#fandom neg

[etoilesbienne]

I don't know how to deal with the situation anymore, on one hand I understand everyone having hope and looking forward to the server repairing, really I do, but like... I feel like every update makes me feel more and more bleak for the communication issues. I'd like to say I feel reassured when a CC comes and says "well things are being fixed up and the admins I talked to are saying it's going great," but I just don't anymore, especially when I go look at one of the said admins public twitter, and they're liking tweets talking about how everyone leaving the company and exposing the way they were treated were just "ungrateful petty pieces of shit," and like... I don't feel comforted, I feel frustrated and like no one is talking to the admins who got ousted even more. Am I supposed to just smile and nod through the fact a language is just gone from the server? Why were we expendable... Why am I supposed to know you "support the admins" because you posted once in support of them a month ago but you proceeded to go on a tirade about how useless and liars all of the now out admins are over a week. I don't know. I don't think we know everything behind the scenes. Everything feels so weird. I just want the admins who got ousted to be okay and know their part of the server meant something to me. I don't know the answer and I doubt I ever will but this last year was a delight. I don't think it could've been the same without every former admin like Léa or Ana or Lumi or Shade or Dianna or Amz3t or Rainylour or Pancks or any of the update admins who kept me up on new content or all of the coders on the backend making websites like qsmp.tv usable and the purgatory website and the elections website and the cool ARG website or all of the builders in game who made events really shine or any of the unnamed many many more admins and people who worked so hard to make the project work so well despite all of the conditions. Like the server with any of these removed is hard to imagine and I still don't think I can fully believe it.

#discourse #neg #crit #fandom crit #fandom neg #qadmin situation

[dazaijustscrollsfic]

okay after yesterday I think people need to think in a meta way too even if just a little, and not always be thinking "everyone is always in roleplay"

"people didn't think tubbo's death was serious" okay I get it, I love q!tubbo. But consider the fact that this is Minecraft! Consider it's literally Minecraft and dying+respawning is a mechanic!

They took it seriously after Creation specified that he's actually dead because, you know, they're in Minecraft and respawning is a mechanic :D

#qsmp #fandom neg #qsmp fandom neg #< just in case #qsmp tubbo #tubblings please dont attack me I'm literally one of you #qsmp meta #dazai thinks #i feel like this is controversial? is it?

[callmebrutus]

and we're back to this discussion again.

you can do whatever you want to your comfort cubitos, but i can't not notice the trend hideduouers/fitpac nation started.

stop making mlm couples Straight. stop drawing them into heteronormative frames. it's Weird.

at first we were fighting for the fact that qpac is Not a Twink. we established the fact that he's a grown strong man, an ex convict, dangerous person who can stand for himself.

now we're again making him twink.

we established that fitpac is such a fresh sight of both adult gay men in media. now we are making one of them a woman.

i just don't understand. don't we have enough straight couples in media? isn't it enough?

why is it suddenly Different?

imo, if you want one character's gender, esp in homosexual relationships, change them BOTH then.

i'm actually tired of this conversation. I'm tired of erasing the representation cc's built for us. we were crying for more of this and now we just ignore it.

am i missing something?

#qsmp #qsmp fitmc #fitmc #pactw #fitpac #qsmp pactw #hideduo #fandom neg #<<kinda? #qsmp discource #also kinda

[sharptoothed-gaze]

Damn it, I wake up and see some Tubblings and Crows fighting in each other’s asks again. I swear the MC community is the most divided fandom.

GUYS I HATE TO SAY IT BUT TUBBO AND PHILZA ARE BOTH FLAWED PEOPLE AND GUARDIANS!!!!! They are currently mentally unstable and that’s interesting and also bad for their kids.

Both are negatively impacting Chayanne with different choices they’re making. Neither realize how much Chayanne has internalized his hero complex nor do they realize the negative impacts this is going to have in the future.

I could write a lot more, but as someone who loves both stories happening seeing so much in-fighting in this fandom space suuuucks.

#qsmp #fandom neg #fandom crit #discourse

[apollos-boyfriend]

all i’ve seen has been people complaining about the purgatory event and how grueling it is to watch but i finally had time to tune into jaiden’s stream today and literally all i saw was her having the time of her life. i think you guys are taking this funny little block game a bit too seriously

#icarus speaks #this is NOT an invitation to tell me why you think it’s a bad arc or event or whatever #and complain about it #it is NOT. #fandom neg

[masterofdumb]

While I as so happy the team Bolas?!?!?! has won today, please STOP TARGETING THE CCS!! It is honestly horrible. If the people who are actually playing and interacting genuinely had a problem between themselves, they would talk to each other, they dont need you to defend them. THEY ARE FRIENDS!! I know it's easy to get caught up in LORE and in-game stuff, but remember, ITS IN GAME!! I love Team Bolas, but the actions the characters take are in a game! The green ninjas and soulfire team are just playing the game, there is no reason to attack them.

#qsmp #badboyhalo #charlie slimecicle #qsmp purgatory #qsmp etoiles #el quackity #foolish gamers #team bolas #team green #blue team #qsmp tubbo #qsmp jaiden #cellbit #fandom neg

[qtubbo]

Also here is the endless list of people I’ve watched be assigned Tubbo’s parent on qsmp: Fit, Pac, Phil, Quackity, Wilbur, Roier, Cellbit, Bagi, Mouse, Niki, Tina, Luzu, Willy, Slime, Mariana, Lenay, Pol, Baghera, Etoiles, Aypierre, Bad, Rubuis, Foolish, and Missa.

I have seen every single one of these, Rubuis was a carry over from squidcraft, Roier was in combo with Cellbit, Pol was because he’s old enough to be Tubbo’s dad, Baghera was because art of them looked similar early on, Etoiles was because Tubbo can’t have friend they must be his dad, Slime and Mariana was through Sunny, and Foolish is I can’t even explain that one.

#qsmp #Qsmp tubbo #fandom neg #neg #Actual correction I remeber the foolish one now it’s from Tubbo wanting to be his grandson so he could have an enternal banana

[lionheartedmusings]

"the story needs to progress somehow" "it wouldn't be cool if at the end of this the eggs all came back"

if you need *child death* to get your story moving, you're not telling it right. if you need emotional torture-porn that never lets up to find a story or story arc rewarding, something isn't right with the way you consume media.

#qsmp #fandom crit #fandom neg #qsmp neg #i guess?? i don't think so much just in case #hell is other people #i have seen such Poor Takes it's wiiiiiiiild

[rhiaarrow]

Hello, hello! The Ghostie with the penchant for long rambling walls of text here to give her unwarranted two cents on the current disagreement between the Tubblings and the Crows!

I'm offering my take as a purely unbiased outsider

(Yes, us Ghosties may be married to the Tubblings but when I first joined the Qsmp Fandom I was a Crow and a Crow only, before I died and became a Ghostie. Thus, while I like both qTubbo and qPhil I don't watch either of them often, ergo unbiased :D )

who has no real reason to attempt to villainise or place either character on a pedestal because to put it bluntly, they are not my cubito.

Without further ado I will begin my ramble.

Today's ramble of course comes with the disclaimer that with me not being a qTubbo or qPhil main there may be areas of their character that I'm not aware of since I don't watch every single one of their streams! Feel free to correct me on literally anything you think I've mischaracterized about your main just please be understanding that nothing is done with malicious intent! :)

I'm not attempting to paint either character as a villain in this ramble, I'm just publishing this in hopes to allow each community to understand that neither cubito is perfect and that's okay!

Okay! For anyone missing context; the current disagreement began when Tubblings expressed feeling happy that Chay was able to be a kid around qTubbo as opposed to being serious with qPhil then the Crows reminded the Tubblings that qTubbo is also attributing to Chay's hero complex through him acting as Chay's egg and asking Chay to protect him. Which has caused both sides to instinctively protect their cubito and is causing arguments within their communities.

As a Ghostie who is more than willing to write 1000 words to raise awareness, and is frankly sick of infighting within the QSMP fandom (it's why I left twitter, please don't bring it here 🫠) I figured I'd try to help 'squash the beef' if you will.

Polite discussions about cubito conflict is fine, going for each other's throats over character takes...yeah let's not do that! :D

Firstly, everyone has to recognize that Chayanne has an almost toxic hero complex. He's had it since the beginning of the server and while neither qPhil or qTubbo is doing it on purpose they are BOTH feeding into it!

He has an overwhelming urge to protect others with no regard for his own safety or wellbeing at times. In the beginning it only extended to eggs. As the older sibling he had a sense of responsibility over them, which was cute! But now it's borderline toxic although it's become so normalized as such a core part of Chayanne's character that no one recognizes it's no longer a healthy mindset.

Now Tubblings can make the defense that qTubbo isn't being entirely serious or that he doesn't truly expect Chay to put his life on the line for him but I watched him look Chayanne in the eyes and BLAME HIM FOR NOT PROTECTING 'HIS EGG'.

Even if that was immediately reincarnated qTubbo who was a little fucked up in the head, even if he no longer fully blames him, even if qTubbo was joking at the time, he looked that kid dead in the eyes and told him it was his fault. Tell me again how qTubbo isn't unintentionally feeding his complex?

Yes qTubbo allows Chay a more carefree space away from his overwhelming need to protect his younger sister and a space to be more relaxed.

Yes qTubbo is joking about a lot of things and a lot of the out of pocket shit he says isn't intended to be taken completely seriously.

BUT you cannot fully disagree with the Crows when they say that qTubbo feeds the complex too. BECAUSE HE DOES, JUST NOT ON PURPOSE THE SAME AS qPHIL!

qPhil is so used to his son being the strong warrior that he doesn't realize that that character trait is actively damaging his son's mental state. His attention is divided between Chay and Tallulah and since Tallulah is more open to talking about her issues he often isn't as attentive to Chay.

Is that a bad thing? Yes!

Is it intentional on qPhil's part? No!

Is it something the Crows need to recognize that qPhil does which unintentionally allows his son to continue to struggle with his hero complex? Yes!

qPhil loves his son unconditionally AND qPhil feeds Chayanne's hero complex are two statements that can and do coexist

qTubbo let's Chay be more of a child AND qTubbo feeds Chayanne's hero complex are two statements that can and do coexist

And as long as both the Crows and Tubblings are willing to understand that neither cubito is perfect and THERE'S NO USE FIGHTING OVER PIXELS then we're good!

- Sincerely a Ghostie who just wants to try to bring understanding between the two fandoms by utilizing her rambling skills!

AGAIN, any severe mischaracterization you feel I may have included is unintentional and feel free to correct anything you feel like I'm misconstruing, they're not my main cubitos so there may be somethings that qTubbo or qPhil mains find to be untrue to the source

HOWEVER if you're gonna call me out for mischaracterizing a character simply because I'm bringing up their flaws and you can't accept a character has flaws, kindly fuck right off :D

#qsmp #qsmp analysis #qsmp lore #qsmp tubbo #qsmp philza #philza #tubbo #qsmp chayanne #chayanne the egg #qsmp crit #tubbo crit #philza crit #fandom neg #fandom crit #qsmp fandom #rhia rambles

[dez-wade]

Hey QSMP French community, I need to tell you this since everyone likes to say the opposite: You're allowed to feel angry and upset! It's not doom posting, it's not lack of empathy.

They're lacking empathy FOR YOU GUYS! All the French admins are gone (it's not even a "if" situation, THAT'S REALITY), and we won't know if they'll ever receive at least financial compensation even though they quit or were "fired".

The future is uncertain even for the CCs, who might follow Lumi's footsteps something they previously claimed they would do.

And that's not even mentioning some community reactions, especially the harassment Lea is getting despite doing the right thing.

It's absolutely insane for people expecting you to smile and still hold out hope for the future. It's absolutely insane the lack of humanity. The lack of support.

You guys more than anyone have the right to feel mad over the work abuse they suffered and the constant exclusion. And if you don't feel optimistic that's completely understandable!

And for those who aren't French: try to put in their place a little. Try to be more understanding. I feel like you guys aren't fully grasping what has been going on. It isn't something small. It's something very serious. It's not about vague ass messages saying "oh this suck hope you get better, anyways!".

And if anyone wants to vent, my inbox is open.

#qsmp #qsmp discourse #<i feel completely sick using this tag but i don't want annoying people bothering me #you guys deserve much better i can't believe people are being self enough to ask you for patience #fandom neg

[sweet-potato-42]

-sigh-

tubbo is not an idiot even if he leaks stuff sometimes

he is very much capable of keeping secrets. He doesn't leak messages if theres a simple line at the start of the message being like "this is a secret"

its sometimes kinda mean when people say that he should be told nothing

Also why are people just assuming he misunderstood or misread after Roier and BBH said its not confirmed that qsmp opens tomorrow. Or people saying they hope he just misread and were waiting for another confirmation???

Like it might be harder but he can still read and if it was completely wrong he would be told?? IDK its weird people dont trust what he said since he's dyslexic.

Same thing happened with the fred fiasco a while back people just jump to assuming he misread when in fact the text was just ambiguous.

and to some people on twitter, saying he's an "r-slur" is wrong even if you don't type out the entire word

like guys chill especially if he messes up and leaks something during the subathon where he streams for days straight and he's sick now as well

#tubbo #fandom neg #discourse #can people liek be normal #twitter discourse #qsmp

[etoilesbienne]

after talking with other people i feel like there really is a disconnect between everyone who has other povs they still have left and everyone who just lost all of their povs (the french)/lost most of their pov's lore (bbh with dapper and pomme). like everyone is stressed and some people are making jokes and i get it i really do i like humor in dark situations, but like... this is the worst case scenario that's happened for everyone who did lose everything. pomme said she wasn't coming back to the server and the french cc all said they wouldn't be coming back if she didn't. i don't feel like joking right now. this situation isn't like the previous two cc who were removed for their own actions, this one was because the studio didn't attempt anything to try to retain a whole language after frequent year-long workplace abuse. this doesn't feel like goofy lore drama anymore it's like, wow we really did lose everything. all because nobody in the upper staff knew how to dm an admin. i wish them well is a nice sentiment and all but i feel a little bit callous to it when the reason they're leaving is that no one talked to them. it was all preventable. no shit sherlock of course i'm upset and my posts reflect that. i wish every post i made being critical of this didn't come across like doomposting. even if qsmp recovers all of the parts i loved most got uselessly cut off in the process. there's not much left i can go back to. even if they replaced pomme's actor there's not going to be cc to come back for that. there's just going to be a hole in the server now when i watch. i feel like i'm going through every stage of grief. i don't want the server to burn down, i'd love to see it continue, but i'd be lying if i said i wasn't terribly bitter about everything.

#discourse #crit #neg #qsmp crit #qsmp neg #negative #qsmp discourse #qadmin situation #fandom neg #fandom crit #is that enough tags #posts from the aether

[atthebell]

This fandom's obsession with angst is annoying

it's agonizing and like i keep saying the complete lack of catharsis is awful like. angst for angst's sake is not satisfying, at least not to me. i want the narrative to make sense and also sorry but i like happy endings!!! i like when love and compassion win out against pessimism!!

#asks #anons #fandom neg

[generalpalacefishgoop]

You know the posts recently about bbh neg on twter, the timing of it with that going on, makes me want to hurl, they don't give a shit about "victims" or the real issues. They just want to dunk on the next cc they hate using the current "momentum".

You know what, I say let them go ahead and try to "cancel" Bad, really, go ahead. They're just regurgitating shit DSMP fans has said over the years again and again about Bad. Its fcking funny actually. Oh not forgetting they had to invent new ones or ones THAT THEIR FAVES HAVE DONE TOO BTW, to "cancel" Bad. To think I was looking forward to QSMP fans being "healthier" or "better" than DSMP ones, oh boy am I sorely disappointed.

Let them run their mouths about Bad. Cuz I'm 100% sure the CCs , QSMP admins, and Quackity give 0 shit about them. Etoiles knows and has already expressed how he knows that Bad is overly hated by the fandom and how he receives neg on the daily. Despite knowing that, he's still cordial with Bad. And he even expressed how he tries to not be "angry" or "frustrated" at Bad or else the parasocial fucks will come running to "defend" him from "evil" BBH when he has said a million times over that its not a fcking big deal, and hes just expressing himself NOT IN A NEG WAY. but noooo parasocial fucks be like "oh no my skunkrly wrunkly his feelings got hurt oh no" same shit with foolish fans. Fcking blind af. Esp the new ones who hasnt experienced the prank wars in dsmp. Fcking joyless fucks who cant handle a fcking block game that theyre not even playing. But thankfully, Etoiles stopped being so concerned, and well, yk with Foolish lmao same old same old.

(Disclaimer: SOME FANS NOT ALL, IM TALKING ABOUT THE TOXIC PARASOCIAL FUCKS, YES EVEN THE BIG ACCOUNTS ON TWITTER WITH THOUSANDS OF FOLLOWERS. You know who. Big numbers doesn't mean they're more RIGHT. A parasocial fuck is a parasocial fuck. Also, when I say parasocial, I mean the ones who are toxic and project themselves onto the CC. Being parasocial is fine, if it's the healthy kind, if you know what I mean)

I digress, there's no fcking unfollows or subtweets from CCs to Bad, unlike with D or F. In fact, some CCs and CLOSE FRIENDS of Bad's have always praised Bad and defended him TO THIS DAY. If that is not enough of an indication of how unproblematic he is, Idk what else to say. Just fuck off and live a life in constant misery and hatred ig. That's why don't respond to fucks like that. Just mute em. They can yap all they want but it means SHIT ALL if you don't see it. BBH's community is WAY WAY smaller than the whole fandom (and theres wayyy more toxic fucks) so bbhs community saying shit back to the toxic shits will also mean SHIT ALL. They CLEARLY don't watch Bad anyways so what's the point. Better way to deal with this shit is fight the misinformation, that's all. Spread more positivity and give ppl FULL context and CORRECT information. If you see some shit against Bad, report it and send it to whatever ban list qsmp uses. Send it to mods or something. Ik that Bagi's discord has something like that.

Oh but ppl be like /rp or /lh or "it's just my opinion", who gives a shit. Still report them. We're not dumb. The mods or whoever admins are not dumb. That negative toxic fuck smell on it, is fcking obvious enough.

STOP GIVING THEM ENGAGEMENTS. We can happily stay in each others bubbles without ever talking to each other, AND THAT IS FINE. Don't let the negative fucks in. Mute and report them, and I guarantee you, that fcking stranger on the Internet, you'll forget within DAYS. those fuckers won't even exist to you, vice versa.

THEIR WORDS HOLD NO POWER OVER YOU OR THE QSMP COMMUNITY. KEEP THE QSMP COMMUNITY HEALTY AND SAFE. Fuck them toxic shits.

#qsmp #qsmp fandom neg #neg #discourse #fandom neg #rant #badboyhalo

[dappersautismcreature]

ik a lot of yall like things to be evenly laid out and known but im sorry the lore right now is wavy and weird and gray. and that is ok, you will survive i promise.

not everything has to make sense, there will be mistakes, retcons, imperfections, jokes that get turned into canon, etc. its a story made by HUMANS, not everything is written down and remembered and edited like a book or script. this is rp.

if you are mad at bad for "messing with canon" consider that the admins gave him permission, he is trying to continue lore that has been put on pause like three times by now, and create fun content while helping gather cookies so eggs DONT DIE

gray area, it doesnt have to make sense, you dont have to connect everything to purely fiction or purely out of character. i promise you it doesnt, its not that important, mistakes can be made, things can be weird. this isnt a purely serious all intensive highly edited tv show, its a roleplay with like 30+ people all with pcs with individual lore.

calm the fuck down. yall are acting like this is the Final Sin. its just,, content,, you will be ok, the story will be ok, THEYRE ADULTS they can sort out their own issues if a cc doesnt like another cc including something in canon.

#i started this out sympathetic #but thinking of all the pathetic whining about 'my canon ToT' is getting on my nerves #its not yours #you dont get to decide anything #and its not making the story worse until we see it damaging the integrity of the story #wait for that and then we can talk #even then #moreso on the admins than the players #qsmp #qpurgatory 2 #tagging both because both are relevant #fandom neg #crit

[considermygenderminecrafted]

hmmmm. Debating makin this post but sure. Fuck it.

context: Sunny felt really hurt over how Phil introduced her to Talullah and some folks are interpreting is as Phil were cruel or that he's tryna be like more fucked up after purgetory

Disclaimer: Sunny is a kid and has every fuckin right to feel how she feels, and interpret things how she does, and it would be great if they talked and figured shit out. Disclaimer over.

Post: Ngl fellas, introducin someone with some banter about a topic you don't see em as insecure about is just kinda summit you Fuckin Do in north england. YUP EVEN WITH THE LITTLENS. My Mam and Dad did it with me nd my sister as a kid, my parents close friends would to it with us, my friends rents do it with them, my mates do with to me, I do it with them. It's like, kinda a thing that just happens,,, It's part of the culture. especially if the person you're introducing them too is nervous, cause its an ice breaker. Like "hey the person you're scared of is a person like you, look they can handle a bit of banter, its all fine we're friends here" type vibes!

Usually, you preface or end it with a compliment to show you're genuine feelings, and usually you don't do it with someone when it's your first meeting with em, but you'll take the piss out of someone you like to show that you like them yknow? Especially if you've like done other shit to establish yous appreciate that thing you're making fun of em about (like qPhil givin Sunny another pretty crown cause she likes gifts and pretty things and feeling like a princess).

You'd also go for something that you don't acutally feel negateiely about, obviously. Phil doesn't give a shit that she and tubbo steal, thats just a like thing that happens sometimes that you can roll your eyes at but whatever kids gonna nick shit /affectionate. It's not a fuckin insult coming from a place to shame or correct, it's intended to be banter, yknow?

Like, its a show that you like the person and know summit about the person and also believe they can handle a bit of banter at their expense. ESPECIALLY if you've seen em take the piss out of you, someone else, or themselves, cause then it's like "oh word you like to play with this dynamic, okay"

And like, does it suck when you misjudge? Absolutely. Does it suck when someone chooses the wrong topic and gets at summit you're genuinely insecure about? Yes. I've had convos with mine being like 'hey can you not use this topic when you're doin banter' and thats like, really fair to do. There are also like more casual ways to tell em to knock it off like, turning it back on them, or lampshadin it etc which are like, accepted way to tell someone to back down a bit, because it's just like. A thing you do here!

Like qPhil takes the piss out of everyone he loves, chayanne and talullah get it all the time, tubbo (the godparents of his kids) gets it SO much, so does fit, so does Etoiles, like its truly is like, just a fuckin, part of friendships.

TO REITERATE. SUNNY HAS EVERY FUCKIN RIGHT TO FEEL THE WAY SHE DOES! SHE IS A KID, SHE'S NOT FROM THE SAME CULTURAL BACKGROUN, SHE DOESN'T KNOW PHIL THAT WELL NOR PHIL AND TUBBOS RELATIONSHIP!!

Did qPhil put his foot in it? Yes. Do they need to have a natter and settle things? Yes.

But it would be fuckin Lovely if we didnae start up "Phil is actually being a bad person and purpose and cc!Phil is making the choice for his character to be bad" when it's just like, a cultural difference from him being northern again

#discouse #q Philza #q tubbo #q tallulah #q sunny #tbh i think this actually applies to most of britian? at least like not the stupid posh parts #but i can only speak to my expriences so #fandom neg