this is the fourth novel adapting goose girl i have read
currently 10% of the way through and the christianity is incredibly heavy handed. both main characters are very concerned about god forgiving them constantly. it is VERY annoying and does not feel natural, more like a sermon.
one aspect i do like dual povs from our goose girl and the duke she will marry (who is ALSO going to be in disguise it looks like)
the narrative starts before her maid makes her change places although we didn't get to know her much before the journey took place, or much about her family relations
the mc had the Revelation that WOW servants are treated with NO respect!! can you BELIEVE
the writing is meh but the audio is pretty good
absolutely no nuance to this book, i am being hit over the head with the morals and the foreshadowing oof
honestly, not sure if i will finish this retelling or not, it could go either way at this point
Book Review: Lady of Disguise by Melanie Dickerson
⭐⭐⭐⭐
Rating: 4 out of 5.
Melanie Dickerson is one of my favorite authors, and she is probably the author who has had the biggest impact on my reading. You can read why here. Since I love Melanie’s books so much, I was thrilled to receive an ARC of Lady of Disguise, which is the first of her books I’ve reviewed on my blog!
Lady of Disguise is the sixth book in Melanie’s A Dericott Tale series.…
Title: Cloak of Scarlet [The Dericott Tales 5]
Author: Melanie Dickerson
Genre: Historical, Fantasy, Romance, Re-Telling
Rating: 1 Star (DNF)
Description/Synopsis:
She was an orphan of no importance . . .
Violet Lambton never imagined herself as anything but average. Adopted as a young child, she’s content with her comfortable life in her small medieval town with her faith, her books, and her…
Veil of Winter (Dericott Tales #3)Melanie DickersonThomas NelsonPublished June 14, 2022
Amazon | Bookshop | Goodreads
About Veil of Winter
Princess Elyce is on the verge of marrying the nephew of the unscrupulous King Conrad of a neighboring kingdom when she discovers that Conrad will use her marriage to force her people to work in his mines. In order to fake her own death and escape him, she…
Ladies and Gents, have any of you read any Dericott books by Melanie Dickerson??? Fairytale retellings set in Medival England with a Strong religious undertone/overtone? Consider me signed up!
Sun Ra Arkestra - Living Sky - the new album is out TODAY on Omni Sound
For more than two decades, the disciple that has most visibly carried on Sun Ra Arkestra’s legacy and sound is their musical director, alto saxophonist Marshall Allen, the iconic fire breather and life force that restored the Arkestra’s vitality in the massive vacuum left by Ra and John Gilmore’s death in the ‘90s. Allen turned 98 in 2022 and, as evidenced by Living Sky, his influence and leadership remain undiminished. Marking the Arkestra’s first new recording since their 2021 Grammy-nominated album Swirling, Living Sky was recorded on June 15, 2021 at Rittenhouse SoundWorks in Philadelphia and features a total of nineteen musicians, including a strings section. It was mixed and mastered by three-time Grammy winner Dave Darlington (Eddie Palmieri, Brian Lynch, Wayne Shorter).
Sun Ra Arkestra
Marshall Allen - Alto Saxophone, Kora, EVI
Knoel Scott - Tenor Saxophone, Baritone Saxophone
Nasir P. Dickerson - Tenor Saxophone
Chris Hemingway - Tenor Saxophone
Michael Ray - Trumpet
Cecil Brooks - Trumpet
Vincent Chancey - French Horn
Dave Davis - Trombone
Robert Stringer - Trombone
Farid Barron - Piano
Dave Hotep - Guitar
Tyler Mitchell - Bass
Wayne Anthony Smith, Jr - Drums
Ron McBee - Percussion
Jorge Silva - Percussion
Elson Nascimento - Percussion
Tara Middleton - Violin, Flute
Gwen Laster - Violin
Melanie Dyer - Viola
Kash Killion - Cello, Sarangi
Dedicated to the legacy of
Sun Ra (1914-1993)
Bandleader, composer, arranger, keyboard player, poet, philosopher and cosmonaut.
In memory of
Hartmut Geerken (1939- 2021)
German musician, composer, writer, journalist, playwright, and filmmaker.
Mehmet Ulug (1959-2013)
Turkish producer & promoter, Omni’s pathway to Sun Ra.
When I learned that the Villains Ever After Series was getting a Swan Lake story, I knew I had to read it. I expected this book to be a new favorite because I love classical ballet, and romance novels inspired by fairytales. However, after finishing this book in just under two days, I am sad to say that The Sorcerer and the Swan Princess is one of the most unromantic adaptation of Swan Lake I have read.
By no means, am I upset with the Sorcerer, named Dietrich, being the love interest instead of the prince. It’s in the title. This creative twist was what interested me to begin with. However, Dietrich, despite the attempts to humanize him, is still not a charming love interest in the slightest.
Ava is the heir to the throne of her kingdom, but has always had dreams to be a ballet dancer. However, she was forced to hang up her pointe shoes following an ankle injury. I liked this feature to Ava’s character both as a nod to the source material and because unfulfilled childhood dreams rips my heart strings right out.
Things finally start looking up for Ava when she receives a visit from an old friend, Prince Siegfried. But, everything changes when Dietrich the Sorcerer appears, turns Ava into a swan against her will, and kidnaps her despite her protest that she wants to go home. Maybe Dietrich has his reasons to do so, maybe he truly has Ava’s best interest at heart despite absolutely not respecting Ava’s autonomy. I personally found the reason to be flimsy. <spoiler> Ava’s twin sister, Lina, asked Dietrich to turn Ava into a swan and kill her so that she can take her place as queen. Dietrich turns her into a swan and kidnaps her instead. I recall Ava asking why he didn’t explain the situation and ask her to come with him instead, and Dietrich’s response is basically, “You would not have believed me”. I would still be bothered if he only kidnapped her, but he also denies Ava, her humanity and twists her body into something unrecognizable. Like, I would not give a man a second chance after that, even if he has a tragic sob story on top of the protecting from an evil twin excuse. </spoiler>
After the initial abduction, Dietrich does not respect Ava or even appears to take her seriously. Towards the middle of the story, Ava and Dietrich are having a very heated discussion, and Dietrich realizes the conversation is not getting anywhere. Ava only becomes more and more upset with him. A mature adult would remove themselves from the situation until both parties have a chance to calm down, but not Dietrich. He turns Ava into a swan again to shut her up. He says it’s because she needs to “cool off”. What I took away from the exchange is that A. Dietrich cannot take any criticism, even if said criticism is the result of his poor communication. B. he is more powerful than Ava and he wants her to know it.
Any efforts to make the characters fall in love just feels forced after this even when Dietrich realizes Ava’s mindreading ability hasn’t been working and finally explains himself. Ava forgives Dietrich, because the premise of the Swan Princess and the Sorcerer falling in love needs to happen not because they had genuinely good chemistry.
Finally, and this is probably is not even a problem, but I am a little confused that some major characters are renamed from the ballet, but others are not. The sorcerer character, Rothbart, is called Dietrich, and the characters filling the roles of Odette and Odile are named Ava and Lina, but the prince's name is still Siegfried.
Okay, I clearly need to calm myself down before some hot sorcerer turns me into an emu and makes me calm down.
Any Swan Lake adaptions I would recommend instead? The issue is I have not read any other books where Ava and Dietrich become a couple. However, an excellent romance book that is more of an adaptation of Robin Hood with Swan Lake elements is The Huntress of Thornbeck Forest by Melanie Dickerson.
*With varying degrees of enmity and reasonableness of enmity
The musical Grease
Disney's Frozen
The CBS Sherlock Holmes show Elementary
Melanie Dickerson's fairy tale retellings
Usual disclaimers that this is extremely personal opinion with personal reasons, and you're not necessarily wrong if you liked any of them.
It appears that there are a few qualifying factors that make something an archnemesis instead of just something I don't like
Something that's of a genre or subject matter that I usually like a lot, so the fact that I don't like it feels more personal and disappointing
Lots of people do like it, and I'm either disappointed I don't get it, annoyed that they don't, or angry that they use their love of the thing they like to put down the thing I do like
(And it appears having a one-word title doesn't help)
Which brings to mind works that share some of the archnemesis requirements but don't qualify as archnemeses:
Thorn by Intisar Khanani (by virtue of being something I should like, so much so that I frequently forget that I don't like it and have to be disappointed all over again. But there are still a lot of things to like about it.)
The third episode of Strange New Worlds. (Too new and too slight to be a true archnemesis, but I'm baffled that it's praised to the skies and that no one can see that even by Star Trek standards the plot is flaming garbage nonsense)
And anyway I've satisfied my list-making and category-defining impulses, so I'll end the post now.
since i will dnf any bad books in the next 2 weeks and have a pretty stellar line up for my end of the year options, i will do my worst books of the year . . .this is based on my reading enjoyment so please don't expect objectivity
peter pan by jm barrie
i mean, this book is great in context with response texts and discussing childrens literature over time but the racism and sexism are overwhelming. i don't regret reading this book but i did not enjoy it overall.
the wonderful wizard of oz by l frank baum
see above but less obvious with racism and sexism
islands at the end of the world by austin aslan
im so over dystopias. also this was racist and sexist yay.
under the dome by kosoko jackson
if you don't mind a protagonist saying he's a journalist 17 times through his story, you might enjoy this.
the grimrose girls duology by laura pohl
in my defense, the fictional text the book focused was really deeply fascinating. or the idea of it was. deeply disappointing as a fairy tale retelling nerd. (i still can't believe i read both of these smh)
the marrow thieves by cherie dimaline
again, i can't do dystopias at my age anymore. also i should have looked up the trigger warnings before reading this. that's on me.
how much of these hills is gold by c pam zhang
i can see how this would appeal to some people. pretty writing but not appealing to me in the least.
the girl in the painting by tea cooper
i read this as an example of christian fiction in class. it was not as bad as i expected.
when women were dragons by kelly barnhill
this reeked of white feminism. there were a lot of good aspects but the message of the story was undercut by the lack of woc in the book.
the noble servant by melanie dickerson
this was what i thought christian fiction would be like. sometimes, i hate being right
beast by donna jo napoli
so racist. so sexist. so much islamophobia. and theres a lion sex scene
legends and lattes by travis baldree
if i wanted to read about a coffee shop being built, i would have read a blog post instead. biggest disappointment of the year.
pictures and stories from uncle toms cabin by harriet beecher stowe