightforward (and a little sweeter) narrative of The Hobbit more—and also has a preference for it because the version he had as a kid was more image-heavy, and he’s an artist. :)
Speaking of Tolkien—Mike absolutely has a one-ring he keeps around his neck like Frodo. (It may even be what he chooses as an engagement ring way, way down the line, but Will is so outdone he decides to just buy it to wear it around his neck instead lol).
When it comes to getting work done, Mike is a think-out-loud type—as in, will talk to himself out loud and not even realize he’s doing it when alone, or with someone he’s comfortable getting into his head around. Will doesn’t say anything about it, because he thinks it’s hilarious—but Mike eventually learns about his own tendency when Will knows about a surprise he had planned before he can even do it…because he was thinking out loud. (He gets up in arms about how Will should have told him, but the more time passes, the funnier the tendency becomes to them).
Mike was hype as hell for the release of Jurassic Park in 1993. Will was also hype, but. Not nearly as excited about it as Mike was. When the Peter Jackson’s LOTR adaptation was announced, they were both over the moon (though Will was a bit scared. He is very picky about his movies, and adaptations even more so).
The two of them would settle in San Francisco, and would definitely be the ones who run a “teach DnD / campaign night” in conjunction with a comic book store in their neighborhood, in an attempt to keep the younger generations’ love for it alive—the same way as the bookstore owner who introduced them to the book. this is maybe based on an actual comicbook store with a dnd night in the SF Castro that I found a few years ago. The world may never know. They are thrilled in 2016 when a new Netflix show (😉) and Critical Role revives people’s love for it when they’re much, much older.
The first time the topic of “going to pride” comes up in the mid-90’s (long before it was the socially accepted event it is today), Will is mildly terrified—and so is Mike, but his “brave paladin” side absolutely talks himself up enough to get Will to join him solely out of a need to prove he can. They end up having a great time, and Mike, who has never really delved into queer history, ends up on a whole tangent of learning about it for an entire month afterward. Will finds it v endearing.
Mike sucks at poker because he cannot keep a single thing off his face. He is, however, really good at playing “the house” in card games, so that’s the role he takes on (comes from years of leading campaigns. He’s a bit of a showman that way).
Will cannot stand cold even after he’s disconnected from Vecna/the UD, and misses California—which is why they move back. When “global warming” talk starts becoming more common, his favorite dad joke to make is “if I think it’s getting hot, it must be,” but no one but the party & family know why it’s funny.
Earlier into their relationship, Will becomes a bit troubled by the fact that Mike is the only person he ever dated. It causes tension in their relationship for a little while, though Will eventually realizes he doesn't want to be with anyone else, so it doesn't matter. (Much later, Mike admits that he thought Will’s concerns were unfounded, considering the only person he ever dated outside of Will happened when he was 13 & probably shouldn’t have even been his girlfriend in the first place, given the fact that she was 3 seconds out of a lab…& he doesn’t even like women anyway).
Mike knows Will is healing more from “the events of the show” when Will starts making dark-humor jokes about being possessed and/or being lost in the upside down—though it takes him a lot to get used to it, given how scared he spent years being about losing Will. Eventually he gets on board and laughs—which Will appreciates, because it helps him to see Mike get less uncomfortable and feel safer about keeping Will safe after all that happened.
There are ten I could think of off top?? LMAO someone ask @magentamee what my other headcanons are I’m sure she’s heard them all by now 😂
Thanks so much for this ask!
50 notes · View notes
Note
Omigod I just found you and I absolutely love with how you write Sam🥹🙏🏻🙏🏻❤️. Could you possibly do a reader who's usually very bubbly and hyper around people, but when she's alone with Sam she gets shy and flustered quite a bit. Maybe Sam gets more confident and his ego boots up? Idk😭 maybe both sfw and nsfw headcannons? It's okay if you don't want to! Love your writing!
(ah thank you so much! I'm so happy that you like my writing, and I'm even happier that people are actually requesting content for Sam! he doesn't get the attention he deserves)
(Sam x gender neutral!reader, some nsfw content - hope you enjoy!)
He is first drawn to you because of how sweet and friendly you seem, and it's a little disheartening to see how quiet you are when it's just the two of you.
Sam is a bit of an overthinker, so at first when he realizes that you act different around him he figures he must've done something wrong or you just don't enjoy spending time with him that much, which he is upset by but he tries to give you space.
It's only when the other hobbits catch on to your behavior and start teasing him (eventually Frodo has to sit him down and tell him) that he starts actively trying to talk to you again.
While before he was reading too much negatively into all your actions. he starts to see your true feelings hidden behind every exchange. The shy look down when he smiles at you, the blush on your cheeks when he talks to you, the stutter in your voice when you reply - it's an ego boost to say the least.
He makes way more of an effort to spend time with just you, while he secretly builds up the courage to ask you out. This doesn't take as much time as he thought it would since, as it turns out, having so much attention on him really helped his confidence.
Your behavior around him gives Sam more of a quiet confidence. He won't become incredibly cocky and he certainly won't make fun of you for being shy (he might make a brief teasing comment when he asks you out but nothing more). It's a feeling he keeps to himself, but the one change you might notice is that he's a lot more certain of his actions and he stops second-guessing himself.
(NSFW)
If you're naturally more submissive (assuming you probably are if you act like that around people you like lmao) then Sam will lean slightly more dominant to compensate.
(I've made a previous post about dom!Sam go check it out)
He will absolutely take advantage of how shy you are and, no matter how flustered you are, he will not touch you until you tell him in detail what you want him to do to you.
Regardless of any of this though, he will spoil you in bed. He is a giver and that will never change.
You have him completely wrapped around your little finger - if you giggle shyly and tuck your hair behind your ear he is somehow already hard and he doesn't understand how.
(god forbid you ever take advantage of this)
61 notes · View notes
lalaloobzy · 5 months
Text
Random aspec fictional character HCs
Matthew Cuthbert (Anne With an E)
Asexual + aromantic
Tumblr media
Lived his whole life unmarried like his sister but, unlike Marilla, never had any relationships in the past. Doesn't reciprocate Jeannie's feelings and tells her his love for his adopted daughter (Anne) is the only love he has room for. Was TERRIFIED when Anne tried to set him up with Jeannie.
*(this is specific to AWAE but I think it can apply to book Matthew as well)
Selah Summers (Selah and the Spades)
Asexual + aromantic
Tumblr media
Tbh this one might be canon (or at least heavily implied). Never has been in a relationship. Admits to Paloma that she's just never been interested in anyone in a romantic or sexual way.
Monkey D. Luffy (One Piece)
Asexual + aromantic
Tumblr media
Just doesn't seem remotely interested in romance or sex. Gets grossed out/ annoyed when people kiss in front of him.
*(this is specific to the anime, idk about the manga or live action adaptation)
**(I am not caught up on the anime, this may turn out to be incorrect)
Willie Jack Sampson (Reservation Dogs)
Asexual + aromantic
Tumblr media
Never had a love interest or showed attraction in the show (to the best of my knowledge. If she did, I missed it). Also, THIS OUTFIT SPECIFICALLY. Her hoodie is aroace colors and her socks look like a mix of the asexual flag and the aromantic flag.
Lucy Wells (Harlots)
Grey asexual/ greysexual (+possibly aromantic? Maybe demiromantic? I haven't decided yet)
Tumblr media
Born into prostitution but HATES sex. Avoids it as much as she can and by the last season finds a way to do her job without having to have sex. The reason I said grey ace is because she DOES seem sexually attracted to Fallon after some time of being with him (I think? I was a little confused about how she felt tbh).
Birdy (Birdy)
Asexual + demiromantic
Tumblr media
Everyone in his life thinks it's weird that he's so interested in birds and not girls. Admits to Al he doesn't see the appeal of sex at all. Very reluctant to go to prom with Doris and had no idea what to do when she parked the car and offered him sex. I can see him developing romantic feelings after close friendship (like with Al) which is why I think he's demiromantic.
Bilbo AND Frodo Baggins (The Hobbit/ The Lord of the Rings)
Both asexual (+ maybe demiromantic, though I can also see Bilbo as aro)
Tumblr media
Both remained bachelors all their lives. Bilbo lived alone and later with Frodo who was like an adopted son. Frodo lives for a long time with Sam and Sam's wife Rosie. I personally think that Sam and Frodo are in a romantic relationship, while Sam and Rosie are in a sexual relationship. Frodo seems content with this arrangement which is why I believe he's ace.
Ted Buckland (Scrubs)
Asexual
Tumblr media
Simply because of the part where Carla says "I don't want any MAN filming me giving birth unless he's completely asexual" and then Ted walks in with a camera and Carla smiles and says "oh hi Ted!". (I think this was a poorly-aged joke about him being "ugly" more than anything but I'm still claiming it). Also when he sings the duet with Gooch and Gooch says "I want to screw you" while Ted says "I want to kiss you.
Fabian Rutter (House of Anubis)
Asexual
Tumblr media
He's nerdy and into space (I know this is a stereotype but representation is scarce I take anything I can get... you get it right). Also his relationship with Nina is very innocent and I can't see him developing sexual attraction even when he becomes an adult.
Dirk Gently and Bart Curlish (Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency)
Dirk- Asexual
Bart- Aromantic
Tumblr media
Neither of them have love interests in the show (although Bart/Ken may have been implied) so this is just how I felt about the characters personally. I think Dirk definitely had a crush on Todd and is gay but I don't think he gets sexual attraction. Bart is the opposite. I can see her developing sexual attractions and feelings but being repulsed by kissing/ dating etc.
*(this is specific to DGHDA, idk about any other versions of these characters)
Anybody feel free to add thoughts and your personal aspec character hcs <3
15 notes · View notes
carolinekatze · 1 year
Text
Lord of the Rings Characters Playing Mario Kart
Inspired by the fact the my father literally begged me to play Mario Kart with him last night.
----
Aragorn-Honestly is very bad and can only come above last place with the bumpers on, but still has fun. Gets excited when he gets a cool power up like Bullet Bill or whatever that thing is that makes you rainbow. He throws a lot of blue shells cuz he's always in last.
Merry-Horrible winner. He's really good and will let you know. Convinces everyone else to turn the bumpers off. Has literally no self control during Mario Kart, will say or do anything. If someone does manage to beat him he is a sore loser. Always plays as a classic character like Mario or Luigi.
Pippin-Insufferable if he manages to win or even comes in the top five. He's really obsessed with those mini battle games and will make everyone play them because he's good at them. Plays as Cat Peach
Frodo-Pretty average and doesn't take the game too seriously. He only uses the cars that look like real cars. Always uses the same character and that character is Lakitu
Sam-Sam is that guy that acts like he doesn't really know how to play and then kicks everyone's ass. He's very humble about it and sometimes lets other people win cuz he feels bad. Uses Shy Guy
Gandalf-Would rather be playing Sonic Riders (does anyone else remember this game or just me???) Yoshi enjoyer. Comes from behind for the win.
Boromir-Thinks that playing with the bumpers on is cheating and ruins the game. Picks his car by actually looking at the stats. Probs plays as Bowser.
Legolas-Really chill and very good at pelting people with items. Plays as Isabelle from Animal Crossing cuz that's his favorite game.
Gimli-Angry, enjoys Wario's Gold Mine. Will yell at someone for throwing a shell at him. Constantly runs into his own banana peels. Has thrown a remote and suffered the consequences
Faramir-Mid Mario Karter. Usually would rather just hang out and watch than actually play. He gives good commentary. When he does play he's always Koopa Troopa
Éomer-Has no idea what is happening. Has never played this game before. Falls off of the edge constantly because he doesn't know how to turn the bumpers on.
Éowyn-Only uses the baby characters. Kicks Merry's ass. Best trash talker. Always in the top three at least.
Arwen-Picks her vehicle based purely on how cute it looks. Not at all interested in stats, doesn't want to hear about it, leave her alone. Enjoys speeding past Boromir on her Yoshi scooter with button wheels.
135 notes · View notes
sage-nebula · 1 year
Note
Tails ~
What I like about them
Tails fits the definition of a classical antihero. While nowadays we think of antiheroes as brooding types who are willing to do less-than-heroic things to get the job done, in classical literature an antihero was a character who, while heroic, displayed personality traits that weren't often associated with heroes. For instance, a classical antihero might be wrangle with self-doubt where a classical hero is confident. A classical antihero may be physically weak where a classical hero is physically strong, so on and so forth. Frodo Baggins is an example of a classical antihero, and so, too, is Tails. And I like this because it gives us interesting avenues to explore his character from. Sonic is great, but as a traditional hero he doesn't wrangle with things like self-doubt or anxiety. What you see is what you get with him: just a guy who loves adventure. But perhaps in part due to being a literal genius, Tails is a lot more cerebral and there's a lot more introspection with him, particularly given his shortcomings and weaknesses. Exploring the ways he grows and learns to work with his anxieties and traumas, rather than against them, makes his character really interesting.
Also, he is so fucking cute oh my god.
What I dislike about them
His character writing has been, to put it politely, inconsistent over the years. He went through all that growth in the Adventure games just to have it completely ripped the fuck away from him in later ones (particularly Forces). It's not great and most days I pretend I do not see it.
Favourite moment
In the games: Either the moment he threw hands with Eggman when he thought Eggman had killed Sonic in Adventure 2, or the acknowledgement of his issues and his whole arc in Frontiers rolled up into one.
In animation: Either saying that Sonic was his "mom, dad, and picket fence" in AoStH, or the episode in AoStH where Sonic was turned to stone and so Tails spent the whole episode trolling Scratch and Grounder Home Alone style. Again, he is so fucking cute oh my god.
In the IDW comics: Either catching Sonic with the Tornado in the middle of the Angel Island arc, or crashing the airship into Neo Metal at the end of that arc, or when he said goodbye to the Cyclone because he had to sacrifice her during the Metal Virus arc, or when he figured out how to take down Surge in their fight against her in the city, or defending Sonic from Kit, or immediately building guns to go save Sonic in the Scrapnik Island mini series, or . . .
Least favourite moment
Forces 🙃All of Forces. I hate it so fucking much.
Also not a fan of how they made him fight Sonic in the Archie comics. Really, any situation which pits those two against each other is an automatic Nope.gif in my books. I will smack that back button so fast, don't test me.
A situation with this character that I want to see explored more
How he's developing his technology to utilize clean energy! We see that he's using hydro power to fuel the Mystic Ruins workshop in the IDW comics; I want more exploration on how Tails' development of technology is not only not detrimental to the planet, but actually works to reverse the damage that Eggman does. Technology doesn't have to destroy the planet; it can be a clean force for good, too!
An interesting AU for this character
Can I promote my own fic Beyond Oblivion? Because that's an interesting AU to me!
A crossover
I'm still very much in love with my Night in the Woods crossover, where Tails spends an autumn in Possum Springs during his solo journeys. All anthro stories take place in the same universe and this one happens in my head and in my heart even if Sega thinks it could never work in canon. Sega doesn't pay me, they can't dictate what I do.
OTP (or OT3+ etc…. just… favourite ship)
None. In fact, adaptations that have tried to give Tails romances (Archie, Sonic X, Boom) are off-putting to me because they try to give Tails romances. He doesn't need a romance for his story to be interesting! In fact, I think a romance arc for him is far more boring than the alternatives like exploring how he overcomes his inner demons or focusing on the clean energy alternatives he creates to improve the world. And even if you want to explore him with other characters, platonic relationships and platonic love stories are a thing! Tails' brotherly relationship with Sonic, his friendships with Amy and Knuckles—these are interesting stories and romance isn't a part of them. Destroy the heterosexual notion that every character must be paired off for a story to be good.
Other ships?
Nope.
BROTP
His big bro Sonic, of course! Like I said above, platonic love stories are a thing, and the platonic love story in Sonic and Tails finding a family in each other when they were both orphaned has been one of my favorites since I was four years old. I don't think that's going to change any time soon.
NOTP
I wish people who ship Sonic with Tails romantically a very do not ever interact with me, ever, in any capacity. Thank you.
An assortment of headcanons!
I have a lot! You can read some here, and here, and here :)
79 notes · View notes
silver-wield · 2 months
Note
The thing about aerith you just shared is fascinating. If we're going with the theme of " there's nothing I don't cherish" and the complete 180° of Zack's character with aerith in terms of stereotypes of heroism.
With Zack, Cloud cries for a good person. Someone he idolized.
With Aerith, cloud cries for uh not so good person (I'm being generous here). Someone he treated severely most of the time.
But both he was grateful for. Both he cried for. Just like with anything. Like, look at how he described jessie in Rebirth. We know she didn't treat him well but in cloud's perspective he was grateful for her reaching out to him. Giving him materia, inviting him with the gang for pizza. I think once wedge told him that she's just being a prick, he ended up being more relaxed about it. But you know what's up? He doesn't think of her romantically AT ALL. Not even a prospect even for a milisecond. She's actually very similar to the way aerith was written here btw.
But yes, long story short. He cherishes everything. Good and bad. But there's only one person he'll ever come to be attracted to and in love with. Tifa obviously duh.
But yeah, like you said, she's an awful person who so happens to be one of the "good guys" in the story. If a clumsy guy can be a hero (Cloud), if the perfect hero can be a hero (Zack), if the perfect heroine can be a hero (Tifa), then, the most questionable person can also be a hero (aerith).
Lol the Sibling energy going strong here, if you noticed what I mean 😂.
But overall, It fits. It's a game with the theme of LIFE in it. We meet so many people.
So in short Nojima is challenging us through aerith to see that. Don't lavish her with flowery words nor look at her through rose tinted glasses (puns intended). LOOK AT HER. She's a POS but she got friends who care for her. She may take them for granted A LOT but she will be there to help save the planet they live in. That's one way to look at it.
But Cloti is TOO KIND still lol. So they need better boundaries and standards for friendship.
Also low key aerith reminds me of gollum here. Gollum is ACTUALLY a hero himself. And if Frodo (cloti) didn't let him into their circle, but they did due to their kindness. They will never be able to kill sauron. So Gollum, by sheer greed and all. Bit Frodo's finger, catches the ring and falls with it. So if they never let aerith into the group, welcomed her with open arms, she wouldn't have been able to do her task and see to it as much as she can. Than alone.
That was long but yeah. Sorry to aerith fans since I compared her to gollum. But it has nothing to do with his looks, just the function he has in the story. And HE IS A VERY IMPORTANT CHARACTER.
That's what I think. What's interesting tho is at least Cloud has the interest and self awareness of knowing he doesn't or does but wanting to prove he deserves Tifa. The modernized Yamato Nadeshiko. Meanwhile aerith is the complete opposite. She just believes she's entitled to it regardless. Zack has uh, an interesting type I'd say. It cringes me he's into "city mouse" but notice the animal she's being compared to lmao. Tbh they're kind of the same in one aspect not only their upbeat personality. Zack would never bat an eye on her if she didn't had the same complexity she had with being weird and different. Same with aerith, she'd never care at all. This will never apply to cloud even if he ends up being a soldier, because he wants to be special afterall, he will never understand aerith and zack's insecurities. But Zack doesn't think being a soldier is special, he feels like a monster but still he wants to be a hero.
Tumblr media
I mean nobody has any issues with Cait Sith, a literal Shinra spy, being a good guy. Nobody has issues with Vincent, a former turk who probably did a lot of questionable shit, being a good guy.
Cid also worked for Shinra and knew Ifalna and never tried to help her despite seeing her around Hojo's lab, but he's a good guy.
Everybody is a flawed hero, but Aerith's flaws are worse because hers cause harm to her own friends. Everybody else's personality flaws are external in nature and project outward towards other characters who aren't part of their group, but Aerith and Cait Sith's flaws project internally to the group. Cait gets ousted after betraying them and Aerith dies.
It's almost like those harmful to the greater good of the planet are removed from the party. Cait returns with a better attitude in a new robot body, but the one that betrayed them also dies.
13 notes · View notes
mischieffoal · 7 months
Text
LotR Musical: Round 3!
Just a bunch of my thoughts, once more. From Wednesday 4th October matinee
Pre-Show: 
Hobbit!Gimli asked if I wanted to play Ring-toss, and Lobelia challenged me to a game… if I gave her a spoon if she won. I went on stage, shook hands, bowed, played and failed, she got one, shook hands, happily congratulated her with a spoon. Which Rosie then accused her of stealing from me! The audacity!! 
Tumblr media
Also, I gave Fatty a chocolate bar, and he loves it when people come back again because they always bring him snacks. Got some very funny photos with him. Also, he was having great fun yelling about food - “Hey! Everyone! If you want a Mars Bar, they’ve got a whole bag!”
Tumblr media Tumblr media
Mrs. Bolger came and chatted to us about the party, and birthdays, and Rose having her birthday the day before Bilbo’s, and Fatty and Mrs.’ twins being born then too! A busy time in the Shire! The little fauntlings are over their with Fatty’s mum! For Bilbo’s speech, Gollum sat right behind me on the picnic table! He was wearing such a cute jumper. I have a problem. 
Tumblr media
Act 1:
Gandalf!! I like this understudy! Actually much better than the original! Patrick Bridgman. More sure of himself, powerful in a way, authoritative. Felt more magic and different from the elves than Peter.
Aragorn carries Frodo in so many different ways in the space of about a minute (fireman's, bridal, piggyback, shoulders round)
When Bilbo says "I'm worried I'll turn into him", Gollum pokes his head in from the side and sneers. I’ve never noticed it before, it’s that subtle. You would only notice it at all if you’d seen it before, because he’s still in full hobbit costume. Holy shit it sent chills down my spine.
Each time they mentioned rings and losing their power, they all held theirs, including Elrond who doesn't even mention his
All the Hobbits are so HAPPY all the time up to and during star of Earendil, when around them others are worried and scared and sad - but they’re still set on their Adventure!! I love them!!
Gimli's outfit has the knotwork on the set, lit up in Moria, I really like that detail. It’s obvious, I just hadn’t made the connection before. He’s connected to the “earth” around them. 
Gandalf hugging Sam into Moria. Everyone in this show hugs so much and I love that.
It's *Legolas* who tells Merry that Gimli is singing a song of his ancestors. Goddddd the elf/dwarf everything in this musical. (Earlier, in the council, Gimli has to sit down on a bench next to Legolas, clearly hesitates, and Legolas literally turns his body away from him once he’s sat down)
The movement in Lothlorien is so *different* and fluid
Frodo just fucking crying his eyes out in Lothlorien. Everyone else is having the time of their lives. Poor poor man.
Boromir really is the bad guy in this musical, huh?
All the chest and head hand signs are so so sweet - touching you to me, sharing my mind and heart and soul. Elrond does it from his heart to Frodo’s heart, touching his chest and it’s just… so affectionate. The three hunters do the same to Boromir’s body, along with all their different prayer signs, and it makes me cry. 
This time the flute music truly was menacing - Saruman’s evil grin held for a while before playing
Have some accidental floating hobbits for the intveral:
Tumblr media
Act 2:
R’s favourite bit was Aragorn and Arwen, she kept talking about it!
Aragorn/Arwen’s duet ends very abruptly with lighting changes and Arwen disappearing to aragorn finishing last note kneeling alone surrounded by men. Yes. God. Dream sequences for the win.
Legolas leaps around and does not-quite-flips in his fighting, whereas Gimli is always on the ground
Legolas snogging his bow
Legolas always looks so... clinical, practiced when fighting
"Come back when you're sober" catty asshole
Wonder - bunch of men (including many principles in human gear) sit on the round. As Galadriel sings each "out of", another person gets up and stands before her, until Aragorn, sword held high, “WONDER” - really uplifting. I also really really love Aragorn’s little bit “day may end”, why isn’t it in the cast recording.
When Gollum climbs, it’s up the wall rather than the ladders like Sam and Frodo, and in act 2’s lighting you can’t even see the holds - very creepy
Shelob was actually fantastic when I was properly aware of her. Beautiful and creepy and so much going on. 
Frodo and Gollum moving together and also SPEAKING together, when Gollum hears Sam say they'll destroy the ring
When Sam is convincing Frodo to get up so they can walk to mordor, he's reaching out to him, everyone comes on stage and reaches out to him, and he eventually manages to grab his hand
Sam yelling as he carries Frodo on his shoulders is spine-tingling again
Gollum's death, was, again, incredible
Tumblr media
Sam and Frodo and Rosie standing together hugging as they wait for the wedding, making me awwww
Group Hobbit foot goodbye aaaaaaa
At the end as Frodo leaves, Gollum and then Bilbo play the tune accompanying him aaaaaa
Final observations:
Head holding situations: 
Aragorn and Boromir practically in each others’ faces as he dies
Aragorn and Frodo practically kissing
Gimli and Legolas do this too!! After they’ve proposed!! The spotlight has gone to Aragorn but they’re holding each other in the darkness!
Funny hobbit versions: 
Gollum x Aragorn Hobbit AU, 500k
Mrs. Bracegirdle is actually in the show! She’s Kelly!
Gollum is a Proudfoot. Need I say more.
Rosie is Scottish! How could I forget this!
After the show, I congratulated Rosie, Legolas, Haldir, Bilbo and Saruman! I passed on E’s praise of “gay supervillain audacity” and they laughed and said “well it’s hard to hide”. (Side note: they’re enby, of course this is why I find him so attractive)
Tumblr media
And, finally, my favourite thing I noticed in the whole show:
For all of Act 2, Frodo's voice is tremulous, breathy and tired EXCEPT directly after Sam says “Well, there’s nothing we can do about that” (the elves leaving for the West). 
“Yes we can.”
Completely normal voice. Terrifying.
18 notes · View notes
heyclickadee · 1 year
Note
For the fandom bingo ask: Lord of the Rings, Boromir!
Tumblr media
Yay!! Thanks for this one! (Also tumblr glitched out while I was writing a response the first time, so hopefully it doesn't do that twice.) So:
Movie Boromir: I want to shake him by the lapels and then give him a hug. He's a little bit of an ass, and he makes one huge mistake (sort of under magical duress), but his relationship with Faramir kills me and he's so kind and protective with Merry and Pippin and then he dies protecting them and I 🫠🫠😭😭😭😭
Book Boromir: All of the above, minus some of the bing a bit of an ass, plus a lot of other stuff. There's something about Boromir that gives off...eh, not exactly himbo energy, but...gentrified country bumpkin energy? Is that a thing? He's actually almost as, if not quite a bit more, parochial in his worldview as Sam is when Sam first steps out if you just swap Gondor for the Shire. He's somewhat ignorant, dismissive, and sometimes straight up distrustful of the peoples beyond his homeland. And there's, I don't know, something even so sad about Boromir in the book. He's a good man, but he's deeply flawed in exactly the way that would make him a target for the ring. Because here's the thing about the ring--it can only offer one thing, and that one thing is dominion, over the other rings specifically but over other living beings generally, too. That's why there are people like Tom Bombadil or Faramir who aren't tempted by the ring at all (Tom is immensely powerful and a whole other kind of being, so the ring doesn't have power over him in that way, but he's also real insistent about all of the creatures and plants and things in his little pocket of middle earth belonging to themselves, so the ring wouldn't be something he'd want anyway), and good people like Gandalf and Galadriel who are, even if it's just a little bit. And between watching Boromir through FOTR and then hearing Faramir talk about him in TTT, we learn that that kind of power is something Boromir wants, even if it is for a mostly good reason. And he really only gives into that temptation for about thirty seconds! But it's still enough to scare Frodo into running off to Mordor alone, or trying to. And then the rest of the fellowship gets attacked, and Boromir dies trying to save Merry and Pippin, and 🫠🫠🫠🫠😭😭😭
And here's the thing that makes all of that even worse; there's every indication that Boromir wasn't supposed to go on the quest or even to Rivendell in the first place. Faramir was the one to have the dream. Repeatedly. And then when ten time winner of the worst father of the year award Denethor refused to send Faramir to Rivendell, Boromir had the dream one time and Denethor sent him. I don't know what the story would have looked like had Denethor actually sent the right kid, but I'm pretty sure Boromir wouldn't have died where he did. He may not have died at all.
Also, I need an account of Boromir's trip from Gondor to Rivendell. It took months and I'm sure there were tons of misadventures along the way.
10 notes · View notes
rosekillerismylife · 7 months
Text
A few things about Lord of the Rings (the books, obviously):
It took me ages to finish all three of them because J. R. R. Tolkien is a genius and imagined a whole new world with many different landscapes and unfortunately, the characters needed to travel very far and very long to get to the final destination.
I HATE GANDALF! Like, what do you mean he just comes and goes as he pleases, dumps metaphorical shit on you that is meant to be wise and thoughtful and then disappears all of a sudden and trusts you to make the right decision and if you make a wrong turn, he appears again and scolds you. What the fuck, man! You are not the center of the earth, fuck of!
Oh my God, Legolas and Gimli are so gay for each other. They are literal soulmates. And you can't disagree with me because have you noticed that they trust each other more than they trust the rest of the travel group? Have you noticed how they always think about each other and always have the urge to tell each other important news like how many creatures they killed during a fight? Have you noticed the conversation they had about Gimli wanting to show Legolas the Caves in 'Helms Klamm' and Legolas wantinf to show Gimli the Fangorn forest and they are going to go there even though Gimli doesn't like the forest and Legolas isn't comfortable with the caves? THAT IS LOVE, MY FRIEND. (even if it's just platonic)
I think Frodo was the inspiration to Harry Potter as a character because he has the same hero complex and the same 'oh no, I should've left my friends and should've taken care of the problem myself. Oh wait, now I have an opportunity, I might just go alone' behaviour. It annoys me! Also, both (Frodo and Harry) had the same situation: If Harry had killed Peter, the second war could have been avoided. If Frodo had killed Gollum, he wouldn't have been captured by the Orks.
Sam is so dear to me. He is a little like Ron (because he doesn't trust Gollum etc.) but the more I think about it, he is like Hira in My Beautiful Man which means (drumroll please) Frodo is Kiyoi and they are in love with each other! If you have watched the series, you know that Hira thinks of Kiyoi as a king and also treats him as one and doesn't think that he deserves someone like Hira. Basically, Sam is the same: He follows Frodo wherever he goes, he protects him, he cares for him, he cooks for him, he abandons his sleep to watch out for him and so on. I love him.
The Hobbits are so funny. I can't with them. They are so unbothered by everything, like little children or even teenagers. As long as they can eat and sing, everythings fine. Like, what do you mean there's no food in this dark tower during a war that may cost us our life?
Éowyn is slaying! She's mostly the only woman and she is so cool! I mean, she disguises herself as a man and fights even though she's not supposed to. Tolkien wrote the series in 1954 and the things Éowyn did were really progressive for that time, I guess. He was ahead of his time.
I love the language Tolkien uses, just because all of it sounds so fancy and special and the way he describes things, gives me chills. There's a reason why he's the father of High Fantasy.
Has anyone of you watched the movies? Do you recommend them?
6 notes · View notes
Text
Rewatching return of the king...
rewatching return of the king makes me utterly furious at amphibia again.
The worst part about the Amphibia finale is that it asserts their friendship is actively harmful to themselves, to others, and it would he better off if they had never met. any time they are together the entire world actively gets worse, any time they are apart everything improves and gets better. the show concludes that they should stay never stay together, yet the text itself shows NOTHING, literally NOTHING positive comes from these three meeting. this is a terrible, *terrible* ending to a TV series.
Anne doesn't win because of her friendship. she wins because she is alone and does what she is told. marcy suffers needlessly and would have been okay if she did what she was told. Sasha improves whenever she is away from the girls, and she poisons everything around her. and she should do what she is told.
The show concludes that you must never disobey your parents, trying to change your life WILL kill you and your friends, and you'd be better off never having them, because you will lose them. but it's okay, because you have memories! never mind that this is all the bad guys ideology in every way, shape, and form.
That bittersweet ending is entirely unearned, entirely unwarranted, and entirely false. It is sickening, it is cruel, it is MEAN, and hurtful.
I wanted an ending like Return of the King. I wanted the Gray Havens, I wanted Sam's ending for the gang. Frodo and Sam's friendship literally saves the world. The Calamity Trio have actively doomed it simply by meeting. And the only way they save it is by separating. I'm not upset because I didn't like Return of the King, or because I'm comparing it to Tolkien, I'm disappointed the ending wasn't like that.
To claim that ending is sweet in any way feels incredibly unearned, and incredibly mean. I hate you, Matt Braly. You are delusional and I wish you would seek help.
0 notes
spaceorphan18 · 1 year
Note
I really want to know who your favourite LOTR characters are! I saw an ask about Silmarillion that said you've already answered this before but I tried searching your blog and couldn't find it
Oh hello! Usually my tag is LOTR for this stuff, but I may have forgotten to tag things.
Anyway... my favorite LOTR Characters!
Bilbo Baggins
Tumblr media
This is probably more due to the Hobbit, which I did read before LOTR. But I've always thought of him as my fictional kindred spirit. He's grumpy and tired and really wants to be left alone so he can write his book. And the only way you'll get him to do anything is show up with 13 dwarves and a wizard to kick him out the door.
Btw - Martin Freeman was a perfect casting for this role. I'm sad the Hobbit films weren't better ones, because Freeman embodies him perfectly.
Gandalf
Tumblr media
Look, I love Wizards. Love. Them. Maybe it's the aesthetic? Maybe it's the idea of some old, frail looking dude being able to kick your butt with ancient magic? Maybe it's the fact that they're the ones who always know the mythology? I don't know. But one of the reasons I love LOTR is for the wizards, and Gandalf is one of the greatest. Plus, he's grumpy and too old for this shit and really would rather just sit back and enjoy the Hobbit nonsense if he could.
Also - another perfect casting choice here with Ian McKellen.
Pippin
Tumblr media
I really love the Hobbits in general, but Pippin is my favorite. I think in both the book and the movies he gets some really great material - he's not as comical in the book, but he does bring levity to the story in both. Plus, his story arc showcases how someone so small can be beneficial to the overall story and he gets to hang out with Gandalf a ton.
Aragorn
Tumblr media
I mean, look at this sexy dude. ;) I think this is one of those instances where the movies gave a lot more complexity to a character who was more of an archetype in the book. But I think I just kind of love the gruff, gritty guy who is actually an heir to royalty but really isn't in it for that trope.
Legolas
Tumblr media
I'm really fond of the Elves in general - and their mythology is one of the hearts of the book. But in the movies, let's be real, it's mostly aesthetic. ;) Also - the fact that there are so many great memes. Lol
Frodo & Sam
Tumblr media
Okay, I originally just had Sam on here - Sam is the literal heart of the whole story, and has one of the best arcs in the whole book. It's really his story, and I absolutely adore him.
I'm including Frodo here, though because in the movies, he and Sam have one of my favorite dynamics. In the books, Frodo and Sam have a very strictly master-companion relationship, it grows into a very strong bond, but there is that level of class that always stays between them. To make it more modern (and I'd say more American - but this is a New Zealand film) they eased up on the class stuff and made it a really strong friendship. I'd even go as far to say that this is perhaps the best 'romance' of the movies. (I don't even mean that in a sexual way - but that their love and connection is very deep and isn't played up for laughs in the same way as Merry and Pippin or Legolas and Gimli.)
Faramir
Tumblr media
Honestly, I think he's a character I enjoy a lot in the movies, and maybe less so in the books. He doesn't have much of a personality in the books - and I'm okay with the movies trying to give him a better character arc. But idk, I've always liked him - maybe because he gets to pal around with Pippin while they're both stuck in Minas Tirith.
Eowyn
Tumblr media
It's really sad that I only have one woman on this list but at least she gets to be badass and gets to do cool things.
****
In case you're wondering about some characters not on this list...
Merry - Poor Merry gets the shaft. But he is the weakest developed of the four main hobbits. His friendship with Pippin is great though.
Gimli - Okay, people don't hate me, I've never been all that into the Dwarven cultures. :/
Gollum - Look, I realize he's, like, the favorite of everyone, the most morally complex, and Andy Serkis should have gotten a damn Oscar for that role, but I just don't like him. Sorry.
Saruman - I really don't think he gets to do all that much in either book or movie. He has some interesting backstory stuff going on, but he's a little generic in the main story.
Boromir - Tolkien doesn't have a lot of morally gray characters in his books, so it's great when we get to see him. But for me, I'm meh on him even if I recognize that he is a good character.
Elrond and Galadriel - Both of whom have better stories elsewhere in Tolkien's mythology.
Arwen - Ug, she's not a character in the books, and barely a character in the films.
Sauron - You know, he's a great character in pre-third age related things. But he's used only as a dark menace here, so I feel, despite being the main antagonist, you don't get a full sense of him and he's not much of a character in LotR.
Okay, did I miss anyone? Despite there being a million characters in these books -- there really aren't that many characters that play an active role.
1 note · View note
elenirlachlagos · 1 year
Text
Tumblr media
Ich habe 764 Mal im Jahr 2022 etwas gepostet
Das sind 47 more posts als 2021!
20 Einträge erstellt (3%)
744 Einträge gerebloggt (97%)
Blogs, die ich am häufigsten gerebloggt habe:
@frodo-baggins
@everythingfox
@lhaewiel
@sarah-yyy
Ich habe 726 meiner Einträge im Jahr 2022 getaggt
Nur 5% meiner Einträge hatten keine Tags
#catcontent – 53 Einträge
#discworld – 50 Einträge
#the untamed – 34 Einträge
#cql – 34 Einträge
#wholesome – 30 Einträge
#jiang cheng – 27 Einträge
#middle-earth – 24 Einträge
#studio ghibli – 23 Einträge
#adult life – 22 Einträge
#ghibli – 22 Einträge
Längstes Tag: 81 characters
#germans - maybe the only nation that has to be reminded of their national holiday
Meine Top-Einträge im Jahr 2022:
#5
My entry for SangCheng Week 2022 - Day 5 - Hostility. I'm a day late. 😅
This is kind of a spin-off idea of the Miss Fisher's Murder Mysteries AU that lives in my head. I tried for the Phryne Fisher/Jack Robinson sexual tension, but I'm afraid I didn't quite get there.
7 Anmerkungen – Gepostet 5. November 2022
#4
instagram
the part of me that is listening to what is being said: 🤣 the part of me that is listening to how it is being said: 🥵
8 Anmerkungen – Gepostet 10. November 2022
#3
I’m seeing this vast campaign against a single person who’s up for elections on AO3. Ok I get, people are worried.
What I find concerning however is that these posts contain screenshots of allegations other random people on the internet make - but not actual information or quotes from the person concerned.
This is Trump-like “lots of people say that” methods and you should be ashamed about sharing something like that.
10 Anmerkungen – Gepostet 13. August 2022
#2
youtube
When my lady walks into the room The lights come on to her sweet perfume I didn't know the devils by her side There I stood I had nothing to hide
My love could teach the blind to see My love's the wildest mystery My love said she'd be the one Now I know
Baby you're a liar You're a liar
I wasn't watching for the danger signs And I never read between the lines She says c'mon boy can you do your thing So I turned around still wondering
When my love dances she makes me cry My love dances with me tonight My love said she's be the one But now I know
Baby you're a liar Oh you're a liar A liar But I'm still burning with desire
With the look of a panther I got lost in the jungle No I can't help myself again I can't help myself Baby you're a liar
My love could teach the blind to see My love's the wildest mystery My love said she'd be the one Now I know
Baby you're a liar Oh yeah you're a liar A liar I'm burning with desire
Oh baby you're a liar Oh baby you're a liar (you're a liar) Oh baby you're a liar (you've bin known to veer from the truth) Lies You're a liar You're telling me lies Baby you're a liar Lies I'm burning with desire Lies Baby you're a liar
20 Anmerkungen – Gepostet 23. Februar 2022
Meine #1 des Jahres 2022
During the Sunshot Campaign one night Jiang Cheng breaks down in the security of the camps in Qinghe. Not in front of his sister - in front of Nie Huaisang. It was just supposed to be a harmless get-together, just some drinks.
But the last battle didn't go well. Jiang Cheng survived, too many others died. And it's just too much. He cries. He failed them. He failed a lot of people. He doesn't know what he's doing. People die because he couldn't protect them. He wants his mother back. He wants his father back. He wants Wei Wuxian back. He's alone. He can't do this anymore. He's a failure. He cries, ugly cries. A lot. And Nie Huaisang does't really know how to deal with it, so he's just kinda awkwardly there.
They never talk about it, never mention it again. But their relationship slightly changed.
32 Anmerkungen – Gepostet 24. Juli 2022
Hol dir deinen Tumblr-Jahresrückblick 2022 →
1 note · View note
tolkien-feels · 2 years
Note
8 for the hobbits? I want all the food-stealing dynamics (and please don't leave out Fatty Bolger!)
Oh my god! However did I miss this? I'm sorry, tumblr notifications are. weird. Anyway, let's have a hobbit party!
Do they ever share (or steal) each other’s food? How do they act/react to it?
Bilbo: Pre-Adventure Bilbo would never steal anyone's food. It would not be proper. Post-Adventure Bilbo? Oh for sure. Only when it's funny, though. Which means he definitely steals food from every elf in Rivendell while saying that's just how hobbits are :) ("That doesn't sound right but I don't know enough about hobbits to dispute it" thinks every elf. Aragorn assures them that's how hobbits are because that's funny. He does, however, refuse to comment on the Bilbo Stole Food Off Elrond's Plate To See What'd Happen incident.) Anyway. Conversely, sharing food is a love language. He just happens to have your favorite food around, come on in, it's so dull eating alone.
Frodo: Baby Frodo canonically did steal mushrooms, so I'm gonna guess he was okay with stealing anything he thought he could get away with. As he grows up into a proper gentleman, though, he stops that. However if you try to steal his food he will slap your greedy hands off his plate. But he shares everything very generously, and he always makes sure to offer food to every guest and friend. Unless he absolutely despises you, in which case you're gonna suffer every second as he pointedly and icily does not offer you anything.
Sam: Would steal food from his brothers and the Cotton boys and that's it. Does share with his sisters and Rosie, and Marigold is welcome to steal anything she wants, which she absolutely does. Invents reverse-stealing during the Quest in that Frodo gets like 2/3 of the food but Sam is very sneaky about it because if Frodo figures that out, it'll backfire. Oh, and eating while cooking is fair game, as is eating things nobody seems interested in. Might steal more ale than it's good for him if he thinks nobody will notice.
Merry: Perfectly capable of refraining from stealing if the situation calls for it, but considers friendly food stealing a bonding activity. Has a knack for keeping meals fun without anything deranging into a mess, and is therefore very popular: the whole of Buckland and part of the Shire will let him steal things and just laugh warmly in response. Wise enough not to steal from Frodo too often, but the only person who can get away with it on occasion, which makes him a hero in Pippin's eyes. Also one of the few hobbits to understand other races have different food cultures and adapt accordingly. Special mention: it's not quite food, but pipeweed is to him what mushrooms are to Frodo.
Pippin: Is the reason those Rivendell elves go "Oh shit maybe Bilbo wasn't lying." Equal opportunity stealer. If he wants it and his hands can reach it, he'll steal it. Semi-constantly tries to steal from Frodo (slapped away, and also scolded), Sam (glared at, and scolded by Frodo again), Fatty (manageable, but Fatty won't be happy about it) and Merry ("Sure!") so you can see by whose side he wants to sit at every meal. Surprisingly generous about sharing, though. Sidenote: he'll never tell anyone this, but he never steals from Legolas because he's afraid to be thrown into a dungeon like Thorin's Company. Would still do it on a dare, though.
Fatty: Follows the Frodo school of thought ("Don't steal from me and I won't steal from you") but isn't as good at looking threatening as Frodo is, which means people do steal things from him, which he Does Not Like. He might let it go once or maybe twice, but after that all bets are off and he's surprisingly good at grabbing unwatched food. Based on literally Nothing I want to believe he and Sam have an alliance against Pippin. 4thAge!Fatty, though, welcomes stealing and sharing just because Saruman hated both and it's now his duty to keep the stealing tradition alive :)
Rosie: Doesn't steal in front of Fancy Company, otherwise steals a normal amount for a hobbit. Hasn't actually stolen anything from Sam since they became tweens, but has very elaborate daydreams about doing it. Volunteers to cook often due to also subscribing to the idea it's not stealing if she's cooking. Will, however, march out of her kitchen anyone who tries to steal food while she's cooking without helping in the actual cooking. (No, not you, Mr Frodo. You're an angel and I'll get you strawberries in November if you want.)
And two bonus you didn't ask for but I feel very strongly about:
Elanor: Is it stealing to bat your eyelashes at your dad until he feeds you as much as mom will allow? Debatable. But even Rosie finds it hard to scold her due to her habit of stealing on her siblings' behalf, which is just Cute.
Honorary hobbit Gandalf, when eating with hobbits: Steals everything. Threatens to turn you into a garden snail if you complain.
146 notes · View notes
marta-bee · 2 years
Note
i just saw your comment on the One Thing you don't like about the PJ movies, and I was wondering... what's wrong with Denethor?
(For context: I know the books inside and out, but I haven't watched the movies, so you can expect me to know everything in Tolkien but this is also an honest question. I'm scared. What did they do to Denethor??)
What an interesting vantage-point! Usually I see people only familiar with the movies asking how the book is different, but I don't think I've ever discussed him with someone only familiar with the books. Not that there's anything wrong with not knowing the book version, but this is new.
You may want to go to the bathroom, or pour yourself a drink, because we're going to be here for a while. Deep breath. :-)
Let's start with the family drama.
Denethor is a really bad father to Boromir and Faramir, Faramir especially. He flat-out tells Faramir he'd wished he had died instead of Boromir, which is a very twisted reading of the parallel book conversation (where Faramir asks if Denethor wishes Boromir's and Faramir's roles had been reversed). Denethor comes across as uncaring and even cruel.
But more than that, because they really did away with the lord's council other than Denethor and Faramir, the strategy debates leading up to the Battle of Pelennor Fields get reduced to a father-son squabble. When Denethor asks who will ride out to defend the Rammas Echor [though in the movies it's Osgiliath], he's not saying it to a group of commanders. Faramir's the only person there to hear him, so it comes out as very passive-aggressive. That means Faramir's decision to lead the charge isn't so much a commander doing his lord's doing as a son trying to prove his worth to his father. The revelation Faramir let Frodo and Sam go doesn't come across as a treasonous decision or an earnest disagreement on how best to handle it, but a son betraying his father. It all felt so pitifully small to me, and lacking the gravitas and thematic weight of the book exchanges. I don't doubt Jackson thought it was more relatable but for me it really hollowed out Denethor's character. It also made him manipulative, and that's even before you get into the whole Pyre sequence.
Second: as a ruler, he's really ineffectual.
There's no Beregond and Bergil, no well-organized evacuation, no him wearing armor under his clothes and working diligently to the point he barely sleeps, no rebuilding of the Wall or bringing in troops from Dol Amroth and all the rest to boost the city's defenses. Minas Tirith is much more ready to defend itself in the books than (say) the Rohirrim at Helm's Deep, and Denethor's great failure is he's so focused on Gondor's defenses it's committed him to too narrow a view of the war. But he's a remarkably good ruler on those narrow terms. In the movies he's just a doddering old fool and Gondor is not only unprepared, it's not actively preparing for war until Gandalf kicks people into action.
Part of that comes down to every movie having to limit its plot points and the details it gives. And I suspect PJ wanted to show why Gondor needed a king, why Aragorn was so important. But in the process he completely failed to show why Gondor was worthy of Aragorn; I remember thinking at the time that if it was me I'd rather have ruled over Rohan. And Denethor himself is just a humiliating shell of a man, let alone of a ruler. There's one famous scene set in the Court of the White Tree where he's raving about how Mordor has come upon them and they're all doomed and Gandalf just... conks him in the head with his staff. There are guards standing on duty, but they completely fail to react to his histrionics but also Gandalf's assault on him. And it's just pitiful.
That scene's actually a recasting of another book scene, the one where Denethor releases Pippin from his service and says they should all go find their death in whatever way seems best to them. But it happens much earlier in the movies, and without any explanation for why Denethor is SO given in to despair. Which leads me to my third reason why Jackson did our steward so wrong.
The movies also take away a really central explanation for Denethor's despair: the palantir. They do have palantiri, but really only the Isengard one recovered by Gandalf and Pippin. If Denethor had one it's never mentioned. Why Denethor used it is also never mentioned, so he doesn't come across as a man who'd fought valiantly but in the process exposed himself to "truth" too heavy to bear up under. It also doesn't explain why he's so sure they were all going to die, and why Faramir was as good as dead. He's just unraveling and comes across as weak and a poor ruler, never mind person.
That's frustrating enough in the scenes leading up to the siege, but you can only imagine what it does to the Pyre episode. More than a decade later, just thinking about that whole sequence just hurts. So I find I don't want to dwell on the details, but I do need to talk about one thing: shorn of any context for why he's so certain Gondor is about to fall, his move to immolate Faramir takes on a much more controlling --even abusive-- tone. There's an element of that in the books, but without any real grounding of why he thinks their destruction is so certain, it just seems like he doesn't want anyone taking control of Faramir away from him.
(He's also denied his stately end: instead of barring the doors and the tomb of the Stewards collapsing upon him, he turns into a fireball and runs all the way back to the Citadel and jumps off the stone outcropping. To say Jackson was showing his Harryhausen influences would be an understatement. :-) )
I try to remind myself that while Denethor may well be my Blorbo, he's actually a fairly minor character in the context of the larger story, and a lot of this may come down to where Jackson needed to center his storytelling. I can appreciate that. But a lot of it was just unnecessary, and robbed him of this high tragedy that made me so love the book character. I wept at the inevitability of book-Denethor's fall; with movie-Denethor, I just groaned.
38 notes · View notes