Dasey fic recs from 2008-2010
I’ve been procrastinating and somehow this led me down the rabbit hole of digging up old Dasey fics. Here’s a short and very random rec list of some of those. (Definitely not exhaustive; this fandom has a disproportionate number of great fics.) I provided AO3 links where they exist because, wow, fanfiction.net is decaying before our eyes.
How Emily Davis Got Her Groove Back by unoriginal_liz (43k, T); read on AO3 or fanfiction.net: "I'm beyond a Shleppette! I'm the uber-Shleppette! There are no depths to which I will not Shlep!"
This is, like, THE fic. It is even better than I remembered. Rereading it in 2021, I laughed and felt all the feelings and was utterly delighted by the whole thing. This should be required reading. Dasey is a background ship but it’s an amazing Dasey subplot. (There seems to be some issue with some missing text in the AO3 version, but it doesn’t really mess up anything but the flow.)
Tapedeck by sparzelli (6.5k, T): She experiences the most curious emotion then. She can feel something slide into place in her head, and then it’s like they’ve been this way their whole lives. It's not real, but it sort of feels like comfort. CxD
I always remember this fic for being a little angsty and having a strong atmosphere. It’s still quite vivid and a different Casey characterization than I often see/write, and the tension threaded through the fic is so good.
The Perils of Alphabetical Seating by TheBucketWoman (3k, T): "They'd agreed to be “friends” which, everyone but Casey knew, didn't mean that they would ever really be at ease with each other." Dasey and featuring, well, someone who used to be with Casey.
This is a Max POV story and it’s really well done. I love how it encapsulates a particular moment and gives such a strong feeling of high school. Dasey through someone else’s eyes is always good, too.
What We Did On Our Summer Vacation by hayseed42 (74.5k, M mostly for language): Nora said their summer trip to the country was going to be an adventure. She didn't mean it quite so literally, but when have Casey and Derek ever been any good at doing what they're told? A slow-building Dasey.
This is a fantasy adventure fic that I’ve never forgotten, but I had to do some digging to find again. It’s just as fun and fast-paced as I remembered, and with great character and ship development. (Content warning for one instance of offensive language referring to disability in Chp. 7.)
A Study in Desire by WhenLightningStrikes / youcallitwinter (1.5k, T); read on AO3 or fanfiction.net: Someone should really look into naming a pathological condition after her.
One thing I really miss from fandom in the past was these smaller character study-type pieces. This one really achieves a lot in grounding the plot in Casey’s headspace, and the ending strikes the perfect note.
Two Ways It Could Have Happened, One Way It Did by justfallapart (700 words, K+): Two ways Derek Venturi could have met Casey McDonald, and the way he actually did.
Like I just mentioned, I miss these smaller character studies. This one explores the common agreement in this fandom that Derek Venturi fell in love first, and in just 700 words encapsulates all the angst you feel because of that.
back to the border by avocadomoon (4k, T): Casey makes the Dean's list. Derek takes up smoking.
I mean, everyone’s read this fic, right? But it was so definitive for the fandom that a Ye Olde Dasey Fic Recs post (even a short, random, and non-comprehensive one) would be incomplete without it. I still remember reading this for the first time. Each scene is so well-drawn, both perfectly connected to the show and establishing its own universe and tone. It’s efficient and elegant and amazing.
131 notes
·
View notes
Best of Dasey: An Essential Fanfiction Reading Guide
I read every single fic in the Dasey tag on AO3, so you don't have to! Instead, here's my guide to the best of the best Dasey fics in the tag.
This guide does not include Derek/Sally/Casey, only Derek/Casey. So, if one is missing that you think should be here, that's probably the reason.
(Note: if a fic has a * at the end, it's a sequel and the first in the series will be above it.
If a fic has ** at the end, it's unfinished, but it's on this list because it is THAT GOOD.)
Best of Casey Goes to New York
this damage you did to me
by theredhoodie | rated E | 12,403 words
It’s been over a year since Casey left her life in Canada and moved to NYC. Derek shows up unannounced at one of her performances wanting to talk about his feelings, while in contrast, Casey’s all about avoiding those feelings.
Who will win this fight, and is there even a fight to win?
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 stars
-
Best of Dasey Sharing a Bed
break the silence
by illicitaffair | rated M | 12,368 words
"Prove it.”
There was a beat of silence as Casey stared up at Derek in confusion. “What?”
“If you really have your life planned out and you’re sure you wouldn’t have any fun engaging in some teenage rebellion, then prove it,” Derek said. He drew in his bottom lip to bite and Casey inhaled sharply.
alternatively: three times derek and casey share a bed and one time they make out instead.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 stars
Your Heart Says Otherwise
by abitofstardust | rated G | 10,023 words
"Derek and Casey were doomed to hate each other for eternity, or at least pretend to do so. Falling in love with her stepbrother was never in her plans, and she hated when things escaped her control. Except this. She didn’t hate this. Not one bit."
Or the one where drunk Derek confesses his feelings for Casey.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 stars
-
Best of Dasey Sharing an Apartment
Two-Step
by avocadomoon | rated T+ | 12,467 words
Pacing back and forth in her bedroom that night, Casey makes a list of everything she's feeling, which is something her therapist told her to do whenever she feels like throwing something expensive out the window. It reads as follows:
1. ANGRY
2. ANGRY
3. ANGRY
(It goes on like this for a bit longer.)
14. GUILTY
15. SAD
16. HORNY ANGRY
17. LONELY,
- which is where she finally stops. It's only going to get more pathetic from here.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 stars
-
Best of Vacation With Derek Fix-Its
Two Pictures of Chaos
by Shadowfox1119 | rated E | 23,969 words
“Yeah, ‘step-sister,’ ‘sister.’ It’s all the same difference, right?”
My take on the before, during, and after the "Vacation with Derek" movie.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 stars
-
Best of Derek is Getting Married
then you come crashing in
by thencallitwinter | rated M | 22,349 words
It ends like these things always do: with that one guy who's in love with this other girl and first hearing about it from Edwin of all people. Derek/Casey. Casey/Jesse. Derek/OC. One-Shot.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 stars
-
Best of Derek's Directorial Debut, but make it a POV
How To Play Charades
by youcallitwinter | rated T+ | 1,675
The thing to know about him is; he's always been clueless. Like that movie Casey likes so much. The one in which those step-siblings get together. And it's not as if he's ever wondered whether that was supposed to imply something.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 stars
right in plain sight
by donutcats | rated T+ | 3,661 words
"I'm seconds away from asking myself some weird philosophical question like 'what is inspiration’.”
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 stars
-
Best of Dasey goes to University
Act II: College Life With Derek
by MoreThanOneInterest | rated T+ | 27,504 words
"So let me get this straight? You want to pretend we don't know each other?"
That's the idea, and Derek thinks it's a good one, so he can distract himself from Casey while at college. It works... at first. Until he can't get her out of his head, and it completely backfires on him. Because she starts dating Prince Charming.
T-M Rating. Might go up, might stay down. No one knows (officially).
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 stars
In Truth (and Otherwise)
by falsettodrop | rated M | 14,230 words
Sometimes she and Derek spoke like this. In little half-sentences, unspoken truths hidden deep within them, too difficult for the average person to find. But they both knew—they knew where to find them, and they knew what they’d find.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 stars
Salomé, as Experienced by Derek Venturi
by APHands | rated T+ | 3,196 words
Derek helps Casey read lines.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 stars
-
Best of Dasey What-Ifs
I Do/I Don't
by retreatingwings | rated T+ | 11,141 words
Derek throws one last house party his senior year of high school. Tispy, he kisses Casey. The next morning, she asks him if it was a drunken mistake, or if he meant it. He imagines the two paths their lives could take from that moment forward: one where he says he didn’t, and one where he says he did.
⭐⭐⭐⭐ 4/5 stars
-
Best of Dasey Texting Fics
Llamas and Siblings and Pies, Oh My!
by WakeUpSoon | rated T+ | 3,727 words
Edwin: I’ve invited you all here today to talk about the elephant in the room.
Lizzie: why do you keep doing this?
in which edwin has points to make, dasey have some secrets, and family is everything.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 stars
-
Best of Hurt/Comfort
If You Hadn't Gone
by Shommey99 | rated T+ | 14,499 words
Derek had always been under the impression that once Casey finally left him alone, he’d be at peace.
Until she did.
⭐⭐⭐⭐🎊 4.5/5 stars
Universe & U*
by Shommey99 | rated M | 19,124 words
Casey knew there was something between them, she wasn’t stupid. She remembered that night at the club so vividly, how she was ready to risk it all if he just asked. But it was him and her, so of course, it was going to be more complicated than that.
Or: A sequel to ‘If You Hadn’t Gone’, from Casey’s point of view.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 stars
Nightmares and Daydreams
by chunchun | rated T+ | 20,278 words
Derek's been having nightmares lately. Casey's trying to deal with a different side of him she's never seen before.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 stars
-
Best of Bittersweet Endings
you are my favorite what if
by donutcats | rated T+ | 1,051 words
No one really talks about unhappy ever afters.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 stars
She Wouldn't Be Gone
by Born2Read | rated T+ | 2,979 words
While searching for Casey to right what he broke, Derek reflects on where he went wrong. If he's lucky, maybe it isn't too late to repair the damage.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 stars
Dancing On My Own
by UntoldGalaxies | Rated T+ | 5,525
It was like a scene out of a fairy tale. Flowing gowns and romantic music swept the room, and they danced.
And Casey watched.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 stars
-
Best of Dasey Reality TV AUs
Dasey: Love Island**
by kensington_queen | rated E | 13,801 words
It's gonna be a long, hot, summer.
The Dasey Love Island AU ;)
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 stars
-
Best of Dasey Secret Kid Fics
Serenity
by Born2read | rated T+ | 38,974 words
The child arches her brow. “I didn’t come for an autograph. Hockey is a vile, violent sport.” She sniffs, and Derek’s reminded of…
“Hey, kid, where are your parents?”
“My name is Serenity,” she starts, pausing and eyeing him. Whatever she’s looking for in his expression, she doesn’t find it. “Serenity Venturi.”
Or, the one where Casey keeps the kid hidden from Derek and he finds out... when she shows up on his doorstep.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 stars
-
Best of Battle of the Bands AUs
Shot in the Dark
by Born2Reach | not rated | 29,096 words
Derek finds himself in debt and starts a band. Casey gets involved. Both have grown from their D-Rock days, and maybe they'll learn to get along. Or, more likely, they'll bicker and fight and deny any type of friendship. Either way, they're determined to win the Battle of the Bands.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 stars
-
Best of Dasey Slowburns with Divorce
so tell me when you're gonna let me in
by avocadomoon | rated M | 16,037 words
In which real, grown-up life is uh, actually not all that fun, sometimes.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5 stars
-
✨Best of the Best | God Tier Dasey Fics✨
Turn to Stone
by Shommey99 | rated T+ | 12,907 words
How well do you really know the people closest to you? Can you help them see reason before it’s too late? Basically, this is The Derek and Casey Show. From the point of view of everyone who’s not, well, Derek and Casey.
✨⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐✨ 10/5 stars
The Last Time*
by Shommey99 | rated M | 26,920 words
Eight years in the lives of Casey and Derek. Including denial, longing, fights, and what really happened in Cancun (twice).
✨⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐✨ 10/5 stars
A Thousand Years Go By (Love Don't Die)
by WakeUpSoon | rated T+ | 7,714 words
Dear Casey, the letter reads, Blah blah blah there’s some ghosts and shit. You guys wanna come see? Xoxo
They’ve been doing this a long time, but it’s not often they get a chance to help an old friend in need rather than a stranger.
Or, the one where the McTuri Siblings have a long-running paranormal investigation show on Netflix, and Sam gets a haunted house.
✨⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐✨ 10/5 stars
This is Life With Derek**
by justcallmedaisy | rated M | 124,619 words
After the announcement of Casey and Derek going to the same university and their "same difference" conversation in the kitchen, the reality sets in for both of them that they are in fact setting forth on this new chapter of their lives together. Both have to work through their ffff-feelings about it and about... each other?
✨⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐✨ 10/5 stars
Defining Life**
by APHands | rated E | 15,994 words
Casey McDonald was ambitious, to say the least. She had every moment and aspect of her education, career, and life planned out before she even entered high school.
And then, instead, her mom married George.
✨⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐✨ 10/5 stars
Ripple Effect
by abitofstardust | rated T+ | 5,820 words
synopsis: When Marti has to go to the hospital, Casey is faced with the task of comforting Derek. But maybe she's the one in need of comfort.
✨⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐✨ 10/5 stars
even if it's a lie
by anniebibannie | rated M | 14,685 words
Casey hadn’t known when she started the stupid, little game it would spiral out of control into… whatever this was turning into. It had been harmless, mostly. But whatever was happening between her and Derek now? Decidedly not harmless.
✨⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐✨ 10/5 stars
Changing on the Fly
by cacnophonous_noise | rated E | 48,005 words
But on that victory lap he finds himself wishing it was still high school, cause when he looks up into the stands, among the thousands of faces, there is one he never sees.
✨⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐✨ 10/5 stars
A Kind of Merry War
by blithers | rated E | 37,167 words
Three games that Derek and Casey played.
✨⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐✨ 10/5 stars
549 notes
·
View notes
❀ Dasey Fic Rec Friday #10
TGIF! It’s time to get comfy and read fanfiction!
A gentle reminder to leave kudos and comments for our incredible writers. <3
1. Holding Back by UntoldGalaxies | Words: 6,411 | Chapters: 1/1
Only our quiet (well, quiet-ish) nights are honest (well, honest-ish, with the exception of a few words).
The fighting, the arguing, what if it was all an act? It’s fluffy AND smutty. A perfectly blended mix, by the hand of a master. I don’t know this author but I think they’re neat.
2. i don’t know anything, but i know i miss you by illicitaffair | Words: 12,061 | Chapters: 1/1
“So, basically, you just want to reenact Clueless,” Emmy says flatly, tapping their worksheet once again.
Laurel ignores her tone and waves her hands around excitedly. “We can go shopping this weekend and buy some outfits! Dibs being Dionne since, you know, Black Girl power. You’re white and blonde, so you can totally pull off being Cher.”
“Girls,” Casey warns, aware that the duo hasn’t touched their worksheet for the last ten minutes. “I expect that to be finished by the end of period.”
“Yeah, sure, Ms McDonald,” Laurel replies. She turns towards Emmy and lowers her voice. “I’ll make a discord group chat. Operation Clueless is a go.”
This fic is so many things and it is everything. I’m not recommending it because it was written for me, but I guess that could be one reason I love it so much. It hits ALL the marks. A teachers AU with a bit of the usual banter and hostility, some honest to god fluff, a hilarious set up, a bunch of dumbass teens who have seen Clueless one too many times and should not be left without supervision, tons of female friendships, and a school dance!
3. For Nosebleeds! Nothing Else! by woochew07 | Words: 9,315 | Chapters: 6/?
Derek Venturi is lucky. He’s a hockey star. He’s attractive. Taller than average. And most importantly, stealth.
This is an AU where Derek is trans and Casey doesn’t even know until he needs supplies from her one day at school.
Listen, this fic had me at trans, but it’s a really genuine and honest exploration of gender identity and transgender issues AND ALSO IT’S A ROMANCE? Sold. Give me all the queer content.
4. Act II: College Life With Derek by MoreThanOneInterest | Words: 26,677 | Chapters: 12/?
"So let me get this straight? You want to pretend we don't know each other?"
That's the idea, and Derek thinks its a good one, so he can distract himself from Casey while at college. It works... at first. Until he can't get her out of his head, and it completely backfires on him. Because she starts dating Prince Charming.
It’s so goooood! Once I started it I could not put it down! The pacing and the humor are otherworldy is how good it is. Derek is at his best here as a scheming devil and, meanwhile, Casey is mostly oblivious to the fact that he is trying to date her. *Chef’s kiss*
5. This Is Life With Derek by justcallmedaisy | Words: 90,519 | Chapters: 8/?
Who said it all ended at Season 4, Episode 18? This is Life with Derek... continued.
An actual continuity of the show, tying in together the finale and the movie, and moving forward, imagining what Life With Derek, Again could have been had it been picked up (I’m still crying about it). It is so well executed, it reads just like watching the show. On point pacing and characterization.
48 notes
·
View notes