The One - A Hilary Knight Imagine
It’s finally here! The long awaited sequel to Sailing Again! If you haven’t read Sailing Again this won’t make much sense to you so read that first
It’s also uh 12000 words soooo settle in
This part is much more angstier than the first part, like, it’s incredibly angsty, more angst than fluff it’s bookended by fluff but there’s not much more fluff in here I apologize
I also realize that this was supposed to be Hilary taking care of R after her concussion and instead became the angstiest thing I’ve written with very little Hilary taking care of R soooo I’ll write a drabble or something of the first night where Hilary stays up taking care of R
The title is from Kodaline’s “The One” but I also think their song “Honest” also fits the vibe of this fic ngl okay I’m done talking you can get to the fic now
TW: vomiting
Y/N’s not allowed to play at all. She’s not even allowed to be on the ice. Not that she wants to, she can barely sit up without getting dizzy. Hilary stayed with her the first night, dutifully waking her up every two hours, sitting on the bathroom floor with her while she threw up for 30 minutes straight, got Y/N water, or food, or pain meds, or anything she needed or wanted. Y/N’s not even sure Hilary slept at all.
Y/N’s managed to convince the staff to let her stay with the team until the end of the tournament, although that might have to do with the entire training staff still being in Beijing and wanting to monitor her concussion first hand than with Y/N’s pleading. She stays in the same hotel, and when she feels up to it she joins the team for meals. She went to one practice, but the bus ride made her nauseous and the light hurt her eyes and she spent the entire practice in the bathroom with the lights off.
Hilary had to go back with her team, and Y/N’s sad about it. She’s really sad about it. She missed Hilary so much and they finally got to a good place and then Hilary had to leave and Y/N can’t even call her because looking at her phone makes her head hurt. She can’t even do anything to distract herself. She’s hurt, she’s miserable, and she just wants to go home.
There’s a knock at her door. She ignores it, she doesn’t feel like getting up, and whatever they want her for is something she doesn’t feel like doing anyway. Still the knocking continues. Y/N just barely restrains herself from hitting her pillow in frustration as she gets up. She opens the door, not even bothering to open her eyes.
“What?”
“I have to say, this isn’t the welcome I expected.”
Y/N’s eyes shoot open.
“Hilary!”
Hilary laughs and wraps Y/N up in her arms when Y/N throws herself at her. “Hi baby,” Hilary says.
They stumble into the room together, neither letting go, and they fall onto the bed and Hilary laughs until Y/N groans and presses her fingers to her temples.
“I’m so sorry, are you okay?” Hilary says, “Can I get you anything?”
“No,” Y/N takes a deep breath, “I’m good.”
“I don’t mind getting you anything, water or painkillers, a damp cloth, anything, okay?”
“What are you doing here?” Y/N asks, changing the subject.
“We’re playing each other tomorrow, the gold medal game,” Hilary says, “We’re staying in the same hotel again finally.”
“Gold medal game?” Y/N asks, “But you just played Russia? No,” Y/N shakes her head, “Switzerland, right?”
Hilary’s smile is tight.
“I’m wrong,” Y/N huffs in frustration, “I can’t even remember what fucking game happened last.”
“It’s okay,” Hilary’s quick to reassure, “I know you haven’t been watching, it’s okay. You don’t need to remember the games, just the game tomorrow, that’s all.”
Y/N doesn’t respond, she just rolls over so she can rest her head on Hilary’s shoulder. Hilary’s hand comes up and gently rubs the back of Y/N’s neck.
“I used to do this to Kess when her concussion was bad, she said it helped a lot,” Hilary whispers, “But she might have been humouring me because I was floundering trying to find something I could do to help.”
Y/N doesn’t know what comes over her, or why, but suddenly she’s crying hard into Hilary’s shoulder. Hilary freezes.
“I’m so sorry, I’m stupid, I shouldn’t have brought Kess up at all,” Hilary starts shifting and Y/N whines when she’s forced to lift her head, “I wasn’t thinking. You’re probably still upset with her and I don’t blame you. Damn, use your brain Hilary.”
“It’s not that,” Y/N says, “I don’t know, I’m just so tired and I missed you so much.”
“I missed you too,” Hilary says, “I love you more than anything. I’m sorry you’re feeling gross, I wish I could help you more.”
“Hold me?”
“I’ll never let you go.”
***
Y/N knows she shouldn’t be here. When Hilary failed to sneak out of bed, she told Y/N to only watch the game (on TV) if her head didn’t hurt. When she boarded the team bus, everyone looked at her like she was crazy, and the trainers tried to get her to go back inside. She insisted she was fine, that her head didn’t hurt and promised that if she started to feel bad that she would leave.
And her head doesn’t necessarily hurt, perse, it’s mostly a dull ache in the back of her skull, so really she’s not technically wrong in saying her head doesn’t hurt. It doesn’t hurt any worse than it’s been hurting, and she hasn’t felt nauseous in days, so what’s the harm in a watching one hockey game?
It turns out, a lot of harm.
The lights immediately are too much, and the dull ache becomes a sharp pain radiating throughout her whole head. She tries to tough it out, after all, it’s the gold medal game, and she wants, needs, to be here to support her team. She presses the heel of her palms against her eyes and tries to ignore the pain. But then the cheers after the first goal are so deafening that Y/N actually feels like her head might split open, and she tries to leave, but standing up makes her dizzy and she’s forced to sit back down.
The pain only gets worse and during the second period she ignores the dizziness because she knows if she sits there much longer, she’ll throw up all over the seats. Somehow, she manages to find her way to the locker rooms and into one of the private bathrooms. She doesn’t know how long she sits on the floor feeling nauseous, but she doesn’t even lift her head when the door opens.
“Occupied,” She mumbles.
“Oh, baby,” Hilary’s gentle voice reaches Y/N’s ears, “Oh, my love, I’m sorry.” Hilary kneels on the floor and brushes Y/N’s hair away from her eyes.
“Hil? Why aren’t you playing?”
“The game’s over. I heard that you left in the second period, I came to find you.”
There’s no fans in the stadium, how did Hilary know where to find her? Or that she was even there? Then Y/N remembers the taxi squads that were sitting in the section to her right, they must’ve seen her.
“Did you win?” Y/N turns her head just enough that she can look Hilary in the eye. Hilary smiles sadly.
“No, you won baby, you guys won, you’re a gold medalist.”
“I am?” Y/N says, “But I didn’t play.”
“You played in the prelims, and you’re on the squad, you get a medal.”
“Sorry.”
“Don’t be sorry, I’m so proud of you. And I don’t need a medal when I got the best prize I could get right here,” Hilary kisses Y/N on the forehead and Y/N leans into her. Then, after breathing through her nose and realizing Hilary hasn’t showered yet, and immediately turns and throws up in the toilet.
“Oh shit, shit babe,” Hilary rubs Y/N’s back, shifting closer, and it only makes Y/N throw up more.
“Hil,” Y/N manages to get out, “Go shower or I will puke on you.”
When Hilary comes back, hair damp and in new clothes, Y/N still hasn’t moved off the floor. Hilary bends down and gently puts her arms under Y/N’s knees and around her back. Slowly, Hilary begins to lift Y/N off the floor. Y/N makes a sound of protest.
“I can walk,” Y/N says.
“I know, but I also know you’re tired, and I don’t mind carrying you.”
“You just played a whole game, put me down.” Y/N begins to squirm in Hilary’s arms. Hilary scrambles to keep Y/N from falling to the floor.
“Y/N! It’s alright, just let me carry you,” Hilary says, “You’re gonna make me drop you.”
“Let me go!” Y/N pushes at Hilary’s chest, “I said I could walk, put me down!”
“Baby…”
“I’m not a baby! Let me down!”
The sound of her own voice makes Y/N pause. Sure, she’s snapped at Hilary before and sure they fought, but she doesn’t think she’s ever sounded so angry. Hilary pauses as well. Before Y/N can think to apologize, Hilary has placed her feet gently on the ground, letting Y/N stand up on her own.
“I’m sorry,” Hilary says, “I just wanted to help. I didn’t mean to make you feel like I’m babying you. I’m sorry, I’ll ask next time, okay?”
“Hil…” Y/N tries to get Hilary to look her in the eye, but Hilary keeps staring at her shoes. Y/N takes Hilary’s hand and tugs her closer. Finally, Hilary looks up. “I didn’t mean to yell. I’ve just been so frustrated. I can’t do anything anymore because of my head and I just want to feel like I’m still in control of myself sometimes.”
“I know, I’m sorry.”
“I forgive you.”
“I know,” Hilary whispers. The guilty look won’t leave her eyes and Y/N wonders if they’re still talking about the same thing.
“You shouldn’t,” Hilary whispers when Y/N turns around.
“What?” Y/N asks. Hilary says nothing, just puts her hand on the small of Y/N’s back and leads her out of the bathroom.
***
Y/N groans when she wakes up, pressing her face into the pillow. The bedside lamp is turned off and Y/N blearily turns her head towards Hilary who’s sitting up in bed beside her. Hilary holds out a glass of water and painkillers. Y/N takes them both gratefully. She sits up long enough to take the painkillers and drink most of the water before she hands the glass back to Hilary and settles back in bed, her head resting on Hilary’s hip. Hilary’s hand rubs between Y/N’s shoulders.
“Y/N,” Hilary says. Y/N hums in acknowledgment. “We need to talk about earlier.”
“What about it? I’m sorry I yelled at you, I didn’t mean it.”
“No, I mean…” Hilary sighs, “I don’t want to upset you. But it was a bad idea for you to go to the game.”
“I wanted to.”
“That doesn’t mean you should’ve gone. Concussions are serious–”
“And you don’t think I know that?” Y/N sits up, moving away from Hilary and crossing her arms.
“I know you know, I just mean that I don’t think you considered the consequences of going. You’re still in the early stages of recovery, it’s so easy to do something that will set you back. The game wasn’t more important than your health.”
“You don’t get to decide what’s important to me!”
“Y/N, you’re not listening–”
“You’re not listening!” Yelling is making Y/N’s head hurt, but she can’t help it. Hilary doesn’t even sound angry, just tired. “It’s my first Olympics and I wasn’t going to miss the gold medal game!”
“You have a concussion, I understand why you wanted to go, but, Y/N,” Hilary takes a deep breath, “You didn’t even get to watch the game because of your head. You should’ve stayed in the hotel and watched the game on TV.”
“I wanted to support my team!”
“You still support them from here, you didn’t need to go to the game to do that.”
“It’s my first Olympics!”
“There will be more Olympics!” Finally, Hilary starts to sound angry, “More tournaments! But there won’t be if you keep doing stupid shit and don’t let yourself heal! You can’t just–” Hilary huffs angrily, “You have a serious injury–”
“And whose fault is that?” Y/N snaps, “I didn’t tell your team to go after me, did I? It’s not my fucking fault you’re so ashamed of yourself that you can’t even be honest with your friends!” Hilary looks like Y/N just slapped her. All the anger is gone from her face, replaced by hurt. She stares at the ceiling for a moment, then she gets off the bed.
“I’m sorry that I’m concerned for you,” Hilary says, “If you’re still upset with me I’ll leave.”
A sob rips from Y/N’s throat. The fight is making her head hurt and the guilt at making Hilary upset is making her feel even worse. She knows she was wrong, she knows she shouldn’t have gone to the game and she knows Hilary is just looking out for her and she knows it’s not fair to take her frustrations out on Hilary. She just wants to be able to do the things she wants to do, things she normally can, and it frustrates the hell out of her that she can’t anymore. And she’s terrified out of her mind that she never will again.
“I’m sorry,” Hilary is at her side in an instant, “I didn’t mean to yell. I wasn’t thinking, what do you need?” Y/N shakes her head. Hilary shouldn’t be apologizing, she’s the one who should be apologizing.
“I’m sorry,” Y/N says through her tears, “I shouldn’t… I’m just so frustrated and I know it’s not your fault. I’m sorry, I’m so sorry, I just don’t… I can’t… I’m so angry.”
“You have every right to be angry,” Hilary says, “I’ve been terrible to you and I know you said you forgive me, but you don’t have to, you can still be angry, I understand.”
“I’m not…” Y/N’s frustration is growing with Hilary not understanding her. “You don’t get it. I’m not angry at you. I’m just…” Y/N rubs her face, growing sticky with the drying tears, “This whole situation sucks and I’m just angry.”
“I’m sorry, I know it’s really frustrating and I’m sorry I’m making it worse,” Hilary lays down beside Y/N and pulls her into her arms, “I just care about you so much and I want you to get better. I love you.”
“I love you too,” Y/N mumbles.
***
The two fly back individually with their own teams and while her team goes on their victory tour, Y/N takes another flight to Minnesota. Hilary meets her at the airport.
“How was your flight?”
Y/N doesn’t answer, just drops her bag at Hilary’s feet and lets her weight rest on Hilary while Hilary’s arms circle around her. Y/N closes her eyes, takes a deep breath, and lets Hilary’s familiar scent relax her.
“Are you tired baby?” Hilary asks, “Does your head feel okay?”
“Just wanna go home.”
***
In all honesty, Hilary is worried about Y/N. She’s not taking care of herself and Hilary worries that if she wasn’t here, Y/N would make her concussion so much worse than it already is. Hilary is the one who drags Y/N out of bed to get a change of scenery or to shower or to eat sitting up at the table instead of slouched in bed. It’s Hilary who makes sure Y/N is eating good meals and not just trash she can have delivered. It’s Hilary who makes sure Y/N goes to bed at a reasonable time, gets enough sleep, stays off electronics that make her headaches worse. If Hilary wasn’t here, Y/N would have no one to take care of her.
Which is why Hilary is terrified to tell her she’s leaving.
Not forever, just for a few weeks. She’s put it off as long as she could, but post-Olympic press can’t wait forever. Her federation has been on her since the Olympics ended to do a press tour. She put it off, saying she needed a break, citing mental health and physical recovery from the demands of the Olympics, and of course she’s Hilary Knight, they’ll give her what she asks but only to a certain extent. She’s already signed up for a camp in San Francisco, as the hometown hero, and a camp in Boston. The federation has signed her up for press conferences and media appearances in New York, Chicago, Houston, and Las Vegas. She forced them to book everything back to back so she’ll only be gone for three weeks max, but it’s three weeks nonetheless.
Hilary’s drawn back to reality when the kettle whistles. She quickly turns it off and pours the hot water into two mugs, adding milk and sugar the way Y/N likes it. Caffeine makes her headaches worse so Y/N’s switched to tea instead of coffee and Hilary switched with her so that Y/N wouldn’t feel jealous that Hilary got to drink coffee and she didn’t. Hilary carries the two mugs, carefully, so that she wouldn’t spill a drop. She places one mug on the nightstand and uses her free hand to gently shake Y/N awake before handing her the other mug.
“Ugh,” Y/N says after taking a sip, “I really miss coffee.”
“Me too.”
“Stop, at least you can actually still drink it,” Y/N bumps her shoulder against Hilary’s, “No one forced you to stop, I don’t know why you would.”
“Solidarity.”
Y/N hums, taking another sip. Hilary holds her mug in her hands, not really drinking it. Y/N drinks her tea and tells Hilary all about the weird dream she had and Hilary tries to react at the appropriate times, but her mind is on the press tour and making a mental list of what she needs to pack and how she can make sure Y/N’s doing okay while she’s away, and maybe if she fakes an injury or an illness she can get out of the second camp and be home a week early and–
“Hilary!”
Y/N’s voice snaps Hilary out of her thoughts.
“Sorry, what were you saying?”
“What’s up with you?”
Hilary sighs. She doesn’t know how to say it. Or how Y/N will react. She promised that she would be here to take care of her and that she wouldn’t ever leave her when she needs her, but now she’s about to tell Y/N that she’s leaving when Y/N’s concussion still makes her daily life so much harder. She wishes more than anything she could tell her federation and her agent to get bent and that she’s not leaving, she knows she can’t.
“Hilary,” Y/N says, “You’re doing it again.”
“Sorry,” Hilary sets her now cold mug of tea on the nightstand, “Sorry, there’s just something I need to tell you.”
“Okay,” Y/N sets her own mug down, turning to give Hilary her full attention.
“I’m leaving.”
A beat, then:
“What the fuck?”
“I’m sorry, I know it’s awful timing, but–”
“You’re leaving?” Y/N says, “Are you kidding me? You said you loved me and now you’re leaving?”
“I do!” Hilary tries to grab Y/N’s hands but she jerks away, “I wouldn’t go if I didn’t have to! My agent has been bugging me for weeks about it.”
“Oh so your agent gets to decide when your relationship is over?”
“Wait what?” Now Hilary is really confused. “What are you talking about?”
“What am I talking about? You just told me you’re breaking up with me!”
“What? No! Nononono, babe,” Hilary frantically tries to grab Y/N’s hands or to hug her, “That’s not what I meant! I’m not leaving you, I’m going on a press tour! I’ll only be gone for like three weeks, I swear, I promise I’ll never leave you. I love you.”
“Oh.”
“I’m sorry, I guess just saying I’m leaving isn’t the right way to have that conversation.”
“Yeah, I guess,” Y/N lets Hilary pull her into her arms, “When do you leave?”
“My flight is Friday.”
Four days from now.
“And you’ll be gone three weeks?”
Hilary nods, “It’s the shortest I could make it. If there was any way out of it I’d do it.”
“It’s okay,” Y/N says, “I get it. And it’s not like holding my hair back every time I throw up is the most glamourous job, huh?”
“I don’t mind taking care of you, you know that,” Hilary says, “I’m not just trying to get away from you, I’d never do that.”
“I know, it was just a joke, sorry.”
“Oh. I guess we’re just completely misunderstanding each other today huh?”
“I guess so,” Y/N lifts her head off Hilary’s chest to look in her eyes and give her a smile, “It’s okay. It sucks that you’re leaving, but I’ll be okay. I can take of myself for three weeks, and we’ll talk, right? When I call you’ll call me back at least?”
“Of course,” Hilary can tell by Y/N’s tone that she’s just teasing, but it doesn’t lessen the guilt that blooms in her chest when she thinks of the weeks she went radio silent.
“I’ll be okay,” Y/N lays her head back on Hilary’s chest, “You don’t have to worry about me.”
Hilary doesn’t say anything, just kisses Y/N’s head and holds her impossibly closer.
***
Friday comes way too quickly for either of them, and all too soon Hilary’s heading off to the airport. Y/N insists that she’ll be fine on her own and Hilary wants to believe her, but she’s so worried that she can’t help but think the second the plane takes off something bad will happen and Hilary won’t be there to help. She waits until the last possible moment to leave the apartment, barely making it to the airport with enough time to get through security. She checks her phone anxiously for a message from Y/N until she’s forced to turn her phone off.
When her plane lands, the first thing Hilary does is turn her phone back on. She still has no messages from Y/N, only a few from her agent. She grabs her bags and meets her agent who drives her to the hotel she’s staying at. Hilary normally loves coming home, back to California, reminding herself of what it was like to grow up here, but right now, all she can think about is Y/N miles away, alone and hurt.
The camp goes by quick but slow at the same time. Hilary loves working with kids, teaching them hockey and seeing how they improve and how their confidence grows each day. It’s the times after the kids have all gone home and Hilary’s left alone. She doesn’t want to go out, she doesn’t want to see people, she just wants to go home. When she’s on the ice with the kids, time flies. But when she’s alone in her hotel room, time drags on until Hilary’s not even sure the clocks are working anymore. When the last kid leaves the ice on the last day, Hilary sighs, knowing there’s nothing to speed the days up while she does interview after interview.
But she only has two weeks left.
***
Y/N’s bored. There’s not much she can do. She can’t go to the gym, she can’t go on the ice, all of her friends in the city are hockey friends who aren’t here because they don’t live here in the offseason or they’re busy doing post Olympics press. Post Olympic press that Y/N should be doing. Her own team is out celebrating their gold medal and she can’t even do that. Sure, she could’ve gone to stay with her family but she didn’t feel like spending a month sleeping on her parent’s couch and she thought Hilary was going to be here with her.
At least when Hilary was still here, Y/N was distracted. Whenever she started to think about the Olympics and what her teammates were doing, Hilary would be there and Y/N would stop thinking about it. But now, she’s alone and there’s nothing to stop her from thinking about it. She needs a distraction before she spirals, and just because Hilary isn’t here, doesn’t mean she can’t be that distraction.
For the first time in weeks, Y/N turns her phone on. She ignores the unopened texts and missed phone calls and goes online, quickly pulling up Hilary’s press interviews. She’s stayed away from electronics since she got injured so it can’t be too bad for her to watch a few short interviews Hilary has done, right?
She loads up the first video and grins as Hilary’s face appears on the screen.
“Today we are joined by Olympian Hilary Knight! Hilary, thank you for being here,” The interviewer says, “First, let me ask how you have been doing?”
“I’m good,” Hilary says, “It’s tough losing the Olympics and coming home with silver, but I’m really proud of the team and honestly, kudos to Canada they deserve it completely, and now it’s just learning from this and coming back stronger.”
“And how do you come back stronger? It’s hard to believe that you Hilary Knight need to work on anything.”
Hilary laughs before answering her question. They ask a few more basic questions about the Olympics and the team and Hilary answers them. Then, the interviewer puts down her notes and turns to Hilary.
“So, Hilary,” She begins, “We understand that you’re quite private about your personal life, but many are asking are you in a relationship?” Hilary looks taken aback.
“Um, well,” Hilary laughs nervously, “Yeah. Yeah I am. And I’m really happy.”
“That’s a bit of a disappointment to fans who’ve been hoping to score a date with you,” The interviewer laughs and Hilary smiles weakly. Y/N wants to launch herself through the screen and give the interviewer a piece of her mind for making Hilary uncomfortable. “What can you tell us about this mystery person?”
“Well,” Hilary shifts in her seat, “Well, I’ll tell you that she’s amazing. The best person I’ve ever met and everyday I think I fall in love a little more and I couldn’t be happier.”
“Well there you have it, Hilary Knight is off the market! Thank you so much for joining us today!”
Part of Y/N is giddy at the things Hilary said about her, but part of her feels apprehensive about it. They never talked about being more open with their relationship or admitting to being in one to the public. Logically, Y/N knows that Hilary didn’t say who she’s dating and she’s not outing Y/N by saying she’s in a relationship with someone. But she can’t help but feel… something and she can’t help but wish that Hilary would have talked to her beforehand. But she also knows the question caught Hilary off guard and she wasn’t prepared for it. Still, Y/N can’t imagine she would immediately admit to being in a relationship in an interview without talking to Hilary first.
Y/N knows she shouldn’t, everyone tells her stay away from the comments, but she can’t help it. The first few comments are just keysmashes and comments on how hot Hilary looks which, well, Y/N can’t argue with. Then as she keeps scrolling, an uneasy pit builds in her stomach.
Did hilary just confirmed her and y/n???
I told you all they were together!!! Did you see how Hilary raced to her when she got hurt?
No wonder hilary ripped into her teammates after y/n’s concussion that’s her gf right there
With each new comment, Y/N feels her anxiety growing. She manages to force herself to close the app but she can’t stop herself from opening twitter and searching her and Hilary’s names. There are more comments about their relationship but now there’s pictures. Paparazzi pictures of the two at the airport, with Hilary’s arms around Y/N. Pictures from the game, of Hilary’s face when Y/N got hit, Hilary kneeling over Y/N on the ice, Hilary following as the trainers took Y/N off the ice. There’s screenshots of Hilary’s Instagram posts with Y/N in them, posts that Y/N knows are from when they weren’t together, but everyone believes they were. The more and more she scrolls, the worse and worse she feels, but she can’t stop. Even when her head starts to spin and the pain behind her eyeballs grows, she can’t stop. It’s only when her phone rings that she stops scrolling.
“Hey,” Jill says when she answers, “Finally turned your phone on, huh? We’ve been trying to call you, see how you’re doing.”
“I’m okay,” Y/N mumbles.
“You sure? You don’t sound good.”
“I’m good.”
“It’s okay, if you’re not,” Jill says, “Honestly if you told me you’ve never felt worse that’d be totally valid. I’m surprised you even answered.”
“I’m allowed to be on my phone!” Y/N snaps.
“I know,” Jill placates, “I just meant I’m surprised you’re feeling up to talking. Is Hilary taking good care of you?” Y/N wants to throw up at the mention of Hilary, her anxiety skyrocketing.
“She’s not here.”
“What?”
“She left. Some press thing. I don’t know,” Y/N says, “Look Jill, I have a headache, I’ll call you back. I promise I’m doing okay.”
Then Y/N hangs up and throws her phone to the side.
***
Hilary frowns when her call goes to voicemail again. Every text since her ‘landed safe’ text from the airport has been left unanswered. She knows Y/N might be sleeping, or showering, or eating, or just doesn’t have her phone on her, but she still worries. And she’s alone in a hotel room with nothing to entertain herself with for another hour and a half while she waits for her next interview.
The phone rings twice before it’s answered.
“Hey Hil, how are things?” Jill says.
“It’s alright, considering. You?”
“Yeah, good. I won’t rub it in so I’ll not tell you how cool it is to show off the gold medal I just won,” Jill teases and Hilary rolls her eyes, “What’s up? Y/N told me you left for some press thing?”
“Yeah, not my choice,” Hilary says, “I’ll be back in two weeks. That’s why I called you. Y/N hasn’t answered my calls and I know she’s probably just not on her phone, you know, with her concussion, but I wanted to ask if you’ve talked to her and if she’s doing okay.”
“You think she’d answer my calls over yours?”
“Well. Maybe,” Hilary rubs the back of her neck, “She said she wasn’t but I think she might still be upset with me. About the whole breakup thing. Not that I blame her, I was a real jerk. I wanted to take it back as soon as I said it.”
“Said what?” Immediately Jill’s tone changes.
“You know,” Hilary says, “During our fight… She didn’t tell you?”
“Tell. Me. What?”
Hilary gulps. She knows Y/N is like a sister to Jill and she honestly thought Y/N would have told Jill what happened. She didn’t think she’d have to tell Jill herself about how horrible she is. She’s known Jill for long enough to know that Jill will tear her a new one for hurting Y/N so bad and for everything that happened afterward. Hilary knows now why Jill never blamed her for Y/N concussion, she didn’t know what really happened.
“Jill, you gotta understand,” Hilary starts, “I didn’t mean it. I was upset and stressed and sleep deprived and I know it doesn’t excuse it but Y/N forgave me and I’m doing everything to make it up to her. I promise I will never hurt her like that again.”
“Hilary.” Jill says, “You are going to tell me right now what you are talking about or I will come hunt you down.”
“I told her I wanted space for the Olympics and she got upset and I got upset and I… I told her… I said that… I couldn’t focus on the Olympics if… if I was too busy babysitting her.”
Jill is silent and Hilary knows she screwed up.
“I didn’t mean it!” Hilary says desperately, “I know I messed up and I’d take it back if I could! I swear I will spend the rest of my life making it up to her and I’d never–”
“Hilary,” Jill says sharply, “I don’t think you understand how much that girl loves you.”
“I do!”
“No. You don’t understand. That girl would do anything for you, even forgive you for something unforgiveable,” Jill says, “Tell me, what did you do to make up for it before she forgave you? I’ll tell you. Nothing. You made that girl’s life hell for weeks and you think it’s okay just because she forgave you right away? You have a hell of a lot of work to do to prove that you’re really sorry and to earn her trust back. You think running off soon after is going to be fine? You think she won’t sit and think and realize you don’t deserve her forgiveness? I saw your interview Hilary. I saw what everyone’s saying. She’s a kid and you’re taking advantage of her. Do you want her to start believing that?”
“Jill…” Hilary croaks, “I… I love her. You know I do. I never… I never wanted to hurt her. I never want to hurt her. I’m not… You don’t think I’m taking advantage of her, do you? That’s not… I’m not…”
“No, I don’t. I know you, and while I think you’re an idiot and did something shitty, I know you’re not a bad person. I know you’re not taking advantage of her. But you need to make sure she believes that.”
“I will, I will. Jill, I gotta go, I gotta go home.”
“Hilary,” Jill says before Hilary can hang up, “If I hear that you hurt her one more time I swear on everything that’s holy I will make your life hell.”
***
It takes a hell of a lot to convince her agent to let her go. She doesn’t give them a choice though. She calls her agent right after she hangs up with Jill and tells him to figure it out, she’s going home and he can’t stop her. After back and forth arguing with Hilary threatening to find new management, he quickly releases a statement, citing the post-Olympic slump and Hilary’s mental and physical health for her absence. Hilary releases her own apology to everyone who signed up for camp with her and to the media personnel she’s inconvenienced. Then she books a flight and goes home.
After a few long hours, Hilary is back and Ubering to Y/N’s apartment. When she finally gets there, exhausted and anxious, she’s torn between ripping the door open just so she can get in bed and cuddle up to Y/N quicker, and never opening the door so that Y/N doesn’t have the chance to leave her for being such a shit girlfriend. In the end, she decides to just open the door slowly, quietly slink inside and see if Y/N’s around or awake.
“Y/N?” Hilary says quietly, “It’s me, I’m home.”
There’s no response, so Hilary sets her bag down by the door. She’ll unpack later, when she feels less tired. The lights in the apartment are off, so Hilary heads first to the bedroom. Sure enough, Y/N’s asleep. She’s wearing Hilary’s sweatpants and one of Hilary’s shirts. Hilary loves it when Y/N wears her clothes. They always make her look tiny and it’s so fucking cute to see Y/N drowning in a shirt that has Knight written across the shoulders.
And maybe Hilary’s a little possessive too.
Hilary strips down and changes into comfy clothes that don’t smell like airplane. She slides gently into bed behind Y/N and spoons her from behind. Hilary can feel Y/N’s sharp intake of breath as she starts to wake up.
“It’s just me, babe,” Hilary whispers, kissing the back of Y/N’s head.
“Hil?” Y/N turns her head just enough that she can look Hilary in the eyes. “You’re not supposed to be home yet.”
“I know. I came back early because…” How does Hilary sum up ‘I came back because I love you and I screwed up before and I don’t think you’ve forgiven me fully and I think I keep making things worse and I don’t know how to exist without you so I came back before you could think to break up with me and I thought if I was here you wouldn’t be mad at me or think that I’m taking advantage of you because I’m not’? “I… I just missed you. And I love you.”
“Missed you too,” Y/N’s eyes are closing gently, sleep beginning to wash over her, “‘nd love you too. You look tired, wanna nap?” Hilary smiles softly, kissing the back of Y/N’s head again when Y/N turns back around to get comfortable in bed again.
“You’re already halfway there,” Hilary whispers, “I can’t wait to join you.”
***
Hilary’s been back for three days. Of course Y/N’s happy. Excited. Thrilled. She missed Hilary and her stupid concussion is making all her emotions go crazy and crying gave her a headache. A terrible combination. But, in general, overall, Y/N’s happy that Hilary is back.
Except, Hilary’s walking on eggshells around her.
She’s so careful in everything she says, everything she does. Every conversation is filled with pauses where Hilary gets this look on her face like she’s debating what to say. Hilary’s never not known what to say to her. It makes Y/N second guess herself, and she finds herself doing the same as Hilary, debating everything she says. Things between them are awkward now, stilted.
Sometimes, sometimes Y/N catches Hilary looking at her with a look of pity and guilt on her face. Y/N doesn’t know why and Hilary never brings it up and she never asks. She never really asks why Hilary came back early either. She doesn’t think she wants to know.
The distance between them grows until they’re laying on opposite sides of the same bed, not touching. Sitting on opposite sides of the table during meals, opposite sides of the couch. They barely talk about anything now. Nothing real. Just simple bullshit ‘how did you sleep?’, ‘did you like the salad?’, ‘looks like rain’. Y/N hates feeling like a stranger around Hilary. She doesn’t know how to fix it.
Y/N wakes up one night and Hilary isn’t in bed beside her. Even though her and Hilary have been basically sleeping apart, Y/N still sleeps better with Hilary in the bed beside her and she doesn’t feel like she’ll fall asleep again until she knows what Hilary’s up to. She finds Hilary in the living room, looking at her phone. Hilary’s back is to her and she doesn’t notice Y/N coming up behind her, giving Y/N a chance to see what she’s looking at. Y/N’s brow furrows. Hilary’s… watching her own interview?
Y/N touches Hilary’s shoulder to get her attention and she can’t hold back the laugh that escapes her when Hilary jumps off the couch with a shriek.
“You! You scared me!” Hilary looks playfully appalled and for a second it’s like the old Hilary and the old Y/N are back. Then, new Hilary slips back in place and Hilary’s face pinches.
“Sorry,” Y/N says, sobering quickly, “I just wanted to know why you’re up.”
“Oh,” Hilary looks down at her phone, “Yeah. I was just… you know. Work stuff.”
“Watching your own interviews is work stuff?”
“It’s…” Hilary opens and closes her mouth, shifts her feet, looks around, swallows, then tilts her chin up, “I’m sorry if I woke you. Let’s go back to bed.”
Hilary walks past Y/N but before she can get far, Y/N grabs her wrist and pulls her back. Hilary looks annoyed for a second before she visibly bites it back.
“Hil, I know something’s bothering you, and I know things have been rocky between us and dammit Hilary,” Y/N says, “I’ll be damned if I lose you twice. Please, just talk to me.”
Hilary sighs. Then she sinks onto the couch and Y/N joins her. Y/N waits for her to speak, but she doesn’t.
“Okay, I’ll start,” Y/N says, “I wanted to be excited when you came home because I love you and I missed you, but then you were acting weird and I thought it was something I did then I realized it was something you did and I’ve been terrified to find out what you did that made you treat me like I would break if you even looked at me.”
Silence.
“Okay, now it’s your turn,” Y/N says, “C’mon Hilary, this has to go both ways.”
“I called Jill,” Hilary sighs, “Because you weren’t answering your phone. And she ripped me a new one for being a shitty girlfriend. And for not doing enough to make up for what I did to you. And made me realize that everyone thinks I’m taking advantage of you because I’m older than you and you’re just a kid. And I was terrified that you’d start to believe that and leave me.”
“I was upset. About your interview. That’s why I didn’t answer your calls.”
“Why?”
“Because you told everyone you were in a relationship. Everyone’s figured out it’s with me and it scares me to be out to the world and for everyone to know about us and I’m worried what that pressure will do to us, especially since we just got back together. And it upset me that you didn’t talk to me first about it.”
“She sprung the question on me,” Hilary says, “I didn’t know she was going to ask it.”
“I know. I still would’ve liked it if you talked to me.”
“How could I have talked to you about something I didn’t know was going to happen?” Hilary’s getting upset, but honestly, Y/N’s grateful for something other than the emotionless Hilary’s she’s been getting recently.
“You didn’t have to answer the question.”
“And that would’ve confirmed it too!”
“Or you could’ve said no and talked to me after about it.”
“So you want me to lie about us? Is that what you want?” Hilary’s not shouting, but she’s on the verge, “You want to hide our relationship? Tell everyone I’m single when I’m not and what? Want me to go on dates to throw everyone off? Maybe me and Kess could fake date to fool everyone if you’re so insecure about us!”
“I’m not insecure!” Y/N takes a deep breath to calm down, “There is nothing wrong with me being upset that you didn’t think to talk to me about something that affects the both of us.”
“It’s not your decision what I reveal about my personal life.”
“It doesn’t just affect you–”
“So I just have to do everything by your rules? Do I not get to make any decisions about us now? No, everything’s about you because you’re younger and you’re not a big star like me and I have to be so careful what I say to you because you’re hurt and it’s all my fault.”
“Hilary,” Y/N feels tears pricking at the corners of her eyes.
“Because I’m the bad guy,” Hilary stands up and shouts, “I’m the bad guy! It’s all my fault!”
The tears start falling and suddenly a sharp pain radiating from the back of Y/N’s head spreads over her whole head. She lets out a cry and doubles over. In an instant, Hilary’s kneeling beside her.
“I’m so sorry,” Hilary whispers, “I shouldn’t have yelled. Do you want me to get you some painkillers? Water? Are you hungry?”
“Painkillers,” Y/N manages to choke out, “Water.”
Hilary gets up and rushes out of the room. When she returns, she presses two pills into Y/N’s hand and hands her a cup of water. Y/N downs the pills and the water and then Hilary takes the cup from her.
“Come on,” Hilary helps Y/N up, “Let’s get to bed. We can talk more in the morning.”
Hilary helps Y/N lay down in bed and climbs in next to her. For the first time in what feels like forever, Hilary holds Y/N and kisses along her hairline. Finally, the pain begins to dull and Y/N finally relaxes.
“I love you,” Hilary whispers.
“I love you too,” Y/N says, but for the first time she doesn’t know if she really means it.
***
In the morning, Y/N wakes up, rolls out of bed without waking Hilary and heads to the kitchen. As she makes herself breakfast she thinks back to the night before. She knows she can’t expect Hilary to want to remain in the closet forever, after all, Hilary’s been in the closet for longer than Y/N and it’s only logical that she’s ready to be out now. But Y/N isn’t sure she’s ready to be out and she thought Hilary would understand that. Or at the very least, Hilary would listen to what she had to say and apologize. All Y/N wants is an apology.
The things Hilary said last night, the way she reacted, really hurt. Hilary’s been different since they got back together and at first, Y/N thought it was just her concussion, but now she’s sure it’s something else. Maybe Hilary regrets getting back together, maybe she wants to break up for good but doesn’t feel like she can because of Y/N’s concussion. And yeah, her concussion sucks but she’s not a baby, she can handle a breakup if that’s what Hilary wants. No reason for both of them to miserable.
Y/N’s so lost in her thoughts that she doesn’t notice Hilary come in. She doesn’t realize Hilary’s in the room until she lays a hand on Y/N’s shoulder. Y/N jumps.
“Penny for your thoughts?” Hilary says. Y/N shrugs. “Does your head still hurt?” Y/N shakes her head. “Good.” Hilary moves around the kitchen, making her own breakfast. She leans next to Y/N at the counter and sighs when Y/N won’t look up at her.
“Look, I wanted to apologize for last night. I shouldn’t have gotten upset like that and I shouldn’t have said what I did. I’ve just been stressed and I’m not handling things as well as I expected. That’s no excuse but I want you to know I’m really sorry.”
“Do you want to break up?”
“What?”
Y/N feels Hilary stand up straighter beside her. She chances a look and sees a look of shock, confusion, and worry on Hilary’s face.
“No!” Hilary says, “Why would you think that?”
Y/N shrugs. “You just… You’re just different. I thought you were only staying with me because you felt like you had to. Because,” Y/N gestures to her head, “It’s okay. I’ll be okay. You don’t have to stay with me ‘cause I’m hurt.”
“I don’t want to break up, I’m sorry I made you feel like that.”
“Well, I know Kess wouldn’t piss you off so much.”
Y/N spits out her name. She’s tried to convince herself that she’s over it, that she’s not upset with Amanda Kessel over her concussion or Hilary’s previous relationship with her, or the fact that she’s still Hilary’s best friend despite everything. But the resentment that rises every time Hilary mentions her name tells another story.
“Why… Why… What are you talking about? What does Kess have to do with any of this?”
The confused, concerned look on Hilary’s face would normally make Y/N smile at how adorable she looks, but instead it just makes her angry. She gives up trying to hold it in and lets it boil over until there’s metaphorical steam coming out her ears.
“Why don’t you just go date Kess if you love her so much?!” Y/N yells, shoving her plate into Hilary’s chest and storming out of the kitchen, leaving a shocked Hilary behind her.
***
“I just don’t know what to do,” Hilary says, “I feel like she’s going to be upset I even called you.”
“Yeah probably,” Amanda says, “I mean, I am mostly responsible for her concussion. Don’t argue with me,” She says before Hilary can even open her mouth, “Which I am so sorry about, by the way but she ignored my DM so safe to say she’s still upset with me. And, Hilary, come on, I know we’re just friends now but I’m still your ex and you’re still friends with me. Let the girl be a little jealous.”
“This is more than a little jealous,” Hilary says, “And it’s more than that. It’s like we don’t know how to talk to each other anymore. Every conversation is a fight.”
“I can’t fix this for you Hil,” Amanda says, “You need to work things out with her, not me.”
“I’m trying.”
“Maybe you’re just not trying the right things. Have you thought about doing couples therapy?”
“Couples therapy?”
“Yeah, you said you can’t talk to each other without it being a fight, so don’t,” Amanda says matter-of-factly, “Talk to someone else about what you’re feeling in front of her. Or talk to her with someone there mediating. It’s not for everyone but just talk to her about it and at least consider it. I know I’ve had my reservations about her but I really want you to be happy Hil, and I know she makes you happy. I want you to find a way to work things out.”
***
“So lets start with why you’re both here,” Shannon, their therapist, says, “Why did you decide to come to couples therapy Hilary?”
“I just… I really love her and I don’t know what’s wrong or how to fix it but I’ll do anything to make things work and… and I just thought that if we can’t talk to each other maybe talking to someone else would help,” Hilary says.
“Good,” Shannon says, “It’s good that you recognize that you might need outside help with the problems your relationship is facing. Y/N, why did you decide to come to couples therapy?”
“Because Hilary asked me to,” Y/N mumbles, not looking up from her lap.
“Okay, thank you for being honest. Now this isn’t for everyone so for our first session I just want to explain the benefits of couples therapy as well as how things will work during our time together and I want to get to know you both a little better as a couple and individuals,” Shannon says.
Shannon begins explaining and Hilary does listen but she also keeps an eye on Y/N. Y/N clearly doesn’t want to be there and Hilary can only hope she starts to open up and commit to trying this. Hilary is just happy that Y/N even agreed to go.
“So, let’s get to you both, okay?” Shannon says. Hilary looks back at her and nods. She sees out of the corner of her eye that Y/N nods too. “So, how did you two meet?” Hilary looks at Y/N but when she realizes Y/N isn’t going to answer, she does.
“We’re both hockey players and we met when we started playing for the same team.”
“And what was your relationship like then? Did you start dating soon after you met or were you friends first?”
“We were friends first,” Hilary looks to Y/N nervously, “I wasn’t… I liked her. When we met. I thought she was cute, um, but I didn’t really think about dating her and then… well, then I was nervous about it. I felt… I was just worried because she’s younger than me, I didn’t think I was allowed to like her, or be attracted to her, um, but I just couldn’t help liking her.” Hilary glances at Y/N, who’s staring at her in surprise. Hilary’s never told her any of this before.
“And what did you think about Hilary?” Shannon asks. After a beat, Y/N finally turns her head away from Hilary.
“I thought she was really hot.”
Hilary snorts.
“What? I did!” Y/N says. She elbows Hilary when Hilary won’t stop laughing. “Sorry I wasn’t as deep as you, I thought we were being honest.”
“Honesty is good,” Shannon says, smiling at the two, “So you thought she was hot.” Hilary snorts again and Y/N rolls her eyes.
“Yes, but then we started getting to know each other and Hilary was my first friend on the team and she’s just so sweet and caring and I… I just felt really good around her. I thought she was way out of my league until she got drunk and asked me out.”
“And was the transition hard? To go from friends to girlfriends?”
“No,” They both say at the same time.
“It was easy,” Hilary says, “We didn’t act much different around each other, we just added, you know, kissing and stuff.” Y/N nods her head in agreement.
“What would you say is the quote-unquote problem in your relationship? Is there perhaps one big issue you can think of or maybe a bunch of small disagreements? Hilary you mentioned that it feels like the two of you can’t talk to each other?”
“It just feels like we’re always fighting,” Hilary says, “Or we’re not talking. And whenever we try and talk things out we just get upset and yell at each other. I’m trying to be understanding but I don’t know what’s wrong because she won’t tell me and then I just get angry.”
“Why am I the problem?” Y/N says.
“I didn’t say that.”
“You said I won’t tell you what’s wrong but you never asked, you’re not understanding you don’t even bother trying,” Y/N crosses her arms and leans back on the couch with an angry huff.
“Well it’s not like you’re asking either,” Hilary mutters.
“Alright,” Shannon interrupts, “Let’s take a step back here. Hilary, you feel like Y/N isn’t telling you when something is bothering her and that frustrates you.” Hilary nods. “Now, Y/N, while you may disagree with Hilary’s side of things right now, what’s she’s doing is sharing how she feels and it’s important that both of you listen to the other and try and understand why they feel that way. So, Y/N, you seem to have a different side to the story than Hilary, can you share what you’re feeling?”
Y/N’s still sulking, but she answers.
“It’s like she doesn’t know what to say to me. Or like she’s hiding something or like she doesn’t want to upset me because of my concussion. She refuses to ever finish an argument because it’s gonna hurt my head or whatever. She just avoids every conversation we try to have. She keeps saying she’s sorry and then doing the same shit over and over! She says something mean in a fight and then says she’s so sorry she didn’t mean it and then she does it again! I don’t know how much more I can forgive her.”
It feels like all the air has been sucked out of the room. For a moment, Hilary’s shocked, speechless. Emotions flow through her, concern, fear, heartbreak, understanding, and then. Anger. It overpowers her and she can’t stop her mouth no matter how much she wants to. She doesn’t know if she wants to.
“This is what I’m talking about! You never talk to me!” Hilary turns towards Y/N, “If you’ve been feeling like this then why didn’t you tell me? I can’t read your mind! God you’re such a…”
“Go on say it!” Y/N snaps, “Say it, I’m such a child right? That’s all you think of me, I’m just some kid you’re taking advantage of because I’m too naïve to say no!”
“I wasn’t going to say that! And I’m not taking advantage of you!”
“Don’t you dare lie! You think I’m a child!”
“I do not!”
Hilary stands up and in an instant, Shannon is out of her seat and placing herself between the two of them. Hilary can still feel the anger thrumming under her skin but she forces herself to look away from Y/N and at Shannon. Shannon has her hands up in a placating gesture. Hilary hasn’t felt such strong, acute anger off the ice.
“I’m taking a walk,” Hilary gets out through gritted teeth.
“That’s a very good idea Hilary.”
Hilary crosses the room stiffly. She walks down to the lobby, each muscle in her body tight. She grabs one of the paper cups and fills it from the water cooler. When she raises it to drink, she notices her hand is shaking. She drinks the entire cup in one gulp then pours another one, gulping that one too. She crushes the cup in her fist before dropping it in the garbage. When she makes it back to the room, she knocks on the door first before opening it. Shannon is back to sitting in her seat and the atmosphere tells Hilary that they were talking about her.
“Welcome back Hilary,” Shannon says, “Are you ready to continue?” Hilary nods, sitting beside Y/N on the couch, leaving a noticeable distance between them.
“Sorry,” Hilary mumbles.
“Sorry too,” Y/N mumbles back.
“Our session is almost up,” Shannon says, “But while you were gone, Hilary, Y/N and I agreed that it would be very beneficial to you both if we had individual sessions as well as couple sessions. What are your thoughts on that?”
“Good,” Hilary says, “It sounds good.”
“Good. I’ll head down to the front with you so we can schedule some time for your individual sessions before our next couple session. Today was a good session and I look forward to seeing how we grow from here.”
***
Hilary has her first solo session a few days later. She’s nervous, but she’s not sure why. For some reason, sharing her deepest thoughts and feelings was easier when Y/N was next to her, but she knows why they should have solo sessions too. If their first session was any indicator, they won’t figure anything out because they’re too busy yelling at each other.
“So, let’s talk about our last session,” Shannon says. They’ve been talking, Shannon asking fairly easy questions for Hilary to answer. “You got quite upset and needed to step out. Can we talk about why you reacted that way?” Hilary shrugs.
“Why did what Y/N said upset you so much?” Hilary stares out the window and doesn’t respond. “Y/N told me about your breakup. About what you said. You got upset when Y/N accused you of something you already said to her.”
“I didn’t mean it.”
“I know. We say things we don’t mean when we’re upset. You understand this, and Y/N understands this. So why did you get upset at her?”
Hilary doesn’t say anything. Mostly because she doesn’t know what she’s supposed to say. She doesn’t know why she got so upset. She doesn’t know why she lost it. She never knows why she gets so upset over things, why she reacts the way she does. When Y/N said Hilary still thinks of her as a child, Hilary got frustrated because she knows it’s not true and Y/N doesn’t believe her.
“She doesn’t believe me.”
“About what?”
“That I didn’t mean it. That’s why she keeps bringing it up.”
“And why does that upset you?”
“If she doesn’t believe me then she doesn’t forgive me.”
“Hilary, you can’t force someone to believe you or forgive you. But the fact that she’s still here, still trying, means that even if she doesn’t, she wants to,” Shannon says, “And part of forgiveness, part of making up after a fight is proving that you won’t do it again. It may be frustrating that she hasn’t forgiven you yet, but she will if you keep putting in the effort to show her that you’re listening to her, that you understand what you did wrong and that you’re growing and becoming better. Hilary, I want to ask you now, have you forgiven yourself?”
Hilary feels like Shannon just smacked her in the face. Has she forgiven herself? Hasn’t everything she’s been trying to do been to make up for what she did? Has she been doing any of it for Y/N? Or has she been doing it for herself? The guilt that fills her whenever she thinks of that night, that’s not because of Y/N, that’s because Hilary still hasn’t forgiven herself for what she did and every time Y/N brings it up, she gets angry at herself and doesn’t know how to handle it.
Hilary shakes her head.
“Okay,” Shannon says, “It’s good that you recognize that. It seems that part of the reason you were so upset is because you’re still angry with yourself, is that correct?” Hilary nods. “And every time you both have a fight it adds to the guilt you feel, making yourself angrier, correct?” Hilary nods again. “Okay, we’ve made some really good progress today. Now, can you do something for me before our next session?” Another nod. “I want you to try and think of good times you and Y/N had together, times where you were a good girlfriend to her, ignore all the times you hurt her or upset her, and think of concrete examples of times where you were supportive or caring or even when you just made her happy to be around you. Can you do that? We’ll start our next individual session with that.”
***
“So, we touched on this briefly in our last session, but I want to discuss your and Hilary’s breakup,” Shannon says, “What she said to you hurt, didn’t it?”
“Of course it did,” Y/N says.
“And in your own words, you forgave her very quickly.” Y/N nods. “And correct me if I’m wrong, but it seems that you both moved on from it without really getting to the bottom of why she said what she did and why it hurt so much.”
“I guess.”
“What are your reasons for forgiving her so quickly and for not speaking it about it after it happened?”
“I just missed her,” Y/N says, “We didn’t talk for so long and I just missed her and I missed when things were okay and… well, I just didn’t want to think about it anymore. I just wanted her back.”
“You wanted to go back to when things were good, that’s understandable. And the Hilary you knew from before would never say those things to you.”
“She loved me – she loves me.”
“And I’m not arguing that,” Shannon says, “But you have realized by now that you can’t ignore what hurts or why it does and expect everything to be normal. That’s why we’re here, things didn’t go back to normal and you’re facing the repercussions of it. So lets talk about why it hurt. What upset you the most about what Hilary said?”
“She called me a child,” Y/N says, “She… I know I’m younger than her, I know I’m younger than anyone else she’s been with and I know she’s been in more relationships than me. I know I’m younger, I’m not as mature or grown up or experienced and I know it bothers her sometimes when I’m not mature and grown up. But she always said it didn’t matter. That everyone else’s opinions didn’t matter. That she loved me – loves me, and I believed her. And then she said that and it just… it just brought up every insecurity I had.”
“Insecurities about your role in the relationship? Or insecurities about yourself in general?”
“Everyone sees me as a kid except Hilary and… I told her once that everyone only tolerated me because they were waiting for her to breakup with me because I’m just a kid and she’s Hilary Knight. Sometimes I can’t help but think… maybe she’d be better off with someone older. Someone closer to her age, someone who gets her, you know someone like…”
“Like what?”
“She says there’s nothing, but I can’t help it. Kess is the reason I got hurt and she’s still best friends with her and she still hangs out with her and talks to her and what if she was happier with her than with me?”
“Have you spoken to her about your feelings towards Kess?”
Y/N crosses her arms and shrinks back in her seat. “No.”
“Do you think maybe you should?”
“I guess,” Y/N mumbles.
“The most important part of a healthy relationship is communication. You and Hilary both need to communicate to the other about insecurities you have and things that bother you before they lead to things like arguments and insults you don’t mean. Do you think you would be here if you and Hilary had discussed the breakup and how it affected you both instead of bottling it up?”
“Probably not.”
“Okay. What my goal is here is to try and help both partners see how their relationships have gotten to the point they did and what each person could have done differently to prevent it. I know it’s hard and it’s not fun, but it’s important and critical to maintaining a healthy, happy relationship that you communicate with Hilary about what you’re feeling. Telling her your insecurities is important, but it’s also about telling her smaller things, like how you don’t like eating pasta three times a week, for example. Trust me, when you get used to communicating the small stuff, the big stuff gets easier.”
Y/N supposes that makes sense. Her and Hilary have always struggled to communicate. They’ve always forgiven each other for their outbursts and times they’ve gotten upset, but maybe, Y/N thinks, they shouldn’t need to forgive each other. They wouldn’t fight or snap at each other so much if they just talked through what they were feeling or admitted when they needed space. Maybe Shannon is onto something here.
“I’m hoping that for our next group session that we can spend some time sharing what is really bothering both of you. I would like you before we meet again to think about things that you’re insecure about and things that bother you that either Hilary does or that other people do that you think Hilary could help you through so that we can discuss the best ways for you both to communicate your emotions and the best ways for each of you to respond.”
***
“I realized that I really just felt guilty and ashamed of myself,” Hilary says, “And I kept taking those negative emotions out on you, which wasn’t fair, and then it made me more guilty and more ashamed and it just kept cycling. I’m working on forgiving myself for what happened and for not allowing the negative things I feel spiral into me hurting you or myself.”
“It wasn’t that I didn’t forgive you, but we kept fighting and that made me revaluate our fight and instead of talking to you I kept it to myself because I was worried that you might confirm my fears that you don’t actually want to be with me,” Y/N says, “And it didn’t help that I’m injured and all my friends are out celebrating a win that I can’t celebrate with them. I shut myself off from you and I shut myself off from them because I hated feeling like I was missing out on something.”
“I’m sorry that I couldn’t help you through what was bothering you.”
“And I’m sorry I kept fighting with you instead of trying to talk about what was actually bothering me.”
“I think we’ve made some great progress today,” Shannon says, “The next steps are learning strategies towards forgiving ourselves and quieting and dealing with negative thoughts and unlearning the urge to hide our true feelings. We cannot silence negative thoughts or feelings, they will always be there, but we can learn to manage them and to discuss them so they won’t be bottled up and we can get reassurances from our loved ones that the negative thoughts aren’t true.”
***
Y/N’s making breakfast when Hilary comes up behind her and wraps her arms around Y/N’s waist. Hilary kisses Y/N’s cheek before resting her head on Y/N’s shoulder. They slowly swayed together.
“What time is your session today?” Hilary asks.
“4:30.”
“Plenty of time then.”
“Time for what?”
“You’ll see,” Hilary says, “Just eat and get dressed.”
Y/N is desperately curious about what Hilary has planned. They’ve been doing better, much better, in the months since they’ve started going to therapy. Still, they haven’t gone out and done much since Hilary’s still worried about Y/N’s concussion. But, Y/N’s doctors have cleared her for exercise and she hasn’t had a debilitating headache in months, so clearly Hilary is confidant that Y/N can handle not only an outside excursion but a surprising one as well.
“Will you at least tell me what to wear?” Y/N asks, “Am I dressing up or am I wearing sweats? It would be easier if you just told me what we were doing.” Y/N says sweetly, leaning up on her toes to kiss Hilary’s cheek. Hilary smiles but doesn’t budge, even as Y/N kisses down her neck.
“You’ll see when we get there,” Hilary gently pushes Y/N away, “I’ll pick out an outfit for you, okay?” Y/N pouts, but acquiesces that Hilary isn’t going to tell her.
Once they’re both dressed and ready, Y/N’s practically vibrating with excitement and curiosity. Hilary laughs when she sees Y/N bouncing on her toes. When they get in the car, Hilary behind the wheel, Hilary doesn’t drive away at first. She spends a few minutes on her phone, but when Y/N tries to lean on her shoulder to see what she’s doing, Hilary turns the screen away from her. Y/N sighs. She’s excited for wherever Hilary’s taking her, she hates that Hilary won’t just tell her.
“You’re not going to make me wear a blindfold are you?” Y/N deadpans.
“Well…”
“Hilary!”
“I’m kidding!” Hilary says, holding her hands up in defence, “I’m not going to make you wear a blindfold, unless you want to?”
“No.”
“Right, then no blindfold. I don’t care if you find out where we’re going because I know you won’t guess what we’re doing.”
“Oh come on,” Y/N whines, “Just tell me!”
“No,” Hilary whines back.
Y/N crosses her arms and pouts. She doesn’t care if she looks childish, she wants Hilary to know she’s annoyed. Hilary doesn’t say anything, she just smiles and shakes her head. After a few minutes, Y/N realizes the turns Hilary is taking.
“Are you taking me to the rink?” Y/N asks. Hilary’s smile tells Y/N enough. “Hil, I was cleared for light exercise not to get on the ice. Hilary, are you even listening to me?” Y/N can’t help the laughter that bubbles up. “Hilary!” Y/N pushes at Hilary’s arm.
“Stop! I’m driving!” Hilary swats at Y/N’s hand, “I know what I’m doing, trust me!”
“I’m sorry if I’m suspicious,” Y/N says, giving Hilary side-eye, “If you just told me what we were doing…”
“I’m not telling! We’re almost there, just be patient for a few more minutes.”
For the next few minutes, Y/N sits and pouts while Hilary smiles but keeps her mouth shut. When Hilary pulls into the parking lot of the rink, Y/N raises her eyebrows and waits for Hilary to finally tell her why they’re here. Hilary raises her eyebrows right back.
“Are you going to sit in the car and ruin my hard work?” Hilary asks.
“I still don’t know why we’re here. What am I supposed to be doing?”
“You’re going to get out of the car and we’re going to walk in the front doors.”
Y/N rolls her eyes, Hilary is so stubborn sometimes. She does what Hilary says though, getting out and walking with Hilary to the front doors. Hilary is almost vibrating from excitement, standing tall with her arm linked with Y/N’s. Hilary holds open the door and when Y/N steps inside, her jaw drops in shock.
“Surprise!” Jill’s hugging Y/N before Y/N can even process that she’s in front of her. Y/N looks around, her entire team is there, in their jerseys with their medals around their necks. Y/N looks to Hilary. Hilary is holding out Y/N’s jersey and medal to her.
“I know how bummed you’ve been about missing all the celebrations, even if you try and hide it,” Hilary says, “So I wanted to give you a chance to experience what a gold medal celebration feels like. Everyone wanted to come out and spray you with champagne and chug beer out of a trophy and… take pictures. I know it’s not the same but I want you to have something from the tournament to look back on that was good.”
“Hil…” Y/N thinks she’s going to cry. This must’ve taken Hilary months to set up and she and everyone else managed to keep it all a secret. The fact that everyone wants to give Y/N the experience she missed out because of her concussion… Y/N doesn’t have words to describe what she’s feeling. She puts on her jersey and grabs the medal with shaky hands. She holds it for a moment, looking at it, before she places it around her neck.
It's an incredible day. Everyone jumps around and cheers and there’s TVs set up playing the gold medal game. Y/N gets sprayed with champagne and she sprays plenty at everyone else. It’s not the same as what the celebration would be like right after the win, but it’s good and it’s fun and Y/N is so happy. Y/N stops in the middle of her jumping around just to stare at Hilary who’s staring right back at her. Y/N loves her so much and she’s so grateful that they worked things out and that they’re happy together. Hilary is the greatest thing Y/N could ever have. Y/N thinks she could spend the rest of her life in this moment, her teammates jumping and screaming around her, a gold medal around her neck, and Hilary looking at her like she hung the moon and the stars in the sky. Y/N jumps and squeals when arms wrap around her waist and lift her into the air.
“Quit staring at your girlfriend and celebrate dammit!” Emily Clark’s loud voice yells in Y/N’s ear. Y/N squirms out of Emily’s arms and pushes her away before she rejoins the celebration. She can hear Hilary’s laugh ringing out over everyone else and Y/N doesn’t think she’s ever been happier.
260 notes
·
View notes